Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Sandie Peggie has lost her case against the nursing union.

1000 replies

RhannionKPSS · 02/11/2026 15:33

Terrible news

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Helleofabore · 07/11/2026 09:24

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 09:06

who they expect to understand the difference between male and female humans

Theory of mind my dear, theory of mind.

And please never call me your dear anything. That is creepy behaviour.

Shedmistress · 07/11/2026 09:34

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 09:06

who they expect to understand the difference between male and female humans

Theory of mind my dear, theory of mind.

What are you banging on about now?

Yet another rabbit hole we have to unpack to make it clear we are talking about reality. Not psychological concepts.

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 11:00

Shedmistress · 07/11/2026 09:34

What are you banging on about now?

Yet another rabbit hole we have to unpack to make it clear we are talking about reality. Not psychological concepts.

What are you banging on about now?

The pp's hypothetical depends on the assumption that everyone has the same understanding of these terms - male and female - as she does: what they mean and how they should be applied.

But they don't. That's the entire point.

Theory of mind: "the cognitive capacity to understand and ascribe mental states—such as beliefs, desires, intentions, emotions, and knowledge—to oneself and others, and to recognize that other people's inner thoughts and perspectives differ from one's own."

DU understands herself to be female; you may not agree, but that is her reality, and it’s the reality from which she answered the question.

She wasn’t saying it’s fine to treat a patient without consent or against their wishes - she explicitly stated several times that is not ok, and that patient consent is paramount.

She was saying that, to her, a request for a female doctor wouldn’t automatically mean the patient was refusing her — and that if the patient made clear they were, she would step aside.

The disagreement isn’t about consent. It’s about what a request for a female doctor means — and that depends on a person's standpoint.

Many people define biological sex in terms of chromosomes. Are women with CAIS allowed to be doctors? And if so are they required to disclose their medical history to any patient who requests a female or male doctor?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/11/2026 11:07

FlirtsWithRhinos · 06/11/2026 23:59

Sigh. Amazing to watch how Genderists fixate on one sentence and not the overall context.

The sentence you half quoted was: a female patient requests female doctor and may not feel able to reject that male doctor or doesn’t understand that it is a male doctor in front of her

I was speaking to the former.

Like I said, despite the weird Genderist obsession with whether women can "always" tell or merely "not 100% always but pretty much fucking always", deception is not normally considered a moral mechanism for obtaining consent.

It’s extremely revealing of what kind of people they are.

Helleofabore · 07/11/2026 11:07

And again, here is a direct negative impact of the destabilisation of language and the promotion of a person’s subjective belief that isn’t based in material reality to be treated as if it is material reality.

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 11:12

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/11/2026 11:07

It’s extremely revealing of what kind of people they are.

What kind of people is that ?

MrsOvertonsWindow · 07/11/2026 11:13

Kudos to those with the energy to take on posters insistent on trying to wedge men into women's spaces, undermine safeguarding children and insist that men pretending to be women are some kind of sacred caste with demands that must be prioritised over the rights of women.

It's still a simple no.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 11:22

The existence of people with a trans experience of some sort is not in doubt.

The assertion that this means they have an innate "Gender Identity" or "recognition of their own sex"that requires the trans person be named and accomodated as a member of the opposite sex is entirely ideological.

The idea that person A disageeing with person B's strong beliefs about themself means person A has no theory of mind is utterly laughable.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/11/2026 11:24

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 11:22

The existence of people with a trans experience of some sort is not in doubt.

The assertion that this means they have an innate "Gender Identity" or "recognition of their own sex"that requires the trans person be named and accomodated as a member of the opposite sex is entirely ideological.

The idea that person A disageeing with person B's strong beliefs about themself means person A has no theory of mind is utterly laughable.

Edited

Exactly.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 07/11/2026 11:26

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 11:22

The existence of people with a trans experience of some sort is not in doubt.

The assertion that this means they have an innate "Gender Identity" or "recognition of their own sex"that requires the trans person be named and accomodated as a member of the opposite sex is entirely ideological.

The idea that person A disageeing with person B's strong beliefs about themself means person A has no theory of mind is utterly laughable.

Edited

Desperate times Flirts. When arguments are based on male supremacy and undermining society's fundamental principles about safeguarding the vulnerable, you must end up clutching at straws.

Helleofabore · 07/11/2026 11:29

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 11:00

What are you banging on about now?

The pp's hypothetical depends on the assumption that everyone has the same understanding of these terms - male and female - as she does: what they mean and how they should be applied.

But they don't. That's the entire point.

Theory of mind: "the cognitive capacity to understand and ascribe mental states—such as beliefs, desires, intentions, emotions, and knowledge—to oneself and others, and to recognize that other people's inner thoughts and perspectives differ from one's own."

DU understands herself to be female; you may not agree, but that is her reality, and it’s the reality from which she answered the question.

She wasn’t saying it’s fine to treat a patient without consent or against their wishes - she explicitly stated several times that is not ok, and that patient consent is paramount.

She was saying that, to her, a request for a female doctor wouldn’t automatically mean the patient was refusing her — and that if the patient made clear they were, she would step aside.

