I developed PPD after my second, but think it was probably PPP although I never had that diagnosis. I didn't have hallucinations but very fixed delusions that there was something wrong with my newborn, and just kept taking him to a&e about normal newborn stuff. I still vividly remember how awful I felt, how intense the feelings were; I didn't have any thoughts about harming my kids but this case really makes me wonder; what if I had of? I was in such a dark place. Any way, that's just my reflection.
I think we all bring our own history to this case and view it via that lens. As you might guess, I feel sympathetic to the NGBI defence. I can't prove it's right, but my balance of probabilities is that it is. Is that because of bias, and a subconscious projection of my experience? Maybe.
But equally I can't understand why that Facebook post is thought to prove anything against her. I don't think she says anything worse than half the parenting posts on here, and not worse than what I say about mine for sure.
Do agree with the argument about 'if she was a babysitter'. Interesting how the perception changes when it's your own kids.
Ramblings over.