Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be offended that SIL told me to return a gift I got for her?

335 replies

chicosmommy · 10/01/2024 19:50

I try to buy my Christmas gifts early in the year, during sales and times when there might be discounts.

I was in Harvey Nics in September and I spotted a gorgeous jumpsuit in SIL's size and in a brand that she loves and wears a lot. It was 50% off. I bought it for her and kept it until Christmas Day to give it to her as her gift.

When Christmas Day came around, she opened the gift, scrunched up her nose at it and said these exact words, "urgh. I wouldn't wear that. Can you return this and get me a voucher instead".

I just took it back, said very little and today, I went in to try get the value of the jumpsuit in a voucher. The store told me that because it was bought in September, it is too far back and they can't give me a voucher.

Clearly, I don't want SIL to know that I'm buying her gift on discount so I ended up buying a voucher for her for £150 & I'm stuck with the jumpsuit, which I'll have to ebay or put on Depop (doesn't fit me).

What are people's thoughts on this? Is it very rude not to accept a gift and if you don't like it, just exchange it yourself? Should you expect the buyer/gifter to exchange it for you?

OP posts:
Ghentsummer · 10/01/2024 20:32

Why not give her £75 as that is what you spent or did you 'accidentally' leave a price tag on so she would think you spent £150?

I think people should only buy clothes for others if they include a gift receipts and it's given in time to change it at the shop.

Just because it is in her size doesn't mean it will fit her. I have clothes in 3 different sizes in my wardrobe that all fit and that's before you account for length, sleeves, bust, shoulders etc.

It was an odd gift.

DappledThings · 10/01/2024 20:34

So you spent £75 on something that was 50% off but didn't want her to know it was in the sale so you bought her a voucher for £150?

Yes, she's seriously rude and expecting to have that much spent on her is over the top. I'd cut your losses for now and forget about it.

But don't buy clothes for people. It's really risky. I can barely choose clothes for myself that I know I'd like nevermind anyone else!

Redshoeblueshoe · 10/01/2024 20:35

I've voted YABU - but that's for getting a gift voucher.

Growlybear83 · 10/01/2024 20:35

So should the sister in law have just thanked the OP for a present which she clearly thought was awful, rather than saying she didn't like it? I agree that the way she said it was very rude but she shouldn't have been expected to keep a present that she would never wear. My husband gave me a pair of earrings for Christmas which were definitely not to my taste and which I would never have worn, so I told him I wanted to return them. He was far less offended than he would have been if I had said nothing and never worn them.

QueenBean22 · 10/01/2024 20:37

She’s rude, but £150 on a sister in law is far too much.

easylikeasundaymorn · 10/01/2024 20:37

she was very rude in the way she said it but £150 seems loads to me to spend on a SIL - if she spent the same on you then it makes sense she might have been a bit aggrieved at you having a nice expensive present and her having something that is worthless to her. As you'll find out it's not going to make anything like the amount you paid for it on depop/vinted.

buying clothes for people is always a bit hit and miss and should include a receipt in case they don't like it/doesn't fit/there's an issue. Without a receipt it's not as if she could take it back herself, is it? So she had to ask you. Also do you both live near London? It's not as if Harvey Nics is like New Look, with one in every town - if she doesn't live close and you do it makes sense for you to return it.

Take it as a lesson learned - don't buy clothes for people even if you're pretty sure they'll like it, or if you do make sure there's a gift receipt and an extended return period!

Althenameshavegone · 10/01/2024 20:37

I’d just explain that you bought it in the sale a while ago and can’t return it, but she can put it on vinted and keep what it sells for. And don’t buy her clothes in the future!

I was once responsible for organising a group birthday gift for a friend, she asked if she could return it and put her own money towards something else from the same shop that she liked more. It was better she got something she would use but I thought it was quite rude.

Gardengirl108 · 10/01/2024 20:38

I gave a book to someone (an adult) as a birthday gift. She unwrapped it, told me she already had it and gave it back to me. I’m not usually lost for words, but I was that day. I never bought her another gift though.

IDontLoveTheWayYouLie · 10/01/2024 20:41

If she didn't like it then that's fine but she didn't need to be rude. I wouldn't have gone out and spent an extra £150 on her to make up for it either.

£20 would seem okay and that's without being lumbered with the extra present she couldn't be arsed with.

Teenagehorrorbag · 10/01/2024 20:42

I just don't get buying presents for other adults, especially not immediate family. We do a few bits for MIL as she always spends Christmas with us (lots of little things to open rather than expensive stuff) but we don't buy for our siblings let alone their partners.

Christmas is about fun and family, not spending huge amounts of money just for the sake of it!

We do sometimes get 'tree presents' if we are likely to see each other over the festive period, or we see something the other would really appreciate or find amusing - but £150.....????? (And that was for a discounted item....😆). We are fortunate that we aren't struggling financially - but even so would never spend that sort of money. Especially not on something the recipient hasn't chosen or requested.

But each to their own I suppose..... In terms of your question - I'm not really sure of the protocol. I'd normally give a gift receipt with the item so a person could change it - but if you bought something in September to get the discount that's obviously not an option. She should have asked for the gift receipt and offered to change it herself - but then you'd have had to say 'sorry, I got it ages ago' - and hopefully she would then sell it on Vinted herself. Not really your job to change it and she was a bit rude.

Bubblybits · 10/01/2024 20:43

First reply got it in one.

My knee-jerk reaction to her comment upon opening it would have been: “well you can return it for credit yourself, I’m not your employee”. She could have done exactly that, or Depop/Vinted etc.

She was undoubtedly horribly rude, but working on your assertiveness would be beneficial too.

WandaWonder · 10/01/2024 20:43

Yes rude but I would never buy clothed as a present, for children/partner yes

planetarynoodle · 10/01/2024 20:44

Don't buy clothes as gifts

MushMonster · 10/01/2024 20:45

Why have you bought a voucher? No way I would do this.
She was beyond rude. But if she does not like it, better to change it.
I would sell the jumpsuit and give her whatever I got for it. Or better, she could do that?

mumofmilly · 10/01/2024 20:45

She was out of order and very rude!! I'd be suggesting just sending cards and not presents next year. No need for blatant rudeness even if you don't like something.

Dominoeffecter · 10/01/2024 20:47

Did this really happen

RawBloomers · 10/01/2024 20:47

It was kind of rude to ask for a voucher instead and it would have been fine for you to say “Sorry, it’s not refundable”. But buying someone clothing is a very risky gift and doing it without the possibility of exchange is a bit thoughtless.

I think being offended is an over reaction on your part and sounds like it’s more related to you not wanting people to know that you don’t spend as much on them as you hope they think you do.

Anywherebuthere · 10/01/2024 20:47

Her face response and her comment is rude. She could have been polite about it.

But the gift isnt something she could easily regift to anyone else so its useless to her and better that she asked for it to be returned. The way she did was wrong.

No one has to keep an unwanted gift but it can be dealt with kindly.

Buying such personal clothes as a gift for someone and at that price is risky. Just because someone like certain clothes (or anything else) from a particular brand it doesnt mean they'l like and want the entire range.

theduchessofspork · 10/01/2024 20:48

TheLightSideOfTheMoon · 10/01/2024 19:53

She’s rude.

But also, you meekly took it back and shuffled to the shops with it, then spent £150 more.

You’re both kind of weird.

Yes.

ManateeFair · 10/01/2024 20:49

If those were her exact words, then yes, she was rude.

However, I think plenty of people would rather someone didn’t waste their money on a gift that won’t get used, so I don’t think it was unreasonable of her to want to return it. The way she asked was rude (“I’m really sorry, I can totally see why you picked this out for me but I can’t see myself wearing this / it doesn’t fit - do you have the receipt? Then I can exchange it” would have been the politer thing to say).

But even if she’d been polite about it, that wouldn’t have changed the fact that you wouldn’t have been able to exchange it. Spending a large amount of money on an item of clothing for someone else, many months before Christmas - especially something like a jumpsuit where the fit has to be perfect for it to look good, and which a lot of women never wear - was a silly decision on your part. Particularly if you’re embarrassed to be caught out buying things in the sales and passing them off as full-price items. If I bought someone a gift in a sale, I wouldn’t try to hide that fact and then get pissed off if they found out.

Somewhere in a parallel Mumsnet universe there’s a thread that says “My SIL bought me a jumpsuit for Christmas. It’s by a brand I sometimes wear but I absolutely hate it - clothes are such a personal thing and I would never wear it. She didn’t enclose the receipt or tell me where it was from and I didn’t want her money to be wasted so I asked if maybe she could exchange it for a gift card. Turns out that she actually bought it half price in a sale and so long ago that it’s non-returnable. Fair enough, just one of those things. But now she’s angry at ME because she’s embarrassed at being caught out! AIBU to say it’s not my fault that she wanted to pass off a sale purchase from a year ago as a new full-price item, and that I couldn’t possibly have known that when I asked to swap it?!”

stayathomer · 10/01/2024 20:50

Don’t give her the voucher. Don’t!!!!

Wildflower86 · 10/01/2024 20:50

Have u given her the voucher?

EasterIssland · 10/01/2024 20:51

mottytotty · 10/01/2024 20:06

Irrelevant.

Not really. She buys a present. The receiver doesn’t like it. Would you prefer it being donated ? Given to a charity shop? Or returned and exchanged for something the receiver likes ? If the latter then don’t buy so much in advance.

I just got a jumper for Xmas. It wasn’t my size. I even have anxiety when buying clothes so clearly buying clothes for me it’s not something I’ll enjoy. I told them to get the money back, I didn’t want anything extra but neither did I want the jumper. If I had kept it I’d have donated it 🤷🏻‍♀️

Dominoeffecter · 10/01/2024 20:52

ManateeFair · 10/01/2024 20:49

If those were her exact words, then yes, she was rude.

However, I think plenty of people would rather someone didn’t waste their money on a gift that won’t get used, so I don’t think it was unreasonable of her to want to return it. The way she asked was rude (“I’m really sorry, I can totally see why you picked this out for me but I can’t see myself wearing this / it doesn’t fit - do you have the receipt? Then I can exchange it” would have been the politer thing to say).

But even if she’d been polite about it, that wouldn’t have changed the fact that you wouldn’t have been able to exchange it. Spending a large amount of money on an item of clothing for someone else, many months before Christmas - especially something like a jumpsuit where the fit has to be perfect for it to look good, and which a lot of women never wear - was a silly decision on your part. Particularly if you’re embarrassed to be caught out buying things in the sales and passing them off as full-price items. If I bought someone a gift in a sale, I wouldn’t try to hide that fact and then get pissed off if they found out.

Somewhere in a parallel Mumsnet universe there’s a thread that says “My SIL bought me a jumpsuit for Christmas. It’s by a brand I sometimes wear but I absolutely hate it - clothes are such a personal thing and I would never wear it. She didn’t enclose the receipt or tell me where it was from and I didn’t want her money to be wasted so I asked if maybe she could exchange it for a gift card. Turns out that she actually bought it half price in a sale and so long ago that it’s non-returnable. Fair enough, just one of those things. But now she’s angry at ME because she’s embarrassed at being caught out! AIBU to say it’s not my fault that she wanted to pass off a sale purchase from a year ago as a new full-price item, and that I couldn’t possibly have known that when I asked to swap it?!”

‘Caught out’ spending £75 on her SIL, ffs

Bettyscakes · 10/01/2024 20:52

Omg I feel so bad now, my MIL got me PJs for Christmas that were far too small so I said thank you they are lovely but if you have the receipt could I change them as they don’t fit.,She said to give her them and she would exchange them. I hope I didn’t offend her, she would just ask if I liked them and I hate lying!

Swipe left for the next trending thread