What DU said when questioned was several things:
That patient consent is of the utmost importance.
That a patient can request a different doctor for any reason at all; that is entirely legitimate and must be respected.
That she would always respect a patient’s wishes if they said they were uncomfortable being treated by her.
That if a patient requested a female doctor, she wouldn’t automatically assume they meant they didn’t want to be treated by a trans woman.
That she is not required to disclose her own medical history to patients.
People are furious about the fourth one, and that is where theory of mind comes in — the capacity to grasp that other people’s beliefs and perspectives differ from your own. I understand that your definition of ‘female’ excludes trans women. Many people don’t share that definition. DU understands herself to be female; you may not agree, but that is her reality, and it’s the reality from which she answered the question. She wasn’t saying it’s fine to treat a patient without consent or against their wishes. She was saying that, to her, a request for a female doctor wouldn’t automatically mean the patient was refusing her — and that if the patient made clear they were, she would step aside. Nobody gets treated against their wishes under what she described. The disagreement isn’t about consent. It’s about what a request for a female doctor means — and that’s a definitional argument.
No patient has ever accused DU of treating them without consent. There has been no finding of misconduct against her of any kind.