Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

How does it feel to be Gender Critical?

939 replies

2021x · 12/11/2026 06:26

I was watching a compilation of Elmo dealing with the fact that everyone is treating Rocco like a living being rather than a rock- especially regarding the cookie!

I felt this is how it feels to be talking to people who wish to validate transgender ideology as a valid identity, or having a conversation about why males shouldn't compete in female categories...

Anyone else have examples of what it is like trying to engage with people who believe TRAs more than their own eyes?

OP posts:
caprioska · Today 05:14

StealthTroublemaker · Today 05:12

You’re not exactly showing the Australian educational system in a good light here mate. But that’s beside the point. How does it feel to be gender Critical at the moment in Australia with all the gender batshittery going on and women being stripped of their rights? It’s nice to see there are some GC people still on that godforsaken island. I mean, you ARE GC I presume, otherwise you might (not by me), be accused of coming to just derail the thread and scold people?

Righto @seethlaw …..

StealthTroublemaker · Today 05:23

caprioska · Today 05:14

Righto @seethlaw …..

Who the chuff is Seethlaw? Why do you keep tagging that person and asking where they went? Are you looking for them? What does that have to do with your feelings as a gender critical person?

As à gender critical person, I find watching the genderborg adherents tie themselves in knots hilarious. Especially on here. They come on the site trying to “own the wims” but just end up looking stupid and getting mocked. Do you get those feelings too?

caprioska · Today 05:27

StealthTroublemaker · Today 05:23

Who the chuff is Seethlaw? Why do you keep tagging that person and asking where they went? Are you looking for them? What does that have to do with your feelings as a gender critical person?

As à gender critical person, I find watching the genderborg adherents tie themselves in knots hilarious. Especially on here. They come on the site trying to “own the wims” but just end up looking stupid and getting mocked. Do you get those feelings too?

Punching on with a thesaurus sorry 'genderborg' now because it won't agree with you are we?

Maybe its time to step away from the keyboard @seethlaw.

StealthTroublemaker · Today 05:39

caprioska · Today 05:27

Punching on with a thesaurus sorry 'genderborg' now because it won't agree with you are we?

Maybe its time to step away from the keyboard @seethlaw.

Are you saying I am seethlaw? I am not seethlaw. I don’t know who this Seethlaw is. Why are you so obsessed with seethlaw? Maybe they ran away from your obsessive stalking? You’re coming across as a bit unhinged here. Getting Kathy Bates vibes honestly. Now, about your feelings as a GC person….

caprioska · Today 05:50

StealthTroublemaker · Today 05:39

Are you saying I am seethlaw? I am not seethlaw. I don’t know who this Seethlaw is. Why are you so obsessed with seethlaw? Maybe they ran away from your obsessive stalking? You’re coming across as a bit unhinged here. Getting Kathy Bates vibes honestly. Now, about your feelings as a GC person….

Every accusation is a confession…

StealthTroublemaker · Today 05:55

caprioska · Today 05:50

Every accusation is a confession…

Ummm. What now? What exactly am I supposed to be confessing to? Not being seethlaw? Ok guv. It’s a fair cop. I am not seethlaw. I may however report you for personal attacks if this continues.

now about being GC, or are you just here looking for your imaginary friend?

BlueLegume · Today 06:43

Who is @seethlaw?

Transperson · Today 07:07

StealthTroublemaker · Today 05:08

But if “man” and “woman” didn’t exist as classes, so there was just “human”, there’d still be two sexes. You can’t eradicate sex. That’s called BIOLOGY. Even if you said everyone was just human, there’d still be one kind of human with penises and one without. So you’d eradicate gender but sex would still be there. Which is why… dun… dun….. sex matters abd gender doesn’t. You’ve literally just made the GC argument. 🏆🏆🏆

No? I'm against drawing boxes for sex too

GreyskySexRealistsky · Today 07:11

Seethlaw is a female poster on here who presents as a man. She dislikes TRAs. She writes interesting and intelligent posts and you can have a fascinating exchange with her.

These two, on the other hand....

GreyskySexRealistsky · Today 07:15

And constantly tagging someone who is not on the thread is classed as bullying

Datun · Today 07:17

FlirtsWithRhinos · Today 01:07

You are making it worse.

Disagree with that all you like, the logic is plain. As soon as you validate the idea that something in the mind, presentation choices or behaviour is what matters for being a man or woman rather than the simple fact of the body, you reinforce gender. You reinforce sexism.

You, a male person, can challenge gender and sexism as a man but you cannot as "a woman" because your ability to be "a woman" depends on them.

So please, save us the self serving justifications. The truth is you do this because you want to, and women - actual women - simply don't matter as much to you as that.

You, a male person, can challenge gender and sexism as a man but you cannot as "a woman" because your ability to be "a woman" depends on them.*

Quite. And the worst possible stereotypes, for most men. Whilst continuing to display stereotypical male behaviour. The need to fetishise women's oppression is paramount.

What baffles me is that as this is splashed across the Internet, from one into the other, why do people imagine we don't know it??

