Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

How does it feel to be Gender Critical?

943 replies

2021x · 12/11/2026 06:26

I was watching a compilation of Elmo dealing with the fact that everyone is treating Rocco like a living being rather than a rock- especially regarding the cookie!

I felt this is how it feels to be talking to people who wish to validate transgender ideology as a valid identity, or having a conversation about why males shouldn't compete in female categories...

Anyone else have examples of what it is like trying to engage with people who believe TRAs more than their own eyes?

OP posts:
Imdunfer · Today 08:11

caprioska · Yesterday 21:23

You aren't listening. 'Sex based rights' (an exemption from anti discrimination law) aren't a given. Exclusion needs to be justified via the criteria for special exemptions.

In other words natal males can challenge an exemption if it its not legally justified. & this is irrelevant to gender identification.

It's you who are confusing gender identification as being the barrier to 'sex based rights' when the barrier is lack of justification.

It is priceless that you tell us that it is we who are not listening. We have explained until the cows come home why our sex based rights are justified. You don't want to hear it.

Imdunfer · Today 08:17

Transperson · Yesterday 23:39

I can't speak for other trans people but that's not the case for me.

For me it's coming from how I want to express myself, I transitioned for myself and I don't have a specific box I put myself in.

Then what did you transition to if you didn't transition to something you saw in other people?

And if it wasn't an already recognised category of humanity, why was "transition" necessary and what did it amount to?

Imdunfer · Today 08:19

Transperson · Today 07:07

No? I'm against drawing boxes for sex too

Are there any other parts of reality you draw the line at believing in?

Comtesse · Today 08:21

How does it feel to be GC? Frustrating because if the need to have circular arguments with smug, bad faith characters (“sex is complicated, gender is whatever I say it is, ultrasounds are just surface level observations” etc etc etc).

solerolover · Today 08:35

Datun · Today 07:17

You, a male person, can challenge gender and sexism as a man but you cannot as "a woman" because your ability to be "a woman" depends on them.*

Quite. And the worst possible stereotypes, for most men. Whilst continuing to display stereotypical male behaviour. The need to fetishise women's oppression is paramount.

What baffles me is that as this is splashed across the Internet, from one into the other, why do people imagine we don't know it??

"There is something about being treated like shit by men that feels like affirmation itself, like a cry of delight from the deepest cavern of my breast... To be the victim of honest, undisguised sexism possesses an exhilarating vitality."

— Grace Lavery
Trans-identifying academic & author

"At the centre of sissy porn lies the asshole, a kind of universal vagina through which femaleness can always be accessed. Getting fucked makes you female because fucked is what a female is."

"...an open mouth, an expectant asshole, blank, blank eyes."

Andrea Long Chu - Trans identified male writer

"...My sexual orientation was not gay. It was not straight. It was not pan. It was is always an attraction to misogyny."

"...my gender was so influenced by a need to be used by men."

"...Not feeling femme enough without being a victim of rape"

Hunter Schafer - Trans identified male activist and actor

"Women around the world have been treated as sexual objects. Yet, if sexual objectification is so categorically awful, then why do I want it so badly?"

Jacob Tobia, "Queer", non-binary activist and writer

"I would imagine myself being sold into sex slavery and having strange men take advantage of me."

Julia Serano, Trans identified male academic, writer and activist

As you say, they latch onto the subjugation and humiliation of the women, because, for these types of misogynistic porn brained men, everything starts and ends with their dicks. It's grotesque and it sickens me quite honestly.

How come they never fetishise doing the bulk of women's unpaid labour? Caring for their ageing parents on top of raising their kids and holding down a job? Yeah, we all now why.

kitex · Today 08:37

Imdunfer · Today 08:11

It is priceless that you tell us that it is we who are not listening. We have explained until the cows come home why our sex based rights are justified. You don't want to hear it.

Imagine men having the audacity to tell women about justification!

kitex · Today 08:52

solerolover · Today 08:35

"At the centre of sissy porn lies the asshole, a kind of universal vagina through which femaleness can always be accessed. Getting fucked makes you female because fucked is what a female is."

"...an open mouth, an expectant asshole, blank, blank eyes."

Andrea Long Chu - Trans identified male writer

"...My sexual orientation was not gay. It was not straight. It was not pan. It was is always an attraction to misogyny."

