Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Sandie Peggie has lost her case against the nursing union.

1000 replies

RhannionKPSS · 02/11/2026 15:33

Terrible news

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Shedmistress · 06/11/2026 08:14

People with disorders of sexual development have either a male or female disorder, so that argument is completely irrelevant to 'trans', so can be struck out as an explanation.

And I believe they would want to be classed as their correct sex, not 'no sex' or 'both sexes' or 'something else'.

Lacksie · 06/11/2026 08:18

nutmeg7 · 06/11/2026 08:04

Lacksie seems to believe that, because someone’s sex is hard to categorise for a tiny, tiny fraction of 1% of the population who have a disorder in normal development involving the reproductive system, sex is therefore not a real and straightforward category for the rest of us.

This is a fallacy, but I can only assume Lacksie clings to it because of their belief that trans people have to be considered by society as the sex they want to be in order to live happily.

From this core belief flows the necessity for arguing that “gender” is a better, more relevant means of organising society than sex. This might be true for trans people, but it is not true for the rest of us.

All the guff about “sex is real but we only give it meaning when we observe it” is just standard philosophical discourse.

It’s of no practical use in dealing with how women navigate society as the physically smaller and weaker sex who are vulnerable to male violence. This includes from some trans identified males.

Trans people can have third spaces. End of argument. They need to start realising that other people have rights too, and look at the bigger picture. Understand that one trans women in a female category or space affects many women. Women who are also fully human. Decent transwomen do this already; plenty of narcissistic ones with a sexual fetish or personality disorder do not consider women other than as useful passive role players in their own personal drama.

Sex is real. It is a complex, multidimensional process of development.

For most people sex is straightforward to classify as the different elements align.

For a small minority of people, the different aspects of sex development are not aligned and classification is more challenging.

It is perfectly easy to recognise and accommodate people with these minority differences in a way that is compatible with their health, wellbeing, fundamental dignity and human rights, without causing language, law and medicine to collapse for the majority.

Shedmistress · 06/11/2026 08:19

For example if someone goes into a doctors and says 'I'm Trans' then the doctor absolutely HAS TO KNOW which sex they ACTUALLY ARE to know whether to give them male or female hormones if they are part of a treatment plan.

A person going into hospital with severe stomach pain needs the doctors to know what sex they ACTUALLY ARE to know whether to check for miscarriage or a distressed baby or not. We know of one case where a pregnant woman was admitted with this and because her paperwork said 'male' they were not allowed to check to find out if she was pregnant or not and the baby died. Yet if they'd have checked they'd probably have been sued and lost their licences.

It is all such utter nonsensical bollocks that puts actual people in danger.

Shedmistress · 06/11/2026 08:21

Lacksie · 06/11/2026 08:18

Sex is real. It is a complex, multidimensional process of development.

For most people sex is straightforward to classify as the different elements align.

For a small minority of people, the different aspects of sex development are not aligned and classification is more challenging.

It is perfectly easy to recognise and accommodate people with these minority differences in a way that is compatible with their health, wellbeing, fundamental dignity and human rights, without causing language, law and medicine to collapse for the majority.

None of this has anything whatsoever to do with 'trans'.

nutmeg7 · 06/11/2026 08:27

Lacksie · 06/11/2026 08:18

Sex is real. It is a complex, multidimensional process of development.

For most people sex is straightforward to classify as the different elements align.

For a small minority of people, the different aspects of sex development are not aligned and classification is more challenging.

It is perfectly easy to recognise and accommodate people with these minority differences in a way that is compatible with their health, wellbeing, fundamental dignity and human rights, without causing language, law and medicine to collapse for the majority.

Of course it is.

But you are using these people to pretend sex is not bleeding obvious and straightforward for most people, and to advance the argument that “gender self ID” is more important.

Because you believe that trans people should be able to identify into the opposite sex category. That’s the only reason you fill up pages with philosophical musings. It’s about blurring meaning as much as possible.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 06/11/2026 08:34

There are some broad brushes we can start with.

No one born with a penis is a woman. Full stop. Because womanhood is physical not mental, and whatever sits within the small group of people for whom different aspects of sex development are not aligned and classification is more challenging, the presence of a penis is not one of the questionable features.

Likewise, no one who menstruates or has menstruated or will menstruate or would menstruate were it not for medication is male. Full stop.

No one born with normally developed vagina, uterus and ovaries is male.

Given that checking for a new born's penis is easier than checking internal structures, in practice this means:

Quick glance at the baby. If it has a penis it's a boy. If it doesn't and her bits look normal, assume it's a girl. If anything looks unusual, further tests.

If a girl doesn't start to menstruate when expected, further tests.

There we go. Pretty easy and simple rules for the majority cases, dealing with the tiny number of people for whom different aspects of sex development are not aligned and classification is more challenging as they arise.

No woman has a penis. A person with a penis who believes himself a woman is mistaken.

Shedmistress · 06/11/2026 08:41

10 years ago we were at 'yeah but intersex.

sanluca · 06/11/2026 08:48

Lacksie · 06/11/2026 08:18

Sex is real. It is a complex, multidimensional process of development.

For most people sex is straightforward to classify as the different elements align.

For a small minority of people, the different aspects of sex development are not aligned and classification is more challenging.

It is perfectly easy to recognise and accommodate people with these minority differences in a way that is compatible with their health, wellbeing, fundamental dignity and human rights, without causing language, law and medicine to collapse for the majority.

Absolutely we can classify and support people with sex development disorders with dignity and respect, like acknowledging they are either male or female and not some third sex.

It also has zero to do with classifying transgender people who are male or female and want to be classified as the opposite or no sex or even both sexes, depending on their view of themselves.

Just to be clear, @Lacksie, we are talking about including male people, no DSD, into the female categorie in legal, medical and societies perception. Are you still in favour of legally removing biological sex classification on the say so of transgender people?

Lacksie · 06/11/2026 08:52

Shedmistress · 06/11/2026 08:19

For example if someone goes into a doctors and says 'I'm Trans' then the doctor absolutely HAS TO KNOW which sex they ACTUALLY ARE to know whether to give them male or female hormones if they are part of a treatment plan.

A person going into hospital with severe stomach pain needs the doctors to know what sex they ACTUALLY ARE to know whether to check for miscarriage or a distressed baby or not. We know of one case where a pregnant woman was admitted with this and because her paperwork said 'male' they were not allowed to check to find out if she was pregnant or not and the baby died. Yet if they'd have checked they'd probably have been sued and lost their licences.

It is all such utter nonsensical bollocks that puts actual people in danger.

No they don't have to know what SEX they ACTUALLY ARE. They have to know their relevant physiological / medical history. Sex is a proxy- it's a useful proxy much of the time, and sometimes it's not.

what is putting people in ACTUAL DANGER is the string of repressive reforms that are making it much less safe for minority people to seek out medical care where they need it.

nutmeg7 · 06/11/2026 08:56

Sex is a proxy for WHAT?

FlirtsWithRhinos · 06/11/2026 08:57

LoL.

Change what a word means.

Sure. Now you are right.

Reality is as it always was. The thing everyone else thinks of sex as is still what matters.

The inner unknown world that only one person on this thread thinks of sex as is utterly irrelevant to any situation in which more than one person exists.

Cailin66 · 06/11/2026 09:01

Lacksie · 06/11/2026 08:52

No they don't have to know what SEX they ACTUALLY ARE. They have to know their relevant physiological / medical history. Sex is a proxy- it's a useful proxy much of the time, and sometimes it's not.

what is putting people in ACTUAL DANGER is the string of repressive reforms that are making it much less safe for minority people to seek out medical care where they need it.

Doctor's do not need to know the sex of a patient to treat them? Okay.... I think my gynecologist would have been surprised if I was a man, in fact if I were a man according to you it wouldn't have made any difference.

Yet, oddly, gynecologists treat women.

They don't treat men, whether that is men men, or men who are so deluded that they think they can be some type of non men, or men who are so deluded that they think can persuade the rest of us that they are non men.

Lacksie · 06/11/2026 09:25

Cailin66 · 06/11/2026 09:01

Doctor's do not need to know the sex of a patient to treat them? Okay.... I think my gynecologist would have been surprised if I was a man, in fact if I were a man according to you it wouldn't have made any difference.