The disagreement isn’t about consent. It’s about what a request for a female doctor means — and that depends on a person's standpoint.

Many people define biological sex in terms of chromosomes. Are women with CAIS allowed to be doctors? And if so are they required to disclose their medical history to any patient who requests a female or male doctor?

Edited

“She was saying that, to her, a request for a female doctor wouldn’t automatically mean the patient was refusing her — and that if the patient made clear they were, she would step aside.”

This requires the female patient, potentially a very vulnerable one, to make the decision of consent based on two sources of information.

First is the fact that the female patient is likely to believe that the person is the female person as per their understanding of the biological term. It requires that patient to understand that someone who is male feels they can legitimately assume the patient includes them in their meaning of female, that also is an aspect of the power dynamic at play here.

Next it requires a female patient to be able to identify the correct sex of that male person and this is something that requires a person to have that ability. There is an additional complication to this where illness and injury may make this identification more unreliable.

Next it relies of a female patient to know they have the ability to reject that doctor and believe there will be no negative repercussions. Many female people don’t have the knowledge that that can do this or feel they can do it freely.

These aspects are vital to understand the impact on consent in this situation.

“The disagreement isn’t about consent. It’s about what a request for a female doctor means — and that depends on a person's standpoint.”

Again, if reference terms describing one of two distinct and definable states of being have been made meaningless because the terms now include the opposite of the two states of being as well as the established and provable definition as well, the person in the position of power that requires another person to give consent for them to proceed, that person in power needs to give full information about their personal medical information to enable that consent to be fully informed.

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 11:30

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 11:22

The existence of people with a trans experience of some sort is not in doubt.

The assertion that this means they have an innate "Gender Identity" or "recognition of their own sex"that requires the trans person be named and accomodated as a member of the opposite sex is entirely ideological.

The idea that person A disageeing with person B's strong beliefs about themself means person A has no theory of mind is utterly laughable.

Edited

The existence of people with a trans experience of some sort is not in doubt.

It's very often cast into doubt - the idea that it's an affectation or pretence, casts it into doubt.

The assertion that this means they have an innate "Gender Identity" or "recognition of their own sex"

This is a question of science - what causes this experience, how do we understand it? We can't assume an answer, we have to look at the evidence.

that requires the trans person be named and accomodated as a member of the opposite sex is entirely ideological

Yes, how we name and accommodate such people - if at all - are political and ideological questions.

Totallygripped · 07/11/2026 11:31

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/11/2026 11:24

Exactly.

Agreed. And I bet that wasn't just a cut and paste from Google AI. Which in context does not get more convincing from sheer repetition.

Helleofabore · 07/11/2026 11:40

Of course, it is also very important to understand that a person who is not transgender may be giving people only ever their perception of what being transgender is. They do not have any lived experience of what a transgender identity means.

If we consider that no male person can ever have the personal experience to provide the reference base for the claim that they are female people. Why do people who are not transgender themselves feel they should be taken seriously when they explain what a person with a transgender identity is?

Just like no other person should be able to discredit any other person’s claim to be transgender.

I think it is a good reminder that some people have self identified as an arbiter of who is and isn’t transgender and what is and isn’t transgender. I am always very wary of people who do this

Helleofabore · 07/11/2026 11:46

I think we can now point out that any person who tells women that there are no negative impacts to the destabilisation of the established reference words female people use to describe themselves as a unique group is incorrect. I also think it can be said to be an act of either gaslighting women or the person is ignorant or they are relying on similar destabilised language to avoid taking responsibility for what the majority understand that denial to mean. Or any combination of those.

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 11:49

Helleofabore · 07/11/2026 11:40

Of course, it is also very important to understand that a person who is not transgender may be giving people only ever their perception of what being transgender is. They do not have any lived experience of what a transgender identity means.

If we consider that no male person can ever have the personal experience to provide the reference base for the claim that they are female people. Why do people who are not transgender themselves feel they should be taken seriously when they explain what a person with a transgender identity is?

Just like no other person should be able to discredit any other person’s claim to be transgender.

I think it is a good reminder that some people have self identified as an arbiter of who is and isn’t transgender and what is and isn’t transgender. I am always very wary of people who do this

This is a non-point, you keep making .

Does Simon Baron-Cohen need to be autistic to study autism? Do we require lived experience of a condition from anyone who explains it? Nobody thinks so; the entire practice of science would be impossible if we did.

Your own analogy is bizarre. Are you suggesting that no male person can explain what a female person is? And by your account, then no female can understand what any other female person is either, since she has only her own experience to go on. By that standard nobody can identify or name anything about anyone. If you're talking about ideological frameworks that cause the naming of categories and identities to collapse... well...

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 11:52

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 11:49

This is a non-point, you keep making .

Does Simon Baron-Cohen need to be autistic to study autism? Do we require lived experience of a condition from anyone who explains it? Nobody thinks so; the entire practice of science would be impossible if we did.

Your own analogy is bizarre. Are you suggesting that no male person can explain what a female person is? And by your account, then no female can understand what any other female person is either, since she has only her own experience to go on. By that standard nobody can identify or name anything about anyone. If you're talking about ideological frameworks that cause the naming of categories and identities to collapse... well...

