Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

How does it feel to be Gender Critical?

740 replies

2021x · 12/11/2026 06:26

I was watching a compilation of Elmo dealing with the fact that everyone is treating Rocco like a living being rather than a rock- especially regarding the cookie!

I felt this is how it feels to be talking to people who wish to validate transgender ideology as a valid identity, or having a conversation about why males shouldn't compete in female categories...

Anyone else have examples of what it is like trying to engage with people who believe TRAs more than their own eyes?

OP posts:
caprioska · 15/11/2026 22:36

MarcTheGenderSkeptic · 15/11/2026 22:22

Ah, these empires weren't totally fascist, they were a heart run by people's who became social democracies, Britain on the other hand is still stuck in the 19th century. And that's why we're TERF Island.
You really are grasping.

Let's face it there was no socialist revolution in the UK like France or Spain hence it's conservative hierarchical mindset still underpins culture despite however much some claim to be of the left. GC ideology is essentially conservative coded in its traditionalist pro conformist leanings.

JanesLittleGirl · 15/11/2026 22:48

caprioska · 15/11/2026 22:36

Let's face it there was no socialist revolution in the UK like France or Spain hence it's conservative hierarchical mindset still underpins culture despite however much some claim to be of the left. GC ideology is essentially conservative coded in its traditionalist pro conformist leanings.

Edited

Enlighten me please? When were these socialist revolutions in France and Spain? Was the French Revolution a socialist revolution? When was the Spanish Revolution?

Why does the English Revolution not count?

lcakethereforeIam · 15/11/2026 22:50

Did someone just erase the Australian aborigines again?

JanesLittleGirl · 15/11/2026 22:55

lcakethereforeIam · 15/11/2026 22:50

Did someone just erase the Australian aborigines again?

We are watching history being rewritten on a massive scale in real time. Indigenous Australians are barely a footnote.

inkymoose · 15/11/2026 23:01

MarcTheGenderSkeptic · 15/11/2026 17:35

Of course I lay myself open to ridicule saying I didn't always used be a Trump naysayer.

You used the word "recently" so I thought it must be another "prominent leader" but thank you for the clarification.

PriOn1 · 15/11/2026 23:07

Prekoc2 · 12/11/2026 07:34

I'm glad someone else asked that (about "your priors"). I was beginning to think I must be being extraordinarily dense.

Apologies, the thread has moved on - should have checked. Never mind…. I’ll leave my post to stand anyway.

We need to stop assuming that we are too stupid to understand when people speak or write clever sounding gibberish.

Those telling the truth and explaining their understanding should be able to do so in a way everyone can understand. I am an intelligent woman, so if I don’t understand, it’s likely the other person is being unclear, perhaps deliberately.

The deliberate use of incoherent “in-crowd” language and ever changing definitions is a hallmark of cults.

Worth challenging, as here, so others can see.

caprioska · 15/11/2026 23:35

JanesLittleGirl · 15/11/2026 22:48

Enlighten me please? When were these socialist revolutions in France and Spain? Was the French Revolution a socialist revolution? When was the Spanish Revolution?

Why does the English Revolution not count?

Why does the English Revolution not count?

Lol, what socialist English revolution?

When were these socialist revolutions in France and Spain? Was the French Revolution a socialist revolution?
😂

caprioska · 15/11/2026 23:43

JanesLittleGirl · 15/11/2026 22:55

We are watching history being rewritten on a massive scale in real time. Indigenous Australians are barely a footnote.

Tell us you know nothing about the decades long government program with billions of dollars of tax payer funding spent on 'Closing The Gap' for indigenous people without telling us.

Tell us you know nothing about the intractable problems Indigenous people who remain in isolated communities face despite every effort made by the Australian tax payer & Government to assist?

You act as if Australia is still in its first fleet mentality & hasn't moved on just because the consequences of from British colonialism weren't eradicated.

Please stop embarrassing yourself.

inkymoose · 15/11/2026 23:47

cryupmykingdom · 15/11/2026 21:00

Come back when you've something useful to add and which hopefully doesn't reveal how ignorant you are.