"...my gender was so influenced by a need to be used by men."

"...Not feeling femme enough without being a victim of rape"

Hunter Schafer - Trans identified male activist and actor

"Women around the world have been treated as sexual objects. Yet, if sexual objectification is so categorically awful, then why do I want it so badly?"

Jacob Tobia, "Queer", non-binary activist and writer

"I would imagine myself being sold into sex slavery and having strange men take advantage of me."

Julia Serano, Trans identified male academic, writer and activist

As you say, they latch onto the subjugation and humiliation of the women, because, for these types of misogynistic porn brained men, everything starts and ends with their dicks. It's grotesque and it sickens me quite honestly.

How come they never fetishise doing the bulk of women's unpaid labour? Caring for their ageing parents on top of raising their kids and holding down a job? Yeah, we all now why.

Edited

These quotes are appalling! It is a sick, perverted fetish.

FlirtsWithRhinos · Today 09:04

Imdunfer · Today 08:11

It is priceless that you tell us that it is we who are not listening. We have explained until the cows come home why our sex based rights are justified. You don't want to hear it.

I'd say (s)he does want to hear it, and understands it perfectly well. (S)he simply enjoys pretending not to understand.

Probably because the only possible way to "argue" his or her case is to fail to acknowledge all the reasons it falls down. And (s)he would rather "win" in his/her own head by avoiding public admission that his/her transparently poor argument has been thoroughly trounced than face the ego-blow of having to deal with the substance of the arguments.

How does it feel to be Gender Critical?
GriseldaandMike · Today 09:14

@Transperson so if we subscribe to your idea that access to female only spaces is unlocked by boobs where are prepubesant girls going? Or women who have a flat chest? Or women who have had a double mastectomy? It is your way of classing 'women' that is dependant on looking a certain way (be-titted) not mine.

BlueLegume · Today 09:15

kitex · Today 08:52

These quotes are appalling! It is a sick, perverted fetish.

And these are a small snapshot of examples of men quite happy to put down in black and white their fetish.

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · Today 09:26

GreyskySexRealistsky · Today 07:11

Seethlaw is a female poster on here who presents as a man. She dislikes TRAs. She writes interesting and intelligent posts and you can have a fascinating exchange with her.

These two, on the other hand....

Edited

She is also French but writes far better English than any of our whiney interlopers.

RapidOnsetGenderCritic · Today 09:28

caprioska · Today 05:50

Every accusation is a confession…

What are you confessing?

BlueLegume · Today 09:43

solerolover · Today 08:35

"At the centre of sissy porn lies the asshole, a kind of universal vagina through which femaleness can always be accessed. Getting fucked makes you female because fucked is what a female is."

"...an open mouth, an expectant asshole, blank, blank eyes."

Andrea Long Chu - Trans identified male writer

"...My sexual orientation was not gay. It was not straight. It was not pan. It was is always an attraction to misogyny."

"...my gender was so influenced by a need to be used by men."

"...Not feeling femme enough without being a victim of rape"

Hunter Schafer - Trans identified male activist and actor

"Women around the world have been treated as sexual objects. Yet, if sexual objectification is so categorically awful, then why do I want it so badly?"

Jacob Tobia, "Queer", non-binary activist and writer

"I would imagine myself being sold into sex slavery and having strange men take advantage of me."

Julia Serano, Trans identified male academic, writer and activist

As you say, they latch onto the subjugation and humiliation of the women, because, for these types of misogynistic porn brained men, everything starts and ends with their dicks. It's grotesque and it sickens me quite honestly.

How come they never fetishise doing the bulk of women's unpaid labour? Caring for their ageing parents on top of raising their kids and holding down a job? Yeah, we all now why.

Edited

Anything from @caprioska in response to this post? All facts recorded and printed. Pretty grim I would say.

Imdunfer · Today 09:49

BlueLegume · Today 09:43

Anything from @caprioska in response to this post? All facts recorded and printed. Pretty grim I would say.

If anyone has any doubts about the authenticity all they need to do is Google "cissy porn". I don't recommend it.

kitex · Today 10:10

BlueLegume · Today 09:43

Anything from @caprioska in response to this post? All facts recorded and printed. Pretty grim I would say.

These men are depraved. They just see women as objects to be played with. This is how I see posters like @caprioska and @Transperson They pretend to be women, but they actually hate women.

