Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

How does it feel to be Gender Critical?

740 replies

2021x · 12/11/2026 06:26

I was watching a compilation of Elmo dealing with the fact that everyone is treating Rocco like a living being rather than a rock- especially regarding the cookie!

I felt this is how it feels to be talking to people who wish to validate transgender ideology as a valid identity, or having a conversation about why males shouldn't compete in female categories...

Anyone else have examples of what it is like trying to engage with people who believe TRAs more than their own eyes?

OP posts:
caprioska · Yesterday 19:59

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · Yesterday 08:08

My quote specifically states "Australia has no long history" that's because its only just over 200 years old as compared to England's 1000 plus years.

Tsk tsk. Indigenous people of Australia would beg to differ. It's rather racist to assume - as you have done - that history is only history if it's white. And you wouldn't want to do that, would you?

Australia has no written history before the First Fleet (actually there's some evidence the Dutch and probably the Portuguese discovered it in the 17c but that's derailing).

Social & class hierarchies only go back 200 hundred odd years in Australia. 65 thousand years of tribal living doesn't exactly qualify as the same thing. Traditional Indigenous Australian societies were largely egalitarian and did not have centralised social or class hierarchies, kings or autocratic chiefs.
Instead of wealth-based or hereditary class systems, social organisation was shaped by complex networks of kinship, age, and spiritual authority.

caprioska · Yesterday 20:02

Imdunfer · Yesterday 08:12

'If we pretend gender doesn't exist by strawmanning the actual claim then we delegitimise trans people as an identity'.

Trans people delegitimise themselves when they claim to be women but can find no other way to explain why they believe they are women than to adopt a gender stereotype of femininity which many women themselves do not adopt.

Nobody cares if you choose to live as you feel comfortable, with a very short list of exceptions.

It is your claim to be a different sex than the one you were born which is not legitimate, not your person.

Sex & gender aren't the same thing & gender is well defined. In fact gender critical feminists defined it as sex stereotypes.

caprioska · Yesterday 20:08

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · Yesterday 08:55

GC ideology is essentially conservative coded in its traditionalist pro conformist leanings.

Could you define what you mean by these 'traditionalist pro conformist leanings,' please? just so we're all talking about the same thing.

Valuing historical precedents, established customs and long-standing social structures.

selffellatingouroborosofhate · Yesterday 20:14

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · Yesterday 19:46

Sorry. I took the question as being about who runs things, as opposed to who is in Debrett, so I was addressing the rulers rather than the absurdity that is that shopping list for aspirational Americans from the Right Family. Do the nobility really run things in England (and Wales and Scotland and Northern Ireland)? Even if they did, a fairly large majority of the House of Lords was new creations by 1930, let alone the present one being quite other than hereditary; there was a bit of legislation this year called The House of Lords (Hereditary Peers) Act which means people with inherited titles can only have seats in the House of Lords if they are separately appointed as Life Peers.

(Not sure how long it has been since the Normans lorded it over anyone in particular; possibly since before Chris de Burgh, ancestry back to Richard II or whatever, not to mention to a particular fishing village in Norway before the time of Rollo, became a pop singer...)

Edited

Who owns the land, holds the true power.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · Yesterday 20:17

caprioska · Yesterday 20:08

Valuing historical precedents, established customs and long-standing social structures.

And what would those be specifically?

caprioska · Yesterday 20:19

selffellatingouroborosofhate · Yesterday 18:31

Charles is still king of Australia, unlike plenty of other ex-colonies that are now republics.

White Australians haven't needed to introduce a class hierarchy because they've got a race hierarchy doing that job, same as the Americans do. The British class hierarchy is a race hierarchy in all but name: Normans lording it over Saxons and Celts since 1066.

If you think english royalty & their aristocracy have any salience in Australia I have news.

Australia is a country of immigrants with over half the Australian population being of a non english speaking back ground from races & ethnicities from all over the world. Not to mention our laws haven't permitted discrimination or hate speech for decades so a 'race' hierarchy is a bit of a tricky sell.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · Yesterday 20:22

caprioska · Yesterday 19:59

Social & class hierarchies only go back 200 hundred odd years in Australia. 65 thousand years of tribal living doesn't exactly qualify as the same thing. Traditional Indigenous Australian societies were largely egalitarian and did not have centralised social or class hierarchies, kings or autocratic chiefs.
Instead of wealth-based or hereditary class systems, social organisation was shaped by complex networks of kinship, age, and spiritual authority.

That's still having a history. I notice you've swerved slightly from claiming Australia has only had history since the First Fleet arrived and gone back to social hierarchies.

Traditional Indigenous Australian societies were largely egalitarian

So not completely egalitarian, then. Doesn't that imply the existence of hierarchies?

caprioska · Yesterday 20:23

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · Yesterday 20:17

And what would those be specifically?

Maybe google the history of conservatism for the details.

OldCrone · Yesterday 20:26

caprioska · Yesterday 20:23

Maybe google the history of conservatism for the details.

What has the history of conservatism got to do with any of this? You seem to be going off on bizarre tangents (no change there).

StealthTroublemaker · Yesterday 20:29

caprioska · Yesterday 20:02

Sex & gender aren't the same thing & gender is well defined. In fact gender critical feminists defined it as sex stereotypes.

So if sex and gender are different, as you have said, why would someone’s “gender” entitle them to use spaces designated for the opposite sex? Surely they should use the mixed gender, single sex spaces of their sex?

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · Yesterday 20:29

caprioska · Yesterday 20:23

Maybe google the history of conservatism for the details.

Nope, I'm asking what YOU mean and understand by those terms. Not a wiki page's meaning, yours.

caprioska · Yesterday 20:29

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · Yesterday 20:22

That's still having a history. I notice you've swerved slightly from claiming Australia has only had history since the First Fleet arrived and gone back to social hierarchies.

Traditional Indigenous Australian societies were largely egalitarian

So not completely egalitarian, then. Doesn't that imply the existence of hierarchies?

If you’re attempting to argue tribal social structures are the same as two hundred year old one's in Australia you won't get any further argument from me. That lunacy is self evident.

caprioska · Yesterday 20:30

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · Yesterday 20:29

Nope, I'm asking what YOU mean and understand by those terms. Not a wiki page's meaning, yours.

I understand them to be the same as what's widely accepted by them. See: google.

caprioska · Yesterday 20:32

StealthTroublemaker · Yesterday 20:29

So if sex and gender are different, as you have said, why would someone’s “gender” entitle them to use spaces designated for the opposite sex? Surely they should use the mixed gender, single sex spaces of their sex?

Because our legal system allows spaces to be contested based on not being justifiably designated to the opposite sex.

Imdunfer · Yesterday 20:35

caprioska · Yesterday 20:02

Sex & gender aren't the same thing & gender is well defined. In fact gender critical feminists defined it as sex stereotypes.

Sex & gender aren't the same thing

I'm pleased to see you acknowledge this. I'm not sure why you felt you needed to tell me, that has never been in doubt in my mind or in anything that I have written.

& gender is well defined.

That's news to me. Gender and how many of them there are varies considerably depending on who's talking about it.

In fact gender critical feminists defined it as sex stereotypes.

Genders are the stereotype. Sex is binary and immutable no matter what the gender presentation is.

Themaghag · Yesterday 20:36

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 12/11/2026 07:46

It's really simple.

Trans people exist. And if you know them and accept them, using their correct name and pronouns is incredibly easy. Because that's just who they are.

Doesn't matter what they look like. My son is my son, regardless of whether he has visible boobs or not.

My stepdad is my dad., same as my half-brother will always be my brother, despite us all looking nothing alike.

It's really easy to see beyond a difference you don't share to the person. All you have to do is be a decent human being who values respect, and keeps an open mind.

Same as it's easy to accept people of different races than your own as equals, gay marriage as equal to straight and, say, women pilots as equal to male in ability.

People different to you all bleed the same, live the same, feel the same. Did no one ever teach you that?

The thing is though, I don't accept them and I will never accept that trans women are women when they are clearly men who expect to retain every last iota of male privilege while also expecting to enjoy the very few, hard won rights of women. I don't want to share single sex spaces with men, I won't use incorrect pronouns and I will never be told what to think or do by any man, however he identifies
And I've completely had it with being kind to men peddling their latest take on weaponised misogyny. Being kind is what has landed us in this mess.

caprioska · Yesterday 20:37

Imdunfer · Yesterday 20:35

Sex & gender aren't the same thing

I'm pleased to see you acknowledge this. I'm not sure why you felt you needed to tell me, that has never been in doubt in my mind or in anything that I have written.

& gender is well defined.

That's news to me. Gender and how many of them there are varies considerably depending on who's talking about it.

In fact gender critical feminists defined it as sex stereotypes.

Genders are the stereotype. Sex is binary and immutable no matter what the gender presentation is.

Two clicks….

"Gender refers to the socially constructed norms, behaviours , expressions, and psychological roles that a given society associates with being a man, woman, boy, or girl, as well as identities beyond a strict binary."

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · Yesterday 20:38

caprioska · Yesterday 20:29

If you’re attempting to argue tribal social structures are the same as two hundred year old one's in Australia you won't get any further argument from me. That lunacy is self evident.

I'm not. But as you appear not to understand straightforward English and trying to have a dialogue with you is futile, I'm giving up the attempt. I look forward to your further explanation of your terms for GC women, though.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · Yesterday 20:39

caprioska · Yesterday 20:30

I understand them to be the same as what's widely accepted by them. See: google.

Again - YOUR understanding of what you mean by those terms you used.

You can't, can you? it was just a word salad.

OldCrone · Yesterday 20:40

StealthTroublemaker · Yesterday 20:29

So if sex and gender are different, as you have said, why would someone’s “gender” entitle them to use spaces designated for the opposite sex? Surely they should use the mixed gender, single sex spaces of their sex?

And if sex and gender are different, why are children with gender identities persuaded that they need to change their bodies to look like the opposite sex? Surely you can just be the sex you are, with the body you already have, and have any gender identity.

caprioska · Yesterday 20:42

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · Yesterday 20:39

Again - YOUR understanding of what you mean by those terms you used.

You can't, can you? it was just a word salad.

Again - Same thing as google.

You act as if there aren't broadly accepted understandings of those terms.

Imdunfer · Yesterday 20:48

caprioska · Yesterday 20:37

Two clicks….

"Gender refers to the socially constructed norms, behaviours , expressions, and psychological roles that a given society associates with being a man, woman, boy, or girl, as well as identities beyond a strict binary."

You're leaving out all the word wrangling about gender.

CIS gender, even if you are a woman who believes you are a woman but present entirely as a man.

Transgender, even when those people maintain that they have changed sex.

Non-binary, meaning who knows what. Refusing to accept living with a gender stereotype? Welcome to the world of many normal women.

Two clicks ...
"Gender Expression: How a person outwardly presents their gender—through clothing, hairstyle, behavior, or voice—which may or may not conform to traditional societal norms or their internal identity. *

IE gender expression may have nothing to do with socially constructed norms, so what is gender then?

OldCrone · Yesterday 20:53

caprioska · Yesterday 20:08

Valuing historical precedents, established customs and long-standing social structures.

caprioska · Today 20:37
"Gender refers to the socially constructed norms, behaviours , expressions, and psychological roles that a given society associates with being a man, woman, boy, or girl, as well as identities beyond a strict binary."

So putting these two posts together, it seems you are saying that you are essentially conservative coded in your traditionalist pro conformist leanings, since you think that regressive gender stereotyping is an essential part of someone's being.

caprioska · Yesterday 21:07

OldCrone · Yesterday 20:53

caprioska · Today 20:37
"Gender refers to the socially constructed norms, behaviours , expressions, and psychological roles that a given society associates with being a man, woman, boy, or girl, as well as identities beyond a strict binary."

So putting these two posts together, it seems you are saying that you are essentially conservative coded in your traditionalist pro conformist leanings, since you think that regressive gender stereotyping is an essential part of someone's being.

Your'e confusing description with prescription. I'm not prescribing a superior choice.

How individuals define their identity is personally subjective values & beliefs based. Liberalism is kind of distinct from conservatism in that its principles are based on individual freedoms rather than only following tradition.

caprioska · Yesterday 21:13

Imdunfer · Yesterday 20:48

You're leaving out all the word wrangling about gender.

CIS gender, even if you are a woman who believes you are a woman but present entirely as a man.

Transgender, even when those people maintain that they have changed sex.

Non-binary, meaning who knows what. Refusing to accept living with a gender stereotype? Welcome to the world of many normal women.

Two clicks ...
"Gender Expression: How a person outwardly presents their gender—through clothing, hairstyle, behavior, or voice—which may or may not conform to traditional societal norms or their internal identity. *

IE gender expression may have nothing to do with socially constructed norms, so what is gender then?

Edited

CIS gender, even if you are a woman who believes you are a woman but present entirely as a man.

You forgot the 'assigned' bit which is kind of relevant to socially construction.

Transgender, even when those people maintain that they have changed sex.

Sex traits are changeable.

Non-binary, meaning who knows what. Refusing to accept living with a gender stereotype? Welcome to the world of many normal women.

Woohoo well done! That wasn't so hard was it?