Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

If you were asked this question, what would your answer be?

133 replies

AnnaQuayRules · Yesterday 11:19

How long does it take a geo-stationary satellite to orbit the earth?

This was a question in last night's quiz at our local, and our answer was apparently wrong. What would you put down?

OP posts:
Bjorkdidit · Yesterday 16:34

So we're all orbitting the earth and travel thousands of km each day?

nevernotmaybe · Yesterday 16:44

No. The first problem is that unless you are directly on the equator you aren't rotating around that axis anyway.

And to be simple about it because that is my limit, an orbit is powered by the gravity caused by the mass, and the centre of that mass is what that orbit goes around. We are just being propelled by the spinning of the Earth, and as I mentioned it is only around that centre if you are directly on the equator. Either way, not an orbit.

AnnaQuayRules · Yesterday 16:44

Bjorkdidit · Yesterday 16:34

So we're all orbitting the earth and travel thousands of km each day?

No, we are all orbiting the sun. But we are travelling thousands of miles through space every day

OP posts:
LewisChessmenMeetSingingHeads · Yesterday 16:52

(Without reading other posts before I answer).

Frankly, I haven't the foggiest idea, so I'd make a complete guess - 8 months.

Greenlawnbrownlawn · Yesterday 16:53

Is the satellite moving relative to the stars? Yes? then it's orbiting the earth, staying over the same point in the earth's surface, over your house, say, doing one orbit every 24 hours. Now if the earth suddenly sped up, the satellite wouldn't be over your house any more, so has it suddenly started orbiting? No, because it has always been orbiting.

The rate of the satellites orbit (24 hours) and the rate of the earths spin (24 hours) aren't related, they just have to match for the satellite to be "geostationary".

Well, that's what I think anyway.

Bjorkdidit · Yesterday 16:54

@AnnaQuayRules It was a reply to @nevernotmaybe and anyone else who argues that satellites orbit around the earth's centre of mass. Because by following that logic, so does anything on the surface of the earth, which is clearly nonsense.

But assuming that we agree that geostationary satellites orbit, but things on the surface of the earth do not. How far above the earth does a geostatioary object need to be to start counting as orbitting - 1 m, 1 km, 1000 km?

Greenlawnbrownlawn · Yesterday 16:57

Bjorkdidit · Yesterday 16:54

@AnnaQuayRules It was a reply to @nevernotmaybe and anyone else who argues that satellites orbit around the earth's centre of mass. Because by following that logic, so does anything on the surface of the earth, which is clearly nonsense.

But assuming that we agree that geostationary satellites orbit, but things on the surface of the earth do not. How far above the earth does a geostatioary object need to be to start counting as orbitting - 1 m, 1 km, 1000 km?

Edited

The only distance at which a satellite is geostationary is 35,786km.

Erin1975 · Yesterday 17:01

But assuming that we agree that geostationary satellites orbit, but things on the surface of the earth do not. How far above the earth does a geostatioary object need to be to start counting as orbitting - 1 m, 1 km, 1000 km? @Bjorkdidit

Exactly 35,786km. That is the only altiudude at which a geostationary orbit can be maintained. Any higher and the object will move slower than the earth's rotation. Lower and it will move faster.

nevernotmaybe · Yesterday 17:10

@Bjorkdidit I did respond to you and answer, I didnt notice that for some reason I can't quote you (and still can't)

Sherararara · Yesterday 17:10

AnnaQuayRules · Yesterday 16:20

But the question wasn't how long does it take a geo stationary satellite to make a full rotation, it was how long does it take it to orbit the earth. And it doesn't orbit the earth.

It does, just the centre of the earth. It’s your perception/assumption that “orbit the earth” means movement relative to the earth surface. It doesn’t.
And I’ve a Masters in Geophysics from Leeds and your Cambridge educated DH is wrong. Geophysics trumps geology every time. Nah nah nah nah😀

Sherararara · Yesterday 17:14

PamPamPamPambaconandPam · Yesterday 16:16

But how long is a day? A day on Earth is not 24 hours.

No, so a day. Which on average is 23 hrs,
59mins etc etc. A previous poster googled it and posted the number.

Sherararara · Yesterday 17:18

Erin1975 · Yesterday 17:01

But assuming that we agree that geostationary satellites orbit, but things on the surface of the earth do not. How far above the earth does a geostatioary object need to be to start counting as orbitting - 1 m, 1 km, 1000 km? @Bjorkdidit

Exactly 35,786km. That is the only altiudude at which a geostationary orbit can be maintained. Any higher and the object will move slower than the earth's rotation. Lower and it will move faster.

Unless it’s powered. But then technically it
wouldn’t be in orbit.

GreenSmithing · Yesterday 17:24

I would it doesn't because it's geostationary so it's fixed in one place above the earth, and turns as the earth turns, it doesn't orbit the earth. So: never.

Going to check the answer now.

But I'm

Dogssleeping · Yesterday 17:24

AnnaQuayRules · Yesterday 11:19

How long does it take a geo-stationary satellite to orbit the earth?

