Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be offended that SIL told me to return a gift I got for her?

335 replies

chicosmommy · 10/01/2024 19:50

I try to buy my Christmas gifts early in the year, during sales and times when there might be discounts.

I was in Harvey Nics in September and I spotted a gorgeous jumpsuit in SIL's size and in a brand that she loves and wears a lot. It was 50% off. I bought it for her and kept it until Christmas Day to give it to her as her gift.

When Christmas Day came around, she opened the gift, scrunched up her nose at it and said these exact words, "urgh. I wouldn't wear that. Can you return this and get me a voucher instead".

I just took it back, said very little and today, I went in to try get the value of the jumpsuit in a voucher. The store told me that because it was bought in September, it is too far back and they can't give me a voucher.

Clearly, I don't want SIL to know that I'm buying her gift on discount so I ended up buying a voucher for her for £150 & I'm stuck with the jumpsuit, which I'll have to ebay or put on Depop (doesn't fit me).

What are people's thoughts on this? Is it very rude not to accept a gift and if you don't like it, just exchange it yourself? Should you expect the buyer/gifter to exchange it for you?

OP posts:
mumofmilly · 10/01/2024 20:53

Couple of years ago I'd looked for months for a super nice Christmas present for my husband's grandma, put loads of thought into it and she was absolutely rude and totally ungrateful. It's gutting when you are excited to see them unwrap the gift and they toss it a side like it's a piece of shite, needless to say, ever since then all she gets from me is a toblerone!! And she's lucky she gets that!

ManchesterBea · 10/01/2024 20:53

Horribly rude, sorry you had to deal with that.

Ugh people.

And Christmas.

ManateeFair · 10/01/2024 20:54

Bubblybits · 10/01/2024 20:43

First reply got it in one.

My knee-jerk reaction to her comment upon opening it would have been: “well you can return it for credit yourself, I’m not your employee”. She could have done exactly that, or Depop/Vinted etc.

She was undoubtedly horribly rude, but working on your assertiveness would be beneficial too.

But the OP says she didn’t want the SIL to know the gift was bought ages ago in a half-price sale. If she’d told the SIL to return it herself, that cat would have been out of the bag.

DeeIee · 10/01/2024 20:54
  1. She was rude
  1. You can't pick clothes for someone and just expect them to like them
  1. Are you mad spending £150
Butterandtoast · 10/01/2024 20:55

I wouldn't buy anyone clothes unless they specifically send me a link for something they liked. It's too personal imo

Girlmumx2 · 10/01/2024 20:55

Do you normally spend this much?
What did she buy you?

Wytchy · 10/01/2024 20:55

Bettyscakes · 10/01/2024 20:52

Omg I feel so bad now, my MIL got me PJs for Christmas that were far too small so I said thank you they are lovely but if you have the receipt could I change them as they don’t fit.,She said to give her them and she would exchange them. I hope I didn’t offend her, she would just ask if I liked them and I hate lying!

that's different. you weren't expecting MIL to do the legwork of returning them.

saraclara · 10/01/2024 20:55

I enclose gift receipts with pretty much every present, and ensure that the gift recipient knows that I really won't mind if they want to change it. It gets harder and harder to buy for people when they already have most of what they need and/or I can't be certain of their tastes or colour preferences.

Having said that, they way she spoke to you was beyond rude. She could have put it far more pleasantly and part-apologetically.

PoinsettiaLives · 10/01/2024 20:55

YABU to have bought clothes that you should have known couldn’t be changed.

SIBU (and rude) to demand a voucher instead.

YABU (and a doormat) to have bought a voucher rather than telling her you couldn’t change it.

YABBU to be spending so much on presents for one another when it sounds like you don’t really want to.

keojam80 · 10/01/2024 20:56

It was rude and you need to stop people pleasing to the point you spent 150 quid more!! Should have just said sorry, I bought it in September so I can't get a voucher now, tell her to sell it on vinted if she doesn't want it. Then next year just get a voucher.
Would I hell be spending more money on her.

Ellie1015 · 10/01/2024 20:57

Sil was very rude.

Have you given her the voucher? If not don't give her it just say sorry it is outwith return period so I can't return it and treat yourself with the voucher. Offer the jumpsuit back.

My 5 year old know to politely say thanks for gifts even if they don't like them.

Theatrefan12 · 10/01/2024 20:57

As others have said she was rude in the way she communicated her dislike of the gift

But I wouldn’t buy clothes for others unless they specifically asked for it and knowing that people likely exchange clothes, I definitely wouldn’t buy in a sale so far ahead of Christmas (unless it was my mum who would be glad I got a bargain!)

LookItsMeAgain · 10/01/2024 20:57

@chicosmommy - why did you spend £150 on the voucher and not give her a voucher for the amount that the jumpsuit/clothes actually cost you? That’s the crazy part.

