Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be offended that SIL told me to return a gift I got for her?

335 replies

chicosmommy · 10/01/2024 19:50

I try to buy my Christmas gifts early in the year, during sales and times when there might be discounts.

I was in Harvey Nics in September and I spotted a gorgeous jumpsuit in SIL's size and in a brand that she loves and wears a lot. It was 50% off. I bought it for her and kept it until Christmas Day to give it to her as her gift.

When Christmas Day came around, she opened the gift, scrunched up her nose at it and said these exact words, "urgh. I wouldn't wear that. Can you return this and get me a voucher instead".

I just took it back, said very little and today, I went in to try get the value of the jumpsuit in a voucher. The store told me that because it was bought in September, it is too far back and they can't give me a voucher.

Clearly, I don't want SIL to know that I'm buying her gift on discount so I ended up buying a voucher for her for £150 & I'm stuck with the jumpsuit, which I'll have to ebay or put on Depop (doesn't fit me).

What are people's thoughts on this? Is it very rude not to accept a gift and if you don't like it, just exchange it yourself? Should you expect the buyer/gifter to exchange it for you?

OP posts:
ButWhatAboutTheBees · 12/01/2024 11:27

AIBU is constantly being plagued by spam posters who just make up stories that reach the limits of credibility or are AI generated using "key words" like in laws, rude, presents etc... so it's really not that much of a stretch OP

ButWhatAboutTheBees · 12/01/2024 11:28

Also - give her the damn shoes back and say you won't wear them. She's already shown she doesn't think that it's rude to ask for a refund for something you won't use.

SecondUsername4me · 12/01/2024 11:29

chicosmommy · 12/01/2024 11:16

I bought her the size she is in a brand she constantly rabbits on about. She has a good few jumpsuits from that brand already. I mistakenly thought I was being thoughtful.

You were being thoughtful. Is it possible she's just a bit of a cow, or doesn't like you?

tenbob · 12/01/2024 11:33

chicosmommy · 12/01/2024 10:17

Clearly I disagree with what I perceive to be her rudeness. In my opinion, two wrongs don't make a right. By me behaving exactly the same as she has done makes me no better than her.

But that is totally ignoring her moral ‘code’ which says it’s fine to tell someone when a gift isn’t right.

It would be a huge mistake to think she would care, but even if she does, so what?

My favourite quote - do you want to be right or do you want to be happy?

CameltoeParkerBowles · 12/01/2024 11:36

A bit late to the party here, but I agree that all gift buying for your in-laws should be left to your husband from now on. Just buy for your own family, and save yourself the stress of trying to please those materialistic twits. Perhaps your DH might find it sufficiently irksome to suggest a no-present rule in future.

rookiemere · 12/01/2024 11:39

I think you're both a bit unreasonable tbh.

Buying an item of clothing at £150 for Christmas when you must know it would be too late to return it if not to taste, was always a recipe for trouble. I have bought items in the sales for people before, but it's low cost items like getting Christmas pjs in the January sales for my friend who has a birthday in November.

On the other hand SIL should have been gracious and either returned the outfit herself "Such a lovely thought and so clever of you to know I love this brand, but this particular outfit just isn't right for me. Do you happen to have the receipt?" or when she found they wouldn't refund or offer credit, she should have put it on Vinted " Wanted to let you know, it's such a pretty piece, but just not for me so I wanted someone else to enjoy wearing it".

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 12/01/2024 11:44

chicosmommy · 12/01/2024 10:17

Clearly I disagree with what I perceive to be her rudeness. In my opinion, two wrongs don't make a right. By me behaving exactly the same as she has done makes me no better than her.

But I think you are jumping through hoops here to prove you are not rude. And to prove that your behaviour is better than hers

She was indeed rude in the way she expressed it.
But its not a question of morals and standards.
You both had gifts that didn't fit and therefore they were no good to either of you.
You can say to her politely, "I'm sorry thank you for thinking of me but these shoes don't fit, is it possible I can return them"
It seems mad to swallow it, keep the shoes that don't fit, say nothing and then pay her more than the original cost of her present, so you will have paid £225 for her present and sucked up the rudeness. Why would you do that to yourself?
She won't even know about it. She won't learn from it. She will continue to behave in the same way.
It's not poor form to be assertive with her. It's not lowering your own standards.
Give her back the shoes that don't fit you and let her decide what she wants to do with them. There is a quid pro quo here, she can either keep the jump suit or give it to you and you can sell it. Or both of you just keep the gifts and sell them on.

Then say lets just buy presents for the DCs in future.

There's no loss of character in doing that. You are ending an arrangement that didn't work for anyone. It could even improve your relationship because it will remove the dashed expectations and resentments. Lifes too short to jump through hoops for no reason.

Thehop · 12/01/2024 12:03

I'd say"it's gone in the sale since Christmas so they won't swap it sorry."

leave it at that the rude cow.

do you feel able to ask for presents to be just for kids and not adults ne y year?

or pretend you want to do some charity work and suggest a donation to charity and a £30 gift limit instead?

LenaLamont · 12/01/2024 12:37

chicosmommy · 11/01/2024 15:54

That can't possibly be true. My reply with the dot was to a poster who called me weird. I get on GREAT with my parents in law. DH's sister is a piece of work, but otherwise I get on FANTASTICALLY with my inlaws.
Can't understand why people are doing a deep-dive into my other posts to try create another narrative about me???, what's your point? Are you trying to discredit me and my OP?
SIL and her DH bully the life out of me. That is true.

Clearly it is true, and it's not a "deep dive," it's normal to click on the Edited tag when a post has been replaced by a full stop to understamnd the context of the thread.

From OP's earlier post on the thread -

"She's an intimidating person and I am bullied by members of my husband's family, so yes, I'm timid. Thanks for pointing that out and calling me weird."

You wanted to look to your SIL like you'd spent an apparently £150 when you'd actually spent £75. She asked you to return the item you'd had for 3 months and you obviously couldn't, so you spent another £150 on vouchers to cover your backside.

I think you're more cross about not getting away with your half price gift than her manners.

If you think £150 is a ludicrous amount (and I would agree with you), then set your boundaries.

phoenixrosehere · 12/01/2024 12:46

Buying an item of clothing at £150 for Christmas when you must know it would be too late to return it if not to taste, was always a recipe for trouble.

Yes. No matter how thoughtful you think a present is, doesn’t mean it is always right.

Curious OP, if SIL had accepted it graciously and later asked for the gift receipt to return it or you found out she put it up on Vinted, how would you have felt or handled it?

Would you have told her the truth?

Having worked in retail, we would have customers try to return things w/o a gift receipt. We would look at the label for a number, if one not found search the system through categories to find the price. We’ve also searched Google images to find an item.

She would have found out somehow either by going to return it in person or asking you for the gift receipt.

With the shoe thing, you should have said something. That is really on you nor would it have been rude to ask for a gift receipt.

“Thank you for the shoes, unfortunately they’re not the right size for me, may I have the gift receipt so I may exchange them for my size?”

If you didn’t like them, could still have mentioned the size issue, get the receipt, return them, and get something else and say the store didn’t have your size if she would have asked about them.

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 12/01/2024 12:49

If you think £150 is a ludicrous amount (and I would agree with you), then set your boundaries.

The OP should get her "great husband" to set out his boundaries and sort out this nonsense about presents for his family. If he's rich enough to spend £150 on presents for adults, let him get on with it.

chicosmommy · 12/01/2024 13:50

Thehop · 12/01/2024 12:03

I'd say"it's gone in the sale since Christmas so they won't swap it sorry."

leave it at that the rude cow.

do you feel able to ask for presents to be just for kids and not adults ne y year?

or pretend you want to do some charity work and suggest a donation to charity and a £30 gift limit instead?

Great advice and going to follow exactly this. Tks

OP posts:
chicosmommy · 12/01/2024 13:59

Many people are commenting that I'm weird to get her a jumpsuit, or I'm a walkover or whatever.

Maybe both are true.

All I know for a fact was that I tried to get something I genuinely believed she'd like (she barely looked at the gift before her comment). Also, that I am not wealthy like them and so yes, I did try to pull one over by spending £75 on what ordinarily was a £150 gift. If I didn't spend the full amount, she'd chastise me for that too. The woman is awful to me in general, doesn't like me and makes no secret of it, usually more sneakily than this Christmas.

Thank you everyone for replying. Disappointed that some people think I'm crazy enough to have fabricated this and put it on mumsnet. To those people, I wish you'd just have jogged on past the post rather than trying to discredit me.

Outcome of the scenario is that I'll hold onto the voucher and if SIL brings it up, I'll say, ohhh by the time I got to the store it was beyond the returns date, sorry.

I'll put the shoes she got me on depop. They are my size. They are noce shoes, just not what I'd wear. They are too tight despite being my size. She wrote my name on the outside of the box (yes, weird) meaning they can't be returned even if i said it to her....which I won't by the way as I fundamentally don't agree with dissing a gift that someone has bought for you.

I'll speak to DH and ask him to put a stop to adult present buying in his family if he can (but I don't hold out hope as his parents lead on this and love giving and receiving expensive gifts).

Wish you all the best of luck.

OP posts:
DappledThings · 12/01/2024 14:26

I'll speak to DH and ask him to put a stop to adult present buying in his family if he can
You don't need to get his family to stop it, just make it his responsibility. DH buys presents for his parents and sister. They are nominally from both of us but I don't know what they are half the time. Same as I don't expect him to buy a separate gift for my family or be involved at all.

