Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

How does it feel to be Gender Critical?

736 replies

2021x · 12/11/2026 06:26

I was watching a compilation of Elmo dealing with the fact that everyone is treating Rocco like a living being rather than a rock- especially regarding the cookie!

I felt this is how it feels to be talking to people who wish to validate transgender ideology as a valid identity, or having a conversation about why males shouldn't compete in female categories...

Anyone else have examples of what it is like trying to engage with people who believe TRAs more than their own eyes?

OP posts:
MarcTheGenderSkeptic · Yesterday 11:21

There have been plenty of crazy things argued in the last few years, but implying that GCs are some sort of unconstructed Victorian prudes espousing a colonialist biological determinist transphobic worldview and TERF Island would not exist if only we'd had a socialist revolution is almost as crazy as... men can become women.

inkymoose · Yesterday 11:29

BlueLegume · Yesterday 11:18

Yes agreed @MrsDanversGlidesAgain - it is meaningless tosh unless of course you work in IT and coding is your job.

We could start saying I have ‘millionaire coded energy’ - doesn’t make me a real millionaire. Or I have ‘tall and willowy coded energy’ when I am 5 foot 3 and curvy. It is just nonsense and one to add to the bingo card .

So much of the language around trans/gender etc is totally irrelevant word salads - the oddball in the office trying to outsmart you - we have all come across them.

Slightly off topic just watch Mr Menno at the HP lights switch on last week. Honestly the small group of protesters are unhinged. Not only can they not pronounce JKRs surname properly but the language they use is completely unhinged.

Edited

The way the trans activists use language is strikingly odd. It's a mixture of very tired clichés, political slogans and absolute rubbish, the kind of thing you might find in an academic paper largely written by AI. It seems to have a viral spread, too. Like the chanting that strikes up in a demonstration, it spreads quickly and loses all meaning as it goes, it becomes mere noise and dissonance.

The trouble is those of us who like to make sense of things waste time in trying to understand what they're actually saying, which is full of sound and fury, signifying nothing, and full of passionate intensity.

The language is indeed "unhinged" reminding me of Pandora's box.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · Yesterday 11:37

but implying that GCs are some sort of unconstructed Victorian prudes espousing a colonialist biological determinist transphobic worldview

There ought to be some sort of prize for constructing a sentence with every perjorative term used for GCs. As there isn't, have a ❤

MarcTheGenderSkeptic · Yesterday 11:46

Recall that I have the prize for most combined phobic opinions, simply for using the term Omnicause...I'm a danger to...women, kids, gays, trans, blacks.
I'm most disappointed this list didn't stretch to the poor or disabled.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · Yesterday 12:52

I think one of the problems may be the assumption made by the idealogues that "gender critical" means "opposed to trans people". As if they had invented the term "gender". They didn't; it was being used before anyone apart from a very small niche group had ever heard of transitioning, and being critical of the stereotypes it stood for was around in the seventies when the trans ideology was a twinkle in pie's eye.

A distinction was being made between "female" and "feminine" as long ago as the sixties, to my certain knowledge; I had arguments about it in a town I moved out of in 1968.

DeanElderberry · Yesterday 12:56

caprioska · 15/11/2026 22:36

Let's face it there was no socialist revolution in the UK like France or Spain hence it's conservative hierarchical mindset still underpins culture despite however much some claim to be of the left. GC ideology is essentially conservative coded in its traditionalist pro conformist leanings.

Edited

There was a revolution in the UK just over a century ago in which socialists, Trades Unionists (and workers generally) took a major part. It was partially successful and 26 of the 32 Irish counties active in it are no longer in the UK as a result. The UK was left with a lower population, a smaller territory, a reduced coastline, fewer harbours, and a very long land border with another country and, in the last half century, the European Union.

It was a revolution that brought about huge changes in society and culture. But maybe not always the ones you'd expect.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · Yesterday 13:39

I am generally dubious about claims that any revolution is truly socialist, since the end result generally seems to be an upper class again, just a different one. Looking at Russia in particular, the USSR definitely had elite and prole classes from day approximately two, if not actually day one.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · Yesterday 13:41

The American revolution certainly gave us a country where the upper class is the monied one, and the trailer trash just have to do the best they can with what the upper class dictate.

Perenelle · Yesterday 13:52

Interestingly in my native language there is only one word for gender and sex.

Language plays such an important role in this whole discussion.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · Yesterday 14:01

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · Yesterday 13:39

I am generally dubious about claims that any revolution is truly socialist, since the end result generally seems to be an upper class again, just a different one. Looking at Russia in particular, the USSR definitely had elite and prole classes from day approximately two, if not actually day one.