Yes she was rude but you didn’t have to go ott on the voucher or even accept it back.

WhereverIlaymycatthatsmyhome · 10/01/2024 20:59

I think it was a very odd choice of gift for another adult. Always a risk she wouldn’t like it or the fit wouldn’t be quite right.

However, SIL was very rude.

RafaistheKingofClay · 10/01/2024 20:59

Agree with others. She was incredibly rude, but the fact it was non-returnable was on you. Clothing isn't really something you can buy discounted way in advance. Either because tastes even within brand vary as does fit. There was always the risk either you would have to return it or she'd end up with £150 piece of clothing she never wears in her wardrobe.

I can just imagine the thread if she'd sold it without every having worn it.

mottytotty · 10/01/2024 21:02

EasterIssland · 10/01/2024 20:51

Not really. She buys a present. The receiver doesn’t like it. Would you prefer it being donated ? Given to a charity shop? Or returned and exchanged for something the receiver likes ? If the latter then don’t buy so much in advance.

I just got a jumper for Xmas. It wasn’t my size. I even have anxiety when buying clothes so clearly buying clothes for me it’s not something I’ll enjoy. I told them to get the money back, I didn’t want anything extra but neither did I want the jumper. If I had kept it I’d have donated it 🤷🏻‍♀️

The giver gives a gift. She has ZERO responsibility beyond that.

The correct response is to say thank you and fuck off home. SIL has been a rude twat and should receive not so much as a BEAN ever again.

lto2019 · 10/01/2024 21:02

She's rude and I would not bother buying her any more presents. I would have taken it off and left it in a bin so she could see what I thought of her rudeness.

Getthethrowonthesofa · 10/01/2024 21:03

Did she spend 150 on you> is that the amount you normally spend?

buying someone clothes is Really risky. Something like a plain jumper, fine, but a jumpsuit, I find was always going to be an issue.

EasterIssland · 10/01/2024 21:04

mottytotty · 10/01/2024 21:02

The giver gives a gift. She has ZERO responsibility beyond that.

The correct response is to say thank you and fuck off home. SIL has been a rude twat and should receive not so much as a BEAN ever again.

Where is this rule written? Also I thought the reason for giving presents is to make the receiver happy not to tick a box. When you put so little thought on what others like / might fit then you risk wasting your money. If you don’t mind wasting your money fair enough. I prefer to make others happy without wasting my money

Bainbridgemews · 10/01/2024 21:04

I think it's pretty awful hanging onto what you think is a £150 jumpsuit that you know you'd never wear. It's an incredible waste of the buyer's money. She was very rude yes, but I don't think it's unusual to return clothing presents as they're often not quite right. A relative always buys my sons clothes from M&S but never gives a gift receipt. It'll be stuff they already have and don't need two of - like dressing gowns - but because she never includes a gift receipt and just about everything in M&S goes into sale immediately after Christmas, I can't even swap them for something useful of the same value. I feel bad thinking about her wasted money.

mottytotty · 10/01/2024 21:05

EasterIssland · 10/01/2024 21:04

Where is this rule written? Also I thought the reason for giving presents is to make the receiver happy not to tick a box. When you put so little thought on what others like / might fit then you risk wasting your money. If you don’t mind wasting your money fair enough. I prefer to make others happy without wasting my money

How did OP not put thought in that gift? Did you read the OP?

ManateeFair · 10/01/2024 21:07

Dominoeffecter · 10/01/2024 20:52

‘Caught out’ spending £75 on her SIL, ffs

I have no issue with the OP spending £75! It’s a lot more than I’d spend and it’s more than generous. But the OP actually says that “obviously” she wanted her SIL to think she spent £150.

I personally think it’s fucking nuts to pass off an already very expensive present as an even more expensive one - but that was what the OP specifically says she trying to do.

If anyone in my family had bought me a luxury gift for half price, they’d have been excitedly telling me what a bargain it was at half-price before I’d even finished opening it! We’re really open with each other about that kind of thing and we don’t have any expectation that someone will spend a certain amount. I’d be pleased for them that they’d managed to save money!

GreatGateauxsby · 10/01/2024 21:08

Hmmm… I’m 50/50

in terms of receiving
she’s a bit rude BUT I think a jumpsuit is a very personal item to buy.

And if I got one and wouldn’t wear it I wouldn’t just say thanks and let it rot in the wardrobe as I’d assume good money was spent and wouldn’t want the money to go to waste.

in terms of giving
I think you were pretty bold…
I'm not sure I would 100% confidently buy my own DSis or DM something like a jumpsuit …!

I am a cheapskate? would also have just got a £75 voucher not £150!!!

Snugglemonkey · 10/01/2024 21:08

Yabu for buying a clothing gift with no gift receipt.

MassiveOvaryaction · 10/01/2024 21:08

Wouldn't it have been worse for you if she'd tried to exchange it and hadn't been able to though @chicosmommy ?