Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

What happens when the current taxpayers retire?

93 replies

TiredOfTheColdNow · Today 15:17

Anyone that reads mumsnet regularly can't help but notice the amount of threads now on NEETS and disabled/sen children.

We already know the country is too 'top heavy' with not enough working adults paying tax to support the ageing population/public services/welfare. What will happen when the current working adults/taxpayers retire and the next generation that are supposed to pick up the taxpaying reigns can't or won't?

With less children being born and those that are increasingly falling into NEETS or disabled/SEN and not expected to ever work what on earth is going to happen with this generation is supposed to be the working one?

As the parents of the disabled/SEN children die off who will pay for them, never mind all the public services and state pensions etc.

I know as the boomer generation die out and my generation (gen x) retire there will be less of us but the country will still be top heavy it seems.

I know that immigration was supposed to 'even things out' with more young people moving here but many of them seem to be doing low paid jobs (so taking out more than they put in to the tax system) and then of course we have the 'boat people' who will probably never contribute anything.

Is anyone else worried about this? I feel I did my stint. Working and paying higher rate taxes for many years but the generations behind me are not stepping up to do their bit?

As our interest rates that we pay on our UK debt are going up and forecast to go up more, there is going to be less money to spend on other things anyway. How are we ever going to get out of this mess. We keep borrowing each month so debt increases. Rates are going up so interest increases. Add to that the workers retiring and being 'replaced' by the NEET generation and the SEN generation and how on earth is this going to work?

I know each generation got a different 'deal'. My generation was lucky enough to get free uni and lower house prices but rubbish private pensions.
I know house prices are out of control and the other problems facing younger generations. Whether it's their 'fault' or not the country is still going to be raising very little money to pay for everything.

OP posts:
Yello24 · Today 15:41

You’re too harsh on young people. The majority still won’t have an SEN diagnosis. So they’ll be working. Just slightly too few of them.
This demographic problem is happening all over the developed world so there’s nothing really unique about the UK even though we do have a lot of neets

42foryou · Today 15:45

Tbh I think we’re screwed. Too many workshy people getting whatever diagnosis they can to claim benefits, doctors giving our diagnosis like confetti because they donut’s want to be accused of discrimination, those same people then working cash in hand.

the work ethic of far too many people is far too limited, everyone thinks the world owes them a favour and that they are entitled to freebies

TiredOfTheColdNow · Today 15:47

Yello24 · Today 15:41

You’re too harsh on young people. The majority still won’t have an SEN diagnosis. So they’ll be working. Just slightly too few of them.
This demographic problem is happening all over the developed world so there’s nothing really unique about the UK even though we do have a lot of neets

It's not my intention to be hard on young people. I'm coming at it from a worried point of view.
It maybe well that mumsnet is giving me a distorted view of young/sen people. There just seems to be so many threads about youngsters being disabled or neet on here that I feel none of them are building careers like we did.
I'm delighted if you think I am wrong and there is nothing to worry about.

OP posts:

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about this subject:

BegbyBoo · Today 15:48

My DS has SEN, he is a few years off of leaving school, and I would LOVE him to work, I think it is good for him socially, mentally, physically and in terms his self worth. It's also good for society.
He will need a ton of support, understanding and adaptions in order to stand a chance of working, and I am doubtful he will get them.
He can work, in the right circumstances, but I very very unlikely to ever be able too (don't read that as fatalist, I will do everything in my power to support him, rather I think it is realistic).

MasterGland · Today 15:52

There is no such thing as the NEET generation that don't want to "step up". Structural imbalances have built up in the system due to woeful government planning.

TiredOfTheColdNow · Today 16:05

42foryou · Today 15:45

Tbh I think we’re screwed. Too many workshy people getting whatever diagnosis they can to claim benefits, doctors giving our diagnosis like confetti because they donut’s want to be accused of discrimination, those same people then working cash in hand.

the work ethic of far too many people is far too limited, everyone thinks the world owes them a favour and that they are entitled to freebies

That's what I'm worried about.

Already the country seems to be buckling under the weight of the fewer and fewer taxpayers paying for more and more non workers (elderly, disabled, neets).

I know the govt is currently reviewing pip for 18-24 year olds and the outrage on the threads that people's children in this age bracket are going to lose their disabled benefits. People seem so unrealistic now and unaware of the state of the UK's finances. I agree peoples work ethic seems to be rapidly disappearing.

I don't think it's helping that lots of people on benefits are very dismissive of the worries of the taxpayers. I don't fall into either category (retired but living on savings so no state pension yet). So I'm not in either camp so not on anyone's 'side'.

However after years and years of paying high rate taxes and no breaks (no kids here) I retired early fifties. In part because I could afford it (inheritance). In part because I was tired of paying high rate taxes and getting less and less back. I mean I have to pay for private dentist now. I've had to see a private GP as my own is practically impossible to get an appointment with. Police don't appear to be dealing with crime anymore and god help you if you need an ambulance or to go to A&E.
If I though taxes were being put to good use (repaying our debt, investing in the country) I wouldn't mind so much. It all seems to be getting used up though on debt interest (and still they keep borrowing) and welfare/neets/sen

I do think the NHS is being phased out gradually and we are going to end up more like America with private healthcare and very little welfare.

All I see is the various groups on mumsnet outraged that 'their' free money might get changed with no awareness of the fact the UK is borrowing huge sums each month to pay for this. I feel like replying don't worry about it, soon none of you will be getting anything.

The country seems to be set up to discourage working. People like me retiring early because they are fed up with it, others cutting their hours to claim benefits. Others going part-time so they don't breach a tax cliff edge. The rights of the unemployed/disabled/immigrants seem to all exceed that of the working man and woman.

I do wonder how long before it all goes 'bang'

It gives me some comfort that others like yourself seem to at least be aware of it. Others are just arguing over which group of people should get their benefits cut first rather than realising they all need to be cut to get the country back on it's feet.

OP posts:
TiredOfTheColdNow · Today 16:08

BegbyBoo · Today 15:48

My DS has SEN, he is a few years off of leaving school, and I would LOVE him to work, I think it is good for him socially, mentally, physically and in terms his self worth. It's also good for society.
He will need a ton of support, understanding and adaptions in order to stand a chance of working, and I am doubtful he will get them.
He can work, in the right circumstances, but I very very unlikely to ever be able too (don't read that as fatalist, I will do everything in my power to support him, rather I think it is realistic).

This is what I mean though. I totally believe you want your child to work and contribute to society but as you say you don't think it will happen.
So regardless of how we got here or blaming anyone, who will pay for your child when you are dead and we have even less taxpayers than we do now.
I just don't see how the current system which is already buckling is going to keep going.

OP posts:
Octavia64 · Today 16:09

There were shitloads if unemployed young people in the early 80s.

the thatcher government set up yts for them and exactly the same things are being says now as were said then,

work shy, lazy, don’t want to work, blah blah.

The economy improved and they got jobs.

except for the coal miners and other manual or factory workers who the thatcher government moved over to sickness benefits to make sure the numbers of unemployed were going down.

that’s the real lost generation.

BegbyBoo · Today 16:11

TiredOfTheColdNow · Today 16:08

This is what I mean though. I totally believe you want your child to work and contribute to society but as you say you don't think it will happen.
So regardless of how we got here or blaming anyone, who will pay for your child when you are dead and we have even less taxpayers than we do now.
I just don't see how the current system which is already buckling is going to keep going.

I'm planning to do the opposite of what you did - work as long as I can, invest every penny I inherit into the highest interest savings accounts I can find, take a second job, minimise outgoings as much as I can, and leave my DS with the best possible support system I can.
I am under no illusion that the state will care for him.

TiredOfTheColdNow · Today 16:13

MasterGland · Today 15:52

There is no such thing as the NEET generation that don't want to "step up". Structural imbalances have built up in the system due to woeful government planning.

I don't have kids so I can only go on what I read in the news and on here. I certainly see lots of youngsters out and about during the day (as if they don't work but who knows).

I agree they have had quite a few things stacked against them - house prices, NHS on it's knees, education being disrupted by disabled children (according to threads on here).

Regardless of how we got here though it seems we do have a huge amount of NEETS and disabled/SEN children. So when our current taxpayers retire what happens?

If the UK is borrowing huge sums each month, never repaying them. Interest rates are going up to borrow for the UK so our spending on debt/interest is taking a bigger and bigger piece of the money each year. If we factor in even less taxpayers than just now and more disabled people who will need cared for when their parents die I just don't see how it can keep functioning.

OP posts:
TiredOfTheColdNow · Today 16:20

Octavia64 · Today 16:09

There were shitloads if unemployed young people in the early 80s.

the thatcher government set up yts for them and exactly the same things are being says now as were said then,

work shy, lazy, don’t want to work, blah blah.

The economy improved and they got jobs.

except for the coal miners and other manual or factory workers who the thatcher government moved over to sickness benefits to make sure the numbers of unemployed were going down.

that’s the real lost generation.

I remember the YTS schemes although I was never on one. I think back then though we didn't have huge house prices, a failing NHS, so many elderly. We also had more social houses didn't we.

We have without a doubt had periods before with unrest, problems, high inflation, long dole queues but just now it all seems to be coming together in a perfect storm.
The UK no longer has the credit rating it used to have and we pay higher interest on our debt.
Schools seemed to work well (and was strict) in the eighties. I remember a few kids going to remedial classes but not many.

I seem to recall being on the dole was embarrasing back then. There was shame associated with not working and being able to provide for yourself.

OP posts:
TiredOfTheColdNow · Today 16:28

BegbyBoo · Today 16:11

I'm planning to do the opposite of what you did - work as long as I can, invest every penny I inherit into the highest interest savings accounts I can find, take a second job, minimise outgoings as much as I can, and leave my DS with the best possible support system I can.
I am under no illusion that the state will care for him.

What a worry for you. I'm glad you have a plan so he /she will have money to be cared for.

I couldn't have kids and so I don't have the worry of leaving anything behind for mine. This of course has impacted my decision on when I could retire.

Even with money behind them though who will actually be caring for your child. I mean if a large amount of the youngsters are neet or sen, who will be actually trained and qualified to carry out the caring role especially if the NHS goes completely.

Years ago families cared for their elderly/sick. We have moved away from this to 'professionals' caring for elderly/sick and quite honestly it does not work terribly well. You only have to look at the problems with care homes or youngsters doing care jobs only because they can't get anything else but have no interest in it as work.

The UK just seems to be on a very downhill journey and I don't see how things are going to get better unless AB really can get all the youngsters back working and off benefits. Is there jobs for them though? Many threads on here recently about people losing their jobs.

OP posts:
Mossyfox · Today 16:29

Then maybe the AI robots will take over. Will they pay tax. Maybe they'll claim UC.

Sosorryaboutthis · Today 16:31

If the government can't raise enough taxes, services will be cut back. If there is not enough money raised then the state will not offer support to so many people.

tomorrowfollowstoday · Today 16:34

TiredOfTheColdNow · Today 15:47

It's not my intention to be hard on young people. I'm coming at it from a worried point of view.
It maybe well that mumsnet is giving me a distorted view of young/sen people. There just seems to be so many threads about youngsters being disabled or neet on here that I feel none of them are building careers like we did.
I'm delighted if you think I am wrong and there is nothing to worry about.

Yes there are concerns about the numbers. But the vast majority of young people ARE either working, in education or in training.

AyeUpChuck · Today 16:35

People with SEN can work. I am autistic and work. Stop believing everything the papers say. Those who cannot work have the more severe versions where they are many years delayed behind their peers. Some of the very best minds and companies are ran by autistic people.

RaggedRocks · Today 16:37

When things get bad enough, we will have another world war and start again like World War II fixed the unemployment of the 1930s.

AyeUpChuck · Today 16:37

Mossyfox · Today 16:29

Then maybe the AI robots will take over. Will they pay tax. Maybe they'll claim UC.

Actually they said AI will take over and the companies will pay universal income.

littlecoffeemug · Today 16:44

I was fascinated watching Question Time this week. A young woman, claiming PIP, adamant she was unable to work because her M.E. exhausted her. Apparently, she was too exhausted to even raise her hand in the audience and had to rest it on her father's shoulder?

And, yet she had somehow endeavoured to get herself up, out and travel to sit in the Question Time audience for several hours and vehemently argue?

redfishcat · Today 16:47

Well, most retired people still have incomes above the tax threshold, so most are paying income tax . they buy stuff and petrol and beer and gin so pay VAT. And the number paying IHT is increasing as house prices are so high, even a modest home up north will exceed the limit.
Pensions are also about to be taxed too, when the person dies and passes it to a spouse or child.

what are you worried about ?

tomorrowfollowstoday · Today 16:47

tomorrowfollowstoday · Today 16:34

Yes there are concerns about the numbers. But the vast majority of young people ARE either working, in education or in training.

Also worth bearing in mind the numbers of NEETs are up, but the stats I saw said it was 12% ten years ago, 13.5% now.
The difference is the current government is willing to actually talk about it.

tomorrowfollowstoday · Today 16:50

littlecoffeemug · Today 16:44

I was fascinated watching Question Time this week. A young woman, claiming PIP, adamant she was unable to work because her M.E. exhausted her. Apparently, she was too exhausted to even raise her hand in the audience and had to rest it on her father's shoulder?

And, yet she had somehow endeavoured to get herself up, out and travel to sit in the Question Time audience for several hours and vehemently argue?

Are you a medical expert?

It's grim for people with ME because if they do anything at all, people then can't understand they can't do everything.

EmeraldRoulette · Today 16:56

@TiredOfTheColdNow what you’re saying is a live issue now, and was a couple of years ago

I went to a seminar about this. I was asked to go because I also am childfree and was looking to retire early 50s.

It was very bizarre. The panel leaders couldn’t seem to accept that working culture has changed so much, it’s a bleeding nuisance for a lot of the more senior staff and if they can retire early, they will. If it was just about doing the task, they would probably consider the reward worth it.

Really small things that people suggested that might tempt this group back into the workplace… they were against all of them.

There was a chancellor who mentioned this specifically wasn’t there? I can’t remember if it was under this administration or the previous one. But someone actually criticised this very specific group, because as far as they’re concerned, that’s lost tax revenue.

Unfortunately, they did the usual thing of lumping everybody in together - so they didn’t differentiate between anyone who might have health problems, anyone who might have caring responsibilities and anyone who might have just packed it in because they can afford it.

but… my closest friend is now one of the late 50 cohort who got made redundant and has had pretty much no leads in the last six months, in spite of being good in tech and AI. She tells me she isn’t in a position to retire (debatable, although obviously I’m not going to get into that debate with her). So maybe there isn’t really a crisis of people retiring early? I don’t know. I was surprised when it got mentioned as being an issue.

But economists are all about GDP and tax receipts. There’s another thread going where we’re talking about how many jobs will be lost to AI. I genuinely don’t think that politicians and civil service in the UK have fully understood this.

EmeraldRoulette · Today 16:57

tomorrowfollowstoday · Today 16:47

Also worth bearing in mind the numbers of NEETs are up, but the stats I saw said it was 12% ten years ago, 13.5% now.
The difference is the current government is willing to actually talk about it.

Didn’t Rishi Sunak talk about it?

Dicedpumpkin · Today 16:58

Yes millenials/ the youngest gen x really need a plan for retirement as gen z and alpha are not as big so even with full employment they are going to struggle to support them.