France's first revolution ended up bringing back the monarchy they got rid of - after considerable amounts of bloodshed.

MarcTheGenderSkeptic · Yesterday 14:06

I swear if Australia was GC and Britain TRA, our little friend here would say sanity ruled the waves because of our long tradition of political stability and proud history of human rights advances in so many ways promoted by the amazing line of feminists over a century.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · Yesterday 14:08

Perenelle · Yesterday 13:52

Interestingly in my native language there is only one word for gender and sex.

Language plays such an important role in this whole discussion.

Doesn't it though. Leaving it alone seems to be impossible for the chaos-makers to manage, messing as they do with singular and plural for individuals.

I expect your language does have a distinction between one chair and two chairs, as we have an s at the end of plurals (well, apart from exceptions like sheep and giraffe, but English is a language full of exceptions)? Languages generally do; it's important to know whether one buffalo or a gurt herd of buffaloes is stampeding towards your house, for example, or stampeding towards all your houses if it's a village they are about to flatten.

That is leaving aside redefining simple words for obvious matters, such as "women" for female people. As opposed, obviously, to cervix-havers, menstruaters, and so forth, which are cumbersome and inaccurate.

Heggettypeg · Yesterday 14:12

Perenelle · Yesterday 13:52

Interestingly in my native language there is only one word for gender and sex.

Language plays such an important role in this whole discussion.

Yes. A big one is linguistic sleight of hand:

"Woman" meant an adult human female, and so spaces and facilities set aside for females were called "women's" spaces.

Some men feel that they feel like a woman and decide to start using the word "woman" to mean "person of either sex who feels like a woman".

Then they lay claim to the "women's spaces".

It's a trick. Imagine plugging a rodent into your computer by the tail, and expecting it to work, on the grounds that a kind of long-tailed rodent and a kind of computer widget are both called a "mouse".

DeanElderberry · Yesterday 14:19

Perenelle · Yesterday 13:52

Interestingly in my native language there is only one word for gender and sex.

Language plays such an important role in this whole discussion.

In formal English, 'gender' was a word used only as a grammatical term until the mid twentieth century. Extending it from being a punchline in bad jokes into the basis for sociological theory only happened in the 1980s. Because nobody had, or thought they needed to have, a sense of 'gender identity'.

Does your language treat grammar and bodies as the same? It is very interesting

Perenelle · Yesterday 15:49

DeanElderberry · Yesterday 14:19

In formal English, 'gender' was a word used only as a grammatical term until the mid twentieth century. Extending it from being a punchline in bad jokes into the basis for sociological theory only happened in the 1980s. Because nobody had, or thought they needed to have, a sense of 'gender identity'.

Does your language treat grammar and bodies as the same? It is very interesting

I did not know that, thank you!

Actually the word for grammatical gender is the same too.
The difference between grammatical and physical gender used to be very clear and a neutral matter, before inclusive language became ideologized.

It is a lot more complicated than in English though. For example non-binary-identifying persons can’t use “they/them” pronouns as it is the same as “she/her”. So some invent neo pronouns like “dey” or “xey” which has no context to our language whatsoever.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · Yesterday 16:38

Those are meaningless in English too; there are dozens of invented pronouns pretty nearly all of which lack context or any basis in the language.

Perenelle, I am interested: is the language Finnish? Or Japanese or Chinese, or Turkish? I am struggling a bit to think of languages without gender at all.

Perenelle · Yesterday 16:43

I’m from a German speaking region.
We do have grammatical gender, much more complicated than in English, just the word for gender and sex is the same.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · Yesterday 16:48

Oh, right! Sorry, I misunderstood what you were saying.

selffellatingouroborosofhate · Yesterday 18:31

caprioska · 15/11/2026 21:32

Tsk tsk tsk! So much 'derailing' & no scolding? 🤔

My quote specifically states "Australia has no long history" that's because its only just over 200 years old as compared to England's 1000 plus years. And given its such a short period its a remarkable turnaround in terms of class/social structures where as the UK still very much has a class structure that's firmly supported by its reverence to royalty, wealth & status. I never suggested was an Australia an egalitarian utopia btw but it certainly doesn't have as many of the 'constraints' to being closer to one that the UK has & has long had systems in place to rectify their colonial influences.

I strongly suspect its 'sex realist' culture is particularly exclusive to the UK because of hierarchical structures being so historically embedded in the British psyche.

Again nuance & historical education matters!

Edited

Charles is still king of Australia, unlike plenty of other ex-colonies that are now republics.

