Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Sandie Peggie has lost her case against the nursing union.

1000 replies

RhannionKPSS · 02/11/2026 15:33

Terrible news

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Totallygripped · 04/11/2026 23:09

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 21:31

No. Why don't you try reading what I actually wrote.

A body has sex characteristics whether or not anyone observes them. But the act of observing them is a process of recognition that is mediated through a brain.

Fine. I have a vulva, a vagina, a uterus and ovaries. I don't put them out for general observation but someone with a mediating brain going through the process of recognition would I hazard say I am female. On the other hand if I had a penis and testicles.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 04/11/2026 23:10

ScrollingLeaves · 04/11/2026 23:03

Thank you I never knew of that coda.

Ah, that is because wasn't observed until today 😁

ScrollingLeaves · 04/11/2026 23:31

FlirtsWithRhinos · 04/11/2026 23:10

Ah, that is because wasn't observed until today 😁

Well that is wonderful.

StealthTroublemaker · 05/11/2026 05:14

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 21:31

No. Why don't you try reading what I actually wrote.

A body has sex characteristics whether or not anyone observes them. But the act of observing them is a process of recognition that is mediated through a brain.

So is that like a cat exists but no one knows it’s a cat unless some one sees it? So what is it if it is never seen? Is it still a cat?

ArabellaScott · 05/11/2026 06:38

.

Cat Zoom GIF by GIPHY News
LinearALinearB · 05/11/2026 07:34

Well, here we are again. Plus ca change.

Lacksie · 05/11/2026 07:46

StealthTroublemaker · 05/11/2026 05:14

So is that like a cat exists but no one knows it’s a cat unless some one sees it? So what is it if it is never seen? Is it still a cat?

Yes the cat is still a cat unobserved; but 'cat' is a word, and words are applied by observers. 'Woman' is a word.

A body has gametes and chromosomes whether or not anyone observes them. But woman isn't a word we apply by observing those features - nobody has ever been called a woman by having her chromosomes read. The word is applied by people looking at people — at bodies, yes, but also at how someone presents, lives, speaks and is treated — and recognising a woman. Nobody checks her gametes. That's how every woman in this thread has been called a woman every day of her life. Yes we might infer things about that persons body- but that's an inference not an observation.

This is also how each of us came to know our own sex: not by inspecting our gametes but by a brain, very early in life, recognising its own body as one kind or other.

That is why being trans makes sense rather than being a puzzle. Recognition is part of how a person develops , and for most people it aligns with features observed at birth so nobody notices it was a judgement at all. For some people it doesn't. Their recognition of themselves departs from expectations based on observable anatomy at birth. That isn't imagination or choice — nor is it mental illness or delusion, any more than having a phantom limb is any of those things. A trans woman is someone whose recognition of herself as a woman is real and at odds with characteristics of sex observed at birth .

Which of those (characteristics of sex observed at birth, or how a person recognises and understands their own body) the word 'woman' should designate is a question about how we use a word, not a question about "the reality" of chromosomes.

Shedmistress · 05/11/2026 07:53

So men are men no matter who is looking.

Unless they have a v neck on in which case everyone simultaneously thinks 'Aah that's a lass' and not 'Oh he's wearing a v neck'?

Come on. Just stop this nonsense.

Lacksie · 05/11/2026 08:00

Shedmistress · 05/11/2026 07:53

So men are men no matter who is looking.

Unless they have a v neck on in which case everyone simultaneously thinks 'Aah that's a lass' and not 'Oh he's wearing a v neck'?

Come on. Just stop this nonsense.

What nonsense? Trying to explain to you what being trans is , and how and why the way words are used are matters of convention not of facts?

The problem is that this conversation can't and won't stop because people whose bodies and identities don't conform to your rigid demands actually exist. They exist independently of anyone's political or intellectual views and will continue to do so. So this argument will continue until people learn to accept - or at least tolerate - that reality.

Shedmistress · 05/11/2026 08:03

Lacksie · 05/11/2026 08:00

What nonsense? Trying to explain to you what being trans is , and how and why the way words are used are matters of convention not of facts?

