Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

How does it feel to be Gender Critical?

991 replies

2021x · 12/11/2026 06:26

I was watching a compilation of Elmo dealing with the fact that everyone is treating Rocco like a living being rather than a rock- especially regarding the cookie!

I felt this is how it feels to be talking to people who wish to validate transgender ideology as a valid identity, or having a conversation about why males shouldn't compete in female categories...

Anyone else have examples of what it is like trying to engage with people who believe TRAs more than their own eyes?

OP posts:
Shedmistress · Today 12:12

Transperson · Today 12:07

I don't do shit? I am not "horrible" nor "awful" to women. Where is my harm?

The problem is you don't see women as human or even able to have boundaries from men like you.

It is awful that no matter what women say you ignore them and use their spaces.

kitex · Today 12:12

Transperson · Today 12:07

I don't do shit? I am not "horrible" nor "awful" to women. Where is my harm?

If you were an actual woman, you would know how horrible and awful you are being to women. The reason you don’t is because you are a man!

kitex · Today 12:15

@Transperson Why don’t you do the decent thing, and stop pretending that you are a woman, and STOP using our spaces!

What is stopping you?

Transperson · Today 12:18

StealthTroublemaker · Today 12:10

You use female spaces when you are not supposed to. You call women bigots for saying no. Use male spaces. .

I'm not obligated to use any specific toilets.
You saying you don't want me to don't mean I have to.
Unless you articulate actual harm that outweighs the harm and discomfort I would otherwise experience.

But that's my subjective, moral decision to make. Not yours, and you can disagree.

Datun · Today 12:20

Philosophically I see people beyond sex, gender, etc and don't think it's relevant in the bigger scale of things.

You use women and their spaces to validate your self image, so you are one hundred percent relying on the fact that sex is entirely relevant to your persona, vital actually.

And then when women oppose that and want their spaces back, suddenly it's irrelevant.

It's male privilege in action, but on steroids.

Datun · Today 12:22

Transperson · Today 12:18

I'm not obligated to use any specific toilets.
You saying you don't want me to don't mean I have to.
Unless you articulate actual harm that outweighs the harm and discomfort I would otherwise experience.

But that's my subjective, moral decision to make. Not yours, and you can disagree.

I'm going to violate your boundaries, use your spaces and there's fuck all you can do about it, and if you object, you're a bigot.

'But there's no harm'.

StealthTroublemaker · Today 12:25

Transperson · Today 12:18

I'm not obligated to use any specific toilets.
You saying you don't want me to don't mean I have to.
Unless you articulate actual harm that outweighs the harm and discomfort I would otherwise experience.

But that's my subjective, moral decision to make. Not yours, and you can disagree.

Yeah tag, you’re full of male entitlement. We get this. How does this align with your gender critical beliefs? I assume you are GC otherwise I’d just presume you came on this thread to scold and derail. Which works not be a very feminine thing to do would it?

OldCrone · Today 12:26

Transperson · Today 12:18

I'm not obligated to use any specific toilets.
You saying you don't want me to don't mean I have to.
Unless you articulate actual harm that outweighs the harm and discomfort I would otherwise experience.

But that's my subjective, moral decision to make. Not yours, and you can disagree.

"Me, me, me, me, me."

I suppose you also identify as not being selfish and entitled.

Mountainlarch · Today 12:27

Far from me to advocate for something so poorly defined as non binary identity to be embedded in law, but wouldn't that make the sex at birth even more important, and trumping gender identity all the time?

BlueLegume · Today 12:28

Transperson · Today 11:19

I haven't met one person who claims to be trans and sissy. Sissy still see themselves as men, that's kinda their whole thing.

All the men in that post say they are trans. Who are you to deny what they say they are @Transperson or is it the reality is you don’t want to be associated with that type of trans?

solerolover · Today 12:29

BackToLurk · Today 11:24

The people quoted in @solerolover's post all claim trans identities. You seem to be rebranding them as 'sissies' so you can exclude them from the category 'trans'.

This is why I'm sex realist/gender critical/have a functioning brain/ common sense/believe in gravity etc. The ability of TRAs to obfuscate, deflect and gaslight in the face of actual evidence, in this case, their own bloody words, is a truly remarkable feat.

Datun · Today 12:29

BlueLegume · Today 12:28

All the men in that post say they are trans. Who are you to deny what they say they are @Transperson or is it the reality is you don’t want to be associated with that type of trans?

If I had a penny for every man who came on here and claimed they are not sissy and are appalled at the very ideah...

Transperson · Today 12:33

Datun · Today 12:22

I'm going to violate your boundaries, use your spaces and there's fuck all you can do about it, and if you object, you're a bigot.

'But there's no harm'.

So with boundaries. Anyone can set any boundary and you need to take into account practicality.

I can announce to the world that I don't want any human being within a kilometre of me. That's not something people can reasonably be expected to do.

And you can't reasonably assume I'll put myself in danger, fear, or harm for the sake of your boundary.

If you force me into harm because of my gender identity, yes that is bigoted.

Kapish?

Datun · Today 12:36

Transperson · Today 12:33

So with boundaries. Anyone can set any boundary and you need to take into account practicality.

I can announce to the world that I don't want any human being within a kilometre of me. That's not something people can reasonably be expected to do.

And you can't reasonably assume I'll put myself in danger, fear, or harm for the sake of your boundary.

If you force me into harm because of my gender identity, yes that is bigoted.

Kapish?

