Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

If you were asked this question, what would your answer be?

133 replies

AnnaQuayRules · Yesterday 11:19

How long does it take a geo-stationary satellite to orbit the earth?

This was a question in last night's quiz at our local, and our answer was apparently wrong. What would you put down?

OP posts:
Erin1975 · Yesterday 12:04

titchy · Yesterday 11:34

Isn’t the point that it doesn’t orbit the earth? Hence the word ‘stationary’.

Geostationary means it is always above the same point of the planet. So it completes an orbit in the same amont of time it takes the planet to revolve - 24 hours.

RaraRachael · Yesterday 12:06

I wouldn't have a clue. Thank goodness our local quizzes don't have questions like that 😅

Bjorkdidit · Yesterday 12:08

Erin1975 · Yesterday 12:04

Geostationary means it is always above the same point of the planet. So it completes an orbit in the same amont of time it takes the planet to revolve - 24 hours.

But it's not 'orbiting around the earth'....

MyOtherCarIsASatsuma · Yesterday 12:08

Thinking some more I am losing faith in the "it doesn't" argument. What does it matter what the earth is doing underneath? The satellite is still going round and round the earth's axis at speed, every 24 (or 23.9!) hours. How can you go round and round something's axis without going round and round it?

To us as specks on the surface they appear stationary but describing it as not orbiting sounds like semantics. High earth orbit, low earth orbit, no one says "not in orbit" for something hurtling through space at many thousands of miles an hour.

Interesting debate.

greenheetah · Yesterday 12:10

It doesn’t orbit the earth if it is stationary does it? Or is this my ND brain misunderstanding?

Erin1975 · Yesterday 12:10

Bjorkdidit · Yesterday 12:08

But it's not 'orbiting around the earth'....

It is. Orbital velocity is not calculated relative to the surface of the planet. It is calculated relative to the centre of the planet.

Bjorkdidit · Yesterday 12:12

To us as specks on the surface they appear stationary but describing it as not orbiting sounds like semantics

But you've disproved your own argument there.

Say a geostationary satellite is directly above my house. Me, my house and the satellite above us all move with the earth and stay in the same spot relative to the earth. You wouldn't say me or my house on the surface of the earth is orbiting around the earth, so why would you say that the satellite above us does?

Sherararara · Yesterday 12:16

24 hr/1 day. It still orbits the center of the earth it just happens to do so at the exact same speed at the planet rotates.

MyOtherCarIsASatsuma · Yesterday 12:27

Bjorkdidit · Yesterday 12:12

To us as specks on the surface they appear stationary but describing it as not orbiting sounds like semantics

But you've disproved your own argument there.

Say a geostationary satellite is directly above my house. Me, my house and the satellite above us all move with the earth and stay in the same spot relative to the earth. You wouldn't say me or my house on the surface of the earth is orbiting around the earth, so why would you say that the satellite above us does?

I'm no expert and happy to admit I may be way off but I don't think I've disproved it. You and your house are essentially stuck to a rotating surface. The satellite is in free fall. These are different things.

Erin1975 · Yesterday 12:32

Bjorkdidit · Yesterday 12:12

To us as specks on the surface they appear stationary but describing it as not orbiting sounds like semantics

But you've disproved your own argument there.

Say a geostationary satellite is directly above my house. Me, my house and the satellite above us all move with the earth and stay in the same spot relative to the earth. You wouldn't say me or my house on the surface of the earth is orbiting around the earth, so why would you say that the satellite above us does?

Your house is orbiting around the centre of the earth.

Imaging your house on the surface of the earth. As the planet rotates so does your house. It is orbiting around the centre of the planet.

Sherararara · Yesterday 12:36

Erin1975 · Yesterday 12:32

Your house is orbiting around the centre of the earth.

Imaging your house on the surface of the earth. As the planet rotates so does your house. It is orbiting around the centre of the planet.

You and your house are on the surface of a rotating body. You aren’t orbiting. The satellite is orbiting a centre of mass, which is also the center of the Earth.

AnnaQuayRules · Yesterday 15:01

Thanks for all the responses everyone!

Our answer was that it doesn't orbit the earth as it's stationary. The quiz answer was 24 hours.

Our team came 2nd by 1 point so we felt hard done by 😂and another team were so aggrieved they argued it for ages. We weren't that petty (for once).

Interesting to see that the MNers are split on this one. Most teams put 24 hours and got a point, although the team who's answers we were marking put 18 hours which seemed a very odd answer.

OP posts:
AnnaQuayRules · Yesterday 15:02

Bjorkdidit · Yesterday 12:12

To us as specks on the surface they appear stationary but describing it as not orbiting sounds like semantics

But you've disproved your own argument there.

Say a geostationary satellite is directly above my house. Me, my house and the satellite above us all move with the earth and stay in the same spot relative to the earth. You wouldn't say me or my house on the surface of the earth is orbiting around the earth, so why would you say that the satellite above us does?

Exactly!

OP posts:
AnnaQuayRules · Yesterday 15:07

pizzaHeart · Yesterday 11:24

My first feeling was a day but if it’s stationary it stays at the same place?
Anyway I would be doing such quiz with DH and he’s good at this sort of things so I would go with his answer. ( he is at work now)

Ask him when he gets home!

My DH has a double first in Natural Sciences from Cambridge plus a PhD in geology and was adamant that the answer was "it doesn't" as it's stationary. He did know what the chemical symbol for Tungsten is though, which the rest of us didn't, so he made up for it!

OP posts:
PamPamPamPambaconandPam · Yesterday 15:27

Does the upper atmosphere orbit the planet, or do we regard it in the same way as we would regard a house on the surface of the planet as per the post upthread? Satellites are in the upper layers of the atmosphere (the thermosphere or the exosphere) so if the atmosphere doesn't orbit the planet, a geostationary satellite won't be either. And yes, I do know about the coreolis effect. 😂

Besides, the Earth doesn't take 24 hours to rotate. It takes 23 hours, 56 minutes and about 4 seconds.

pizzaHeart · Yesterday 15:42

AnnaQuayRules · Yesterday 15:07

Ask him when he gets home!

My DH has a double first in Natural Sciences from Cambridge plus a PhD in geology and was adamant that the answer was "it doesn't" as it's stationary. He did know what the chemical symbol for Tungsten is though, which the rest of us didn't, so he made up for it!

DH said 24 hours straight away, he said it’s obvious 😄😄😄
He didn’t know symbol for Tungsten though so small mercies …

nocoolnamesleft · Yesterday 15:43

A day. Because it’s geostationary, and it takes the Earth a day to rotate.

Bjorkdidit · Yesterday 15:48

But the question (according to the OP, so back to my point about the question possibly being ambiguous) is 'how long does it take to rotate around the earth', which it doesn't do.

The chemical symbol for tungsten is W, I knew that without looking it up (BSc(Hons) first class in chemistry).

PamPamPamPambaconandPam · Yesterday 16:16

nocoolnamesleft · Yesterday 15:43

A day. Because it’s geostationary, and it takes the Earth a day to rotate.

But how long is a day? A day on Earth is not 24 hours.

AnnaQuayRules · Yesterday 16:20

nocoolnamesleft · Yesterday 15:43

A day. Because it’s geostationary, and it takes the Earth a day to rotate.

But the question wasn't how long does it take a geo stationary satellite to make a full rotation, it was how long does it take it to orbit the earth. And it doesn't orbit the earth.

OP posts:
AnnaQuayRules · Yesterday 16:21

PamPamPamPambaconandPam · Yesterday 16:16

But how long is a day? A day on Earth is not 24 hours.

Blimey, it's a pub quiz not University Challenge!

OP posts:
WallaceinAnderland · Yesterday 16:22

it doesn't orbit the earth

Was that the correct answer?

Minasama · Yesterday 16:22

If it’s stationary it doesn’t move so no time since it does not orbit?

Bjorkdidit · Yesterday 16:24

I suspect the question setter took the answer from the AI option of google, which says 'A geostationary satellite takes 23 hours, 56 minutes, and 4 seconds (one sidereal day)—often rounded to 24 hours—to complete one orbit around the Earth', without engaging their brain or understanding that an orbit is not the same as a rotation. The moon orbits, geostationary satellites match the earth's rotation.

nevernotmaybe · Yesterday 16:26

Bjorkdidit · Yesterday 12:08

But it's not 'orbiting around the earth'....

The statement "orbiting the Earth" is a messy one. Technically what it really means is orbiting the centre of mass of Earth/the planet in question, there is no other meaning. And the satellite has to moving around this centre, to be moving at the same speed as the Earth is spinning.

Swipe left for the next trending thread