Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

What happens when the current taxpayers retire?

95 replies

TiredOfTheColdNow · Today 15:17

Anyone that reads mumsnet regularly can't help but notice the amount of threads now on NEETS and disabled/sen children.

We already know the country is too 'top heavy' with not enough working adults paying tax to support the ageing population/public services/welfare. What will happen when the current working adults/taxpayers retire and the next generation that are supposed to pick up the taxpaying reigns can't or won't?

With less children being born and those that are increasingly falling into NEETS or disabled/SEN and not expected to ever work what on earth is going to happen with this generation is supposed to be the working one?

As the parents of the disabled/SEN children die off who will pay for them, never mind all the public services and state pensions etc.

I know as the boomer generation die out and my generation (gen x) retire there will be less of us but the country will still be top heavy it seems.

I know that immigration was supposed to 'even things out' with more young people moving here but many of them seem to be doing low paid jobs (so taking out more than they put in to the tax system) and then of course we have the 'boat people' who will probably never contribute anything.

Is anyone else worried about this? I feel I did my stint. Working and paying higher rate taxes for many years but the generations behind me are not stepping up to do their bit?

As our interest rates that we pay on our UK debt are going up and forecast to go up more, there is going to be less money to spend on other things anyway. How are we ever going to get out of this mess. We keep borrowing each month so debt increases. Rates are going up so interest increases. Add to that the workers retiring and being 'replaced' by the NEET generation and the SEN generation and how on earth is this going to work?

I know each generation got a different 'deal'. My generation was lucky enough to get free uni and lower house prices but rubbish private pensions.
I know house prices are out of control and the other problems facing younger generations. Whether it's their 'fault' or not the country is still going to be raising very little money to pay for everything.

OP posts:
FirmSnake · Today 17:58

Churchbell · Today 17:56

I mean life ticks on, people still fall in love and have babies, there's food, Christmases and happy days.

Sure, for some people. For others their brains were blow up, their homes were repossessed, their children starved. Things do not always work out. Turn on the news occasionally, pick up a history book.

greenheetah · Today 18:00

Churchbell · Today 17:56

I mean life ticks on, people still fall in love and have babies, there's food, Christmases and happy days.

No.

No they aren’t still having babies.

That is a big part of the problem.

frozendaisy · Today 18:01

The UK is quite temperate. There will always be people to fill in any population gaps.

We get rain (or could irrigate) with some forward thinking. To grow and export food.

Honestly a few NEETs won’t be a problem.

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about this subject:

GartredGrenvile · Today 18:02

I do not know anyone who doesn't work. Everyone in my family and circle of friends works, including the young. Both my DC work. I know a couple of people with ADHD. They still work. In fact, one is excelling in her career. A friend is autistic. She works.

You will only hear parents with problems coming on MN. Those like me won't.

Churchbell · Today 18:04

FirmSnake · Today 17:58

Sure, for some people. For others their brains were blow up, their homes were repossessed, their children starved. Things do not always work out. Turn on the news occasionally, pick up a history book.

This has been the story of humanity since time began. Almost nothing benefits the whole of humanity all of the time.

Things change. Everything changes.
Some things get better. Some get worse.
Standards of living now compared with the time of the industrial revolution are transformed. Child mortality rates have decreased for example.

DeflectionAndWhataboutery · Today 18:05

Dragonscaledaisy · Today 17:28

We've never had a situation where the welfare bill has exceeded the take from income tax. That's a hugely significant milestone for the UK.

Except that isn't true. It has been the case since the 2010s.

Welfare payments have not exceeded income tax ‘for the first time ever’ – Full Fact

Welfare spending, which includes state pensions, has been higher than income tax for at least 13 years, contrary to a claim in the Conservatives’ Alternative King’s Speech.

https://fullfact.org/economy/income-tax-versus-welfare-spending/

Churchbell · Today 18:06

greenheetah · Today 18:00

No.

No they aren’t still having babies.

That is a big part of the problem.

People are having less babies in huge part because they have the choice.

The Baby Boom has caused its own problems.

Society will have to adapt.

FirmSnake · Today 18:07

Churchbell · Today 18:04

This has been the story of humanity since time began. Almost nothing benefits the whole of humanity all of the time.

Things change. Everything changes.
Some things get better. Some get worse.
Standards of living now compared with the time of the industrial revolution are transformed. Child mortality rates have decreased for example.

So you are in fact aware that things don't always work out. What you mean is that things have worked out well for you so you dont care.

Dragonscaledaisy · Today 18:07

DeflectionAndWhataboutery · Today 18:05

Except that isn't true. It has been the case since the 2010s.

Then a brutal cut in welfare spending is long overdue.

FunGoldStork · Today 18:08

TiredOfTheColdNow · Today 15:17

Anyone that reads mumsnet regularly can't help but notice the amount of threads now on NEETS and disabled/sen children.

We already know the country is too 'top heavy' with not enough working adults paying tax to support the ageing population/public services/welfare. What will happen when the current working adults/taxpayers retire and the next generation that are supposed to pick up the taxpaying reigns can't or won't?

With less children being born and those that are increasingly falling into NEETS or disabled/SEN and not expected to ever work what on earth is going to happen with this generation is supposed to be the working one?

As the parents of the disabled/SEN children die off who will pay for them, never mind all the public services and state pensions etc.

I know as the boomer generation die out and my generation (gen x) retire there will be less of us but the country will still be top heavy it seems.

I know that immigration was supposed to 'even things out' with more young people moving here but many of them seem to be doing low paid jobs (so taking out more than they put in to the tax system) and then of course we have the 'boat people' who will probably never contribute anything.

Is anyone else worried about this? I feel I did my stint. Working and paying higher rate taxes for many years but the generations behind me are not stepping up to do their bit?

As our interest rates that we pay on our UK debt are going up and forecast to go up more, there is going to be less money to spend on other things anyway. How are we ever going to get out of this mess. We keep borrowing each month so debt increases. Rates are going up so interest increases. Add to that the workers retiring and being 'replaced' by the NEET generation and the SEN generation and how on earth is this going to work?

I know each generation got a different 'deal'. My generation was lucky enough to get free uni and lower house prices but rubbish private pensions.
I know house prices are out of control and the other problems facing younger generations. Whether it's their 'fault' or not the country is still going to be raising very little money to pay for everything.

Short answer it won't!

daisydreamies · Today 18:09

littlecoffeemug · Today 16:59

What's the difference between getting up, out and travelling to sit in the Question Time audience for several hours, arguing and debating? And, getting up out and travelling to sit in an office for several hours (but not having to argue, hopefully).

That's not asking someone to do everything. It's asking someone to do something.

The difference is doing that same thing every day.

I don't have ME, but suffer with chronic fatigue due to another condition I have. I could work one day, but the next I'll be trapped in bed with horrendous fatigue (not just regular tiredness, fatigue where even lifting an arm requires a great deal of strength and I feel like I haven't slept in weeks) and in extreme amounts of pain.

Just because you saw someone for just a small space of time, doesn't mean you can judge that they're fine as you don't know the price they've had to pay to do that. You can't know how much recovery she needed.

Churchbell · Today 18:09

FirmSnake · Today 18:07

So you are in fact aware that things don't always work out. What you mean is that things have worked out well for you so you dont care.

I'm not talking about me personally or any other individual.

I'm talking generally about change, fear and the fact that society and humanity adapt. You can waste a lot of days worrying about tomorrow.

FirmSnake · Today 18:11

Churchbell · Today 18:09

I'm not talking about me personally or any other individual.

I'm talking generally about change, fear and the fact that society and humanity adapt. You can waste a lot of days worrying about tomorrow.

Things don't always work out for societies either though do they?

Musicaltheatremum · Today 18:11

Some retirees will continue to pay tax. Obviously we are very fortunate to have decent pensions so I remain a higher rate tax payer (in Scotland so it kicks in £7000 earlier). My husband and father both paid into private pensions so earn enough to keep paying tax.

Dicedpumpkin · Today 18:11

Churchbell · Today 18:06

People are having less babies in huge part because they have the choice.

The Baby Boom has caused its own problems.

Society will have to adapt.

Well thats kind of ops point. How will society adapt to having a much smaller generation supporting a bigger generation. We all know adaptions needed but what will this look like? How will we plan it.

marion1997 · Today 18:12

greenheetah · Today 18:00

No.

No they aren’t still having babies.

That is a big part of the problem.

None of my four kids in their twenties want kids although I guess this could change. Climate catastrophe, lack of jobs, risk of kids being born with severe needs, little hope of ever being able to afford their own homes are all reasons they have given. My dd says she would like to adopt.

greenheetah · Today 18:12

Churchbell · Today 18:06

People are having less babies in huge part because they have the choice.

The Baby Boom has caused its own problems.

Society will have to adapt.

Yes it will, but at what cost to our young people?

skibidinet · Today 18:12

ASM WINS BETCHEZ

[FROM THE HIGHLANDS TO THE WEST END, JESS ASATO IS A BELLEND]

#SKIDSNET #ASM

GimmieABreakOr3 · Today 18:17

FirmSnake · Today 17:14

Things will get harder. Not because young people are useless, but because future retirees will have less than current ones, and salaries and house prices show no sign of realigning. We will all be a lot poorer i think.

If you are Gen X, Millennial or below, you already are a lot poorer…….

Pieceofpurplesky · Today 18:17

DS has a degree and a masters. Only one of his university friends has a job with decent career prospective. The majority are in bars, part time supermarket or phone sales. DS is autistic and his mental health is shot because he can't find a job he actually wants to do - he is working but it's minimum wage and he doesn't enjoy it.
Maybe if people retired earlier there would be more jobs for graduates.
I was one of the YTS Thatcher years teens and it wasn't as hard then. It didn't matter if you didn't get top grades or go to university. If you did you didn't have £50k of debt and rent/house prices were within reach.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page