Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

What happens when the current taxpayers retire?

95 replies

TiredOfTheColdNow · Today 15:17

Anyone that reads mumsnet regularly can't help but notice the amount of threads now on NEETS and disabled/sen children.

We already know the country is too 'top heavy' with not enough working adults paying tax to support the ageing population/public services/welfare. What will happen when the current working adults/taxpayers retire and the next generation that are supposed to pick up the taxpaying reigns can't or won't?

With less children being born and those that are increasingly falling into NEETS or disabled/SEN and not expected to ever work what on earth is going to happen with this generation is supposed to be the working one?

As the parents of the disabled/SEN children die off who will pay for them, never mind all the public services and state pensions etc.

I know as the boomer generation die out and my generation (gen x) retire there will be less of us but the country will still be top heavy it seems.

I know that immigration was supposed to 'even things out' with more young people moving here but many of them seem to be doing low paid jobs (so taking out more than they put in to the tax system) and then of course we have the 'boat people' who will probably never contribute anything.

Is anyone else worried about this? I feel I did my stint. Working and paying higher rate taxes for many years but the generations behind me are not stepping up to do their bit?

As our interest rates that we pay on our UK debt are going up and forecast to go up more, there is going to be less money to spend on other things anyway. How are we ever going to get out of this mess. We keep borrowing each month so debt increases. Rates are going up so interest increases. Add to that the workers retiring and being 'replaced' by the NEET generation and the SEN generation and how on earth is this going to work?

I know each generation got a different 'deal'. My generation was lucky enough to get free uni and lower house prices but rubbish private pensions.
I know house prices are out of control and the other problems facing younger generations. Whether it's their 'fault' or not the country is still going to be raising very little money to pay for everything.

OP posts:
mamaof4losingmymind · Today 17:26

Id be way more concerned about ai then I would disability

seahorsessky · Today 17:28

TiredOfTheColdNow · Today 15:47

It's not my intention to be hard on young people. I'm coming at it from a worried point of view.
It maybe well that mumsnet is giving me a distorted view of young/sen people. There just seems to be so many threads about youngsters being disabled or neet on here that I feel none of them are building careers like we did.
I'm delighted if you think I am wrong and there is nothing to worry about.

I know quite a few young people with serious, permanent disabilities which stop them doing the kinds of things many take for granted (couldn't go on the types of holiday most enjoy/do sports or even walk easily)-but who work, despite pain and having to spend their own (or parents') money on healthcare that the NHS doesn't cover.
Having disabilities does not mean h
Just because they have disabilities does not mean they don't work-the issue is there's so few jobs, and the teenagers in my extended family with no disabilities are struggling to find work.

Dragonscaledaisy · Today 17:28

FirmSnake · Today 17:17

It's not actually a bigger issue than it has been for most of the last 50 years. Look at the stats pre 2010. Current circumstances aren't unusual in recent history.

We've never had a situation where the welfare bill has exceeded the take from income tax. That's a hugely significant milestone for the UK.

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about this subject:

EmeraldRoulette · Today 17:28

Thank you to the posters who said that the figures are similar to what they are in the past. I did not know that. That makes me feel better. Have I just fallen for a bunch of government nonsense then? In relation to the tax take in the past, was it similar?

The young people I come across through work are very motivated but I appreciate it a self selecting group.

herewegoagainonwednesday · Today 17:29

To be honest, anyone who isn’t retired yet and relies on the state pension is screwed. The won’t get one. We also won’t get anything but the most basic medical care without having to pay.
Social security/universal credit etc will only kick in once all assets are liquidated, including property.
Not a fun future, but the only one even remotely financially possible.

XenoBitch · Today 17:30

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 17:26

Id be way more concerned about ai then I would disability

Yep, and it wont care how old you are when it takes your job.

GreenFlagGhost · Today 17:30

GiaGia16 · Today 17:14

According to government figures it isn’t.

I looked it up myself. 15% of 18-24 year olds are NEET (ONS) which means 85% are in education, employment or training.