Edited

Why have you written such a dismissive comment about what @DeanElderberrywrote? Surely she is entitled to her opinion?

StealthTroublemaker · Yesterday 05:09

caprioska · 15/11/2026 23:43

Tell us you know nothing about the decades long government program with billions of dollars of tax payer funding spent on 'Closing The Gap' for indigenous people without telling us.

Tell us you know nothing about the intractable problems Indigenous people who remain in isolated communities face despite every effort made by the Australian tax payer & Government to assist?

You act as if Australia is still in its first fleet mentality & hasn't moved on just because the consequences of from British colonialism weren't eradicated.

Please stop embarrassing yourself.

Yes yes, but how do you feel being gender critical? If we wanted à badly written and inaccurate history of Australia someone would have started a thread on it. Please stop derailing the thread and stick to the topic.

DeanElderberry · Yesterday 07:31

inkymoose · 15/11/2026 23:47

Why have you written such a dismissive comment about what @DeanElderberrywrote? Surely she is entitled to her opinion?

Indeed. There's an irony in someone who described the policy en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_Australia_policy designed to control the racial make-up of a country/continent by saying

The White Australia Policy was seen as progressive at the time, and supported by virtually all of the labour movement and the Labor Party.

So too was putting Aboriginal kids with white families so they'd have better life chances.

then saying that pointing out it was 'racist' and comparable to other racist political strategies was using a 'tedious mantra'. Always remember edits don't delete.

DeanElderberry · Yesterday 07:36

Also as recent decades in Europe have demonstrated, not all revolutions are socialist. Even revolutions with a strong working class input have unpredictable outcomes.

I doubt anyone, particularly any woman, who participated in the Irish revolution was entirely satisfied with how things developed.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · Yesterday 08:08

My quote specifically states "Australia has no long history" that's because its only just over 200 years old as compared to England's 1000 plus years.

Tsk tsk. Indigenous people of Australia would beg to differ. It's rather racist to assume - as you have done - that history is only history if it's white. And you wouldn't want to do that, would you?

Australia has no written history before the First Fleet (actually there's some evidence the Dutch and probably the Portuguese discovered it in the 17c but that's derailing).

DeanElderberry · Yesterday 08:12

There's also the matter that literate people who move take their books, and therefore their history, with them.

Imdunfer · Yesterday 08:12

caprioska · 15/11/2026 21:52

Err I didn't use "all," "every," "always," or "never" to describe groups of people that flattens human individuality and curdles into prejudice or stereotypes so no generalisation 'sin' here as opposed to your doubling down on sex sorry, 'focus' to 'engage' on.

As I said upthread regarding 'zero sum' thinking, denial of existence (sorry 'focus') is the sex realist strategy. That's probably why the movement has shifted from 'gender critical' as a label because it can't be admitting a concept exists if that concept justifies the 'opponents' existence. And let's not forget being gender critical was justified by gender identity perpetuating sex stereotypes. In other words gender identity did exist under a gender critical conceptual lens.

Now think about what's actually being said here: 'If we pretend gender doesn't exist by strawmanning the actual claim then we delegitimise trans people as an identity'.

Seems the cookie monster analogy is relevant but not in the way the OP thinks.

'If we pretend gender doesn't exist by strawmanning the actual claim then we delegitimise trans people as an identity'.

Trans people delegitimise themselves when they claim to be women but can find no other way to explain why they believe they are women than to adopt a gender stereotype of femininity which many women themselves do not adopt.

Nobody cares if you choose to live as you feel comfortable, with a very short list of exceptions.

It is your claim to be a different sex than the one you were born which is not legitimate, not your person.

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · Yesterday 08:21

MarcTheGenderSkeptic · 15/11/2026 13:11

Sure, but they were the most visible societal cover, emboldened by their golden reputation helping enact same sex marriage legislation.