ButWhatAboutTheBees · 12/01/2024 14:27

You just want to act morally superior because you don't like her

There's nothing wrong with asking for a gift that doesn't fit or isn't your style to be returned and either a voucher given or exchanged for a bigger size

She was rude with the way she said it but what she wanted wasn't unreasonable

LordyMe · 12/01/2024 14:31

OP, how about posting a picture of those purple shoes? That would shut the doubters up and also satisfy my curiosity?
This is all super outing so no more so with a photo 👀👀👀
👠👠

AnnieSnap · 12/01/2024 14:32

@chicosmommy Sounds like you are handling it well. I’m sorry you have had grief off some posters. Mumsnet brings out some nasty people who seem to enjoy sniping at others with little or no provocation, but fortunately they are not in the majority.

I do think you need to put gift buying for your in-laws in the hands of your husband. Release yourself from the stress. Let him deal with it in a way of his choosing. You really are not responsible for keeping them happy. 🙂

OriginalUsername2 · 12/01/2024 15:38

Buying presents for people that make it clear they don’t like you is just plain silly.

I would say to DP that I’m not buying her gifts anymore because she’s ungrateful and rude about it. Let the chips fall where they may but I respect myself enough to not lay down and be walked over and I’m onto grown adults throwing tantrums to get their way. I just won’t have it!

Ganainm488 · 12/01/2024 15:45

I’m so glad you’ve decided to keep the voucher. I know what it’s like to feel bullied by supposedly close family. They can be so good at taking advantage of kind people. You’re right to stick to your guns about the shoes if that’s how you feel. But please leave your DH to buy his family presents from now on. I used to buy my MIL birthday gifts because I felt so bad for her if she didn’t get anything. And my DH would always forget. And typically the wife is blamed as she is expected to buy the presents. But when I handed this responsibility to my DH it changed everything. Of course he forgot the first couple of times but eventually he has taken it on and he buys all his family presents now. I realised that I was taking on the responsibility for someone else’s feelings when it wasn’t my responsibility.

GeckoEcho · 12/01/2024 15:51

Definitiely keep the voucher for yourself.

I believe you. I had a SIL(brother's girlfriend) who was an ungrateful, spoilt shit and she made my mother cry on Christmas Day by refusing a beautiful gift and demanding cash. She also tried the same shit with me and I promptly regifted her gift to my sister who was in the same room. Did I fuck pay her cash.🤣

Their relationship broke down this year after a decade or so and everyone in our family and all my brother's friends are punching the air. Sounds horrible, but she was pointedly vile to absolutely everyone connected with my brother. She even tried to get his boss in trouble with the police over a private Facebook post (after she misunderstood it completely) and was also the only person our family dog ever refused to go near.

Some people are just shit, OP. To hell with these people! And never buy them anything ever again.

ConsuelaHammock · 12/01/2024 15:56

It’s rude to give a gift of clothing without a gift receipt tbh. You assumed you knew what she would like and you got it wrong. Also £150 for a gift for a sil? Just stop doing gifts!? What did she buy you? If you agreed a budget of £150 and she spent £150 on you but you spent £75 on her , I can understand your embarrassment.

phoenixrosehere · 12/01/2024 15:59

She wrote my name on the outside of the box (yes, weird) meaning they can't be returned even if i said it to her....which I won't by the way as I fundamentally don't agree with dissing a gift that someone has bought for you.

How does that mean they can’t be returned? It’s on the box, not the shoes.

ConsuelaHammock · 12/01/2024 16:04

My apologies. I really should have read the full thread before commenting.
I’d start with ‘ If we’re comfortable asking for gifts to be returned would you mind getting me a voucher for the shoes you bought me too. They’re not really my style, colour etc . I didn’t want to say anything but since you felt comfortable to ask me I’m sure you don’t mind me asking you.
Also cut out buying presents. No adult needs several £150 presents from everyone. It’s not acceptable if all participants aren’t willing. Your husband needs to grow a pair and tell his family you’d prefer to spend your Christmas budget on your own family from now on.
She sounds horrible and you sound lovely . But stop trying to keep up with them. Money doesn’t make them better than you. You sound much nicer!

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 12/01/2024 17:35

I have to say, on a scale of weirdness, buying shoes for someone far outranks buying a jumpsuit.

While clothing is a no no, shoes are a "are you fucking insane?!" item. I can try every shoe on in my size in a shoe store and not find a single pair I both like the look of and I feel comfortable in. I NEVER buy shoes from a catalogue.

So op, glad to hear you're keeping the voucher. I rather doubt there would have been anything you could buy that she would be happy with. So try to either stop the gifts for your DH's family or limit it to just his parents and children.

RampantIvy · 12/01/2024 20:00

I can try every shoe on in my size in a shoe store and not find a single pair I both like the look of and I feel comfortable in. I NEVER buy shoes from a catalogue.

@OrderOfTheKookaburra I often wonder how many people have standard shaped feet or whether they just put up with uncomfortable shoes. I can never buy online either. I usually end up trying on 20+ pairs of shoes before I can find any that are comfortable.