Yet, oddly, gynecologists treat women.

They don't treat men, whether that is men men, or men who are so deluded that they think they can be some type of non men, or men who are so deluded that they think can persuade the rest of us that they are non men.

Edited

Just look at what you’ve written there. ‘So deluded that they think they can be some type of non-men.’ Can you see how contemptuous that is? These people are not criminals. They’re people whose existence doesn’t fit your classification, and that’s all. I know this subject is unintuitive for a lot of people. But maybe take a step back and look at where you’ve ended up

Cailin66 · 06/11/2026 09:39

Lacksie · 06/11/2026 09:25

Just look at what you’ve written there. ‘So deluded that they think they can be some type of non-men.’ Can you see how contemptuous that is? These people are not criminals. They’re people whose existence doesn’t fit your classification, and that’s all. I know this subject is unintuitive for a lot of people. But maybe take a step back and look at where you’ve ended up

I didn't start this, men did. And I'll push back on men trying to trample over women's rights every second of every day.

I've nothing but contempt for any man barging his way into winning in women's weight lifting, any male doctor pretending to be a woman and stating he will treat female patients who only want a female doctor. How's that for contempt. But you don't call out that. I consider that to be criminal, as in sexual assault. How about you? Do you agree?

naffogato · 06/11/2026 09:41

Lacksie · 06/11/2026 09:25

Just look at what you’ve written there. ‘So deluded that they think they can be some type of non-men.’ Can you see how contemptuous that is? These people are not criminals. They’re people whose existence doesn’t fit your classification, and that’s all. I know this subject is unintuitive for a lot of people. But maybe take a step back and look at where you’ve ended up

That’s where you’re wrong. They do fit our classification no matter how much they don’t like it.

naffogato · 06/11/2026 09:44

Lacksie · 06/11/2026 08:18

Sex is real. It is a complex, multidimensional process of development.

For most people sex is straightforward to classify as the different elements align.

For a small minority of people, the different aspects of sex development are not aligned and classification is more challenging.

It is perfectly easy to recognise and accommodate people with these minority differences in a way that is compatible with their health, wellbeing, fundamental dignity and human rights, without causing language, law and medicine to collapse for the majority.

Oh look you’re doing the meme. DSDs are nothing to do with trans. We were talking about unambiguously male people pretending to be women.

Sandie Peggie has lost her case against the nursing union.
Lacksie · 06/11/2026 09:46

Cailin66 · 06/11/2026 09:39

I didn't start this, men did. And I'll push back on men trying to trample over women's rights every second of every day.

I've nothing but contempt for any man barging his way into winning in women's weight lifting, any male doctor pretending to be a woman and stating he will treat female patients who only want a female doctor. How's that for contempt. But you don't call out that. I consider that to be criminal, as in sexual assault. How about you? Do you agree?

No. I don't think it's criminal for a doctor to be trans.

DU was extremely clear that patient consent matters and that she would never treat anyone who asked for a different doctor.

There has never been a single allegation of that kind against her, nor of professional misconduct or criminal behaviour of any sort.

The claims being posted across these boards come from people who have either not read what she said or have been unable to put themselves in her position long enough to understand what she actually meant — a basic failure of theory of mind. Repeating those claims as fact is, quite frankly, defamatory.

Cailin66 · 06/11/2026 09:51

Lacksie · 06/11/2026 09:46

No. I don't think it's criminal for a doctor to be trans.

DU was extremely clear that patient consent matters and that she would never treat anyone who asked for a different doctor.

There has never been a single allegation of that kind against her, nor of professional misconduct or criminal behaviour of any sort.

The claims being posted across these boards come from people who have either not read what she said or have been unable to put themselves in her position long enough to understand what she actually meant — a basic failure of theory of mind. Repeating those claims as fact is, quite frankly, defamatory.

Edited

You're now rewriting a trial. LOL. Go for it Lacksie. We all know what Upton said, and we all know what he meant. And in a twist, that nobody could have predicted, he's at it again in Australia .....

Transgender doctor Beth Upton in new row at Australian hospital

A female patient refused treatment from Upton at Port Macquarie Base Hospital on the basis that the doctor was biologically male, ......

