Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

How does it feel to be Gender Critical?

993 replies

2021x · 12/11/2026 06:26

I was watching a compilation of Elmo dealing with the fact that everyone is treating Rocco like a living being rather than a rock- especially regarding the cookie!

I felt this is how it feels to be talking to people who wish to validate transgender ideology as a valid identity, or having a conversation about why males shouldn't compete in female categories...

Anyone else have examples of what it is like trying to engage with people who believe TRAs more than their own eyes?

OP posts:
Transperson · Today 12:54

FlirtsWithRhinos · Today 12:44

I'm not "punishing" trans people, I'm simply saying that whatever it is that you experience as your "gender" is a separate thing to my sex, and as long as women (in the original female meaming)'s sex has consequences for us, it's not ok for male people to identify themselves into "womanhood" and into our language, protections and rights because we still need them.

So you can with my blessing coin whatever new name you want to describe the group of people you feel you most belong to. No issues at all with you being who you are.

My issue is with you being something you are not, ie female, and what it does to those of us who are female to have to accept you as somehow "the same" as us based on a definition of us we don't even recognise.

Well I'm precieved as female sex, I can't really ignore that, regardless of my genetypic sex.

I don't think we are in dispute about sex differences.

All I am saying is that properly done uni sex spaces and women's SSSs happens to be where it's safest for me, because I am precieved as female.

Forcing me to use the mens would be directly putting myself in harm.

As an individual I don't really have a choice.
Society enforces harm if I don't do this.

GreyskySexRealistsky · Today 12:55

Transperson · Today 12:54

Well I'm precieved as female sex, I can't really ignore that, regardless of my genetypic sex.

I don't think we are in dispute about sex differences.

All I am saying is that properly done uni sex spaces and women's SSSs happens to be where it's safest for me, because I am precieved as female.

Forcing me to use the mens would be directly putting myself in harm.

As an individual I don't really have a choice.
Society enforces harm if I don't do this.

Edited

It's PERceived. PERceived. PER. CEIVED.

kitex · Today 12:55

Transperson · Today 12:43

Well it's my moral decision to consider the positives and negatives to myself and others.

I have heard your points and I understand where you are coming from. I decided the risk and discomfort for me outweighs the points and possible harm.

Sometimes in society we have to make this kind of decisions, whatever I do someone would be unhappy. Again it's my own subjective moral decision to make.

If you have a problem with me making this decision, I am not the person to tell that to.

Unless you have further points you want to make that are adding more context and isn't a repeat of the other points I have heard by you or others?

Do you even know what morals are?

FlirtsWithRhinos · Today 12:56

solerolover · Today 08:35

"At the centre of sissy porn lies the asshole, a kind of universal vagina through which femaleness can always be accessed. Getting fucked makes you female because fucked is what a female is."

"...an open mouth, an expectant asshole, blank, blank eyes."

Andrea Long Chu - Trans identified male writer

"...My sexual orientation was not gay. It was not straight. It was not pan. It was is always an attraction to misogyny."

"...my gender was so influenced by a need to be used by men."

"...Not feeling femme enough without being a victim of rape"

Hunter Schafer - Trans identified male activist and actor

"Women around the world have been treated as sexual objects. Yet, if sexual objectification is so categorically awful, then why do I want it so badly?"

Jacob Tobia, "Queer", non-binary activist and writer

"I would imagine myself being sold into sex slavery and having strange men take advantage of me."

Julia Serano, Trans identified male academic, writer and activist

As you say, they latch onto the subjugation and humiliation of the women, because, for these types of misogynistic porn brained men, everything starts and ends with their dicks. It's grotesque and it sickens me quite honestly.

How come they never fetishise doing the bulk of women's unpaid labour? Caring for their ageing parents on top of raising their kids and holding down a job? Yeah, we all now why.

Edited

@Transperson

Just coming back to this because I'm not sure you realised that

every single one of these quotes is a published quote from a transwoman other than the one from an AMAB NB.

These are transwomen who have written books about their lived experience of womanhood. Many have medically transitioned.

Are these transwomen lying about being women? If so, how can you tell? And if some transwoman are just pretending even if they have taken those huge medical steps, how on earth can women (female people) be comfortable that any individual random transwoman they encounter in a woman-only space is the real deal?

Transperson · Today 12:57

GreyskySexRealistsky · Today 12:55

It's PERceived. PERceived. PER. CEIVED.

It's the same harm regardless of my genotypic sex. Harm is harm.
If I'm female or precieved as female doesn't matter here because the harm would be the same or worse.

BlueLegume · Today 12:58

Well done @Transperson you completely made the thread all about you. You stole the title of the thread to make it all about you. You told us you do not respect any boundaries other than your own. You told us you use women’s facilities.

You told us you decide who passes as trans and the unpalatable ones are denied their trans identity by you.

Anyway this thread is nearly full. Let’s see where you pop up next. Thanks to some great people on this thread.

Transperson · Today 12:59

kitex · Today 12:55

Do you even know what morals are?

I don't care about your judgment of your morals, you demonstrates lack of empathy and understanding of trans people.

Actually worse you showed harmful things like calling trans people predators.

BlueLegume · Today 12:59

FlirtsWithRhinos · Today 12:56

@Transperson

Just coming back to this because I'm not sure you realised that

every single one of these quotes is a published quote from a transwoman other than the one from an AMAB NB.

These are transwomen who have written books about their lived experience of womanhood. Many have medically transitioned.

Are these transwomen lying about being women? If so, how can you tell? And if some transwoman are just pretending even if they have taken those huge medical steps, how on earth can women (female people) be comfortable that any individual random transwoman they encounter in a woman-only space is the real deal?

Ignoring the unpalatable @Transperson ?

StealthTroublemaker · Today 13:01

Transperson · Today 12:33

So with boundaries. Anyone can set any boundary and you need to take into account practicality.

I can announce to the world that I don't want any human being within a kilometre of me. That's not something people can reasonably be expected to do.

And you can't reasonably assume I'll put myself in danger, fear, or harm for the sake of your boundary.

If you force me into harm because of my gender identity, yes that is bigoted.

Kapish?

But I thought women were supposed to budge up, #bekind and put others first, You don’t seem to be behaving in a very woman way here. I’m seeing more male entitlement and rage …. Almost like you’re mot à woman….

FlirtsWithRhinos · Today 13:02

All about the individual isn't it.

No conception whatsoever about the wider harm done to women and girls if we lose our legal, social and political identity as the female half of humanity in favour of being subsumed into some vague mixed-sex "looks/feels a bit girly and doesn't like the gents bogs" definition that exists entirely for the benefit not of us but of a handful of men who want to pretend to be us.

Transperson · Today 13:02

FlirtsWithRhinos · Today 12:56

@Transperson

Just coming back to this because I'm not sure you realised that

every single one of these quotes is a published quote from a transwoman other than the one from an AMAB NB.

These are transwomen who have written books about their lived experience of womanhood. Many have medically transitioned.

Are these transwomen lying about being women? If so, how can you tell? And if some transwoman are just pretending even if they have taken those huge medical steps, how on earth can women (female people) be comfortable that any individual random transwoman they encounter in a woman-only space is the real deal?

I already responded to some of the quotes, I don't know the entire context.

Could please read some of my previous replies to the quotes and respond to those or point out to specific quotes you would like my opinion on?

StealthTroublemaker · Today 13:02

Transperson · Today 12:59

I don't care about your judgment of your morals, you demonstrates lack of empathy and understanding of trans people.

Actually worse you showed harmful things like calling trans people predators.

Oh nooooo!! That’s literal genocide right there.

Full House 90S GIF
BlueLegume · Today 13:05

Transperson · Today 13:02

I already responded to some of the quotes, I don't know the entire context.

Could please read some of my previous replies to the quotes and respond to those or point out to specific quotes you would like my opinion on?

You stated the men in the post were not trans @Transperson all the while saying we should believe people when they say they are trans. You literally denied them their trans ness.

GreyskySexRealistsky · Today 13:06

In answer to the thread title, THIS is how it feels to be gender critical.

Dealing with men like this.

CompleteGinasaur · Today 13:07

Transperson · Today 13:02

I already responded to some of the quotes, I don't know the entire context.

Could please read some of my previous replies to the quotes and respond to those or point out to specific quotes you would like my opinion on?

"That will do extremely well, child. You have delighted us long enough". Pretty sure there is nothing, quote or otherwise, that anyone would like your opinion on.

Transperson · Today 13:07

FlirtsWithRhinos · Today 13:02

All about the individual isn't it.

No conception whatsoever about the wider harm done to women and girls if we lose our legal, social and political identity as the female half of humanity in favour of being subsumed into some vague mixed-sex "looks/feels a bit girly and doesn't like the gents bogs" definition that exists entirely for the benefit not of us but of a handful of men who want to pretend to be us.

I thought we were advocating for dismantling the patriarchy and gender.
And that sex doesn't matter in an ideal world.

I am just taking steps towards that.

Perenelle · Today 13:08

Transperson · Today 13:07

I thought we were advocating for dismantling the patriarchy and gender.
And that sex doesn't matter in an ideal world.

I am just taking steps towards that.

Sex matters. Stereotypes shouldn't.

GreyskySexRealistsky · Today 13:09

Transperson · Today 13:07

I thought we were advocating for dismantling the patriarchy and gender.
And that sex doesn't matter in an ideal world.

I am just taking steps towards that.

Only a man would say "sex doesn't matter". Women know from a young age that sex matters very much in certain contexts. We know what those specific contexts are and why.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread