And in your need to disparage people for not agreeing with you, you make a comment that overlooks women and girls who either don’t have understand that someone that they trust may be acting in a way that contradicts their request, or who cannot tell it is a male people because they have some difficulty, eg they have a sight issue or any sensory or perception difficulty that may block their understanding that that is a male person. They also may be too scared, or worried to process that kind of information. Or too ill or injured or just too distracted.
Or they don’t know their rights and cannot vocalise their concern.
That last one involves women such as me who has twice gone through internal scans made very painful because of my discomfort and distress when I didn’t understand that I could ask for a female person. Many people don’t understand that they can ask for a female person if a male person comes to do their procedure.
Very few posters on this board make the absolute blanket statement you have just referred to. Usually it is used a some kind of misrepresentation of what is usually acknowledged, that being that the majority of female people will be able to correctly identify a male person’s sex category with interaction at some time. Amongst the minority is also an assumption that there will be those who lack the ability such as have no underlying medical or perception difficulty that may prevent them recognising the sex category. There is also anecdotal evidence from people who come and make statements that they simply cannot identify a person’s sex category reliably.
So, no. I don’t believe it is said that everyone can 100% of the time correctly identify the sex category of humans in an instant or with minimum interaction. Despite the phrase ‘you/we can always tell’ being use to discredit feminists discussing one aspect of why single sex provisions are needed.
I do believe there may be some people who do have the ability to tell 100% of the time at an instant. But not every person claims this ability at all. Yet it is a phrase used to misrepresent what feminists are saying. Often it is used as an absolute or blanket generalisation style of cognitive distortion.
But if you wish to think you have a great ‘gotcha’ moment, go for it. It says more about you than others.