"There is something about being treated like shit by men that feels like affirmation itself, like a cry of delight from the deepest cavern of my breast... To be the victim of honest, undisguised sexism possesses an exhilarating vitality."

— Grace Lavery
Trans-identifying academic & author

Datun · Today 07:18

GreyskySexRealistsky · Today 07:15

And constantly tagging someone who is not on the thread is classed as bullying

I wonder why he's so obsessed with her? Seems like she must've really hit a nerve.

GreyskySexRealistsky · Today 07:20

She spoke A LOT of sense

Compare and contrast

StealthTroublemaker · Today 07:21

Transperson · Today 07:07

No? I'm against drawing boxes for sex too

Unfortunately biology doesn’t give a flying fart what you’re against. Mammals will always come in two sexes and reproduction will need one of each. This may make you sad. I give even less of a flying fart than biology does. So how do you feel being GC and trans? Is that not a huge contradiction?

DialSquare · Today 07:22

Datun · Today 07:18

I wonder why he's so obsessed with her? Seems like she must've really hit a nerve.

She is respected by a lot of the regular posters here so kind of disproves the supposed transphobia.

StealthTroublemaker · Today 07:22

GreyskySexRealistsky · Today 07:11

Seethlaw is a female poster on here who presents as a man. She dislikes TRAs. She writes interesting and intelligent posts and you can have a fascinating exchange with her.

These two, on the other hand....

Edited

Thankyou. I was so confused. So that’s why out Aussie friend is obsessed with her?

GreyskySexRealistsky · Today 07:25

Lawd knows

GriseldaandMike · Today 07:33

Transperson · Today 00:07

Aren't you policing what women should look like?

I'm not whining and definitely not campaigning to isolate trans people from public life.

I am trying to advocate for myself and share my lived experience. Yes it's selfish, but you kinda have to be selfish to some extent to have self-preservation and advocate for it.

Edited

Aren't you policing what women should look like?

Absolutely not, in fact the very opposite you are saying because you have some characteristics that you read as female (boobs and long hair?) You are a woman. I am saying that woman something slightly over 50% of the human population is regardless of how they look. Flat chested women are women, shorthaired women are women, very tall women are women, butch presenting woman are women. Small men with delicate features, long hair, boobs, make up and dresses may look feminine but they are not women.

Woman isn't a look, it's not a costume a man can put on, it's not a way to act or to think, it is imutable biology.

GriseldaandMike · Today 07:40

@Transperson it clarify I don't think you aren't a woman because you don't look womanly enough, I think you aren't a woman because your Y chromosome has made you develop down the pathway of a body that produces small mobile gamates and the those bodies and the experiences of people that have them are very different to the bodies and experiences of the people who have bodies developed to make large immobile gamates.

kitex · Today 07:41

The posts from @caprioska and @Transperson are absurd. Face it, we are never going to think what you are doing is right. You both come across as unhinged and creepy.

Neither of you has a clue what being a woman entails, simply because you are men.

If you were women, you wouldn’t be acting this way. You would understand automatically why we don’t want men in our spaces. (We have to repeat ourselves a lot in these discussions!)

Datun · Today 07:42

Datun · Today 07:17

You, a male person, can challenge gender and sexism as a man but you cannot as "a woman" because your ability to be "a woman" depends on them.*

Quite. And the worst possible stereotypes, for most men. Whilst continuing to display stereotypical male behaviour. The need to fetishise women's oppression is paramount.

What baffles me is that as this is splashed across the Internet, from one into the other, why do people imagine we don't know it??

"There is something about being treated like shit by men that feels like affirmation itself, like a cry of delight from the deepest cavern of my breast... To be the victim of honest, undisguised sexism possesses an exhilarating vitality."

— Grace Lavery
Trans-identifying academic & author

Just quoting my own post here, because this is a running theme.

There is something about being treated like shit by men that feels like affirmation itself

Almost all the TIMs who post here talk about being the subject of misogyny, or even worse.

OldCrone · Today 07:42

Aren't you policing what women should look like?

What has anyone said on here that makes you think that @Transperson?

GreyskySexRealistsky · Today 07:44

Obviously no one should suffer harassment or attacks. But it's not misogyny if you're male.

BlueLegume · Today 07:45

kitex · Today 07:41

The posts from @caprioska and @Transperson are absurd. Face it, we are never going to think what you are doing is right. You both come across as unhinged and creepy.

Neither of you has a clue what being a woman entails, simply because you are men.

If you were women, you wouldn’t be acting this way. You would understand automatically why we don’t want men in our spaces. (We have to repeat ourselves a lot in these discussions!)

Quite. Well said. Mansplaining at its finest.

Datun · Today 07:45

OldCrone · Today 07:42

Aren't you policing what women should look like?

What has anyone said on here that makes you think that @Transperson?

It's so tedious.

They take a feminist issue, women being judged for their looks, and then use it to double down on the claim that they're still women, despite having an Adam's apple, a beard, whatever.