“A woman in hospital should not have to defend her boundaries from the very people entrusted with her care,” she said. “The New South Wales health minister must urgently investigate why a vulnerable woman seeking emergency care felt she needed her husband’s protection to ensure her wish to be treated by a female doctor was respected.”

A friend of the patient was quoted as saying: “Her husband stayed the whole time she was in to make sure they didn’t bully her into accepting treatment.”

BTW you didn't respond to me about cats who think they are dogs?

Verifying Device

https://www.thetimes.com/uk/scotland/article/beth-upton-australia-complaint-tnzfxfhrf

MyAmpleSheep · 06/11/2026 09:54

334bu · 06/11/2026 06:47

"Or a definition of what a man who identifies as a woman is actually feeling that makes them believe they're a woman"
"this was answered extensively on several threads."
Silly me, I seem to have missed these. Could you please post some links to these definitions.

Let’s just say that as a question, it identifies as being answered. We don’t recognize it as such, but that’s our bigotry at play and we should take it at its word.

It’s not the only unanswered question that identities as having been answered, either. Unanswered questions that identify as being answered have always existed!

Cailin66 · 06/11/2026 09:55

Being busy, and excited watching the US Mid Terms I completely missed that the fabulous, and brave, Sandie Peggie is appealing. What good news to wake up to today. She's done so so much already. (with an honorary mention to the delectable rapist Isla Bryson's pink leggings) .

This week has been brilliant for women's rights.

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 06/11/2026 09:56

Lacksie · 06/11/2026 09:46

No. I don't think it's criminal for a doctor to be trans.

DU was extremely clear that patient consent matters and that she would never treat anyone who asked for a different doctor.

There has never been a single allegation of that kind against her, nor of professional misconduct or criminal behaviour of any sort.

The claims being posted across these boards come from people who have either not read what she said or have been unable to put themselves in her position long enough to understand what she actually meant — a basic failure of theory of mind. Repeating those claims as fact is, quite frankly, defamatory.

Edited

Upton said that he would present himself as a woman to a patient requesting a female doctor. He would not tell the patient he was a man (his legal status) & would only back down if the patient objected. Given the power imbalance & deception this is cannot be valid consent.

Lacksie · 06/11/2026 09:56

Cailin66 · 06/11/2026 09:51

You're now rewriting a trial. LOL. Go for it Lacksie. We all know what Upton said, and we all know what he meant. And in a twist, that nobody could have predicted, he's at it again in Australia .....

Transgender doctor Beth Upton in new row at Australian hospital

A female patient refused treatment from Upton at Port Macquarie Base Hospital on the basis that the doctor was biologically male, ......

“A woman in hospital should not have to defend her boundaries from the very people entrusted with her care,” she said. “The New South Wales health minister must urgently investigate why a vulnerable woman seeking emergency care felt she needed her husband’s protection to ensure her wish to be treated by a female doctor was respected.”

A friend of the patient was quoted as saying: “Her husband stayed the whole time she was in to make sure they didn’t bully her into accepting treatment.”

BTW you didn't respond to me about cats who think they are dogs?

he's at it again in Australia.

AT what.

Read the article. There is no claim whatsoever DU treated any patient without consent.

A woman turned up at A&E and was outraged to discover a trans doctor was present.

The end.

alcovecupboards · 06/11/2026 10:00

Lacksie · 06/11/2026 09:56

he's at it again in Australia.

AT what.

Read the article. There is no claim whatsoever DU treated any patient without consent.

A woman turned up at A&E and was outraged to discover a trans doctor was present.

The end.

That's the only situation that actually occurred. The others on here are utterly determined to lie about what happened in an effort to harm Dr Upton. It is reprehensible.

MyAmpleSheep · 06/11/2026 10:03

alcovecupboards · 06/11/2026 10:00

That's the only situation that actually occurred. The others on here are utterly determined to lie about what happened in an effort to harm Dr Upton. It is reprehensible.

How does it harm him?

Lacksie · 06/11/2026 10:05

alcovecupboards · 06/11/2026 10:00

That's the only situation that actually occurred. The others on here are utterly determined to lie about what happened in an effort to harm Dr Upton. It is reprehensible.

Agree. It's online bullying and defamation.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.