Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Spoiling child at Xmas, DP flounced off in a huff

254 replies

PottedPlantsObsess · 12/10/2023 12:43

I have one DD aged 11. Was a single parent till she was 6, met DP when she was 7.

I. At Xmas my daughters total gift budget is $400(around 200 quid). I earn good money and she doesn’t often get bought much here and there, so I think this is fair.

this year I got her tickets to see Pink in the new year, they were about $600 in total, but paid for about six months ago. We live in regional Australia so flights+hotel will be another $1000 on top for the three of us, but it’s DPS birthday while we are there and it’s in the city that his family live in, which we would visit that time of year anyway so I have not considered that $1000 as part of the cost of DD ‘Xmas gift’ as we would usually spend nearly that visiting his fam anyway….

anywho, I told him tonight I was planning on getting her a few extra bits to actually open on Xmas day, like pyjamas a book, maybe some earrings, so she has some stuff to open on the day.

DP has got really wound up, that I’m spending a fortune and spoiling her- setting us up for the next year because we have to match it (I disagree I think she will understand it’s a one off time in a life type thing). He thinks she shouldnt have anything extra on top of the tickets and trip and I’ve already gone way overboard.

we had a bit of a Barney, I think that our usual gift budget is fairly frugal when I compare (thief of joy I know) what other people drop on their kids at Christmas… anyway am I being unreasonable with getting extra gifts to open when I’ve already nearly doubled the usual budget on tickets.

is he being unreasonable to view the hotel and flights as part of the gift expense on her behalf?

is $400 reasonable budget for a kid at Christmas anyway?

OP posts:
BowlOfNoodles · 13/10/2023 15:54

Its actually none of hes business

Mememe9898 · 13/10/2023 16:20

oohsharon · 12/10/2023 14:50

"Half of 11 is 5.5 years, we’ve been together for five years… so yes, he has been around for half of her life."

I know it is. My point was that at first you said you didn't even meet him until she was 7. Now she was 5.5 🤷🏽‍♀️ it doesn't matter either way but if you're trying to make it sound more solid than it is then you should take a moment to work out why.

I also didn't say that expensive gifts equal love. I was suggesting that he wouldn't have huffed if this was his own child. He doesn't love her like his own, she's not his own. And he wants her to stay cheap, well, kids only get more expensive.

Why would he not get annoyed if it is his own child? Surely if he disagrees with spending large sums of money on gifts whether it’s his biological kid or not is what matters. I’m incredibly frugal and have two kids. I wouldn’t spend £400 on them at Xmas but I do buy them lots of things throughout the year albeit small inexpensive things.
Hes allowed to disagree but in this case I don’t think it’s necessarily just for her as the whole family benefits so I wouldn’t count the full amount as her Xmas gift. Sounds like mum wants to go too.

Mememe9898 · 13/10/2023 16:28

PottedPlantsObsess · 13/10/2023 10:05

Your absolutely right.

it is a maths problem, and a miscommunication problem.

after reading all these responses I’m feeling super grateful for my family and my life and realise that in the heat of the moment I took a black and white approach- so many black and white answers here, confronting to think this attitude occurs when not even remotely caught up in the emotion of the issue like I was.

my partner has a different approach. I respect him and therefore I consider this. We talked and he recognises his paper was lit also.

its a complete non issue now.

as awful as many many many of these responses were (I’m an unloving parent, he’s abusive, my daughter will be detached and miserable as an adult, we are miserly as a family) …. It was a huge lesson in looking at issues from an aerial rather than a pinhole perspective…

I walk away from this being grateful that we are not material people and neither is our child (his badly worded assumption that this could ever make her so forgiven), that our mutual respect for each other is only strengthened by the sheer uninformed judgement that as a ‘step’ parent his opinion is somehow less.

I am grateful that our relationship does not hinge on one disagreement, that we can negotiate our differences and not burn what we have built in a ball of flames simply because we do not agree on one thing. That we can compromise, forgive and move forward as a family.

I am happy for so many of these commenters that have either never had to traverse the challenges of familial separation or blended families- but a word of warning, matching DNA does not give you a parenting gold access card and perhaps a little more recognition of the extra love, care and effort required to walk into pre-existing family’s life. How sad that we as a community still blame the parent that stayed and exclude the parent that CHOSE to step in.

I hope you all have a wonderful Christmas, as I know we will - focusing on what matters, how we show up for each other every day, in ways that matter and investing energy and time- rather than $$$

Great response. From my experience of Mumsnet, most people tell you to “get rid” of your partner when they disagree with you.
If they don’t do as you ask them they are abusive 🫣
People on here blow things so out of proportion and also wonder why there relationships fail when there’s no compromise and open communication. Sounds like you have found a mutual solution. My advice - don’t ask for relationship advice on mumsnet as there seems to be a lot of bitter and angry people on here. I’m normally here to read the drama 😂

Panaa · 13/10/2023 16:33

Ilovelifeverymuch · 13/10/2023 15:21

That's fine if that's how you want to manage your finances but OP shares finances with her partner so again there is no "I will do what I want here" they both have to be on the same page and discuss and agree.

And the fact you have a mentality of I will do what I want even when married to the father of your children doesn't mean that is the right way to do it, it is not.

This is the same mentality that leads to the many posts we have on mumsnet where the woman is at a disadvantage because she earns less than her husband due to taking time to look after kids and the husband takes a "it's my money so I will do what I want" approach leaving her struggling while he spends money on hobbies or "saves" it for them even though she doesn't have any access to the so called family savings.

Sorry to disappoint you but that is not what true marriage and partnership is about.

Edited

Sharing finances for most couples doesn't tend to mean that they run every single purchase by their partner. Most have a bit of purchasing freedom. They certainly don't run every purchase by their partner.
All she bought was concert tickets.

StarlightLime · 13/10/2023 16:34

You said you met your dp when your dd was 7, op. Presumably he didn't take on a stepfatherly role immediately? If she's 11 now, that's not so very long at all.

Ilovelifeverymuch · 13/10/2023 17:07

Panaa · 13/10/2023 16:33

Sharing finances for most couples doesn't tend to mean that they run every single purchase by their partner. Most have a bit of purchasing freedom. They certainly don't run every purchase by their partner.
All she bought was concert tickets.

Sharing finances means you agree how much you can spend without discussing and we can agree that for majority of people expenses running into £1-£2k warrants a discussion. This threshold will obviously depend on income of the higher your income the higher the threshold and risk tolerance of both parties.

If OP has said that have agreed they can both spend 10k without discussing then that's fine as that's what they have agreed but this obviously not the case is it?

And when it comes to things like gifts for kids Christmas you should both be on the same page rather than each person doing what they want and end up buying different competing presents just because you can't talk and agree like adults.

As I said already I think it's fine to buy some gifts for her to open to Christmas day given the tickets are one off but I disagree with the "I will do what I want" mindset.

Nepmarthiturn · 13/10/2023 17:10

Ladyj84 · 13/10/2023 00:04

I think in a good marriage first it doesn't matter after years who's child it is and second things should be discussed and come to an agreement

Of course it matters. Particularly when the boyfriend is happy to spend multiple thousands of pounds on things he wants but begrudges an 11 year old a few inexpensive Christmas gifts because no decent parent would prioritise themselves over their child in that way, so his attitude towards her is different to that of a parent. That is why parents need to do parenting, not parents' partners.

Panaa · 13/10/2023 17:34

Ilovelifeverymuch · 13/10/2023 17:07

Sharing finances means you agree how much you can spend without discussing and we can agree that for majority of people expenses running into £1-£2k warrants a discussion. This threshold will obviously depend on income of the higher your income the higher the threshold and risk tolerance of both parties.

If OP has said that have agreed they can both spend 10k without discussing then that's fine as that's what they have agreed but this obviously not the case is it?

And when it comes to things like gifts for kids Christmas you should both be on the same page rather than each person doing what they want and end up buying different competing presents just because you can't talk and agree like adults.

As I said already I think it's fine to buy some gifts for her to open to Christmas day given the tickets are one off but I disagree with the "I will do what I want" mindset.

Edited

The expenses didn't run into £1k to £2k though.
They go on a trip to the same place to see his family at that time of year annually anyway.

The extra spend was literally just £300 on concert tickets.

But for some bizarre reason the DP decided to make out that the entire cost of the trip was all to do with the daughter and the concert, which isn't the case, because they would have went on the trip anyway.

Coop21 · 14/10/2023 10:43

I would only include her ticket for Christmas and get her a few more things, I can’t imagine only getting a concert ticket for my child especially if I can afford it, I love seeing my kids faces on Christmas morning opening presents, I have 5 kids and we do give them a bit more at Christmas as they don’t always getting treated throughout the year. I always try and buy in the sales as boys are in men’s clothes so can be expensive. My partner doesn’t really say much about what I spend as he knows that I am more than capable to budget and give our kids a nice Christmas as well.

Harry12345 · 14/10/2023 17:01

Taking your child to concerts and fun experiences is not spoiling them materially and even more so with books and pyjamas, life is short and you have one child, it goes fast, have fun

TeamGeriatric · 14/10/2023 17:51

As others have said, at 11 she still needs stuff to open on Xmas day. Whilst she will love the concert, I am sure she'd feel disappointed on Christmas day if she only had a piece of paper to open. I spend about the same as you do on my kids for Xmas, and track my spending fairly religiously to make it as equitable as possible between the kids. My husband usually leaves the shopping to me, so he never really checks what I'm spending. The couple of times we've bought a bike as a birthday present I've still got my daughter a few things to open as well as that's important to them, even if the bike has well exceeded the usual budget. I think you need to negotiate hard with your other half on this.

Daisyblue77 · 15/10/2023 11:22

All these people saying its none if his business are incorrect, as you say you live together and he is ‘dad’ . No i dont think its too much. Its a one off treat, soubds amazing, an i agree for her to have presents to open at christmas. Shes a child and money means nothing to her, i hope it all works out you have a great time x

Beezknees · 15/10/2023 11:51

Daisyblue77 · 15/10/2023 11:22

All these people saying its none if his business are incorrect, as you say you live together and he is ‘dad’ . No i dont think its too much. Its a one off treat, soubds amazing, an i agree for her to have presents to open at christmas. Shes a child and money means nothing to her, i hope it all works out you have a great time x

It's still none of his business what OP spends on her child unless she is getting into debt to do it.

Daisyblue77 · 15/10/2023 13:46

Of course it is. You cant be in a live in relationship with someone acting as a step parent and then when suits you say “ it nothing to do with you “. But still expect them to care for the child as if they are their own

JenniferJuniper80 · 15/10/2023 13:56

I couldn't put up with living with such a fun sponge!
Were his childhood christmasses miserable?

StarlightLime · 15/10/2023 13:58

Daisyblue77 · 15/10/2023 13:46

Of course it is. You cant be in a live in relationship with someone acting as a step parent and then when suits you say “ it nothing to do with you “. But still expect them to care for the child as if they are their own

He is a live in boyfriend. Not a step parent.

Op has tried to fudge the numbers by claiming that the man she met when her 11 year old dd was 7 has been involved with her dd for half her life, but it's clearly nonsense.

Layla30 · 15/10/2023 14:10

After just pricing up a PS5 that my DS has spoken about I think that gift for your DD Christmas is absolutely fine along with some things to open on the day.
I personally spend around £300 on my children for Christmas but use it to get something big and I would imagine most folk are the same.
Ignore the ones shouting about red flags that’s just some trying to be as negative as they can in true mumsnet style!!

ThinWomansBrain · 15/10/2023 14:13

If you've got a concert ticket for him too, sell it. If you've booked the flights already, is his refundable?

Tbry · 15/10/2023 15:26

Enjoy your Christmas OP and the concert with your daughter.

Some of the comments on here are literally beyond me. I have no idea how some mumsnet mums get these bizarre opinions 🤷‍♀️. I’ve been with my partner a couple of decades we have a joint mortgage and joint bills we also have our own money, lives, hobbies and interests as I thought all humans do?

My adult sons milestone birthday is in November, we will both be buying him separate gifts so he has some things to open. We all buy each other gifts every birthday and Christmas.

He is my beloved son, I only have one child, and all decisions relating to my son whilst he grew up were mine entirely from the moment he was born. Even now all these years later I feel exactly the same on this topic as I’m the one who lived through DV and was the lone parent NOT my partner. So my son is literally that MY son.

And as well as the bits I’d already bought for him I have just bought him some expensive tech too…..did I check with my partner first???? Did I heck!

If I honestly had to check with my partner in advance of a purchase I am paying for for a gift I think that would be the end our relationship 😳

YerArseInParsley · 15/10/2023 16:40

PottedPlantsObsess · 12/10/2023 12:43

I have one DD aged 11. Was a single parent till she was 6, met DP when she was 7.

I. At Xmas my daughters total gift budget is $400(around 200 quid). I earn good money and she doesn’t often get bought much here and there, so I think this is fair.

this year I got her tickets to see Pink in the new year, they were about $600 in total, but paid for about six months ago. We live in regional Australia so flights+hotel will be another $1000 on top for the three of us, but it’s DPS birthday while we are there and it’s in the city that his family live in, which we would visit that time of year anyway so I have not considered that $1000 as part of the cost of DD ‘Xmas gift’ as we would usually spend nearly that visiting his fam anyway….

anywho, I told him tonight I was planning on getting her a few extra bits to actually open on Xmas day, like pyjamas a book, maybe some earrings, so she has some stuff to open on the day.

DP has got really wound up, that I’m spending a fortune and spoiling her- setting us up for the next year because we have to match it (I disagree I think she will understand it’s a one off time in a life type thing). He thinks she shouldnt have anything extra on top of the tickets and trip and I’ve already gone way overboard.

we had a bit of a Barney, I think that our usual gift budget is fairly frugal when I compare (thief of joy I know) what other people drop on their kids at Christmas… anyway am I being unreasonable with getting extra gifts to open when I’ve already nearly doubled the usual budget on tickets.

is he being unreasonable to view the hotel and flights as part of the gift expense on her behalf?

is $400 reasonable budget for a kid at Christmas anyway?

@PottedPlantsObsess
The only gift your daughter is getting out of this is one pink ticket. The other tickets are yours and DP's and the flights and accommodation is between 3 and it's also to visit HIS family so that doesn't make all that your daughters present.

Tell him if he wants to play it that way then the trip is also HIS present. One pink ticket is not enough, of course your daughter will need more presents to open. You do what you want with your daughter and tell him to get stuffed.

Beezknees · 15/10/2023 16:56

Daisyblue77 · 15/10/2023 13:46

Of course it is. You cant be in a live in relationship with someone acting as a step parent and then when suits you say “ it nothing to do with you “. But still expect them to care for the child as if they are their own

I wouldn't expect any step parent to care for a child as if it were their own. That's movie nonsense.

girlfriend44 · 15/10/2023 17:30

Why does a child need a load of gifts because it's Christmas? Don't they have a birthday?

Making a rod for your own back springs to mind.

It's not the presents they remember anyway, it's the simple things.

Some replies are gross. Of course your daughter will need more presents to open.
Why?

Lindar79 · 15/10/2023 18:58

I’d say that budget is fairly small but everyone can only do what they can afford. Honestly. I’d give my boys the earth at Christmas if I could because they deserve it ! You spend what you want on her and I absolutely guarantee when the shoe is on the other foot he won’t be saying that ! Ditch him before it’s too late. He doesn’t see your daughter as an equal.

Lindar79 · 15/10/2023 19:00

Then you should step away. To suggest you can’t love a child that isn’t your own in the same way is quite frankly ludicrous and narrow minded

SpatulaSpatula · 15/10/2023 19:46

Bizarre responses! I think he's being very unreasonable in terms of what he's counting towards the expense of her present, and perhaps he's struggling a bit with the contrast between his childhood and hers. Worth unpicking with him but I can't see any abuse and WTAF is going on with people thinking it's none of his business? I'm sure you'll resolve things and your DD is going to be absolutely over the moon. The fact that you're even here discussing this shows there's absolutely no way she'll see this as the norm and turn into an entitled brat.