Mate, you're the one putting women in danger. Not the other way round.

It's the law, stay out.

kitex · Today 12:36

Transperson · Today 12:18

I'm not obligated to use any specific toilets.
You saying you don't want me to don't mean I have to.
Unless you articulate actual harm that outweighs the harm and discomfort I would otherwise experience.

But that's my subjective, moral decision to make. Not yours, and you can disagree.

It’s ALL about what you want, with no regard for women at all.

Datun · Today 12:40

It’s ALL about what you want, with no regard for women at all.

The thing is, it is all about the women for men like this. I've said this before.

The women are vital.

Their presence is crucial for the men who want to enter the spaces. The space itself is meaningless, it's just four walls and a ceiling. If the women moved to another place, that would become the target.

Without the presence of women and girls, there is no validation to be had.

It's the women who are the resource, they are the prop, they are the ones being used.

It's far worse than not regarding women at all, it's actively using them. It's their entire purpose.

The women have to be there. And if they're uncomfortable or scared, then I suspect that's just a plus.

Comtesse · Today 12:41

Transperson · Today 12:33

So with boundaries. Anyone can set any boundary and you need to take into account practicality.

I can announce to the world that I don't want any human being within a kilometre of me. That's not something people can reasonably be expected to do.

And you can't reasonably assume I'll put myself in danger, fear, or harm for the sake of your boundary.

If you force me into harm because of my gender identity, yes that is bigoted.

Kapish?

However those are not the conclusions reached by the Supreme Court FWS judgement.

GreyskySexRealistsky · Today 12:41

Transperson · Today 12:18

I'm not obligated to use any specific toilets.
You saying you don't want me to don't mean I have to.
Unless you articulate actual harm that outweighs the harm and discomfort I would otherwise experience.

But that's my subjective, moral decision to make. Not yours, and you can disagree.

You saying you don't want me to don't mean I have to.

Wow.

In this week, of all weeks.

Datun · Today 12:42

GreyskySexRealistsky · Today 12:41

You saying you don't want me to don't mean I have to.

Wow.

In this week, of all weeks.

I know. Operation let them speak. It never fails.

solerolover · Today 12:43

GreyskySexRealistsky · Today 12:41

You saying you don't want me to don't mean I have to.

Wow.

In this week, of all weeks.

It's so galling isn't it? And so unashamedly male.

Transperson · Today 12:43

kitex · Today 12:36

It’s ALL about what you want, with no regard for women at all.

Well it's my moral decision to consider the positives and negatives to myself and others.

I have heard your points and I understand where you are coming from. I decided the risk and discomfort for me outweighs the points and possible harm.

Sometimes in society we have to make this kind of decisions, whatever I do someone would be unhappy. Again it's my own subjective moral decision to make.

If you have a problem with me making this decision, I am not the person to tell that to.

Unless you have further points you want to make that are adding more context and isn't a repeat of the other points I have heard by you or others?

FlirtsWithRhinos · Today 12:44

Transperson · Today 11:55

I never rejected how horrible men see and treat women, we also have some women with internalised misogyny.

I am not saying we are there now, and you seem to agree that sex shouldn't matter.

In that context it means that trans people aren't the issue. Misogyny and patriarchy are. Trans people aren't a representation of those issues.

So why punish trans people?

Edited

I'm not "punishing" trans people, I'm simply saying that whatever it is that you experience as your "gender" is a separate thing to my sex, and as long as women (in the original female meaming)'s sex has consequences for us, it's not ok for male people to identify themselves into "womanhood" and into our language, protections and rights because we still need them.

So you can with my blessing coin whatever new name you want to describe the group of people you feel you most belong to. No issues at all with you being who you are.

My issue is with you being something you are not, ie female, and what it does to those of us who are female to have to accept you as somehow "the same" as us based on a definition of us we don't even recognise.

kitex · Today 12:47

Datun · Today 12:40

It’s ALL about what you want, with no regard for women at all.

The thing is, it is all about the women for men like this. I've said this before.

The women are vital.

Their presence is crucial for the men who want to enter the spaces. The space itself is meaningless, it's just four walls and a ceiling. If the women moved to another place, that would become the target.

Without the presence of women and girls, there is no validation to be had.

It's the women who are the resource, they are the prop, they are the ones being used.

It's far worse than not regarding women at all, it's actively using them. It's their entire purpose.

The women have to be there. And if they're uncomfortable or scared, then I suspect that's just a plus.

Edited

Thanks for explaining this. They are predators. This type of behaviour is so dangerous for girls and women.

Shedmistress · Today 12:51

Transperson · Today 12:43

Well it's my moral decision to consider the positives and negatives to myself and others.

I have heard your points and I understand where you are coming from. I decided the risk and discomfort for me outweighs the points and possible harm.

Sometimes in society we have to make this kind of decisions, whatever I do someone would be unhappy. Again it's my own subjective moral decision to make.

If you have a problem with me making this decision, I am not the person to tell that to.

Unless you have further points you want to make that are adding more context and isn't a repeat of the other points I have heard by you or others?

I have heard your points and I understand where you are coming from. I decided the risk and discomfort for me outweighs the points and possible harm.

His comfort is more important than the risk he poses to all women.

BlueLegume · Today 12:53

No answer from you @Transperson about the fact you denied the men on the post by @solerolover are actually trans.

They all say they are trans so by the logic of trans we have to believe them. Why did you deny they were/are trans?

Too unpalatable to be associated with them?

Swipe left for the next trending thread