Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Sandie Peggie has lost her case against the nursing union.

1000 replies

RhannionKPSS · 02/11/2026 15:33

Terrible news

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Helleofabore · 06/11/2026 21:11

It has been said before, if a male doctor cannot understand that when a female patient requests female doctor and may not feel able to reject that male doctor or doesn’t understand that it is a male doctor in front of her, that is just one example of harm that has come
about because certain reference language has been made meaningless for conveying instantly and accurately interpretable messages.

Yet those who deny some language terms have been made meaningless will then deny any harm to woman and girls because of this language destabilisation. The denials seem completely dishonest in light of this.

alcovecupboards · 06/11/2026 22:14

Helleofabore · 06/11/2026 21:11

It has been said before, if a male doctor cannot understand that when a female patient requests female doctor and may not feel able to reject that male doctor or doesn’t understand that it is a male doctor in front of her, that is just one example of harm that has come
about because certain reference language has been made meaningless for conveying instantly and accurately interpretable messages.

Yet those who deny some language terms have been made meaningless will then deny any harm to woman and girls because of this language destabilisation. The denials seem completely dishonest in light of this.

That shouldn't happen. You can always tell. Right?

FlirtsWithRhinos · 06/11/2026 22:20

Sigh. The point is she can tell, but being presented with it anyway, despite having requested exactly the opposite, as a fucking patient in a hospital, how much fight does she have in her to object?

Women rolling their eyes and putting up with men's shit because said men are going to make it as hard as they can for her to stick to her guns, or a doctor treat her like a difficult patient for standing up for herself, is hardly a new story.

Well, unless she's unconscious of course.

StealthTroublemaker · 06/11/2026 22:25

Lacksie · 06/11/2026 10:05

Agree. It's online bullying and defamation.

But isn’t defamation stating something thst isn't true? So calling DU à man is the truth. There is the transcript where he states he will treat a patient who asks for a female doctor. That is true. So it’d be up to him to prove it wasn’t true. Do keep up dear.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 06/11/2026 22:25

Also, despite the weird Genderist obsession with whether women can "always" tell or merely "not 100% always but pretty much fucking always", deception is not normally considered a moral mechanism for obtaining consent.

Totallygripped · 06/11/2026 22:47

alcovecupboards · 06/11/2026 22:14

That shouldn't happen. You can always tell. Right?

Alcove. Be clear. What are you really saying? Irrespective of Sandie Peggie's views on anything. I am not Sandie Peggie and I don't see her as a figurehead for a "movement". So?

alcovecupboards · 06/11/2026 22:57

FlirtsWithRhinos · 06/11/2026 22:20

Sigh. The point is she can tell, but being presented with it anyway, despite having requested exactly the opposite, as a fucking patient in a hospital, how much fight does she have in her to object?

Women rolling their eyes and putting up with men's shit because said men are going to make it as hard as they can for her to stick to her guns, or a doctor treat her like a difficult patient for standing up for herself, is hardly a new story.

Well, unless she's unconscious of course.

So if she can tell, why say this - "doesn’t understand that it is a male doctor in front of her"? Clearly, you can't 'always tell' as claimed.

Totallygripped · 06/11/2026 23:21

alcovecupboards · 06/11/2026 22:57

So if she can tell, why say this - "doesn’t understand that it is a male doctor in front of her"? Clearly, you can't 'always tell' as claimed.

Others have noted your prodigious output. What is the basic message you would like us to take away and reflect on? I am sure many will get back to you once we understand that.

alcovecupboards · 06/11/2026 23:31

Totallygripped · 06/11/2026 23:21

Others have noted your prodigious output. What is the basic message you would like us to take away and reflect on? I am sure many will get back to you once we understand that.

I don't seem to lack people 'getting back' to me on here.

Totallygripped · 06/11/2026 23:52

alcovecupboards · 06/11/2026 23:31

I don't seem to lack people 'getting back' to me on here.

Well that might be so. Whether that means what you think it means might be quite different things.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 06/11/2026 23:59

alcovecupboards · 06/11/2026 22:57

So if she can tell, why say this - "doesn’t understand that it is a male doctor in front of her"? Clearly, you can't 'always tell' as claimed.

Sigh. Amazing to watch how Genderists fixate on one sentence and not the overall context.

The sentence you half quoted was: a female patient requests female doctor and may not feel able to reject that male doctor or doesn’t understand that it is a male doctor in front of her

I was speaking to the former.

Like I said, despite the weird Genderist obsession with whether women can "always" tell or merely "not 100% always but pretty much fucking always", deception is not normally considered a moral mechanism for obtaining consent.