Just like no other person should be able to discredit any other person’s claim to be transgender.

Also this. Your entire philosophy is founded on the premise that we can and must discredit another person's claim to be female!!!

Helleofabore · 07/11/2026 11:52

MrsOvertonsWindow · 07/11/2026 11:26

Desperate times Flirts. When arguments are based on male supremacy and undermining society's fundamental principles about safeguarding the vulnerable, you must end up clutching at straws.

I think all we are going to get is the denial that there is an issue with safeguarding by posters who have shown they don’t even understand the principles of safeguarding.

We will get philosophically based discourse about how consent can be given when it is quite apparent that this is false. That without full disclosure of the relevant facts, no consent can be given.

This particular discussion about consent is all about centring a male person’s demands and his subjective belief about himself that doesn’t reflect material reality. It require copious philosophical theory discussions to come up with something that still doesn’t support consent but which makes some people progressive about themselves.

Ultimately though, in this particular scenario it is female people who are harmed.

StealthTroublemaker · 07/11/2026 11:54

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 11:49

This is a non-point, you keep making .

Does Simon Baron-Cohen need to be autistic to study autism? Do we require lived experience of a condition from anyone who explains it? Nobody thinks so; the entire practice of science would be impossible if we did.

Your own analogy is bizarre. Are you suggesting that no male person can explain what a female person is? And by your account, then no female can understand what any other female person is either, since she has only her own experience to go on. By that standard nobody can identify or name anything about anyone. If you're talking about ideological frameworks that cause the naming of categories and identities to collapse... well...

Well, a female person is a person whose body is designed around the creation of large gametes, and who possesses the capacity to be pregnant.
A male is not a woman, humans cannot change sex, sex is binary and immutable.
People with a VSD do not prove sex is a spectrum. A woman is an adult human female.
People’s inner feelings are not a substitute for biological reality.

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 11:55

StealthTroublemaker · 07/11/2026 11:54

Well, a female person is a person whose body is designed around the creation of large gametes, and who possesses the capacity to be pregnant.
A male is not a woman, humans cannot change sex, sex is binary and immutable.
People with a VSD do not prove sex is a spectrum. A woman is an adult human female.
People’s inner feelings are not a substitute for biological reality.

and who possesses the capacity to be pregnant

Oh dear.

Helleofabore · 07/11/2026 11:55

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 11:52

Just like no other person should be able to discredit any other person’s claim to be transgender.

Also this. Your entire philosophy is founded on the premise that we can and must discredit another person's claim to be female!!!

It is not my philosophy. It is proven science.

A male person is not ever a female person. That is philosophical belief.

Helleofabore · 07/11/2026 11:57

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 11:49

This is a non-point, you keep making .

Does Simon Baron-Cohen need to be autistic to study autism? Do we require lived experience of a condition from anyone who explains it? Nobody thinks so; the entire practice of science would be impossible if we did.

Your own analogy is bizarre. Are you suggesting that no male person can explain what a female person is? And by your account, then no female can understand what any other female person is either, since she has only her own experience to go on. By that standard nobody can identify or name anything about anyone. If you're talking about ideological frameworks that cause the naming of categories and identities to collapse... well...

You are a person without a transgender identity arbitrating who is and is not a transgender person.

You are giving only your personal view point here.

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 11:57

Helleofabore · 07/11/2026 11:55

It is not my philosophy. It is proven science.

A male person is not ever a female person. That is philosophical belief.

It is proven science.

How do you know? You don't have the lived experience of a male person who thinks he's a female person so you are not allowed to comment on the science right? According to your own logic that is..

Shedmistress · 07/11/2026 12:00

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 11:00

What are you banging on about now?

The pp's hypothetical depends on the assumption that everyone has the same understanding of these terms - male and female - as she does: what they mean and how they should be applied.

But they don't. That's the entire point.

Theory of mind: "the cognitive capacity to understand and ascribe mental states—such as beliefs, desires, intentions, emotions, and knowledge—to oneself and others, and to recognize that other people's inner thoughts and perspectives differ from one's own."

DU understands herself to be female; you may not agree, but that is her reality, and it’s the reality from which she answered the question.

She wasn’t saying it’s fine to treat a patient without consent or against their wishes - she explicitly stated several times that is not ok, and that patient consent is paramount.

She was saying that, to her, a request for a female doctor wouldn’t automatically mean the patient was refusing her — and that if the patient made clear they were, she would step aside.

The disagreement isn’t about consent. It’s about what a request for a female doctor means — and that depends on a person's standpoint.

Many people define biological sex in terms of chromosomes. Are women with CAIS allowed to be doctors? And if so are they required to disclose their medical history to any patient who requests a female or male doctor?

Edited

DU understands herself to be female; you may not agree, but that is her reality, and it’s the reality from which she answered the question

Of course he doesn't think he is female.

Nobody think he is female.

Totallygripped · 07/11/2026 12:01

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 11:55

and who possesses the capacity to be pregnant

Oh dear.

I think we all know what was meant here by "capacity" so your arch comment does you no credit.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread