Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Spoiling child at Xmas, DP flounced off in a huff

254 replies

PottedPlantsObsess · 12/10/2023 12:43

I have one DD aged 11. Was a single parent till she was 6, met DP when she was 7.

I. At Xmas my daughters total gift budget is $400(around 200 quid). I earn good money and she doesn’t often get bought much here and there, so I think this is fair.

this year I got her tickets to see Pink in the new year, they were about $600 in total, but paid for about six months ago. We live in regional Australia so flights+hotel will be another $1000 on top for the three of us, but it’s DPS birthday while we are there and it’s in the city that his family live in, which we would visit that time of year anyway so I have not considered that $1000 as part of the cost of DD ‘Xmas gift’ as we would usually spend nearly that visiting his fam anyway….

anywho, I told him tonight I was planning on getting her a few extra bits to actually open on Xmas day, like pyjamas a book, maybe some earrings, so she has some stuff to open on the day.

DP has got really wound up, that I’m spending a fortune and spoiling her- setting us up for the next year because we have to match it (I disagree I think she will understand it’s a one off time in a life type thing). He thinks she shouldnt have anything extra on top of the tickets and trip and I’ve already gone way overboard.

we had a bit of a Barney, I think that our usual gift budget is fairly frugal when I compare (thief of joy I know) what other people drop on their kids at Christmas… anyway am I being unreasonable with getting extra gifts to open when I’ve already nearly doubled the usual budget on tickets.

is he being unreasonable to view the hotel and flights as part of the gift expense on her behalf?

is $400 reasonable budget for a kid at Christmas anyway?

OP posts:
Quitelikeit · 12/10/2023 15:34

But why are you so frugal?

Do you have thousand in savings?

What are you saving for?

TomatoSandwiches · 12/10/2023 15:37

PottedPlantsObsess · 12/10/2023 15:32

I think you misunderstand.
he has no issue with the trip at all. He thinks it’s a great Christmas gift.
however, he does think that this is enough in terms of a Christmas gift and it’s excessive to get extra things- particularly as the trip is costing more than we would normally spend for Christmas presents.

neither of us equate money or gifts with love, therefore I don’t think either opinion has any correlation with how much we love our child. It’s really just a question of whether you agree with him that it’s financially excessive, or agree with me that it’s a one off and it won’t do any harm.

Edited

But you would be spending a similar amount at a similar time anyway.
So he is wrongly attributing ALL of the trips cost on your DD.
He is wrong.
He has no justifiable reason to object to you buying some presents for her to open on Christmas day.
His behavioir ( flouncing and huffing ).is designed to modify YOUR behaviour so you capitulate and give in to his pov for whatever reason he truly has.
He is not being reasonable op.

Mari9999 · 12/10/2023 15:39

@PottedPlantsObsess
I think you work to provide for yourself and your child. You know what you can afford and what you would like to give your child for Xmas. You are not asking your partner to contribute to the gift, and his opinion can be considered but it should not be determinative.

I would imagine that you may voice an opinion about what he gives his son for Xmas but that you respect him enough not to expect your opinion to be controlling .

We gave our 16 year old a car last Xmas. Her gift this Xmas won't come remotely close in value and she won't be expecting it to be equal in value.

What is the purpose of hard work and some measure of success if you can't occasionally indulge your children? That is not something for which you should feel guilty or apologetic. I can't speak for you, but that is one of the motivators for working as long and hard as I work. Your daughter will only have this one childhood making it pleasurable for her when you have the means and opportunity to do so. is not spoiling her.

BetterWithPockets · 12/10/2023 15:41

Namerequired · 12/10/2023 15:08

No I agree with you here, he either has a father role or he doesn’t, you don’t pick and choose. If he acts like her father (and you’re happy with that), he’s raising her, paying for her etc he has a right to an opinion. I also think his opinion here is wrong though. The only part of the gift that is truly hers is $300 for her ticket. I don’t think you can pile the flights and hotel on unless it is literally just a trip for her, about her etc without other things thrown in. So about £150? Which is not a large budget for an 11yr old, and is certainly not going to spoil her. Not that there’s anything wrong with occasional spoiling. Has he seen what tech costs? I can see where he’s coming from when he groups all the costs together but he’s benefiting from those costs.

This! Especially this bit: I agree with you here, he either has a father role or he doesn’t, you don’t pick and choose. If he acts like her father (and you’re happy with that), he’s raising her, paying for her etc he has a right to an opinion. I also think his opinion here is wrong though.

If it’s very out of character for him though, have you tried to unpick why he reacted as he did, OP? Is he worried about money, for example? (I know you said you don’t have money worries, but there’s clearly something behind his reaction…)

RantyAnty · 12/10/2023 15:42

Does he have a job at all or is he on centrelink?

IVFfirsttimer91 · 12/10/2023 15:45

If you can afford it comfortably I think that as a one off experience with your daughter spending the extra money for P!NK tickets is a fab thing to do. But she should also get some smaller gifts to open on actual Christmas too, yes you’ve blown the budget this once, but that’s what it is, once and you shouldn’t back down from buying the extra gifts.

Your partner was probably just a bit stunned by the amount of money spent compared to usual. He’ll calm down and realise that spending an extra $100 on some small bits for her isn’t the end of the world.

I hope you have the best time!

Antst · 12/10/2023 15:45

I'd usually be first in line to tell people not to spend a fortune on kids at Christmas. There are all kinds of reasons. However, in this case, I think the decision is justified.

Parents are the only people who can afford tickets to major concerts these days. Your daughter won't be able to afford tickets in 10 or probably even 20 or 30 years. It would be nice for her to have this special experience. It's not every day that Pink goes to Australia.

Also, like you said, the ticket is $600 and the flights can reasonably be counted as part of the cost of seeing relatives at Christmas. If you don't go overboard on extras (i.e., if you really do stick to a book and pajamas--which you'd need to buy your daughter anyway), then even someone as tight and spoiling-averse as me has no problem with your plan.

It's interesting that your partner doesn't see expensive flights as an extravagance, but has a problem with your daughter's gift.

The only "but" I have is if you're having financial issues. If you are, then don't go spending your money on flights and concerts. If you're not, then this sounds like a great experience for you and your daughter to have. My parents were always short of money and childhood was nothing but feeling guilty about every penny they spent and never having special experiences. It would be nice to do this for your daughter.

jollygoose · 12/10/2023 15:47

Flip it the other wat and can you imagine a child not getting a few gifts for christmas just because she will be having an experience. What a miserable christmas morning that would be she is 11 for heavens sake let her enjoy a few gifts he sounds a real joy sucker.

cartagenagina · 12/10/2023 15:49

I’m confused @PottedPlantsObsess

You usually spend $400 on DD at Christmas. This year you have bought two tickets for Pink, one for you and one for her, costing $300 each. So if you buy DD some books and a jumper or similar, you will have spent around $400 which is the same as usual.

The trip would be happening anyway and actually is in part to celebrate HIS birthday.

So what’s his actual problem? Does he think DD should pay for your ticket or that a child that age should be going to a concert alone? He really doesn’t sound very nice.

INeedAnotherName · 12/10/2023 15:50

he was raised extremely frugally and his family do not really do gifts (other than his mum sending things for DD)
neither of us are big on gifts, we usually go camping to celebrate each others birthdays or he makes me something, he usually makes something for DD too, although he gives her this on Christmas Eve because that’s more in line with the way his family celebrated when he was a child. He never even wraps it

I repeat - He never even wraps it

He's a fucking tight arse. And you typing extremely frugally means you subconsciously know that too. I bet no expense is spared when he's the recipient but not you or the daughter. A miserable miser.

And in what land is buying a book or pyjamas to unwrap is spoiling? Seriously!?

JANEY205 · 12/10/2023 15:53

As you spend a LOT on seeing this man’s family, why can’t you spend the same on treating your daughter? He is being horrible! So it’s fine for him to have money spent on you seeing his family who actually are nothing to do with you or your daughter? I wouldn’t be having this! It’s NONE of his business and she’s old enough to understand this is a big deal type present. My mum took me to concerts growing up and I never expected to keep going, I knew it was a one at a time thing! Go and have fun with your girl!

Millybob · 12/10/2023 15:53

Go without him - cut out the visit to his family. That will bring down the cost overall. Then spend your money on your daughter as you see fit. If this man hasn't committed to you after five years, he's a boyfriend not a partner.

SplendidUtterly · 12/10/2023 15:53

I'm low key impressed an 11 year old even knows who pink is let alone wanting to go see her!
(Not hating, I use to love P!nk in the 2000's)

AbbeyGailsParty · 12/10/2023 15:55

Comefromaway · 12/10/2023 12:47

There is a difference between spoiling and treating.

This. It’s a special treat. Of course she needs a few bits to open Christmas Day, it won’t feel like Christmas otherwise.

PottedPlantsObsess · 12/10/2023 15:57

BetterWithPockets · 12/10/2023 15:41

This! Especially this bit: I agree with you here, he either has a father role or he doesn’t, you don’t pick and choose. If he acts like her father (and you’re happy with that), he’s raising her, paying for her etc he has a right to an opinion. I also think his opinion here is wrong though.

If it’s very out of character for him though, have you tried to unpick why he reacted as he did, OP? Is he worried about money, for example? (I know you said you don’t have money worries, but there’s clearly something behind his reaction…)

Hmmm I’m not sure, I think lots of the comments here have picked him way wrong.

I don’t think his actions are because he begrudges our child a nice Christmas or gifts, even though he doesn’t see the point of Christmas connected to presents…

I dunno, maybe because I am usually so strict with our budget for things- (maybe I’m the red flag 🤣).

in the heat of the moment it came across that he felt like we were setting ourselves up for year on year ‘topping’ last years presents which is really out of line with both our values…..but maybe on reflection he is worried about money, we’ve spent a lot on the house this year and putting money aside to get married, I hold the purse strings so maybe he just sees me spending and hasn’t seen me squirrelling for the last few years…

im pretty blown away by all the ‘not her dad, not his business’ comments.

