Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Sandie Peggie has lost her case against the nursing union.

1000 replies

RhannionKPSS · 02/11/2026 15:33

Terrible news

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Ereshkigalangcleg · 06/11/2026 10:12

Sad times!

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 06/11/2026 10:23

Lacksie · 06/11/2026 10:05

Agree. It's online bullying and defamation.

If Upton thinks it's defamation for me to call him a man then if he contacts me I am happy to pass on my details so he can sue me for libel.

alcovecupboards · 06/11/2026 10:36

MyAmpleSheep · 06/11/2026 10:03

How does it harm him?

If I were feeling uncharitable then I'd suggest that claims she has deliberately targetted a woman for unwanted contact, refused to leave her alone and tried to do something nefarious to said patient are designed to whip up action against her that can only do harm. If not - why not stick to the facts? Why make up other things with no evidence of it?

murasaki · 06/11/2026 10:49

alcovecupboards · 06/11/2026 10:36

If I were feeling uncharitable then I'd suggest that claims she has deliberately targetted a woman for unwanted contact, refused to leave her alone and tried to do something nefarious to said patient are designed to whip up action against her that can only do harm. If not - why not stick to the facts? Why make up other things with no evidence of it?

Why not stick to the facts, eh? He's a man.

MyAmpleSheep · 06/11/2026 10:50

I didn’t realize anyone had said:

Upton deliberately targeted a woman for contact,
Upton refused to leave her alone,
Upton tried to do something nefarious to her.

I do think what Upton said under oath raises legitimate concerns about whether and how he respects women’s boundaries.

Totallygripped · 06/11/2026 11:32

Lacksie · 06/11/2026 09:46

No. I don't think it's criminal for a doctor to be trans.

DU was extremely clear that patient consent matters and that she would never treat anyone who asked for a different doctor.

There has never been a single allegation of that kind against her, nor of professional misconduct or criminal behaviour of any sort.

The claims being posted across these boards come from people who have either not read what she said or have been unable to put themselves in her position long enough to understand what she actually meant — a basic failure of theory of mind. Repeating those claims as fact is, quite frankly, defamatory.

Edited

I don't think anyone has suggested that it should be per se criminal for a doctor to be trans. But it is i think irrefutable that DU said that DU would present as a female physician to a patient requesting a female physician. My theory of mind (whatever that means) might be very basic but I find that statement in itself concerning. Because wouldn't that patient already have set out the parameters of her consent by that simple request?

Shedmistress · 06/11/2026 12:06

Lacksie · 06/11/2026 08:52

No they don't have to know what SEX they ACTUALLY ARE. They have to know their relevant physiological / medical history. Sex is a proxy- it's a useful proxy much of the time, and sometimes it's not.

what is putting people in ACTUAL DANGER is the string of repressive reforms that are making it much less safe for minority people to seek out medical care where they need it.

Of course medical staff need to know what sex their patients are.

Males and females have different differential diagnosis on so many problems, if a person pretending to be a man comes in with the female symptoms of a heart attack the wrong diagnosis will be made.

Honestly. We've done this to death over the years. The people denying that sex is a thing are the ones putting people in danger.

Lacksie · 06/11/2026 12:15

Totallygripped · 06/11/2026 11:32

I don't think anyone has suggested that it should be per se criminal for a doctor to be trans. But it is i think irrefutable that DU said that DU would present as a female physician to a patient requesting a female physician. My theory of mind (whatever that means) might be very basic but I find that statement in itself concerning. Because wouldn't that patient already have set out the parameters of her consent by that simple request?

What DU said when questioned was several things:

That patient consent is of the utmost importance.

That a patient can request a different doctor for any reason at all; that is entirely legitimate and must be respected.

That she would always respect a patient’s wishes if they said they were uncomfortable being treated by her.

That if a patient requested a female doctor, she wouldn’t automatically assume they meant they didn’t want to be treated by a trans woman.

That she is not required to disclose her own medical history to patients.

People are furious about the fourth one, and that is where theory of mind comes in — the capacity to grasp that other people’s beliefs and perspectives differ from your own. I understand that your definition of ‘female’ excludes trans women. Many people don’t share that definition. DU understands herself to be female; you may not agree, but that is her reality, and it’s the reality from which she answered the question. She wasn’t saying it’s fine to treat a patient without consent or against their wishes. She was saying that, to her, a request for a female doctor wouldn’t automatically mean the patient was refusing her — and that if the patient made clear they were, she would step aside. Nobody gets treated against their wishes under what she described. The disagreement isn’t about consent. It’s about what a request for a female doctor means — and that’s a definitional argument.

No patient has ever accused DU of treating them without consent. There has been no finding of misconduct against her of any kind.

LinearALinearB · 06/11/2026 12:22

Lacksie is effectively arguing:

  1. People recognise women without checking their biology.
  2. Trans women can also be recognised as women.
  3. Therefore, womanhood is determined by recognition rather than biological sex.
The third proposition does not follow from the first two. It is possible to recognise something without knowing precisely why it belongs to a particular category. My assessment: This is rhetorically effective because it draws attention to ordinary human experience, but it doesn't establish the conclusion Lacksie wants it to establish.
StellaAndCrow · 06/11/2026 12:26

Totallygripped · 06/11/2026 11:32

I don't think anyone has suggested that it should be per se criminal for a doctor to be trans. But it is i think irrefutable that DU said that DU would present as a female physician to a patient requesting a female physician. My theory of mind (whatever that means) might be very basic but I find that statement in itself concerning. Because wouldn't that patient already have set out the parameters of her consent by that simple request?

Because wouldn't that patient already have set out the parameters of her consent by that simple request?

Yes, exactly.

I can't imagine any situation in which a woman would specifically request healthcare from the group [woman or a transwoman] but not [man who doesn't say he's a woman].

Maybe there are situations that I haven't considered?

Helleofabore · 06/11/2026 13:00

Lacksie · 06/11/2026 12:15

What DU said when questioned was several things:

That patient consent is of the utmost importance.

That a patient can request a different doctor for any reason at all; that is entirely legitimate and must be respected.

That she would always respect a patient’s wishes if they said they were uncomfortable being treated by her.

That if a patient requested a female doctor, she wouldn’t automatically assume they meant they didn’t want to be treated by a trans woman.

That she is not required to disclose her own medical history to patients.

People are furious about the fourth one, and that is where theory of mind comes in — the capacity to grasp that other people’s beliefs and perspectives differ from your own. I understand that your definition of ‘female’ excludes trans women. Many people don’t share that definition. DU understands herself to be female; you may not agree, but that is her reality, and it’s the reality from which she answered the question. She wasn’t saying it’s fine to treat a patient without consent or against their wishes. She was saying that, to her, a request for a female doctor wouldn’t automatically mean the patient was refusing her — and that if the patient made clear they were, she would step aside. Nobody gets treated against their wishes under what she described. The disagreement isn’t about consent. It’s about what a request for a female doctor means — and that’s a definitional argument.

No patient has ever accused DU of treating them without consent. There has been no finding of misconduct against her of any kind.

Edited

All this continues to ignore the very core issues.

That a patient would need to understand a male person’s personal definition of a female doctor to be able to make a fully informed choice. The onus should never be on a vulnerable patient to have to understand that the male person in front of them is using an alternative definition to them and that they, as a male person, not only believes he fits the role of female doctor as requested but that the male person believes that the patient shares that same definition, or is even likely to understand that definition.

While reference terms have been rendered meaningless because they mean the opposite as well as the established description of that reference item, no consent can be assumed from female people using the common usage language. And yet, we are being told that the onus is on the requester to make something clear that that may not understand this obligation on them, and highly likely never knew they had to make it clear.

That is the antithesis of safeguarding principles at the foundation of consent.

Not only this, but the male doctor is also in a position of trust and is trusted to act ethically. By informing the patient fully if they are using a personal subjective definition of the word ‘female’. That a doctor also has the power in that relationship should not be ignored or dismissed.

Arran2024 · 06/11/2026 13:08

Lacksie · 06/11/2026 12:15

What DU said when questioned was several things:

That patient consent is of the utmost importance.

That a patient can request a different doctor for any reason at all; that is entirely legitimate and must be respected.

That she would always respect a patient’s wishes if they said they were uncomfortable being treated by her.

That if a patient requested a female doctor, she wouldn’t automatically assume they meant they didn’t want to be treated by a trans woman.

That she is not required to disclose her own medical history to patients.

People are furious about the fourth one, and that is where theory of mind comes in — the capacity to grasp that other people’s beliefs and perspectives differ from your own. I understand that your definition of ‘female’ excludes trans women. Many people don’t share that definition. DU understands herself to be female; you may not agree, but that is her reality, and it’s the reality from which she answered the question. She wasn’t saying it’s fine to treat a patient without consent or against their wishes. She was saying that, to her, a request for a female doctor wouldn’t automatically mean the patient was refusing her — and that if the patient made clear they were, she would step aside. Nobody gets treated against their wishes under what she described. The disagreement isn’t about consent. It’s about what a request for a female doctor means — and that’s a definitional argument.

No patient has ever accused DU of treating them without consent. There has been no finding of misconduct against her of any kind.

Edited

Dr Upton is describing himself as a woman because society has given him the framework to do so - up until very recently this would not have been available to him and he wouldn't have dared try it.

He grew up understanding full well how girls are treated - he was born with all the gifts upper class Britain can bestow on its sons.

He may have decided to turn his back on all those benefits but all he can ever do is role play being a woman. He can never be a woman regardless of what anyone tells him or what he thinks about himself.

This is hard for him, no doubt. But why is anyone giving his belief the time of day? What if he role played as a baby? A dog? Should we accommodate those too?

The problem is that gender ID is simply a provocative concept. It is not empirically true. It is easily knocked down by opposing arguments. It belongs in academia and fantasy, like the concept of time travel - worthy of consideration in academic and creative work but not a design for life.

nutmeg7 · 06/11/2026 13:45

Arran2024 · 06/11/2026 13:08

Dr Upton is describing himself as a woman because society has given him the framework to do so - up until very recently this would not have been available to him and he wouldn't have dared try it.

He grew up understanding full well how girls are treated - he was born with all the gifts upper class Britain can bestow on its sons.

He may have decided to turn his back on all those benefits but all he can ever do is role play being a woman. He can never be a woman regardless of what anyone tells him or what he thinks about himself.

This is hard for him, no doubt. But why is anyone giving his belief the time of day? What if he role played as a baby? A dog? Should we accommodate those too?

The problem is that gender ID is simply a provocative concept. It is not empirically true. It is easily knocked down by opposing arguments. It belongs in academia and fantasy, like the concept of time travel - worthy of consideration in academic and creative work but not a design for life.

“The problem is that gender ID is simply a provocative concept. It is not empirically true. It is easily knocked down by opposing arguments. It belongs in academia and fantasy, like the concept of time travel - worthy of consideration in academic and creative work but not a design for life.”

Exactly this. A provocative concept that is not empirically true.

Heggettypeg · 06/11/2026 14:04

Some other societies traditionally recognise a "third gender" of men who are uncomfortable with being men ( a similar accommodation for women is rarer ). They do this by giving this group its own name, sometimes meaning things like "in the manner of a woman" or "endeavouring to be like a woman", but not by saying that those men actually are a subset of women. For example, the Samoan president did not think that fa'afafines ( their term) belong in women's sports.

So the assumption of being automatically entitled to use women's spaces is not created, and the rest of society is not forced to pretend that they don't see what they see or else be labelled a bigot.

There is therefore nothing natural or inevitable about the linguistic forced teaming of women with men who identify as feminine that is such a feature of western gender ideology. This forced teaming is the cause of the erosion of women's rights to their own unique spaces and identity wherever that particular version of gender has taken root. It is the cause of most of the trouble - that and the social and medical transitioning of children and young people.

"I don't feel like a man, therefore I am a woman and should be included with women" is not a recognition of objective truth. It is a culturally conditioned explanation for a feeling, however real that feeling may be.

murasaki · 06/11/2026 14:07

Yes, there's a Samoan fa'afafine who aged in the international men's football team for years. There was never a question of him playing with the women.

Shedmistress · 06/11/2026 14:28

If a woman is in need of a female doctor, a male doctor who takes notes about women who avoid the female changing rooms to specifically avoid him, is NOT what they mean.

AND he knows it.

Totallygripped · 06/11/2026 15:38

Perception, beliefs, internal "reality". I find this all quite chilling.

ILikeDungs · 06/11/2026 15:58

Good God there is a lot of one poster on this thread. I know much of the replies are for the lurkers, but there is just so much "I am going to have you do the intellectual labour of convincing me otherwise even though I have absolutely no interest in being convinced".

Hasn't posted for over an hour, probably having a kip. Worn out by all that 'showing women how badly they understand what it is to be women'.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 06/11/2026 17:31

Shedmistress · 06/11/2026 14:28

If a woman is in need of a female doctor, a male doctor who takes notes about women who avoid the female changing rooms to specifically avoid him, is NOT what they mean.

AND he knows it.

Yes, all this.

ScrollingLeaves · 06/11/2026 17:54

Heggettypeg · 06/11/2026 14:04

Some other societies traditionally recognise a "third gender" of men who are uncomfortable with being men ( a similar accommodation for women is rarer ). They do this by giving this group its own name, sometimes meaning things like "in the manner of a woman" or "endeavouring to be like a woman", but not by saying that those men actually are a subset of women. For example, the Samoan president did not think that fa'afafines ( their term) belong in women's sports.

So the assumption of being automatically entitled to use women's spaces is not created, and the rest of society is not forced to pretend that they don't see what they see or else be labelled a bigot.

There is therefore nothing natural or inevitable about the linguistic forced teaming of women with men who identify as feminine that is such a feature of western gender ideology. This forced teaming is the cause of the erosion of women's rights to their own unique spaces and identity wherever that particular version of gender has taken root. It is the cause of most of the trouble - that and the social and medical transitioning of children and young people.

"I don't feel like a man, therefore I am a woman and should be included with women" is not a recognition of objective truth. It is a culturally conditioned explanation for a feeling, however real that feeling may be.

Yes, that is all so true.

I feel extremely annoyed by how often the examples of other cultures are ignorantly wheeled out as validation for TWAW when none of them say a man is a woman, but do say here is a different sort of man with his own niche and group, who even may have a potentially valuable social role.

People sound so smug and holy when they talk about how ‘this has been around forever, think of two spirit native Americans…’ etc.

ScrollingLeaves · 06/11/2026 17:57

ScrollingLeaves · 06/11/2026 17:54

Yes, that is all so true.

I feel extremely annoyed by how often the examples of other cultures are ignorantly wheeled out as validation for TWAW when none of them say a man is a woman, but do say here is a different sort of man with his own niche and group, who even may have a potentially valuable social role.

People sound so smug and holy when they talk about how ‘this has been around forever, think of two spirit native Americans…’ etc.

NB ‘Two Spirit’ is a modern term like Cis.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 06/11/2026 18:22

ScrollingLeaves · 06/11/2026 17:54

Yes, that is all so true.

I feel extremely annoyed by how often the examples of other cultures are ignorantly wheeled out as validation for TWAW when none of them say a man is a woman, but do say here is a different sort of man with his own niche and group, who even may have a potentially valuable social role.

People sound so smug and holy when they talk about how ‘this has been around forever, think of two spirit native Americans…’ etc.

I know. I want to shake a copy of a logic textbook at them and say "If those cultures really thought male people could be women just like female people they wouldn't have a special name for them, they'd just call them women!!"

Totallygripped · 06/11/2026 18:47

I don't know that the stressing that DU woujd be so magnanimous as to step away from a patient is helpful or in anyway persuasive. That's pretty basic surely? And it doesn't answer the question of when this "internal reality" shifts the dial. Is it when the person starts "presenting" as a particular gender? Which begs questions about what on earth that means. For the sake of argument, if DU's internal reality/understanding of self has always been female, presumably DU (not going to attempt pronouns) if previously faced with a male patient asking for a male doctor when DU was male presenting DU would have declined? I cannot believe that anyone going through medical school and then further training in the UK would not understand what a patient asking for a male or female doctor means.

Helleofabore · 06/11/2026 19:16

“I cannot believe that anyone going through medical school and then further training in the UK would not understand what a patient asking for a male or female doctor means.”

I was always surprised when people claim it is acceptable that a doctor would think that a female person would be intending that the word ‘female’ would mean both male and female. Because to me, if a doctor has a personal definition of the word, how can that doctor communicate with the overwhelming majority of their patients? It seems very much contradictory to care standards to not accept and use established definitions of reference terms such as female and male.

Totallygripped · 06/11/2026 19:50

Helleofabore · 06/11/2026 19:16

“I cannot believe that anyone going through medical school and then further training in the UK would not understand what a patient asking for a male or female doctor means.”

I was always surprised when people claim it is acceptable that a doctor would think that a female person would be intending that the word ‘female’ would mean both male and female. Because to me, if a doctor has a personal definition of the word, how can that doctor communicate with the overwhelming majority of their patients? It seems very much contradictory to care standards to not accept and use established definitions of reference terms such as female and male.

You and me both.
I might be wrong in my recollection that Isla Bumba at Fife spoke of unknown personal chromosomes. Let's all be re educated and pile in on her for being so reductively stupid.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.