White Australians haven't needed to introduce a class hierarchy because they've got a race hierarchy doing that job, same as the Americans do. The British class hierarchy is a race hierarchy in all but name: Normans lording it over Saxons and Celts since 1066.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · Yesterday 18:44

Good Lord! Has no Norman-descended person married anyone of Saxon descent in the almost-a-thousand years since the Norman Conquest?

Where do the Flemings and the French Huguenots and the Germans and the Russian Jews and the Irish and.... fit?

What about the Jutes and the Danes? Or do they just count as Saxon?

selffellatingouroborosofhate · Yesterday 18:55

caprioska · 15/11/2026 22:36

Let's face it there was no socialist revolution in the UK like France or Spain hence it's conservative hierarchical mindset still underpins culture despite however much some claim to be of the left. GC ideology is essentially conservative coded in its traditionalist pro conformist leanings.

Edited

I think you've mistaken France and Spain for Russia. It was Russia that had the socialist revolution.

France was about getting rid of the aristocracy and weakening the church, but it wasn't setting up workers committees and state ownership of the means of production.

Spain: the Second Spanish Republic wasn't exactly a roaring success, was it? Franco took over, then they reverted back to monarchy.

We tried a very early modern European republic under Cromwell, extended the suffrage with the Reform Acts, and founded a free-at-point-of-access healthcare service.

There is nothing "conformist" about recognising that sex is real and is important in law and policy, any more than it's "conformist" to recognise that gravity is real and the effect of the Earth's gravity on, say, a roofer, matters when crafting workplace safety law.

selffellatingouroborosofhate · Yesterday 19:02

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · Yesterday 18:44

Good Lord! Has no Norman-descended person married anyone of Saxon descent in the almost-a-thousand years since the Norman Conquest?

Where do the Flemings and the French Huguenots and the Germans and the Russian Jews and the Irish and.... fit?

What about the Jutes and the Danes? Or do they just count as Saxon?

I'm talking about the origins of social class, as a class analysis.

That the occasional royal has married a commoner doesn't alter the tendency of the nobility to marry amongst their own.

If you want to know what the feudal equivalent of the "one drop rule" is, look up "morganatic marriage".

selffellatingouroborosofhate · Yesterday 19:07

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · Yesterday 11:15

If there's one term I'm coming to loathe. it's the '<something> coded.'

"Queer-coded" is used to mean "straight, but with fashion styling according to gay or lesbian stereotypes". I hate it. Gay men weren't jailed and gays and lesbians denied marriage because of their fashion choices.

FlirtsWithRhinos · Yesterday 19:24

selffellatingouroborosofhate · Yesterday 18:55

I think you've mistaken France and Spain for Russia. It was Russia that had the socialist revolution.

France was about getting rid of the aristocracy and weakening the church, but it wasn't setting up workers committees and state ownership of the means of production.

Spain: the Second Spanish Republic wasn't exactly a roaring success, was it? Franco took over, then they reverted back to monarchy.

We tried a very early modern European republic under Cromwell, extended the suffrage with the Reform Acts, and founded a free-at-point-of-access healthcare service.

There is nothing "conformist" about recognising that sex is real and is important in law and policy, any more than it's "conformist" to recognise that gravity is real and the effect of the Earth's gravity on, say, a roofer, matters when crafting workplace safety law.

There is nothing "conformist" about recognising that sex is real and is important in law and policy, any more than it's "conformist" to recognise that gravity is real and the effect of the Earth's gravity on, say, a roofer, matters when crafting workplace safety law.

Excellent illustration, thank you.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · Yesterday 19:46

selffellatingouroborosofhate · Yesterday 19:02

I'm talking about the origins of social class, as a class analysis.

That the occasional royal has married a commoner doesn't alter the tendency of the nobility to marry amongst their own.

If you want to know what the feudal equivalent of the "one drop rule" is, look up "morganatic marriage".

Sorry. I took the question as being about who runs things, as opposed to who is in Debrett, so I was addressing the rulers rather than the absurdity that is that shopping list for aspirational Americans from the Right Family. Do the nobility really run things in England (and Wales and Scotland and Northern Ireland)? Even if they did, a fairly large majority of the House of Lords was new creations by 1930, let alone the present one being quite other than hereditary; there was a bit of legislation this year called The House of Lords (Hereditary Peers) Act which means people with inherited titles can only have seats in the House of Lords if they are separately appointed as Life Peers.

(Not sure how long it has been since the Normans lorded it over anyone in particular; possibly since before Chris de Burgh, ancestry back to Richard II or whatever, not to mention to a particular fishing village in Norway before the time of Rollo, became a pop singer...)