OldCrone · Today 10:17

solerolover · Today 08:35

"At the centre of sissy porn lies the asshole, a kind of universal vagina through which femaleness can always be accessed. Getting fucked makes you female because fucked is what a female is."

"...an open mouth, an expectant asshole, blank, blank eyes."

Andrea Long Chu - Trans identified male writer

"...My sexual orientation was not gay. It was not straight. It was not pan. It was is always an attraction to misogyny."

"...my gender was so influenced by a need to be used by men."

"...Not feeling femme enough without being a victim of rape"

Hunter Schafer - Trans identified male activist and actor

"Women around the world have been treated as sexual objects. Yet, if sexual objectification is so categorically awful, then why do I want it so badly?"

Jacob Tobia, "Queer", non-binary activist and writer

"I would imagine myself being sold into sex slavery and having strange men take advantage of me."

Julia Serano, Trans identified male academic, writer and activist

As you say, they latch onto the subjugation and humiliation of the women, because, for these types of misogynistic porn brained men, everything starts and ends with their dicks. It's grotesque and it sickens me quite honestly.

How come they never fetishise doing the bulk of women's unpaid labour? Caring for their ageing parents on top of raising their kids and holding down a job? Yeah, we all now why.

Edited

They told us to educate ourselves.

They told us to listen to what transpeople were saying.

We listened. We learnt.

kitex · Today 10:33

“One should judge a man mainly from his depravities. Virtues can be faked. Depravities are real.”

Transperson · Today 10:36

Imdunfer · Today 08:17

Then what did you transition to if you didn't transition to something you saw in other people?

And if it wasn't an already recognised category of humanity, why was "transition" necessary and what did it amount to?

Edited

Well on a personal level I'm just enacting what makes me feel better and happier with my body and sense of self.

Philosophically I see people beyond sex, gender, etc and don't think it's relevant in the bigger scale of things.

Socially to an outside observer I changed my phenotypic sex.

BlueLegume · Today 10:42

Transperson · Today 10:36

Well on a personal level I'm just enacting what makes me feel better and happier with my body and sense of self.

Philosophically I see people beyond sex, gender, etc and don't think it's relevant in the bigger scale of things.

Socially to an outside observer I changed my phenotypic sex.

We know you have told us over thousands of posts @Transperson you seem to need to convince yourself with the repeated use of verbose language.

Any thoughts on the post by @solerolover outlining just a few men who know they are where they are because of porn?

Transperson · Today 10:55

BlueLegume · Today 10:42

We know you have told us over thousands of posts @Transperson you seem to need to convince yourself with the repeated use of verbose language.

Any thoughts on the post by @solerolover outlining just a few men who know they are where they are because of porn?

I'm responding to others, you might know.
The day people won't ask me, I won't tell.

Porn? What idk what post you are referring to. But, figuring out one's sexuality is unrelated to this conversation?

solerolover · Today 10:57

kitex · Today 08:52

These quotes are appalling! It is a sick, perverted fetish.

Yep. I forgot to add this extract from The Transsexual Empire (1979) by Janice Raymond (very elucidating read btw), where she's taking about the trans identitied male historian Jan Morris and his fetishisation of and revelling in misogyny:

With all the fervor used to espouse the masculine, he now espouses the feminine. “Her frailty is her strength, her inferiority is her privilege” (pp. 167-68). Thus in one surgical stroke, Morris accepts the woman-on-a-pedestal myth. “She” extolls eternal womanhood in the same way “she” extolls “male swank and swagger.” Now it seems only “common sense” to want to be a woman rather than a man. Not only does “she” like being a woman, but “she” likes all of the proclaimed “benefits” of womanhood. “I like being a woman, but I mean a woman. I like having my suitcase carried.. . . I like gossiping with the lady upstairs.. . . And yes, I like to be liked by men. ”

“Her” first experience of “being liked” by a man was in a London taxi cab where the driver “boldly” kissed her “roughly and not at all disagreeably on the lips, ” after which he said, “There’s a good girl, ” and “patted her bottom. ” “She” loved it because it gave “her” a first experience of what it was to be loved and “cherished” by a man as a woman.

