Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Sandie Peggie has lost her case against the nursing union.

1000 replies

RhannionKPSS · 02/11/2026 15:33

Terrible news

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Lacksie · 05/11/2026 12:39

ScrollingLeaves · 05/11/2026 12:13

Are you suggesting ‘she’ always felt the word ‘woman’ /‘girl’ applied to her, as soon as ‘she’ could speak? Is this the Stonewall propaganda that people know they are trans from as young as two years old?

This is not true, but if it were, like a person with a phantom limb, that is in their own individual mind.

They will always be different from those for whom the actual limb/chromosomes do exist and whose lives are accordingly set in motion along certain patterns because of it.

Incidentally, though I understand you are suggesting chromosomes are irrelevant to the meaning given to ‘woman’ anyway, what you said here is not true:

“nobody has ever been called a woman by having her chromosomes read“

This not-reading-of-chromosomes may be true in the context of general daily life (a lot else is ‘read’ though), but obviously chromosomes are read frequently within tests in pregnancy.

In some cases the result leads to the female-identified child being aborted, while a baby boy who escapes to be born to call himself a woman one day will escape this fate.

Was his/her escape just because he was only ‘assigned’ male when the chromosome test was read and they turned out to have got it wrong? Do all test tube tests lack a reality beyond an individual interpretation - resulting in the vagueness of ‘assignment’? Should we not recognise Ebola under a microscope because the Ebola is just a word?

The first is a good question. Some children express a persistent sense of being the other sex very early in life. Others, while they might have had a long-standing sense that something was wrong — ‘something was off’, ‘I wasn’t me’ — take longer to acquire the cultural understanding and vocabulary to articulate their experience. For others still, the issue doesn’t become a problem until their body starts to change at puberty and they realise it isn’t developing in a way that fits their internal sense of their sex. And others know but fear the social consequences of coming out. None of that is Stonewall; it’s what the people concerned describe - and there's a vast academic and clinical literature documenting this.

On the phantom limb — I'm not sure what point you are making? It occurs because of the brain’s map of the body persists regardless of the physical anatomy itself. The brain carries such a map, it’s laid down in development, and it can diverge from the anatomy.

In terms of chromosomes: yes, in recent years it has become much more common to do genetic prenatal testing, which can also reveal sex. Nobody is saying chromosomes can’t be read or aren’t real — Ebola is a virus whether or not we have a word for it. But it remains the case that this isn’t how sex is assigned. That happens at birth, on the basis of visible anatomy. It almost always aligns with chromosomes anyway, and where it doesn’t, chromosomes are not what determines assignment.

As for sex selective abortion - nobody got the chromosomes wrong, chromosomes are real. The test read them correctly. What the test can’t tell you is who that child will become, because a chromosome is a chromosome, it is not a person. And note, the female foetus is aborted in this cases, not because of anything the chromosomes do, but because of what society has decided a girl is worth. Which is my point about the words 'girl', 'woman', - the meaning that society infuses in these categories is never just the material fact of the chromosomes - to pretend that it is is reductive and false. "Sex" is not a just a descriptor of material facts about the body, it is a word that carries psychological, social, cultural, legal etc, meanings.

Arran2024 · 05/11/2026 12:47

Lacksie · 05/11/2026 07:46

Yes the cat is still a cat unobserved; but 'cat' is a word, and words are applied by observers. 'Woman' is a word.

A body has gametes and chromosomes whether or not anyone observes them. But woman isn't a word we apply by observing those features - nobody has ever been called a woman by having her chromosomes read. The word is applied by people looking at people — at bodies, yes, but also at how someone presents, lives, speaks and is treated — and recognising a woman. Nobody checks her gametes. That's how every woman in this thread has been called a woman every day of her life. Yes we might infer things about that persons body- but that's an inference not an observation.

This is also how each of us came to know our own sex: not by inspecting our gametes but by a brain, very early in life, recognising its own body as one kind or other.

That is why being trans makes sense rather than being a puzzle. Recognition is part of how a person develops , and for most people it aligns with features observed at birth so nobody notices it was a judgement at all. For some people it doesn't. Their recognition of themselves departs from expectations based on observable anatomy at birth. That isn't imagination or choice — nor is it mental illness or delusion, any more than having a phantom limb is any of those things. A trans woman is someone whose recognition of herself as a woman is real and at odds with characteristics of sex observed at birth .

Which of those (characteristics of sex observed at birth, or how a person recognises and understands their own body) the word 'woman' should designate is a question about how we use a word, not a question about "the reality" of chromosomes.

Edited

What you say makes some sense until you state it's not a mental illness.

You can't just decide that Trans is Gender ID and ignore the other possible explanations.

Some people identify as a cat. Where does that fit into your theory?

Lacksie · 05/11/2026 12:50

nutmeg7 · 05/11/2026 12:39

So what?

So the characteristics of the body are separate from the recognition/ observation of them. The characteristics of the body are one thing; the recognition of them is another. The second can’t be reduced to the first, it's reductive and false to pretend it can. ‘Woman’ is the language of recognition. It carries meaning, and that meaning is read from the material facts of the body — but it can never be reduced to them, because they are not the same thing.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 05/11/2026 13:11

The phrase "distinction without a difference" comes to mind here.

The practical outcome that women (in the original female sense) experience different social consequences to male because of how other people think about our bodies remains the same whether we express that as those other people reacting to our sex or as those other people reacting to their internal cognition of our sex.

Shedmistress · 05/11/2026 14:01

Lacksie · 05/11/2026 12:50

So the characteristics of the body are separate from the recognition/ observation of them. The characteristics of the body are one thing; the recognition of them is another. The second can’t be reduced to the first, it's reductive and false to pretend it can. ‘Woman’ is the language of recognition. It carries meaning, and that meaning is read from the material facts of the body — but it can never be reduced to them, because they are not the same thing.

None of which turns a man into a woman.

Lacksie · 05/11/2026 14:20

Shedmistress · 05/11/2026 14:01

None of which turns a man into a woman.

And nobody said it did.
You are arguing with a straw man.

Shedmistress · 05/11/2026 15:22

Lacksie · 05/11/2026 14:20

And nobody said it did.
You are arguing with a straw man.

So trans women are not women then.

Phew. That took a decade to get to!

StealthTroublemaker · 05/11/2026 16:07

Shedmistress · 05/11/2026 14:01

None of which turns a man into a woman.

Do as woman is the English word for an adult human female, as no male can ever be read as female, you’re saying males can never be women? Gotcha.

Shedmistress · 05/11/2026 16:20

StealthTroublemaker · 05/11/2026 16:07

Do as woman is the English word for an adult human female, as no male can ever be read as female, you’re saying males can never be women? Gotcha.

Am well aware that men cannot be women.

Did you quote the wrong post?

StealthTroublemaker · 05/11/2026 16:59

Shedmistress · 05/11/2026 16:20

Am well aware that men cannot be women.

Did you quote the wrong post?

I did sorry. That was to the lovely @Lacksie

Manxexile · 06/11/2026 00:21

I think a couple of days ago @Lacksie was asked for their definition of a woman.

Or a definition of what a man who identifies as a woman is actually feeling that makes them believe they're a woman.

Has there been an answer? (I've not followed this for a couple of days)

StealthTroublemaker · 06/11/2026 05:26

Manxexile · 06/11/2026 00:21

I think a couple of days ago @Lacksie was asked for their definition of a woman.

Or a definition of what a man who identifies as a woman is actually feeling that makes them believe they're a woman.

Has there been an answer? (I've not followed this for a couple of days)

Nope. Answer was there none. #sadtimes.

Lacksie · 06/11/2026 05:51

Manxexile · 06/11/2026 00:21

I think a couple of days ago @Lacksie was asked for their definition of a woman.

Or a definition of what a man who identifies as a woman is actually feeling that makes them believe they're a woman.

Has there been an answer? (I've not followed this for a couple of days)

Or a definition of what a man who identifies as a woman is actually feeling that makes them believe they're a woman

this was answered extensively on several threads.

334bu · 06/11/2026 06:47

"Or a definition of what a man who identifies as a woman is actually feeling that makes them believe they're a woman"
"this was answered extensively on several threads."
Silly me, I seem to have missed these. Could you please post some links to these definitions.

Helleofabore · 06/11/2026 06:55

Confidently asserting that something is what you believe it is doesn’t make it materially so if it is only a person’s belief in their subjective reality and not supported by material reality. Particularly when language has been destabilised to mean the opposite to the established meaning for a small group of people while still also retaining it established meaning.

That remains true for some people’s claims about identities and about their claims that they have done something. Once reference terms have been rendered effectively meaning the opposite status as well as the established status meaning, communication has failed.

It has failed, but for those who still haven’t worked out that the words someone uses includes both states of being instead of a specific state (eg. woman), they can still be manipulated into thinking that a person is giving a specific statement while that statement is completely obfuscated of shared communication.

Langauge, eh! It is a powerful thing.

Hence when very common use words such as discussion and woman are only two are used, a sentence can mean both the very opposite of the established meaning and the established meaning.

And so the cycle continues.

Helleofabore · 06/11/2026 06:57

334bu · 06/11/2026 06:47

"Or a definition of what a man who identifies as a woman is actually feeling that makes them believe they're a woman"
"this was answered extensively on several threads."
Silly me, I seem to have missed these. Could you please post some links to these definitions.

It depends on what meaning the poster means for reference terms in those statements you have highlighted.

What the poster means could mean the complete opposite, yet will confidently make the statement leaving people to wonder which meaning they are using.

sanluca · 06/11/2026 07:11

To be honest, all this discussion about reading chromosomes, feeling, acting, knowing is just sidelining the real discussion.

@Lacksie should there be a word in society for adult human females that excludes all males, that is based on biological fact? Should that word be written in law, to protect adult human females in limited circumstances. Yes or no?
My guess is your answer is no as you deem it too difficult to be able to say who is adult human female and who is adult human male. And any legal protections are not necessary and sexism is not a thing or if it is, it is based on appearance and not things like pregnancies. Also specific female healthcare is not needed and there is no need to test medications on female people.
Sorry but that is not a society I want to live in, ignoring the specific needs of half the population.

Talk about invisible women

Lacksie · 06/11/2026 07:19

sanluca · 06/11/2026 07:11

To be honest, all this discussion about reading chromosomes, feeling, acting, knowing is just sidelining the real discussion.

@Lacksie should there be a word in society for adult human females that excludes all males, that is based on biological fact? Should that word be written in law, to protect adult human females in limited circumstances. Yes or no?
My guess is your answer is no as you deem it too difficult to be able to say who is adult human female and who is adult human male. And any legal protections are not necessary and sexism is not a thing or if it is, it is based on appearance and not things like pregnancies. Also specific female healthcare is not needed and there is no need to test medications on female people.
Sorry but that is not a society I want to live in, ignoring the specific needs of half the population.

Talk about invisible women

And any legal protections are not necessary and sexism is not a thing or if it is, it is based on appearance and not things like pregnancies. Also specific female healthcare is not needed and there is no need to test medications on female people

I believe passionately in all of these things. I am female and raised a feminist.

I also think biological sex is complicated, and that trans experience is real, legitimate and biological- not an affectation, pose or pretence- and that trans people deserve the same dignities, protections and services like anyone else.

sanluca · 06/11/2026 07:23

So how would you go about achieving these things if there is no word for adult human females or young human females, and no legal recognition of biological sex whereby male and female people are two distinct classes. For example you can't legally mandate testing on female people if legally female people don't exist as a separate class

Cailin66 · 06/11/2026 07:29

Lacksie · 05/11/2026 08:05

Again,
Being trans is not the same as being non conforming in dress and has nothing to do with what scarfs people wear.

Edited

Can a cat believe they are a dog? If they can, does that mean they are a dog? If they can’t, how do you know they can’t think they are a dog?

LouisTheYardTeacher · 06/11/2026 07:42

@Lacksie
If being a woman is about recognition, if someone recognises themselves as a woman, but I recognise them as a man, what are they?

If someone recognises themselves as a woman some days but a man on other days what are they?

If someone recognises themselves as a pigeon but I recognise them as a human what are they?

Lacksie · 06/11/2026 07:43

sanluca · 06/11/2026 07:23

So how would you go about achieving these things if there is no word for adult human females or young human females, and no legal recognition of biological sex whereby male and female people are two distinct classes. For example you can't legally mandate testing on female people if legally female people don't exist as a separate class

Edited

Interpreting the words "woman" and "female" expansively to include rare minority variations, does not imply that language, law or medicine for female people at large will collapse.

The idea that it will is very silly.

Shedmistress · 06/11/2026 07:57

Lacksie · 06/11/2026 07:43

Interpreting the words "woman" and "female" expansively to include rare minority variations, does not imply that language, law or medicine for female people at large will collapse.

The idea that it will is very silly.

Edited

If the word woman means also some men then of course the word woman ceases to apply to female people. As it then also includes male people thus rendering the word completely useless.

nutmeg7 · 06/11/2026 08:04

Lacksie seems to believe that, because someone’s sex is hard to categorise for a tiny, tiny fraction of 1% of the population who have a disorder in normal development involving the reproductive system, sex is therefore not a real and straightforward category for the rest of us.

This is a fallacy, but I can only assume Lacksie clings to it because of their belief that trans people have to be considered by society as the sex they want to be in order to live happily.

From this core belief flows the necessity for arguing that “gender” is a better, more relevant means of organising society than sex. This might be true for trans people, but it is not true for the rest of us.

All the guff about “sex is real but we only give it meaning when we observe it” is just standard philosophical discourse.

It’s of no practical use in dealing with how women navigate society as the physically smaller and weaker sex who are vulnerable to male violence. This includes from some trans identified males.

Trans people can have third spaces. End of argument. They need to start realising that other people have rights too, and look at the bigger picture. Understand that one trans women in a female category or space affects many women. Women who are also fully human. Decent transwomen do this already; plenty of narcissistic ones with a sexual fetish or personality disorder do not consider women other than as useful passive role players in their own personal drama.

sanluca · 06/11/2026 08:10

Why is it silly? You are arguing that being an adult human male is a 'rare minority variation' to being female. I find that stance counterproductive when arguing to the legal protection of the female sex or even as simple as testing medication on female people. Yes, every medication needs to be tested on male and female people to see the difference but we will include male people in the set of female people... The end result is then useless.

Again, how can society work with a term that you want to mean all people instead of just female people and have no word to mean just female people. Btw, men don't seem to have this issue, men still means adult human male. In practice. It is just women who are told their word no longer means what it always has meant and what most women still want it to mean. Why do you think this push for change is so one sided?

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread