Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Spoiling child at Xmas, DP flounced off in a huff

254 replies

PottedPlantsObsess · 12/10/2023 12:43

I have one DD aged 11. Was a single parent till she was 6, met DP when she was 7.

I. At Xmas my daughters total gift budget is $400(around 200 quid). I earn good money and she doesn’t often get bought much here and there, so I think this is fair.

this year I got her tickets to see Pink in the new year, they were about $600 in total, but paid for about six months ago. We live in regional Australia so flights+hotel will be another $1000 on top for the three of us, but it’s DPS birthday while we are there and it’s in the city that his family live in, which we would visit that time of year anyway so I have not considered that $1000 as part of the cost of DD ‘Xmas gift’ as we would usually spend nearly that visiting his fam anyway….

anywho, I told him tonight I was planning on getting her a few extra bits to actually open on Xmas day, like pyjamas a book, maybe some earrings, so she has some stuff to open on the day.

DP has got really wound up, that I’m spending a fortune and spoiling her- setting us up for the next year because we have to match it (I disagree I think she will understand it’s a one off time in a life type thing). He thinks she shouldnt have anything extra on top of the tickets and trip and I’ve already gone way overboard.

we had a bit of a Barney, I think that our usual gift budget is fairly frugal when I compare (thief of joy I know) what other people drop on their kids at Christmas… anyway am I being unreasonable with getting extra gifts to open when I’ve already nearly doubled the usual budget on tickets.

is he being unreasonable to view the hotel and flights as part of the gift expense on her behalf?

is $400 reasonable budget for a kid at Christmas anyway?

OP posts:
TomatoSandwiches · 12/10/2023 16:15

The flights, hotel and ticket for you are not part of her present.
You were right to consider it 2 birds 1 stone.
Also, it's fine to spend £££ to visit his family but not treat your daughter as a one off for Christmas?

It is a fact op which is why people are saying it. He isn't her father, she has one already and you aren't married yet.

PottedPlantsObsess · 12/10/2023 16:19

INeedAnotherName · 12/10/2023 15:50

he was raised extremely frugally and his family do not really do gifts (other than his mum sending things for DD)
neither of us are big on gifts, we usually go camping to celebrate each others birthdays or he makes me something, he usually makes something for DD too, although he gives her this on Christmas Eve because that’s more in line with the way his family celebrated when he was a child. He never even wraps it

I repeat - He never even wraps it

He's a fucking tight arse. And you typing extremely frugally means you subconsciously know that too. I bet no expense is spared when he's the recipient but not you or the daughter. A miserable miser.

And in what land is buying a book or pyjamas to unwrap is spoiling? Seriously!?

He actually gets extremely uncomfortable with expensive gifts.

his family came here on humanitarian visas so I think frugal is right. He and they are by no means tight arses. His family is extremely generous, they would give you the clothes of their backs if that’s what you needed- as would my partner, he just can’t reconcile spending lots of money on gifts.
I think in this case he is over reacting, but I would never describe him as a miserable miser. We have a nice life and are lucky to not feel pressured to afford the necessities.

OP posts:
PrinceHaz · 12/10/2023 16:22

I think the fact that you generally align with his no presents (between you and him) philosophy means that you don’t get the opportunity to assess his level of meanness moneywise.
I wonder, if you were the type to like romantic presents, well thought out birthday and Christmas presents that cost a bit - would he compromise with you or would he stick rigidly to his position?

Lollypop701 · 12/10/2023 16:24

Yanbu. You can say your ticket is DD present… it’s for both of you and you will love the experience of the concert. So you are getting a gift this year too.

The flights are a family holiday that you do every year. More expensive perhaps but that’s not her responsibility. Also the extra things you are suggesting would be normal thing’s she would need anyway? Pjs, books, nice deodorant, hair clips. So you’re just buying them at Christmas, she would need them throughout the year.

Imo the only thing you have bought specifically for her is 1 ticket .. so the extras are included in the extra 100 you would usually spend.

DH is allocating all of the cost to DD for Christmas.. if you split it out maybe your partner will calm down, plus explaining you have the money as you mentioned you are spending on house and saving for wedding. (Oh and I think the fact he’s a step dad is a red herring, you are a family)

Nanaof1 · 12/10/2023 16:24

I think that having one special "big" Christmas is wonderful. I would also want to get my DC a few little things to open on Christmas Day too. Maybe a tee to wear to the concert, a poster, and all of your ideas are great. PJs are always fun and so are earrings. I always loved the "little things" to buy for DD. DS was not so easy for little things when he was a tween/teen but DD was a blast.

TomatoSandwiches · 12/10/2023 16:26

" he just can’t reconcile spending lots of money on gifts. "

It's an experience more so than a physical item isn't it, not that it should matter.

He gets to spend £800 every year on the experience of seeing family.
He's more than ok about spending money on his things op.

Gymnopedie · 12/10/2023 16:33

his opinion is that the flights and hotel are also included, therefore I’ve spent $1600 rather tha. $400 like I’m normally would.

Are you paying for it all OP? Cut the cost. Go see Pink just you and DD, that will save you his fares and hotel. Then all the cost is related to her Christmas present.

If he wants to go and see his family then that's a separate trip, organised and paid for separately. And I'm not really joking. Genuinely I think the fact that you'll be combining the two is muddying the water because it's increasing the cost even though the extra isn't going to DD in any way. It will bring home to him how much he's benefitting from your generosity. And if he doesn't think you should be generous with DD, why should you be generous with him?

Justkeepingplatesspinning · 12/10/2023 16:36

I thought this was going to be about too many presents or something.
P!nk tickets are a once in a childhood thing, I'd not be seeing those as Christmas gifts to be honest. And you are in for an amazing experience, her show is fabulous (we saw her in Sunderland this summer).
Having something to open on the day isn't being spoiled.
As for your DP, he's sulking and in a strop for some reason. Does he not like P!nk? Leave him at home to stew in his own juices.

dogmandu · 12/10/2023 16:38

with the state of the world with many children not getting anything, I think it's a hell of a lot of money to spend on one little girl.
If it were me and I had that much money to spare I'd feel much happier giving some of it away, especially at Christmas .

Strictlyfanoftenyears · 12/10/2023 16:41

dogmandu · 12/10/2023 16:38

with the state of the world with many children not getting anything, I think it's a hell of a lot of money to spend on one little girl.
If it were me and I had that much money to spare I'd feel much happier giving some of it away, especially at Christmas .

Really?

newYear10 · 12/10/2023 16:41

200 isn't a lot to spend on in any case so I don't know what's the big deal. It seems like you can easily afford it so what's the issue?? I would tell him to butt out really.

Sunplant · 12/10/2023 16:46

Of course you should get her things to open on the day. Your DP is being unreasonable and ridiculous. Why would she expect the same spent on her next year? Children don't tend to add up the cost of their gifts and compare how much has been spent on them from one year to the next

ginasevern · 12/10/2023 16:48

@PottedPlantsObsess

OP, I don't think £200 is remotely unreasonable to spend on your daughter at Christmas and I think the Pink tickets are a wonderful idea. I also think you should buy her something to open on Christmas Day. But, I'm wondering whether your partner is worried about something else which is has manifesres in his outburst about Christmas. If it was me I would dig a little deeper as his trantrum about presents could be masking a bigger concern.

Mari9999 · 12/10/2023 16:50

@PottedPlantsObsess
I imagine that it is difficult to see money spent in was that seem extravagant when you have experienced a life that money was in short supply.. However there is a difference between waste and occasional indulgence.

You both sound very responsible, but what is the purpose of hard work if not to provide a comfortable life with occasional indulgences for your children? Your children then learn that a comfortable life comes through hard work and effort. That is a valuable life lesson.

I don't think that this has anything to do with who is the father or father figure. Biological parents can have differing opinions related to gift giving and often longer discussions are needed.

In our case it was always helpful to remember exactly why we work so hard and what kind of lifestyle that we want to provide for our kids. We have ensured that they know that every gift and benefit flows from hard work and considerable effort.

Panaa · 12/10/2023 16:52

PottedPlantsObsess · 12/10/2023 16:04

I think we both attributed the two tickets(mine and hers) as her gift (600) but reading through the posts maybe that’s a stretch and therefore (my opinion) yes there would be 100 left….

his opinion is that the flights and hotel are also included, therefore I’ve spent $1600 rather tha. $400 like I’m normally would.

we normally go see his family around that time of year and would be booking flights and a hotel anyway (although prices definitely are inflated that week due to the concert and Valentine’s Day) so if it was just going to see his family would normally be much less-maybe $800

So the trip is only an extra $200 and would have cost that extra $200 anyway because prices would be inflated whether you were going to the concert or not because you always go at this that time of year.

So the cost of the trip isn't relevant, you got 2 tickets and one is for your daughter and one is for you which will be an amazing experience and memory for you too....so her gift was $300.

Panaa · 12/10/2023 16:54

dogmandu · 12/10/2023 16:38

with the state of the world with many children not getting anything, I think it's a hell of a lot of money to spend on one little girl.
If it were me and I had that much money to spare I'd feel much happier giving some of it away, especially at Christmas .

It's not all on the girl though is it?

They go to the same place every year anyway 😂so that is already an annual trip they take.

OP bought 2 tickets, one for her, one for her daughter....so it's literally £150 for the daughters ticket.

SapphireSeptember · 12/10/2023 16:55

dogmandu · 12/10/2023 16:38

with the state of the world with many children not getting anything, I think it's a hell of a lot of money to spend on one little girl.
If it were me and I had that much money to spare I'd feel much happier giving some of it away, especially at Christmas .

Um, I spent quite a lot of money to go and see my favourite band last year (I paid for the ticket in 2019) but the hotel and train fare, plus taxi to and from the venue, food, and buying merch soon added up. Obviously no one is allowed to do anything nice because the world is going to hell. 🙄

SapphireSeptember · 12/10/2023 16:59

Actually, thinking about it, I can't fix the world's problems. If the worst happens and WW3 kicks off and I die, at least I'll have done things that make me happy, rather than worry about it all and made myself miserable.

MrsMarzetti · 12/10/2023 17:21

Get rid of the boyfriend.

LivingDeadGirlUK · 12/10/2023 17:22

What is his response when you point out the below

'his opinion is that the flights and hotel are also included, therefore I’ve spent $1600 rather tha. $400 like I’m normally would.

we normally go see his family around that time of year and would be booking flights and a hotel anyway (although prices definitely are inflated that week due to the concert and Valentine’s Day) so if it was just going to see his family would normally be much less-maybe $800'

Do you have any niggles about the relationship at all? It's quite common for men who are checking out of a relationship or getting cold feet to not mentally commit to future time together. Sorry its a random tangent to what you are asking but its odd he can't see these costs are something that would be spent anyway.

Someoneonlyyouknow · 12/10/2023 17:33

You know your daughter and whether she is likely to be spoiled by this gift. I think she's old enough to have some idea of prices and realise that she won't get this kind of gift/treat every year. Your usual budget doesn't seem high to me but people's circumstances differ. I have 3 DC and aim to spend roughly equal amounts on each at Christmas but I don't overthink it (if I find a good bargain I don't buy extra to balance the amount spent).
Perhaps point out that a lot of the expense is your annual trip to visit his family and find out if he has other money concerns. I think, even as an adult, that part of the excitement in the lead-up to Christmas is a growing pile of presents under the tree. So I would put the concert ticket in a beautifully wrapped, massive box rather than just an envelope. And a few other little things to open because we all need chocolate, a book and new pjs

Lavenderflower · 12/10/2023 17:36

I think it depends on your actual circumstances; if you can afford by all means go ahead. He attitude and opinion regarding money may have to with his own upbringing etc My friend took her son abroad for his birthday - she wasn't able to afford to him much else however, he really appreciated going on holiday.

Blinkityblonk · 12/10/2023 17:41

He actually gets extremely uncomfortable with expensive gifts perhaps he shouldn't go to Pink or the hotel or to see his family in that destination to save money? Hmm, thought not.

I hate these posts, I hope one day to open a thread that says something like 'AIBU, my partner/boyfriend/new husband is undermining me by being really nice all the time to my children, he buys them lots of presents and is always so generous with his time and energy, it's making me look bad and grumpy.'

Sadly, it's always men, from outside, who don't want the children to have money, gifts, time, energy, are naughty, are not parented properly, need more discipline, need less of everything else. It's so sad and makes me determined there will never be another man in my house in any type of parental role, as there just aren't enough good ones.

JustWimpy · 12/10/2023 17:41

"He has no issue with the trip at all. He thinks it’s a great Christmas gift."

This is directly contradicted by you saying in your OP that he thought you had 'already gone way overboard' with the tickets. Interesting how he sees spending money annually on flights and a hotel for him to see his parents is fine, but not for your DD to see a once off concert.

It's a bit depressing that he's trained you to think that gifts for yourself 'aren't your thing'.

Blinkityblonk · 12/10/2023 17:42

I mean what mum would think up not giving their own child a present to open on Christmas Day? Whatever their big gift is.