Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Spoiling child at Xmas, DP flounced off in a huff

254 replies

PottedPlantsObsess · 12/10/2023 12:43

I have one DD aged 11. Was a single parent till she was 6, met DP when she was 7.

I. At Xmas my daughters total gift budget is $400(around 200 quid). I earn good money and she doesn’t often get bought much here and there, so I think this is fair.

this year I got her tickets to see Pink in the new year, they were about $600 in total, but paid for about six months ago. We live in regional Australia so flights+hotel will be another $1000 on top for the three of us, but it’s DPS birthday while we are there and it’s in the city that his family live in, which we would visit that time of year anyway so I have not considered that $1000 as part of the cost of DD ‘Xmas gift’ as we would usually spend nearly that visiting his fam anyway….

anywho, I told him tonight I was planning on getting her a few extra bits to actually open on Xmas day, like pyjamas a book, maybe some earrings, so she has some stuff to open on the day.

DP has got really wound up, that I’m spending a fortune and spoiling her- setting us up for the next year because we have to match it (I disagree I think she will understand it’s a one off time in a life type thing). He thinks she shouldnt have anything extra on top of the tickets and trip and I’ve already gone way overboard.

we had a bit of a Barney, I think that our usual gift budget is fairly frugal when I compare (thief of joy I know) what other people drop on their kids at Christmas… anyway am I being unreasonable with getting extra gifts to open when I’ve already nearly doubled the usual budget on tickets.

is he being unreasonable to view the hotel and flights as part of the gift expense on her behalf?

is $400 reasonable budget for a kid at Christmas anyway?

OP posts:
Caroparo52 · 12/10/2023 17:46

Sell the moaning wankers DPs ticket.
That resolves it. All you're doing is a night out with your daughter whilst visiting his DPs.
Deffo get the PJs and earrings etc too. FFS he can go without presents at Xmas and just look forward to seeing his DPs.
Is this a sign to consider he wants to control your spending? danger... Get rid?

MojoJojo71 · 12/10/2023 17:47

I’m totally with you. I’ve bought my DD who will be 11 n November tickets for Olivia Rodrigo for Christmas. In total with hotel and travel it’s going to cost £500 for her and I to go. I have never, ever spent that much on a Christmas present for her but, like yours, she will totally freak when she finds out. I know she’ll realise this is a one off special and I wouldn’t dream of not giving her anything else for Christmas. Who does that to a child??

Steev · 12/10/2023 18:00

He sounds like a prick, it's not a present for her to stay in a hotel.

Newestname002 · 12/10/2023 18:01

@PottedPlantsObsess

Reading your OP and further posts made me so sad. No doubt you'll say I'm wrong but your partner sounds so joyless, unbending and unimaginative.

Will he be applying the same "extreme frugality" he's showing now when, for example, your daughter is going to university, or other points in her life, eg her wedding, her wedding dress, presents for any potential future babies, price of her house and furnishings etc etc. How will you deal with any disagreements at these important points in her life? Does he have the final veto? 🌹

Panaa · 12/10/2023 18:03

Someoneonlyyouknow · 12/10/2023 17:33

You know your daughter and whether she is likely to be spoiled by this gift. I think she's old enough to have some idea of prices and realise that she won't get this kind of gift/treat every year. Your usual budget doesn't seem high to me but people's circumstances differ. I have 3 DC and aim to spend roughly equal amounts on each at Christmas but I don't overthink it (if I find a good bargain I don't buy extra to balance the amount spent).
Perhaps point out that a lot of the expense is your annual trip to visit his family and find out if he has other money concerns. I think, even as an adult, that part of the excitement in the lead-up to Christmas is a growing pile of presents under the tree. So I would put the concert ticket in a beautifully wrapped, massive box rather than just an envelope. And a few other little things to open because we all need chocolate, a book and new pjs

They go on the same trip every year, the only difference is this time she gets to go to a concert. She's not going to be spoiled by that.

Mostlyoblivious · 12/10/2023 18:04

Could part of his issue be that as it is such a big gift he felt he should have been involved in the conversation before it was all booked as he is going to be her step Dad and treats her like his own perhaps he felt this removed him from that role somewhat and that you ultimately will always do what you decide? I understand the setting the bar high aspect (however disagree as it clearly is a one off..) but I wonder if it is a few things and what he’s able to verbalise is the financial side of it?

Tbry · 12/10/2023 18:06

She is your DD it is not up to him, he should also have a separate budget which he saves up for for his gifts to you and her.

I also have a child before I met my partner, my partner is my partner not my child’s parent and I always made all child related decisions exactly the same as I did as a single parent. Some years there would be a few gifts with both our names on them (and from the pets too) and then other gifts from me. But usually gifts from me and separate gifts from my partner. My child is an adult now and has a milestone birthday soon, I’m buying little things to open to go with cash. My partner is giving a separate present.

In your case I think the travel costs and the hotel do not count as your DD”s gift they count as the family holiday.

So DD’s gift so far is 1 of the tickets at 300 leaving 100 for other small things to open on the day. That is not extravagant.

OR the ticket is a one off treat, as I think it is, and does not come out of the normal present budget which means there’s still 400 left for her presents, maybe 200 spending money for her special holiday and for new clothes and things whilst on holiday and 200 for standard under the tree gifts.

Panaa · 12/10/2023 18:07

Mostlyoblivious · 12/10/2023 18:04

Could part of his issue be that as it is such a big gift he felt he should have been involved in the conversation before it was all booked as he is going to be her step Dad and treats her like his own perhaps he felt this removed him from that role somewhat and that you ultimately will always do what you decide? I understand the setting the bar high aspect (however disagree as it clearly is a one off..) but I wonder if it is a few things and what he’s able to verbalise is the financial side of it?

Edited

No, because the gift is literally a concert ticket.
They already go to the same place every year to visit his parents.

His issue is that this year he's doing mental gymnastics to pretend that the entire cost for the annual family trip is being spent on the daughters Christmas gift.

He's being an idiot.

Miss93 · 12/10/2023 18:24

dogmandu · 12/10/2023 16:38

with the state of the world with many children not getting anything, I think it's a hell of a lot of money to spend on one little girl.
If it were me and I had that much money to spare I'd feel much happier giving some of it away, especially at Christmas .

I really doubt that.
Kids shouldn't be held responsible for the worlds ills.

She's seeing someone who might never go to Australia again,what about the 11 year old,is she not allowed to have anything nice because some other child somewhere hasn't got the same.

Haffiana · 12/10/2023 18:35

Christ on a stick, OP. Stop justifying enabling a miserly tight-arse to indulge in his obsession with not spending money. If you don't 'equate spending money with love', then why not just spend it because it will be a nice thing for your daughter? It won't mean you love her less either, will it?

Just stop enabling his beloved hobby, which is not spending money. If he doesn't like spending money and you 'are in agreement' that being given an unwrapped frugal, cheap day in a tent or whatever is the acme of your relationship, then fine.

But don't let it affect your daughter. And it will affect her, just like a parent with an eating disorder will affect their DC unless they can keep it utterly hidden.

Miserliness is the single most unattractive thing in a partner. Most women would run a mile. Look at you tying yourself in knots to demonstrate how frugal you are, how your values agree - all of that you are performing for him. Of course you imagine you have the same values because you have always gone along with his wishes until now. Now you can finally see what he is. Do not ignore this.

Daisybuttercup12345 · 12/10/2023 18:38

KombuchaKalling · 12/10/2023 12:45

None of his business. He’s your boyfriend, not her Dad.

This. And he wouldn't be a boyfriend for much longer if he behaved like that to me.

Haffiana · 12/10/2023 18:40

dogmandu · 12/10/2023 16:38

with the state of the world with many children not getting anything, I think it's a hell of a lot of money to spend on one little girl.
If it were me and I had that much money to spare I'd feel much happier giving some of it away, especially at Christmas .

But you still have your laptop and mobile phone, don't you? Why haven't you given those away to someone who has nothing?

You are living in luxury and yet preaching to others...

Lose10kyesterday · 12/10/2023 18:42

Panaa · 12/10/2023 18:07

No, because the gift is literally a concert ticket.
They already go to the same place every year to visit his parents.

His issue is that this year he's doing mental gymnastics to pretend that the entire cost for the annual family trip is being spent on the daughters Christmas gift.

He's being an idiot.

@Panaa - I agree totally. All these mental gymnastics some respondents are doing to make it look as if the OP is in the wrong somehow are ridiculous and quite frightening. He's the selfish bellend, not her.

billy1966 · 12/10/2023 18:44

OP,

Her gift is her ticket.

You going with her is a part of your choice to choose this treat.

It is utterly bizarre that you wouldn't challenge his assertions that the expensive yearly trip to visit HIS family, happening at the same time this year as the concert, is now part of your daughters gift.

He sounds absolutely awful.

How could you not challenge such a manipulative misrepresentation of the facts.

Are you really so blind as to not see how awful it is for him to begrudge you spending YOUR money on YOUR child?

He's no prize.

You are her mother.

You should be absolutely appalled at finding yourself so close to marrying a man so determined to begrudge your small child a few little things Christmas morning.

He sounds mean, manipulative and begrudging of a child.

Absolute ICK.

Nepmarthiturn · 12/10/2023 18:49

He's bonkers. As if you should leave an 11 year-old with no physical gifts to open on Christmas day.

As you say, what you spend on her is modest anyway. Even if it wasn't, treating children doesn't "spoil" them any more than cuddling a crying baby "spoils" them. If they appreciate what they get then why should you not treat them if you can afford to and want to?

He sounds very selfish that he's happy for far more than that to be spent on things he wants to do but not on your DD.

And frankly it's none of his business! Tell him you are her parent, you will make the parenting decisions and to keep his opinions to himself from now on.

AlexandriasWindmill · 12/10/2023 18:51

The cost of her ticket is her gift. The logistics of getting there are your's. I recently took DD to a concert. I wouldn't have dreamt of counting the travel and hotel costs as part of her gift. It would be the equivalent of charging her whenever I drive her somewhere.
I know you're surprised at the pushback against your DP but that's because you're viewing this as a budgeting issue. It isn't. Even frugal families get their DCs more than one gift for Christmas. So your DP's view that opening one thing is enough is waving a tiny red flag and sounding little alarm bells, especially when it's coming after you've set a wedding date, etc. That shift towards becoming married is often a time when a man can become more controlling and start to exert more authority over all the family relationships, holidays and spending. It's something to be aware of and monitor.

WeWereInParis · 12/10/2023 19:07

we share finances

You are unreasonable to share finances with someone and then spend a large sum of money without discussing it. This is regardless of whether the present is reasonable. I don't think you can share finances with someone and then also say they have no say over presents for your child when they're coming from joint money.
The concert tickets were more than your normal budget, I don't think they were excessive but I also don't think that's really the point.

Don't share finances if you don't want to discuss purchases.

potatoheads · 12/10/2023 19:14

2 or 3 tickets? If it's 3 then 200 plus bits and pieces. That's less than the normal 400. Even if it was 300 for her plus but then it's around 400. SURELY HE ISN'T COUNTING HIS/YOUR ticket as her present???? And the accommodation doesn't count as you'd be doing that anyway. What's wrong with him?

Tiredmum100 · 12/10/2023 19:47

No one would ever tell me what I could or could not spend on my dc. I think your partner is being unreasonable.

Nepmarthiturn · 12/10/2023 20:02

I don’t think his actions are because he begrudges our child a nice Christmas or gifts, even though he doesn’t see the point of Christmas connected to presents…

Why don't you think this, when it's exactly what he has told you?

in the heat of the moment it came across that he felt like we were setting ourselves up for year on year ‘topping’ last years presents which is really out of line with both our values…..but maybe on reflection he is worried about money, we’ve spent a lot on the house this year and putting money aside to get married, I hold the purse strings so maybe he just sees me spending and hasn’t seen me squirrelling for the last few years…

im pretty blown away by all the ‘not her dad, not his business’ comments.

So he is happy to spend lots of money on what he wants: the house, the wedding, expensive annual trips to visit his family. Yet some pyjamas for your daughter will break the bank?

God, it sounds thoroughly miserable. Miserable miserliness.

People have said that it isn't his business because it isn't. She is your child. And since he has demonstrated such an ungenerous attitude towards her you need to ensure that you put a very firm boundary in place that he will not be dictating how you parent her.

ElizaMulvil · 12/10/2023 20:16

He's training you in preparation for your life after the wedding.
He's jealous of your love for your daughter and wants you to put him first. ( Compensation for subconscious resentment towards his parents for behaving like he does?) This you will prove when you defer to him on all decisions ( otherwise he will strop).

You are going to spend your time being anxious about how he will react if you want to pay for tennis lessons, throw a party, pay for a tutor, buy a prom dress, give her money for Uni fees etc etc. So the risk is you won't do them for an easy life.

Only it won't be an easy life for you daughter . She will be picking up on the situation soon enough when she sees how other parents behave. She'll wonder why you couldn't help her in the same way even though you had the money.

The risk is she will leave for Uni and rarely return because she will be faced with a barage of objections to any request for money ( ie they will be refused ) and/or objections to every thing she spends for herself. The easy thing will be to not discuss things with you.

You will be here in 8 -10 years time wondering why she hardly ever sees you.

billy1966 · 12/10/2023 22:57

@ElizaMulvil great post and on the money.

That child will be long gone and will judge her mother harshly for bringing into her life a mean jealous man that disputed any money spent on her.

She will see her mother, her poor choices and the consequences clearly.

How anyone would feel confident marrying a man that would begrudge a child a few Christmas presents is beyond me.

Ilovelifeverymuch · 12/10/2023 23:29

KombuchaKalling · 12/10/2023 12:45

None of his business. He’s your boyfriend, not her Dad.

That's the wrong mentality to have if he has been in her life for about 5 years and this is a committed long term relationship.

To OPs question if it's one off then there nothing wrong getting her other things for Christmas day, maybe not spend the whole $400 budget depending on your finances, but to say he should just mind his business etc is so wrong and if that's the case OP should just stay single then.

They are now a family not f**k buddies.

Ilovelifeverymuch · 12/10/2023 23:35

Tiredmum100 · 12/10/2023 19:47

No one would ever tell me what I could or could not spend on my dc. I think your partner is being unreasonable.

Nonsense. They are now a family and share finances so they should be discussing and agreeing spending, it doesn't matter if it's for OPs daughter or not.

I do agree that given the Pink tickets are one of she can still get her somethings for Christmas day itself but this mentality of don't tell me what to do with my child is so wrong when you're in a committed relationship and he is a major part of the child's life.

If OP doesn't want him to have a say I'm her daughters life then please breakup and go focus on your daughter.

oohsharon · 12/10/2023 23:36

"That's the wrong mentality to have if he has been in her life for about 5 years and this is a committed long term relationship."

Committed to what? Making her feel like shit for wrapping up a book and some pjs? Not that he would wrap them up of course, he's too frugal and doesn't "do" that.

Long term? They didn't even meet until this girl was 7, she's only 11 now. And there's some bloke huffing and storming off because her mum wants to give her a few small things to open on Christmas Day. Bought with money she earned.