Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

What happens when the current taxpayers retire?

95 replies

TiredOfTheColdNow · Today 15:17

Anyone that reads mumsnet regularly can't help but notice the amount of threads now on NEETS and disabled/sen children.

We already know the country is too 'top heavy' with not enough working adults paying tax to support the ageing population/public services/welfare. What will happen when the current working adults/taxpayers retire and the next generation that are supposed to pick up the taxpaying reigns can't or won't?

With less children being born and those that are increasingly falling into NEETS or disabled/SEN and not expected to ever work what on earth is going to happen with this generation is supposed to be the working one?

As the parents of the disabled/SEN children die off who will pay for them, never mind all the public services and state pensions etc.

I know as the boomer generation die out and my generation (gen x) retire there will be less of us but the country will still be top heavy it seems.

I know that immigration was supposed to 'even things out' with more young people moving here but many of them seem to be doing low paid jobs (so taking out more than they put in to the tax system) and then of course we have the 'boat people' who will probably never contribute anything.

Is anyone else worried about this? I feel I did my stint. Working and paying higher rate taxes for many years but the generations behind me are not stepping up to do their bit?

As our interest rates that we pay on our UK debt are going up and forecast to go up more, there is going to be less money to spend on other things anyway. How are we ever going to get out of this mess. We keep borrowing each month so debt increases. Rates are going up so interest increases. Add to that the workers retiring and being 'replaced' by the NEET generation and the SEN generation and how on earth is this going to work?

I know each generation got a different 'deal'. My generation was lucky enough to get free uni and lower house prices but rubbish private pensions.
I know house prices are out of control and the other problems facing younger generations. Whether it's their 'fault' or not the country is still going to be raising very little money to pay for everything.

OP posts:
littlecoffeemug · Today 16:59

tomorrowfollowstoday · Today 16:50

Are you a medical expert?

It's grim for people with ME because if they do anything at all, people then can't understand they can't do everything.

What's the difference between getting up, out and travelling to sit in the Question Time audience for several hours, arguing and debating? And, getting up out and travelling to sit in an office for several hours (but not having to argue, hopefully).

That's not asking someone to do everything. It's asking someone to do something.

XenoBitch · Today 17:00

littlecoffeemug · Today 16:44

I was fascinated watching Question Time this week. A young woman, claiming PIP, adamant she was unable to work because her M.E. exhausted her. Apparently, she was too exhausted to even raise her hand in the audience and had to rest it on her father's shoulder?

And, yet she had somehow endeavoured to get herself up, out and travel to sit in the Question Time audience for several hours and vehemently argue?

She said she was studying at university. It was literally the first thing she said.

I bet the whole thing wiped her out for days. She was their with her dad, who she needed for support.

littlecoffeemug · Today 17:03

XenoBitch · Today 17:00

She said she was studying at university. It was literally the first thing she said.

I bet the whole thing wiped her out for days. She was their with her dad, who she needed for support.

Yeah, really cannot muster the energy to play even the teeniest violin.

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about this subject:

XenoBitch · Today 17:05

littlecoffeemug · Today 16:59

What's the difference between getting up, out and travelling to sit in the Question Time audience for several hours, arguing and debating? And, getting up out and travelling to sit in an office for several hours (but not having to argue, hopefully).

That's not asking someone to do everything. It's asking someone to do something.

People do not tend to go on Question Time for 8 hours, 5 days a week. Even Fiona Bruce doesn't 😂
Anyway, she is a student. She did not say anything about not being able to work at all. She explained how hard it was to claim PIP and what she uses it for.

This reminds of when the lady with anxiety was on there. Such outrage about it, and she said she was looking for work.

greenheetah · Today 17:05

Octavia64 · Today 16:09

There were shitloads if unemployed young people in the early 80s.

the thatcher government set up yts for them and exactly the same things are being says now as were said then,

work shy, lazy, don’t want to work, blah blah.

The economy improved and they got jobs.

except for the coal miners and other manual or factory workers who the thatcher government moved over to sickness benefits to make sure the numbers of unemployed were going down.

that’s the real lost generation.

But at that time there were shitloads of Boomers working and paying taxes which paid the UB and YTS for GEN X young adults.

Now we have this ever decreasing number of people of working age trying to prop up a disproportional number of pensioners. It is not working and I feel really sorry for the hideous tax burden on Gen Z and Gen Alpha…

XenoBitch · Today 17:06

littlecoffeemug · Today 17:03

Yeah, really cannot muster the energy to play even the teeniest violin.

I would suggest you muster the energy to learn about chronic conditions, especially about ME/CFS.
You are not immune to being affected by it one day.

Cars4Gov · Today 17:08

Another factor is AI impact on the workplace, if no entry jobs exist then how do people gain experience to take on/be promoted into the senior roles? Potentially this generation, who manage to get jobs and are willing to work hard could climb the ladder faster than the Gen X (who will be retiring).

littlecoffeemug · Today 17:09

XenoBitch · Today 17:06

I would suggest you muster the energy to learn about chronic conditions, especially about ME/CFS.
You are not immune to being affected by it one day.

There's 1001 far more interesting things to learn about.