ETA: and this!! Perfectly mirrors the point I made earlier about men who say they're women, only wanting what they consider to be the "desirabl"e parts of womanhood. Raymond was such a visionary my goodness, this is from nearly half a century:

My own interview data confirms the same kind of contradictions. R., for example, said “she” didn’t believe in part of the stereotypic ally feminine role, such as doing housework, wanting kids, staying around the house, but “she” delighted in wearing profuse make-up and frilly feminine clothes.

BlueLegume · Today 11:08

solerolover · Today 08:35

"At the centre of sissy porn lies the asshole, a kind of universal vagina through which femaleness can always be accessed. Getting fucked makes you female because fucked is what a female is."

"...an open mouth, an expectant asshole, blank, blank eyes."

Andrea Long Chu - Trans identified male writer

"...My sexual orientation was not gay. It was not straight. It was not pan. It was is always an attraction to misogyny."

"...my gender was so influenced by a need to be used by men."

"...Not feeling femme enough without being a victim of rape"

Hunter Schafer - Trans identified male activist and actor

"Women around the world have been treated as sexual objects. Yet, if sexual objectification is so categorically awful, then why do I want it so badly?"

Jacob Tobia, "Queer", non-binary activist and writer

"I would imagine myself being sold into sex slavery and having strange men take advantage of me."

Julia Serano, Trans identified male academic, writer and activist

As you say, they latch onto the subjugation and humiliation of the women, because, for these types of misogynistic porn brained men, everything starts and ends with their dicks. It's grotesque and it sickens me quite honestly.

How come they never fetishise doing the bulk of women's unpaid labour? Caring for their ageing parents on top of raising their kids and holding down a job? Yeah, we all now why.

Edited

This @Transperson this post by @solerolover

BlueLegume · Today 11:10

Transperson · Today 10:55

I'm responding to others, you might know.
The day people won't ask me, I won't tell.

Porn? What idk what post you are referring to. But, figuring out one's sexuality is unrelated to this conversation?

So you select which posts to read as well. The one posted by @solerolover was pretty hard to miss and ignore.

Transperson · Today 11:11

solerolover · Today 10:57

Yep. I forgot to add this extract from The Transsexual Empire (1979) by Janice Raymond (very elucidating read btw), where she's taking about the trans identitied male historian Jan Morris and his fetishisation of and revelling in misogyny:

With all the fervor used to espouse the masculine, he now espouses the feminine. “Her frailty is her strength, her inferiority is her privilege” (pp. 167-68). Thus in one surgical stroke, Morris accepts the woman-on-a-pedestal myth. “She” extolls eternal womanhood in the same way “she” extolls “male swank and swagger.” Now it seems only “common sense” to want to be a woman rather than a man. Not only does “she” like being a woman, but “she” likes all of the proclaimed “benefits” of womanhood. “I like being a woman, but I mean a woman. I like having my suitcase carried.. . . I like gossiping with the lady upstairs.. . . And yes, I like to be liked by men. ”

“Her” first experience of “being liked” by a man was in a London taxi cab where the driver “boldly” kissed her “roughly and not at all disagreeably on the lips, ” after which he said, “There’s a good girl, ” and “patted her bottom. ” “She” loved it because it gave “her” a first experience of what it was to be loved and “cherished” by a man as a woman.

ETA: and this!! Perfectly mirrors the point I made earlier about men who say they're women, only wanting what they consider to be the "desirabl"e parts of womanhood. Raymond was such a visionary my goodness, this is from nearly half a century:

My own interview data confirms the same kind of contradictions. R., for example, said “she” didn’t believe in part of the stereotypic ally feminine role, such as doing housework, wanting kids, staying around the house, but “she” delighted in wearing profuse make-up and frilly feminine clothes.

Edited

Wow a book in the 80s about gender stereotypes and how society enforces them, who would have thought.

Although much of society still operates on these stereotypes, regardless of the existence of trans people.

Also do you not notice that the quote is a perspective of how she is discovering what it feels like to be comfortable with her sense of self? And interact with the world with that comfortability for the first time.

Her being treated differently because she is presenting herself differently isn't in her control.

It would be problematic if one didn't transition for themselves but instead for society and its stereotypes.

Comtesse · Today 11:14

That’s a funny take on the Jan Morris experience. Most women would be deeply annoyed / upset by being hit on the backside by a random taxi driver. Not rather delighted by the experience.

Swipe left for the next trending thread