Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

If you were asked this question, what would your answer be?

133 replies

AnnaQuayRules · Yesterday 11:19

How long does it take a geo-stationary satellite to orbit the earth?

This was a question in last night's quiz at our local, and our answer was apparently wrong. What would you put down?

OP posts:
PamPamPamPambaconandPam · Yesterday 18:01

Greenlawnbrownlawn · Yesterday 16:53

Is the satellite moving relative to the stars? Yes? then it's orbiting the earth, staying over the same point in the earth's surface, over your house, say, doing one orbit every 24 hours. Now if the earth suddenly sped up, the satellite wouldn't be over your house any more, so has it suddenly started orbiting? No, because it has always been orbiting.

The rate of the satellites orbit (24 hours) and the rate of the earths spin (24 hours) aren't related, they just have to match for the satellite to be "geostationary".

Well, that's what I think anyway.

Is the satellite moving relative to the Earth? No. So it isn't orbiting the Earth.

SerendipityJane · Yesterday 18:07

Orbital mechanics. Loadsafun.

Here's another related question.

You sight the sun directly overjhead. How long until you can next sight the sun overhead again ?

This is critical to making sundials even vaguely accurate.

Greenlawnbrownlawn · Yesterday 18:18

PamPamPamPambaconandPam · Yesterday 18:01

Is the satellite moving relative to the Earth? No. So it isn't orbiting the Earth.

It's orbiting the earth every 24 hours, but you have it your way. Perhaps you'd like to edit the Wikipedia entry on geostationary satellites (and every other scientific and technical web site and textbook) because they've got it it all wrong as well.

EntirelyUnnecessary · Yesterday 18:19

PamPamPamPambaconandPam · Yesterday 18:01

Is the satellite moving relative to the Earth? No. So it isn't orbiting the Earth.

That's not what orbiting means though, is it?

It is going around the earth and so it is orbiting. The fact that it matches the earth's rotation and so appears to be above a fixed point on the earth's surface doesn't mean that it isn't still going around the earth.

Stuckintheswing · Yesterday 18:19

It doesn't orbit, it stays in the same place. (Going to see what everyone else has said and if I'm right now).

Erin1975 · Yesterday 18:22

AnnaQuayRules · Yesterday 17:40

How does it stay at exactly that altitude? Please make the answer simple - I haven't got a science brain!

Gravity pulls them down towards the earth but they are moving round the planet at such velocity that the ground falls away at the sme rate. Essentially they are constantly falling but the ground disappears from underneath them.

NotYoCheese · Yesterday 18:22

godmum56 · Yesterday 17:42

aglet

Doh! I would have said Flugelbinder (who watched Cocktail too many times as a teenager?!)

Greenlawnbrownlawn · Yesterday 18:26

Forget about the earth turning. If you want a satellite to orbit in 24hours you stick it at 24000 miles, job done. It will take 24 hours to do one orbit. It's orbiting. No question. Now stand on the earth, also turning at one turn per 24 hours, the satellite appears to be in the same place. Is it orbiting? Of course it is.

godmum56 · Yesterday 18:27

NotYoCheese · Yesterday 18:22

Doh! I would have said Flugelbinder (who watched Cocktail too many times as a teenager?!)

Its what I do. I drink and I know things.

NotYoCheese · Yesterday 18:30

godmum56 · Yesterday 18:27

Its what I do. I drink and I know things.

Well I thought I did too... turns out I drink and don't quite know things!

EntirelyUnnecessary · Yesterday 18:30

This might not make sense to anyone else but this is how I see it:

Alice slowly spins whilst Bob walks around her.

Whether Bob moves quickly or slowly we would all agree that he is walking in circles around Alice.

Now imagine that Bob chooses a particular pace which means that Alice is always facing him as she turns. Alice's eyes are always on Bob, and Bob never goes behind Alice's back because she spins as he moves.

But what Bob is doing hasn't changed - he is still walking in circles around Alice. This is the equivalent of a geostationary orbit. The length of time that it takes for him to do a full circle around Alice is the same as the amount of time it takes for Alice to spin 360 degrees.

BillieWiper · Yesterday 18:31

godmum56 · Yesterday 17:40

no, it means that it moves at the same speed as the earth (or other heavenly body) is rotating so stays hovering over the same place.

Thank you! You should've been in the quiz! 😊

godmum56 · Yesterday 18:31

NotYoCheese · Yesterday 18:30

Well I thought I did too... turns out I drink and don't quite know things!

its a quotation....

Sherararara · Yesterday 18:34

PamPamPamPambaconandPam · Yesterday 18:01

Is the satellite moving relative to the Earth? No. So it isn't orbiting the Earth.

It’s moving relative the centre of mass of the Earth. You are incorrectly thinking the position relative to Earth surface bears any relavance to the question.
Nothing orbits “the Earth”. All our satellites orbit the center of mass of the Earth. We just refer to it as “orbiting the earth”.

Coconutter24 · Yesterday 18:35

titchy · Yesterday 11:34

Isn’t the point that it doesn’t orbit the earth? Hence the word ‘stationary’.

They do orbit

NotYoCheese · Yesterday 18:41

godmum56 · Yesterday 18:31

its a quotation....

Ok, second doh! (Just looked it up, not familiar with GOT)

Coconutter24 · Yesterday 18:41

PamPamPamPambaconandPam · Yesterday 16:16

But how long is a day? A day on Earth is not 24 hours.

There’s 24 hours in a day

Bergamotte · Yesterday 18:41

AnnaQuayRules · Yesterday 17:38

I bet you also know the chemical symbol for Tungsten 🤣🤣

I'm going to bow to your expertise and break it to DH that he was wrong.

He was gobsmacked that I knew the answer to "what is the specific term for the end of a shoelace" I'm great in pub quizzes where they ask random crap like that rather than complicated physics questions!

Is the the end of a shoelace "aglet"? Our homework diaries in secondary school had a fact at the bottom of each page and I think that was one of them. I don't think I have ever used it, but I find it very pleasing somehow!

myusername2026 · Yesterday 18:42

I suppose it orbits the Earth’s Axis? If that is what the question said verbatim. But in the face of it is doesn’t move and would be livid if I was marked down for it !

W and Aglet!

ColinISabirthdaycake · Yesterday 18:50

EntirelyUnnecessary · Yesterday 18:30

This might not make sense to anyone else but this is how I see it:

Alice slowly spins whilst Bob walks around her.

Whether Bob moves quickly or slowly we would all agree that he is walking in circles around Alice.

Now imagine that Bob chooses a particular pace which means that Alice is always facing him as she turns. Alice's eyes are always on Bob, and Bob never goes behind Alice's back because she spins as he moves.

But what Bob is doing hasn't changed - he is still walking in circles around Alice. This is the equivalent of a geostationary orbit. The length of time that it takes for him to do a full circle around Alice is the same as the amount of time it takes for Alice to spin 360 degrees.

This is a great explanation!

OP I know the chemical symbol for Tungsten :)

godmum56 · Yesterday 18:55

NotYoCheese · Yesterday 18:41

Ok, second doh! (Just looked it up, not familiar with GOT)

I never actually watched it, no idea where I found the quote but it resonated.

PamPamPamPambaconandPam · Yesterday 19:12

Ah. I've just checked on the ESA website and they say it is called a geostationary orbit and it takes the same time to orbit as the Earth takes to revolve. I don't know why I didn't check on there in the first place.

So I guess that's it.

Bergamotte · Yesterday 19:21

AnnaQuayRules · Yesterday 17:40

How does it stay at exactly that altitude? Please make the answer simple - I haven't got a science brain!

If you stand on top of a ladder and throw a ball straight forwards, it will start falling towards the ground as soon as it leaves your hand (because of gravity) but it will still be going forwards at the speed you threw it, so it will fall in a curve.
(First picture)

If you stand on a high enough ladder and throw it fast enough, the ball falls in the same curve but the surface of the earth curves away from it, so it doesn't hit it.
(Second picture)

At this point we have to remember that gravity pulls things towards the centre of earth. I can turn my paper around and keep tracing the path of the ball falling down, in green pencil. But again, as the ball falls, the earth curves away from it.

So turn the paper and follow the ball falling, with blue pencil. The earth still curves away before the ball hits it.
Turn the paper again and follow the ball falling with pink pencil. The ball falls right past the point where you first threw it from, and keeps falling.
Assuming there is no friction/ air resistance to slow it down, it will just keep falling around and around the earth indefinitely. This is a satellite.

If you pick the right height and starting speed, it will happen to fall at the same speed as the earth turns, so it will always be in the sky over the same point on the ground.

(I hope I have remembered that correctly!)

If you were asked this question, what would your answer be?
If you were asked this question, what would your answer be?
If you were asked this question, what would your answer be?
If you were asked this question, what would your answer be?
Myli1 · Yesterday 19:38

As I understood it, geostationary orbit means something rotating at exactly the same rate as Earth, like satellites used for communication and tv transmissions etc, so I’d say the answer is it doesn’t orbit the Earth at all?

nocoolnamesleft · Yesterday 19:44

AnnaQuayRules · Yesterday 16:20

But the question wasn't how long does it take a geo stationary satellite to make a full rotation, it was how long does it take it to orbit the earth. And it doesn't orbit the earth.

By making a full rotation round the Earth, it has orbited the Earth. Once.

Swipe left for the next trending thread