XenoBitch · Today 17:09

littlecoffeemug · Today 17:09

There's 1001 far more interesting things to learn about.

Well, stop making ignorant comments on something you know nothing about.

GreenFlagGhost · Today 17:13

I don’t know any NEETs, my adult DD and her friends are all working. I think it’s overblown on MN.

FirmSnake · Today 17:14

Things will get harder. Not because young people are useless, but because future retirees will have less than current ones, and salaries and house prices show no sign of realigning. We will all be a lot poorer i think.

Laulon · Today 17:14

littlecoffeemug · Today 17:03

Yeah, really cannot muster the energy to play even the teeniest violin.

Delightful.

As is usually the case with the ‘tiny violin’ - a good indication of bitterness if not insight.

GiaGia16 · Today 17:14

GreenFlagGhost · Today 17:13

I don’t know any NEETs, my adult DD and her friends are all working. I think it’s overblown on MN.

According to government figures it isn’t.

Roseshavethorns · Today 17:15

What worries me more is that, as we are having fewer and fewer children (so we can stay in the workplace) who is actually going to provide support for our more vulnerable who don't actually need care just a bit of help? There is no point in being able to pay for help if there is no-one to pay.
Gen Z and, more so, Gen Alpha are going to be squashed never mind squeezed from every angle.
I am recently widowed . My (adult) children have been a huge emotional support to me. I don't need much physical help (I was 59 when DH died) but I know if I do, they will be up here in a heartbeat. I hope I never get to the point I need care and, if I do, I hope there are AI robots to look after me. But I do have a degree of comfort in knowing that, at the moment, there is someone there for me.
I have a couple of single, child-free friends in their 60s. They are successful and have had amazing lives and now they are a bit scared of the future. Friends all get old together and become more vulnerable together.

FirmSnake · Today 17:17

GiaGia16 · Today 17:14

According to government figures it isn’t.

It's not actually a bigger issue than it has been for most of the last 50 years. Look at the stats pre 2010. Current circumstances aren't unusual in recent history.

mincepye · Today 17:17

You seem to forget that retired people continue to pay tax.

TheSmallAssassin · Today 17:18

OP, as you couldn't have kids, I wonder whether you know any young people? I've got two in their early 20s and the majority of their friends have had part time jobs from 16. One of mine did from that age, it took the other a bit longer but they have part time job now. Both of mine are ND. One is still in education, the other graduated this year but is working more hours in their last PT job, volunteering and doing work experience to get more experience for the career they want to pursue.

So many of the young people I know have a really good work ethic, of course you are going to hear more from those who struggle on here, or those dealing with troublesome young people because they are the ones who need help or advice.

Favouritefruits · Today 17:19

one of my children has SEN he’s only 9 but goes to mainstream school, I can’t see why he wouldn’t work in the future? Employers need to be more flexible and understanding which I think k will find in the future.

GreenFlagGhost · Today 17:20

GiaGia16 · Today 17:14

According to government figures it isn’t.

How many 18-24 year olds are NEET?

Simonjt · Today 17:23

littlecoffeemug · Today 16:59

What's the difference between getting up, out and travelling to sit in the Question Time audience for several hours, arguing and debating? And, getting up out and travelling to sit in an office for several hours (but not having to argue, hopefully).

That's not asking someone to do everything. It's asking someone to do something.

How is attending university to gain a degree not doing something?

GiaGia16 · Today 17:23

FirmSnake · Today 17:17

It's not actually a bigger issue than it has been for most of the last 50 years. Look at the stats pre 2010. Current circumstances aren't unusual in recent history.

Bigger problem now than ever before as outlined in Millburn report. What used to be temporary joblessness driving the figures is now long standing, entrenched joblessness.

GreenFlagGhost · Today 17:24

Simonjt · Today 17:23

How is attending university to gain a degree not doing something?

Agree - that’s “in education” whereas N is for Not and one of the Es is for education.

Kirbert2 · Today 17:25

My disabled son is only 11 and I'm not entirely sure what his future holds. It's very possible that I will outlive him.

I'd love for him to be able to work but he would need significant support and I can't see many willing workplaces with multiple other options that don't include many reasonable adjustments, flexible hours etc.

PamPamPamPambaconandPam · Today 17:25

TiredOfTheColdNow · Today 15:47

It's not my intention to be hard on young people. I'm coming at it from a worried point of view.
It maybe well that mumsnet is giving me a distorted view of young/sen people. There just seems to be so many threads about youngsters being disabled or neet on here that I feel none of them are building careers like we did.
I'm delighted if you think I am wrong and there is nothing to worry about.

But the people posting are the ones who are concerned about their young adult dc for whatever reason. Everybody else has nothing to be bothered about so won't be posting.

We don't hear about all the brides who aren't Bridezillas, do we? People only post about the ones who are.

Dicedpumpkin · Today 17:26

GreenFlagGhost · Today 17:20

How many 18-24 year olds are NEET?

Its 13.5%. It hasnt been below 10% for decades. In the 80s it was quite a bit higher than now. Before the oil crisis in the mid 70s it was lower.

There are some changes in neets with more saying mental health is a barrier to them working than before.