2021 it was 10.8%
2016 it was 13.6%
2006 it was 16.1%

They are the ONS figures.

Octavia64 · Today 17:31

greenheetah · Today 17:05

But at that time there were shitloads of Boomers working and paying taxes which paid the UB and YTS for GEN X young adults.

Now we have this ever decreasing number of people of working age trying to prop up a disproportional number of pensioners. It is not working and I feel really sorry for the hideous tax burden on Gen Z and Gen Alpha…

North sea oil paid for the benefits.

seriously, in the 80s and 90s North Sea oil was coming on stream and the government was raking it in from that plus privatisations from about 84 onwards.

the early 80s recession fucked the economy and the cost of yts plus unemployment benefits and sickness benefits was really high. That group of people - miners and factory workers etc etc who were made redundant in the early 80s were mostly on sickness benefits for the rest of their life.

we are in a broadly similar position now with Brexit, Covid and AI. We’re not in quite as bad a position (yet!) but the impact in the employment market is being felt at both ends - youngsters who can’t get work and people retiring early because they can’t get another job and the money just about works.

DrumsPleaseFab · Today 17:32

OP it looks like you are falling victim to the right wing press

there are some serious problems and challenges in society

are they being caused by poor people, people with learning disabilities and migrants? Or are these convenient scapegoats to hide that the real problem within lies with those in power, the self enrichment of the ruling classes (Tory, during their reign, let’s see if Labour politicians will turn out equally corrupt and greedy, I know Tony Blair and his cronies were) the unlimited greed of millionaires and billionaires, of hedge funds, of venture capitalists….

They grab money for themselves whilst saying: look! A migrant! A child with SEN, they are coming for you! 🧐

FirmSnake · Today 17:34

Dragonscaledaisy · Today 17:28

We've never had a situation where the welfare bill has exceeded the take from income tax. That's a hugely significant milestone for the UK.

True. But that isn't because of unemployed young people.

SirenScream · Today 17:35

With each generation there will be fewer and fewer people until the population collapses, Japan will be first to go.
(People may also be 'less' in the sense of shorter or lighter?)

marion1997 · Today 17:41

It's a ticking timebomb isn't it. The government seriously need to get a grip of the benefits bill for a start. I've worked in this are for many years and the number of middle aged people who are stuck on PIP and UC/ ESA for years on end is quite shocking not to mention the huge increase in kids DLA who will likely be on benefits for life. Ultimately there just won't be enough taxpayers to pay for it which is why I strongly believe reform needs to happen now so that the most seriously disabled are protected. We need to accept that there just isn't going to be the funding for everyone who currently gets support to continue getting it at the eand amounts they get. It should never have been allowed to get to where we currently are. We are going to see a lot of jobless people. I think we'll see a return to maybe just one of a couple working or both working part time. I've worked for 40 years but reluctant to retire because I feel the need to try to save as much as I can to help my kids who will likely find themselves jobless at some point.
I have one ds who has graduated with a good degree but can only find a 16 hour retails job, dd graduated as a Nurse next year but there are no jobs, yet my brother in laws gf can just waltz over from the Philippines and work as a qualified nurse. Our young people have been utterly failed and I feel the future is grim.

GiaGia16 · Today 17:41

GreenFlagGhost · Today 17:30

I looked it up myself. 15% of 18-24 year olds are NEET (ONS) which means 85% are in education, employment or training.

2021 it was 10.8%
2016 it was 13.6%
2006 it was 16.1%

They are the ONS figures.

. .

Strawberriesandpears · Today 17:46

Roseshavethorns · Today 17:15

What worries me more is that, as we are having fewer and fewer children (so we can stay in the workplace) who is actually going to provide support for our more vulnerable who don't actually need care just a bit of help? There is no point in being able to pay for help if there is no-one to pay.
Gen Z and, more so, Gen Alpha are going to be squashed never mind squeezed from every angle.
I am recently widowed . My (adult) children have been a huge emotional support to me. I don't need much physical help (I was 59 when DH died) but I know if I do, they will be up here in a heartbeat. I hope I never get to the point I need care and, if I do, I hope there are AI robots to look after me. But I do have a degree of comfort in knowing that, at the moment, there is someone there for me.
I have a couple of single, child-free friends in their 60s. They are successful and have had amazing lives and now they are a bit scared of the future. Friends all get old together and become more vulnerable together.

Not everyone is lucky enough to meet a partner and have children, even though they would like to. I agree it is a concern. I am a childless only child and am absolutely to terrified of what the future holds. I will have no support at all.

FirmSnake · Today 17:47

Strawberriesandpears · Today 17:46

Not everyone is lucky enough to meet a partner and have children, even though they would like to. I agree it is a concern. I am a childless only child and am absolutely to terrified of what the future holds. I will have no support at all.

But they have also been higher than currently.
Not to say that it isn't an issue of course.

Sorry wrong post!

GiaGia16 · Today 17:47

GiaGia16 · Today 17:41

. .

Edited

The ONS figures I’m seeing are

2016 - 11.9%
Mid 2026 - 13%

Churchbell · Today 17:48

It'll all work out. It always does.
When I left school youth unemployment was the highest it had ever been and I went onto a youth employment scheme. Now I'm a boomer, about to retire and it's all been ok.

From the industrial revolution to the second world war and beyond there's always been the unknown. It always works out.

GreenFlagGhost · Today 17:50

GiaGia16 · Today 17:47

The ONS figures I’m seeing are

2016 - 11.9%
Mid 2026 - 13%

18.6% in 1995.
20.1% in 1992.

FirmSnake · Today 17:51

Churchbell · Today 17:48

It'll all work out. It always does.
When I left school youth unemployment was the highest it had ever been and I went onto a youth employment scheme. Now I'm a boomer, about to retire and it's all been ok.

From the industrial revolution to the second world war and beyond there's always been the unknown. It always works out.

It only "always works out" if you're very selective with your history and current affairs...

tomorrowfollowstoday · Today 17:53

littlecoffeemug · Today 16:59

What's the difference between getting up, out and travelling to sit in the Question Time audience for several hours, arguing and debating? And, getting up out and travelling to sit in an office for several hours (but not having to argue, hopefully).

That's not asking someone to do everything. It's asking someone to do something.

You are ill-informed @littlecoffeemug

DriveVerySlowlyPastNumber23IWantThemToSeeMyHat · Today 17:54

Yes, SEN is on the rise. However, I do think we're also encouraging children not to learn how to cope.

Churchbell · Today 17:56

FirmSnake · Today 17:51

It only "always works out" if you're very selective with your history and current affairs...

I mean life ticks on, people still fall in love and have babies, there's food, Christmases and happy days.

Rwqury · Today 17:56

I also think screwed—
of dh family directly only he works. The other 2 people dont work. (And obviously parents retired).
of the school in y6 10% had autism diagnosed!
my younger dc has a kid in class who basically cant read or write at all and clearly should be in sen school.
While it’s obvious some of the kids are incorrectly diagnosed and are just standard average kids, i also know at least 3 kids moved to sen schools, and 1 to unit in a school. Other kids nearly excluded and its very hard to do that…
i think the difference is that these kids parents even if they also had sen /behaviour issues etc they did work. Im not convinced the next gen will. Its similar to being spoilt.

GreenFlagGhost · Today 17:58

Rwqury · Today 17:56

I also think screwed—
of dh family directly only he works. The other 2 people dont work. (And obviously parents retired).
of the school in y6 10% had autism diagnosed!
my younger dc has a kid in class who basically cant read or write at all and clearly should be in sen school.
While it’s obvious some of the kids are incorrectly diagnosed and are just standard average kids, i also know at least 3 kids moved to sen schools, and 1 to unit in a school. Other kids nearly excluded and its very hard to do that…
i think the difference is that these kids parents even if they also had sen /behaviour issues etc they did work. Im not convinced the next gen will. Its similar to being spoilt.

Autistic people can work, always have, with reasonable adjustments.