Helleofabore · 07/11/2026 01:55

alcovecupboards · 06/11/2026 22:14

That shouldn't happen. You can always tell. Right?

And in your need to disparage people for not agreeing with you, you make a comment that overlooks women and girls who either don’t have understand that someone that they trust may be acting in a way that contradicts their request, or who cannot tell it is a male people because they have some difficulty, eg they have a sight issue or any sensory or perception difficulty that may block their understanding that that is a male person. They also may be too scared, or worried to process that kind of information. Or too ill or injured or just too distracted.

Or they don’t know their rights and cannot vocalise their concern.

That last one involves women such as me who has twice gone through internal scans made very painful because of my discomfort and distress when I didn’t understand that I could ask for a female person. Many people don’t understand that they can ask for a female person if a male person comes to do their procedure.

Very few posters on this board make the absolute blanket statement you have just referred to. Usually it is used a some kind of misrepresentation of what is usually acknowledged, that being that the majority of female people will be able to correctly identify a male person’s sex category with interaction at some time. Amongst the minority is also an assumption that there will be those who lack the ability such as have no underlying medical or perception difficulty that may prevent them recognising the sex category. There is also anecdotal evidence from people who come and make statements that they simply cannot identify a person’s sex category reliably.

So, no. I don’t believe it is said that everyone can 100% of the time correctly identify the sex category of humans in an instant or with minimum interaction. Despite the phrase ‘you/we can always tell’ being use to discredit feminists discussing one aspect of why single sex provisions are needed.

I do believe there may be some people who do have the ability to tell 100% of the time at an instant. But not every person claims this ability at all. Yet it is a phrase used to misrepresent what feminists are saying. Often it is used as an absolute or blanket generalisation style of cognitive distortion.

But if you wish to think you have a great ‘gotcha’ moment, go for it. It says more about you than others.

Helleofabore · 07/11/2026 01:58

alcovecupboards · 06/11/2026 22:57

So if she can tell, why say this - "doesn’t understand that it is a male doctor in front of her"? Clearly, you can't 'always tell' as claimed.

Who is ‘she’?

me? Another specific female person? A collective ‘she’ referring to a group of female people? Who is it you are referring to please?

Helleofabore · 07/11/2026 02:23

FlirtsWithRhinos · 06/11/2026 23:59

Sigh. Amazing to watch how Genderists fixate on one sentence and not the overall context.

The sentence you half quoted was: a female patient requests female doctor and may not feel able to reject that male doctor or doesn’t understand that it is a male doctor in front of her

I was speaking to the former.

Like I said, despite the weird Genderist obsession with whether women can "always" tell or merely "not 100% always but pretty much fucking always", deception is not normally considered a moral mechanism for obtaining consent.

Thanks Flirts.

I consider anyone who uses that phrase in an attempt to discredit a point being made about consent to really be showing their priority in using whatever leverage they think they can to shame others they may have disagree with or have a disagreement with.

It is quite enlightening to see some posters who will on one thread vilify people using a safeguarding situation to highlight an issue where discussion is needed, then on another thread will dismiss issues regarding obtaining consent for what they seem to perceive is their own political gain.

It was a remark that ignored the needs of those who are rated the highly vulnerable female people in a hospital situation where that ability might be reduced for obvious health reasons, or where highly vulnerable female people are likely to be a very high proportion of those using the service.

It really does show aspects of the distraction tactics being used rather than engaging with the issue. I did notice in the past some posters have avoided answering the direct question of whether they believe a female patient can give full consent to treatment if a male doctor comes when that patient has specifically rewuested a female doctor.

I wonder why that question has been ignored when I ask it. I have my thoughts on that, of course.

sanluca · 07/11/2026 07:24

alcovecupboards · 06/11/2026 22:14

That shouldn't happen. You can always tell. Right?

That is such a nasty response and shows absolutely no empathy and a serious lack of morals.

Gloating that sick women are being gaslighted into accepting a male doctor when they requested a female one. Just think: you are lying there in pain, sick, worried. You ask for a female doctor and you get one you see as male. But you asked for a female one. Didn't you? Should you complain? Make a fuss? Maybe you are mistaken? Do you want this? And so on and so on.

Making the whole experience much worse than it needs to be. Whilst you are sick. And not many women ask for a female doctor, many are fine with male doctors or don't want to make a fuss. So to even disrespect a sick woman who had the courage to ask for a female doctor because her reasons are intensive enough for her, is really really low and despicable.

Shedmistress · 07/11/2026 08:17

Like the actual medical staffer that had to have an internal exam and requested a female chaperone, and was on the table being examined and looked at the chaperone's feet to realise it was another man in the room.

She couldn't say a word about it because she needed the treatment and she needed her job.

When you are ill and in need of support, and you ask for a female you should get a bloody female. Or be told, there is no female available.

Helleofabore · 07/11/2026 08:40

“Amongst the minority is also an assumption that there will be those who lack the ability such as have no underlying medical or perception difficulty that may prevent them recognising the sex category. ”

That should be “Amongst the minority is also an assumption that there will be those who lack the ability such as have an underlying medical or perception difficulty that may prevent them recognising the sex category. “

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 08:41

Totallygripped · 06/11/2026 15:38

Perception, beliefs, internal "reality". I find this all quite chilling.

How strange. Is it cognition generally that creeps you out - or just the idea of other people's?

StealthTroublemaker · 07/11/2026 08:45

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 08:41

How strange. Is it cognition generally that creeps you out - or just the idea of other people's?

When other people are delusional, it does a bit to be honest. Like the guy in our town who scream that the aliens walk amongst us. Or the bloke who says God is coming to kill all the unbelievers. I mean, if one is so convinced he’s a woman, despite all the biological reality, yeah, I would be worried about him and hope he got the help he needed. I mean, if someone is perched on a ledge threatening to jump off because they believe they can fly, do you affirm them or get them help to realise biological reality?

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 08:46

nutmeg7 · 06/11/2026 08:27

Of course it is.

But you are using these people to pretend sex is not bleeding obvious and straightforward for most people, and to advance the argument that “gender self ID” is more important.

Because you believe that trans people should be able to identify into the opposite sex category. That’s the only reason you fill up pages with philosophical musings. It’s about blurring meaning as much as possible.

But you are using these people to pretend sex is not bleeding obvious and straightforward for most people

No? I've agreed that it is straightforward and obvious for most people. There are rare cases where it isn't.

to advance the argument that “gender self ID” is more important

More important than what?

Because you believe that trans people should be able to identify into the opposite sex category.

I don't 'believe they should be able to identify into the opposite sex category', I understand that the reality of their experience is that they do.

I believe that reality should be recognised, and that we should seek to understand it rather than to judge.

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 08:47

StealthTroublemaker · 07/11/2026 08:45

When other people are delusional, it does a bit to be honest. Like the guy in our town who scream that the aliens walk amongst us. Or the bloke who says God is coming to kill all the unbelievers. I mean, if one is so convinced he’s a woman, despite all the biological reality, yeah, I would be worried about him and hope he got the help he needed. I mean, if someone is perched on a ledge threatening to jump off because they believe they can fly, do you affirm them or get them help to realise biological reality?

There's no evidence that trans people are "delusional", but good to know that mental illness creeps you out as well.
Can't say I'm surprised.

Helleofabore · 07/11/2026 08:47

alcovecupboards · 06/11/2026 22:14

That shouldn't happen. You can always tell. Right?

Do you believe that a female patient can give consent that is with full knowledge and no coercion if a male doctor (who they expect to understand the difference between male and female humans and who they trust would act ethically and that they have to trust to treat them) presented themselves as being the female doctor that they requested?

It is a yes or no question. Do you believe they can give consent based on this scenario or not?

StealthTroublemaker · 07/11/2026 08:53

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 08:47

There's no evidence that trans people are "delusional", but good to know that mental illness creeps you out as well.
Can't say I'm surprised.

À man claiming he is à woman is obviously delusional, as a man can never be a woman. If someone said they were Jesus, would you crucify them? Or try to persuade them they were not in fact the second coming….

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 09:06

Helleofabore · 07/11/2026 08:47

Do you believe that a female patient can give consent that is with full knowledge and no coercion if a male doctor (who they expect to understand the difference between male and female humans and who they trust would act ethically and that they have to trust to treat them) presented themselves as being the female doctor that they requested?

It is a yes or no question. Do you believe they can give consent based on this scenario or not?

who they expect to understand the difference between male and female humans

Theory of mind my dear, theory of mind.

Helleofabore · 07/11/2026 09:23

Lacksie · 07/11/2026 09:06

who they expect to understand the difference between male and female humans

Theory of mind my dear, theory of mind.

So, is that a ‘yes, you do believe that female people can consent without having full knowledge and that you don’t believe there is a power dynamic that also can act as a coercive force’?

Because you sound like you are about theorise your support for a flawed consent principle.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.