OP posts:
Nonplusultra · 12/10/2023 15:57

You’re getting to an age where the buying power of $400 is about to drop significantly. That’s a mountain of gifts for a child but for teenage interests it won’t go far at all.

It’s not a good sign at all that the two of you can’t have a grown up discussion about money - it’s absolutely essential in a marriage. Money is tricky. Gifts and Christmas are tricky. They don’t mean the same things to people, and they can be hugely emotive. It really is a litmus test of a relationship. But he’s flounced off and you’re on the internet canvassing strangers.

You both have entirely valid positions on this and these types of issues won’t go away. Either marry someone with similar financial values or someone who can communicate respectfully with you and vice versa

JustEatTheOneInTheBallPit · 12/10/2023 15:58

I honestly cannot understand it when a step parent doesn’t want to “spoil” their step children a bit. (As long as there is definitely enough money to do so, of course.) It’s a lovely thing to share but it doesn’t smack of “I’m trying to replace your parent”. I love buying treats for mine.

PinkRoses1245 · 12/10/2023 15:59

None of his business, if you can afford it without being short/borrowing money.

Starseeking · 12/10/2023 16:04

It doesn't sound like you are asking him to pay anything towards your DDs presents, therefore it's none of his business.

PottedPlantsObsess · 12/10/2023 16:04

cartagenagina · 12/10/2023 15:49

I’m confused @PottedPlantsObsess

You usually spend $400 on DD at Christmas. This year you have bought two tickets for Pink, one for you and one for her, costing $300 each. So if you buy DD some books and a jumper or similar, you will have spent around $400 which is the same as usual.

The trip would be happening anyway and actually is in part to celebrate HIS birthday.

So what’s his actual problem? Does he think DD should pay for your ticket or that a child that age should be going to a concert alone? He really doesn’t sound very nice.

I think we both attributed the two tickets(mine and hers) as her gift (600) but reading through the posts maybe that’s a stretch and therefore (my opinion) yes there would be 100 left….

his opinion is that the flights and hotel are also included, therefore I’ve spent $1600 rather tha. $400 like I’m normally would.

we normally go see his family around that time of year and would be booking flights and a hotel anyway (although prices definitely are inflated that week due to the concert and Valentine’s Day) so if it was just going to see his family would normally be much less-maybe $800

OP posts:
DocMart7n · 12/10/2023 16:08

I am a stepmum and me and my DH have separate bank accounts and split the bills. The rest of our money we spend as we wish.

It is not my place to dictate what nice things my Husband can or cannot do for his kids. Wtf!

The only situation I would get furious about in is if my husband's spent a what you have (into the 1000s) at Christmas on the kids and then came to me and said he couldn't afford to contribute to the bills.

It does not sound like that is the case so it's none of his business.

Marblessolveeverything · 12/10/2023 16:10

She is 11, so old enough to understand the one off gift. And I am sure she would appreciate a few less expensive gifts to open on the morning.

I would be having a quiet frank conversation with the boyfriend about boundaries. Whilst none likes to see children over spoilt I do think every child should have at least one birthday or Xmas when life delivered above and beyond.

Namerequired · 12/10/2023 16:11

PottedPlantsObsess · 12/10/2023 16:04

I think we both attributed the two tickets(mine and hers) as her gift (600) but reading through the posts maybe that’s a stretch and therefore (my opinion) yes there would be 100 left….

his opinion is that the flights and hotel are also included, therefore I’ve spent $1600 rather tha. $400 like I’m normally would.

we normally go see his family around that time of year and would be booking flights and a hotel anyway (although prices definitely are inflated that week due to the concert and Valentine’s Day) so if it was just going to see his family would normally be much less-maybe $800

So even adding that those tickets are inflated that’s still only an extra 200 than he would still be paying. Assume she’s paying for the stuff herself (her budget or money family gave her), does he really think she should pay for flights and hotels for yous all to see his family? I assume he wouldn’t. His thinking here is badly off. He needs to think of the 2things as separate.

Didshejustsaythatoutloud · 12/10/2023 16:11

Treat your daughter all you want, life can be short. I was a single parent for years, scrimt and scraped but at Xmas I would spoil them and get into debt to do it. (Single parent guilt, I guess). I met my partner when my boys were 9&12. Partner said I spent too much at Xmas but helped me out cos he didn't want me in debt. Boys are now 25&22 and my partner is just as bad as me for spoiling them over the years.
Good luck x

mewkins · 12/10/2023 16:12

PottedPlantsObsess · 12/10/2023 14:08

We’ve been together five years. This is the first time something like this has come up. I wouldn’t say it’s a red flag.

I think before you get married it's important to have the conversation about parenting etc. You dd will be a teenager soon and the decisions you will have to make over how to parent will ramp up quite a lot. I co parent with my dc's dad and we make the parenting decisions, no one else regardless of partners etc. I think you need to establish who will make which decisions going forward (financial and others) or else it will lead to issues down the line.

Swipe left for the next trending thread