This was a question in last night's quiz at our local, and our answer was apparently wrong. What would you put down?

To orbit the earth it doesn’t as it is fixed, above a fixed point. Although the earth orbits once a day on its own axis - so it rotates once every 24 hours but at a faster speed (same angular speed / rotation) around the earths axis- as it is has a bigger circumference as bigger distance away. To be fair I would have clarified my answer to that.

nevernotmaybe · Yesterday 17:33

Dogssleeping · Yesterday 17:24

To orbit the earth it doesn’t as it is fixed, above a fixed point. Although the earth orbits once a day on its own axis - so it rotates once every 24 hours but at a faster speed (same angular speed / rotation) around the earths axis- as it is has a bigger circumference as bigger distance away. To be fair I would have clarified my answer to that.

To put the explanation together, the word orbit means something specific.

Orbiting a planet, is orbiting the centre of mass of that planet, powered only by the gravity of that mass. This is an orbit. A geostationary satellite is orbiting this centre, but at the same angular velocity of the Earths spin.

It completes one orbit, in the same time it takes the Earth to spin once. From our perspective it remains set in position, but anyone out in space looking in is seeing an object clearly going around a centre of mass, which is an orbit.

AnnaQuayRules · Yesterday 17:38

Sherararara · Yesterday 17:10

It does, just the centre of the earth. It’s your perception/assumption that “orbit the earth” means movement relative to the earth surface. It doesn’t.
And I’ve a Masters in Geophysics from Leeds and your Cambridge educated DH is wrong. Geophysics trumps geology every time. Nah nah nah nah😀

I bet you also know the chemical symbol for Tungsten 🤣🤣

I'm going to bow to your expertise and break it to DH that he was wrong.

He was gobsmacked that I knew the answer to "what is the specific term for the end of a shoelace" I'm great in pub quizzes where they ask random crap like that rather than complicated physics questions!

OP posts:
Thisusernameisalwaysavailable · Yesterday 17:39

Never?

godmum56 · Yesterday 17:40

BillieWiper · Yesterday 11:46

Does geo-stationary mean that it's stuck to some land? Like the moon or a rock or earth? Rather than just floating in space? Like it doesn't move at all and it's a trick question or something? Gawd I'm rubbish at pub quizzes.

no, it means that it moves at the same speed as the earth (or other heavenly body) is rotating so stays hovering over the same place.

AnnaQuayRules · Yesterday 17:40

Erin1975 · Yesterday 17:01

But assuming that we agree that geostationary satellites orbit, but things on the surface of the earth do not. How far above the earth does a geostatioary object need to be to start counting as orbitting - 1 m, 1 km, 1000 km? @Bjorkdidit

Exactly 35,786km. That is the only altiudude at which a geostationary orbit can be maintained. Any higher and the object will move slower than the earth's rotation. Lower and it will move faster.

How does it stay at exactly that altitude? Please make the answer simple - I haven't got a science brain!

OP posts:
Thisusernameisalwaysavailable · Yesterday 17:41

Oh. No. 24hrs.

Frostynoman · Yesterday 17:41

I would have answered the same, that it doesn’t orbit but that is apparently wrong. The answer is, according to google ai, 23 hours, 56 minutes and 4 seconds..🤷🏼‍♀️

godmum56 · Yesterday 17:42

AnnaQuayRules · Yesterday 17:38

I bet you also know the chemical symbol for Tungsten 🤣🤣

I'm going to bow to your expertise and break it to DH that he was wrong.

He was gobsmacked that I knew the answer to "what is the specific term for the end of a shoelace" I'm great in pub quizzes where they ask random crap like that rather than complicated physics questions!

aglet

godmum56 · Yesterday 17:45

the only pub quiz I have ever done, we were a group of six made up on the night of people who hadn't come in a team so the quizmaster put us all together. One was my mate, the other 4 were complete strangers. We blew the rest of the teams out of the water including the team who "usually" won. Prize was six bottles of good wine. We were not popular!!

nevernotmaybe · Yesterday 17:53

@AnnaQuayRules Imagine the satellite without gravity, it would travel at its speed in a straight line and fly off into space. But gravity is pulling it towards the centre of the Earth. Orbit is when both these things are balanced enough or it to go around, it is trying to go in a straight line, and being kept instead going around the planet by gravity.

At different heights, these forces balance at a different speed. There is a height where this is balanced, and the speed it travels to be balanced at that height matches how fast the Earth spins.

In space without an atmosphere, or very little, an object will just keep travelling at the same speed. So once you set this orbit up, you dont have to do anything generally.

CrystalRabbit · Yesterday 17:56

LewisChessmenMeetSingingHeads · Yesterday 16:52

(Without reading other posts before I answer).

Frankly, I haven't the foggiest idea, so I'd make a complete guess - 8 months.

Oh thank god, someone similarly clueless. I confidently thought ‘a year’ before I looked at the responses.

Swipe left for the next trending thread