My point was that Stonewall is a UK charity. It wasn't Stonewall that invented LGBTQIA+ & pushed it into the USA, Canada, Australia etc. Stonewall might be guilty for their actions in the UK but other forces did the same in the rest of the world.

Imdunfer · Yesterday 08:32

caprioska · 15/11/2026 22:36

Let's face it there was no socialist revolution in the UK like France or Spain hence it's conservative hierarchical mindset still underpins culture despite however much some claim to be of the left. GC ideology is essentially conservative coded in its traditionalist pro conformist leanings.

Edited

I'm sure it helps you a great deal to think of yourselves as valiant class warriors breaking down the barriers of society by claiming to have changed sex.

I could piss myself laughing (don't get too excited about your ability to create that reaction, pissing yourself when laughing is a female pelvic floor phenomenon related to childbirth and age) at you believing this while justifying your beliefs using a female stereotype from the last century to prove your female-ness.

😂🤣😂

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · Yesterday 08:55

GC ideology is essentially conservative coded in its traditionalist pro conformist leanings.

Could you define what you mean by these 'traditionalist pro conformist leanings,' please? just so we're all talking about the same thing.

DeanElderberry · Yesterday 09:17

Good question. Conformity to which traditions I wonder?

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · Yesterday 09:28

DeanElderberry · Yesterday 09:17

Good question. Conformity to which traditions I wonder?

AFAIK the only conformity of GC is that biological sex is immutable. Apart from that it's the broadest of broad churches i.e apart from that believe what you like, live as you like.

I'll wait for that poster's definition; having stated it so confidently, I'm sure they will have no trouble saying what they mean by it.

FlirtsWithRhinos · Yesterday 09:31

How it often feels to be a Gender Critical Feminist on FWR...

Credit to the late, great Sir Terry Pratchett.

How does it feel to be Gender Critical?
FlirtsWithRhinos · Yesterday 09:43

DeanElderberry · Yesterday 09:17

Good question. Conformity to which traditions I wonder?

The tradition that women are physically female, I assume. What closed minds we have eh?

Of course, as I've noted before, they get it backwards.

They assume as Feminism is for women, if they claim "woman" means something new now, Feminists have to be fighting for that.

They don't realise Feminism is and always has been for Female people. It's not defined by a word but by the people underneath the word.

And that will continue to be the case whatever naive, sexist or bad faith new meanings they manage to push into the media or even into law. Because female people exist and we don't need to check a dictionary to know who those people are. As long as our sex has physical and social consequences for us there will never not be women who understand this and chose to fight for ourselves against the inequities we face.

Shortshriftandlethal · Yesterday 09:48

caprioska · 15/11/2026 22:36

Let's face it there was no socialist revolution in the UK like France or Spain hence it's conservative hierarchical mindset still underpins culture despite however much some claim to be of the left. GC ideology is essentially conservative coded in its traditionalist pro conformist leanings.

Edited

If by 'conservative coded' you mean cognisant with measurable reality and pragmatic, then yes.

Both Spain and France have been subject to despots and totalitarian regimes in a way that the UK has not. Britain tends to be known for its lack of extremism and its stability. You owe your Australian democratic structures and legal system to Britain.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · Yesterday 11:15

If there's one term I'm coming to loathe. it's the '<something> coded.'

BlueLegume · Yesterday 11:18

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · Yesterday 11:15

If there's one term I'm coming to loathe. it's the '<something> coded.'

Yes agreed @MrsDanversGlidesAgain - it is meaningless tosh unless of course you work in IT and coding is your job.

We could start saying I have ‘millionaire coded energy’ - doesn’t make me a real millionaire. Or I have ‘tall and willowy coded energy’ when I am 5 foot 3 and curvy. It is just nonsense and one to add to the bingo card .

So much of the language around trans/gender etc is totally irrelevant word salads - the oddball in the office trying to outsmart you - we have all come across them.

Slightly off topic just watch Mr Menno at the HP lights switch on last week. Honestly the small group of protesters are unhinged. Not only can they not pronounce JKRs surname properly but the language they use is completely unhinged.