Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

If you were asked this question, what would your answer be?

133 replies

AnnaQuayRules · Yesterday 11:19

How long does it take a geo-stationary satellite to orbit the earth?

This was a question in last night's quiz at our local, and our answer was apparently wrong. What would you put down?

OP posts:
CandidMintCat · Yesterday 11:24

I would guess 24hrs

pizzaHeart · Yesterday 11:24

My first feeling was a day but if it’s stationary it stays at the same place?
Anyway I would be doing such quiz with DH and he’s good at this sort of things so I would go with his answer. ( he is at work now)

Fooshufflewickjbannanapants · Yesterday 11:26

Guessing it’s still in the sky as it were so 24 hrs?

titchy · Yesterday 11:34

Isn’t the point that it doesn’t orbit the earth? Hence the word ‘stationary’.

RoseyLentil · Yesterday 11:38

It doesn’t orbit.
interested to know what the accepted answer was. Please share 🙏

VinoVeritasBattenburg · Yesterday 11:39

Geo-stationary means it remains in the same position above the Earth. They’re used for communication aren’t they?

HobgoblinNorFoulFiend · Yesterday 11:40

RoseyLentil · Yesterday 11:38

It doesn’t orbit.
interested to know what the accepted answer was. Please share 🙏

Agree also interested in the answer, so watching the thread.

chirrupybird · Yesterday 11:41

It stays still relative to a point on the earth, they rotate together.

HobgoblinNorFoulFiend · Yesterday 11:42

I think it’s an update of the old question if you walk round a tiger, but it constantly turns to face you, have you actually walked around it, since you’ve only seen it from the front.

brownbootsandhats · Yesterday 11:43

Interesting question

instinctive answer is it isn’t orbitting as it’s geostationary

but orbit describes how it moves in relation to the earth and it certainly does move or it wouldn’t be geostationary- its orbit - movement in relation to earth - is in sync with the rotation of the earth

so that would give 24 hrs

btw i did need to look up the meaning of orbit first

edit for clarity - the rotation of the earth is irrelevant and to the ORBIT - the motion - of the satellite. By setting the speed of orbit ti match the rotation we get the geostationary effect

IronEverything · Yesterday 11:43

Another vote for it doesn't orbit as it's stationary.

Bjorkdidit · Yesterday 11:45

RoseyLentil · Yesterday 11:38

It doesn’t orbit.
interested to know what the accepted answer was. Please share 🙏

This, also bearing in mind that the accepted answer wasn't necessarily correct.

Years ago, I had an argument with a pub quiz person because the question was something I knew about from work and his answer was wrong, which he wouldn't accept on the night, although he did admit to an acquaintance some years later that I had been right all along.

BillieWiper · Yesterday 11:46

Does geo-stationary mean that it's stuck to some land? Like the moon or a rock or earth? Rather than just floating in space? Like it doesn't move at all and it's a trick question or something? Gawd I'm rubbish at pub quizzes.

HRTtoHeart · Yesterday 11:49

Hmm, interesting question. I'd say 24 hours because it has circled the earth, but the earth is also turning to face it, so to speak.

But I can also see the argument for "it doesn't, because it stays still relative to earth."

The ISS, on the other hand, takes about 90 minutes. (DS was obsessed with waving to it when he was little)

DanFmDorking · Yesterday 11:53

The orbit takes 23 hours, 56 minutes, and 4 seconds (one sidereal day) - often rounded to 24 hours.

brownbootsandhats · Yesterday 11:53

If the earth stopped moving the satellites wouldn’t change its motion - why would we say it’s speed of movement has changed because the earth changed ?

SatinHeart · Yesterday 11:54

My initial thought was 'it's not orbiting as it's stationary'

But then if it isn't moving at all it would change position relative to the Earth (or fall out of the sky...). so I assume that the answer they are looking for is that its orbit is 1 Earth day (24 hours ish).

brownbootsandhats · Yesterday 11:54

BillieWiper · Yesterday 11:46

Does geo-stationary mean that it's stuck to some land? Like the moon or a rock or earth? Rather than just floating in space? Like it doesn't move at all and it's a trick question or something? Gawd I'm rubbish at pub quizzes.

No it means it hovers over the same spot and to do so it needs to move at the same speed as the earth is rotating

AutumnOakTree · Yesterday 11:55

Watching for correct answer.

Bjorkdidit · Yesterday 11:55

BillieWiper · Yesterday 11:46

Does geo-stationary mean that it's stuck to some land? Like the moon or a rock or earth? Rather than just floating in space? Like it doesn't move at all and it's a trick question or something? Gawd I'm rubbish at pub quizzes.

No, its in space but stays above the same point of the earth so orbits around the earth's axis at the same rate.

It doesn't orbit around the earth like the moon does or like the earth goes around the sun.

One of those questions that, unless correctly written and read out, could well be ambiguous.

MyOtherCarIsASatsuma · Yesterday 11:55

I can see arguments for 23.9 hours and "it doesn't". 23.9 because every day the earth has to go slightly past 360 degrees in 24h to end up aligned the same way to the sun, because it has also moved through space. Orbiting the earth is relative to the earth and not the sun, and the earth rotates with respect to itself (or perhaps the rest of space??) in 23.9 hours, not 24h. Then there is Feb 29th to factor in I suppose...

Would I play 23.9 hours? Probably not.

It's an interesting question for a debate over a pint, but a bad question for a pub quiz.

PamPamPamPambaconandPam · Yesterday 11:56

If it is geostationary then it doesn't orbit the planet at all. It stays in the same position above the same place all the time. It does go round in a circle, so it is orbiting the place in space where the Earth is located, so it all depends on your interpretation of the word 'orbit'.

Besides, even it if was orbiting the Earth, you can't work out how long it takes without knowing its altitude and speed.

KnickerlessParsons · Yesterday 11:56

If it’s geo stationary it doesn’t orbit the earth. It stays in the same place above the earth and moves at the same rate the earth does.

BillieWiper · Yesterday 11:58

Bjorkdidit · Yesterday 11:55

No, its in space but stays above the same point of the earth so orbits around the earth's axis at the same rate.

It doesn't orbit around the earth like the moon does or like the earth goes around the sun.

One of those questions that, unless correctly written and read out, could well be ambiguous.

Crikey. I don't see how many people would know that! Interesting though! Thank you.

shazshaz · Yesterday 11:59

I know they orbit the earth at the same speed as the earth turns, which makes them appear stationary. So I'm going to say 24 hours.