The problem is that this conversation can't and won't stop because people whose bodies and identities don't conform to your rigid demands actually exist. They exist independently of anyone's political or intellectual views and will continue to do so. So this argument will continue until people learn to accept - or at least tolerate - that reality.

Edited

Yes, men exist as men.

If you choose to see one with gender non conforming clothes on, and make a decision to call him a woman, that's your decision to make.

Think about it, if we all looked at men with a punchy scarf on and thought 'Aah what a lovely bird', nobody would be transphobic because we'd all have been duped.

That fact that we can see the man no matter what he is wearing, means your theory isn't working for the rest of us.

Lacksie · 05/11/2026 08:05

Shedmistress · 05/11/2026 08:03

Yes, men exist as men.

If you choose to see one with gender non conforming clothes on, and make a decision to call him a woman, that's your decision to make.

Think about it, if we all looked at men with a punchy scarf on and thought 'Aah what a lovely bird', nobody would be transphobic because we'd all have been duped.

That fact that we can see the man no matter what he is wearing, means your theory isn't working for the rest of us.

Again,
Being trans is not the same as being non conforming in dress and has nothing to do with what scarfs people wear.

Shedmistress · 05/11/2026 08:07

Lacksie · 05/11/2026 08:05

Again,
Being trans is not the same as being non conforming in dress and has nothing to do with what scarfs people wear.

Edited

Your words:

The word is applied by people looking at people — at bodies, yes, but also at how someone presents, lives, speaks and is treated — and recognising a woman

FlirtsWithRhinos · 05/11/2026 09:13

All anyone is "demanding" is that the language pertaining to the female half of humanity, who very much exist, is not appropriated to mean something other than the female half of humanity. Because we, our sex, our history, our needs, our rights, matter, and are not interchangeable with a male person's self image, self recognition or presentation preferences however much he, looking at us from the outside, may genuinely think they are.

All that is needed here is separate language. No one wants to stop anyone expressing who theu feel they feel they are. We just do not accept a redefinition of ourselves to enable it. Because that is just as bad, indeed given the very real physical and social consequences of having a female bady I'd say far far worse, as telling a trans identifying male person the word "woman" is not appropriate for him.

And, because Genderists always hilariously get this bit wrong, I'm not proposing a special othering word for transwomen. I'm suggesting a new, inclusive word for everyone who identifies as the gender they currently erroneously label "woman". A Gender which is, as we finally all agree, not the same as being of the female sex, so it needs a separate name that all the transwomen can use as well as their sex-based designation of "man" , and those women who label themselves "cis" and feel a strong similarity of gender with transwomen can use as well as their sex-based designation of "woman".

(Always amuses me that Genderists, who are supposed to naturally see trans- and cis- woman as the same group of people, automatically jump to the wrong conclusion here. It shows us how they really think under their performative acceptance, I believe)

Still, I'm glad in all the "sure it exists but it's only a "cat" when it's observed and labelled by someone else" derail, we finally have an acknowledgement that Sandie Peggie was entirely correct to observe the person in her changing room was a man.

Shedmistress · 05/11/2026 09:22

At least we have a checklist now...

bodies - presume male or female
presentation - clothes
living as - whatever that means
speaks - presumably voice coaching and the testosterone helps make the point here
is treated - in a queue of women, men will definitely be treated differently so be careful what your checklist includes

So if people see a male person it fails at the first hurdle.

ApplebyArrows · 05/11/2026 09:52

Where do people learn to write like Lacksie? I can only assume it must come about as a result of studying not very hard for a humanities degree at one of the lesser universities.

Lacksie · 05/11/2026 09:55

Shedmistress · 05/11/2026 08:07

Your words:

The word is applied by people looking at people — at bodies, yes, but also at how someone presents, lives, speaks and is treated — and recognising a woman

Yes, that is how we recognise male/ female/ man/ woman/ boy/ girl in everyday contexts - presentation is obviously a factor. To say otherwise is demonstrably false.

However, being trans has got nothing to do with what clothes a person's wears.

Lacksie · 05/11/2026 09:56

ApplebyArrows · 05/11/2026 09:52

Where do people learn to write like Lacksie? I can only assume it must come about as a result of studying not very hard for a humanities degree at one of the lesser universities.

Is that all you've got?

Catiette · 05/11/2026 10:22

StealthTroublemaker · 05/11/2026 05:14

So is that like a cat exists but no one knows it’s a cat unless some one sees it? So what is it if it is never seen? Is it still a cat?

At least the tree falling in a wood conundrum's been resolved at last. Total silence. The flurry of birds and skittering ants, irrelevant.

ScrollingLeaves · 05/11/2026 11:17

StealthTroublemaker · 05/11/2026 05:14

So is that like a cat exists but no one knows it’s a cat unless some one sees it? So what is it if it is never seen? Is it still a cat?

There are some philosophical people on here who understand better what these ideas are supposed to mean, but I think it may be that you could say, even if the cat is seen by a person what does saying ‘it’s a cat’ even mean’? Everyone will have a different idea of a cat etc ….

Like Magritte’s painting
“Ceci n’est pas une pipe”

Sandie Peggie has lost her case against the nursing union.
Shedmistress · 05/11/2026 11:22

Lacksie · 05/11/2026 09:55

Yes, that is how we recognise male/ female/ man/ woman/ boy/ girl in everyday contexts - presentation is obviously a factor. To say otherwise is demonstrably false.

However, being trans has got nothing to do with what clothes a person's wears.

Presentation or not presentation? That is the question.

I'd probably stop now or you are in danger of being transphobic and will have to cancel yourself.

Lacksie · 05/11/2026 11:32

Shedmistress · 05/11/2026 11:22

Presentation or not presentation? That is the question.

I'd probably stop now or you are in danger of being transphobic and will have to cancel yourself.

I have no idea what you are talking about, but I will continue to share what is accurate and true in response to the deluge of misinformation and prejudice passed off as 'common sense fact' on this board. And I really don't care who it offends, or how much sneering it provokes in those who feel challenged by that.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 05/11/2026 11:34

ApplebyArrows · 05/11/2026 09:52

Where do people learn to write like Lacksie? I can only assume it must come about as a result of studying not very hard for a humanities degree at one of the lesser universities.

On this particular thread there's a lot of AI content.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 05/11/2026 12:00

Not all because surely AI knows the plural of scarf 🧣

ScrollingLeaves · 05/11/2026 12:13

Lacksie · 05/11/2026 07:46

Yes the cat is still a cat unobserved; but 'cat' is a word, and words are applied by observers. 'Woman' is a word.

A body has gametes and chromosomes whether or not anyone observes them. But woman isn't a word we apply by observing those features - nobody has ever been called a woman by having her chromosomes read. The word is applied by people looking at people — at bodies, yes, but also at how someone presents, lives, speaks and is treated — and recognising a woman. Nobody checks her gametes. That's how every woman in this thread has been called a woman every day of her life. Yes we might infer things about that persons body- but that's an inference not an observation.

This is also how each of us came to know our own sex: not by inspecting our gametes but by a brain, very early in life, recognising its own body as one kind or other.

That is why being trans makes sense rather than being a puzzle. Recognition is part of how a person develops , and for most people it aligns with features observed at birth so nobody notices it was a judgement at all. For some people it doesn't. Their recognition of themselves departs from expectations based on observable anatomy at birth. That isn't imagination or choice — nor is it mental illness or delusion, any more than having a phantom limb is any of those things. A trans woman is someone whose recognition of herself as a woman is real and at odds with characteristics of sex observed at birth .

Which of those (characteristics of sex observed at birth, or how a person recognises and understands their own body) the word 'woman' should designate is a question about how we use a word, not a question about "the reality" of chromosomes.

Edited

Are you suggesting ‘she’ always felt the word ‘woman’ /‘girl’ applied to her, as soon as ‘she’ could speak? Is this the Stonewall propaganda that people know they are trans from as young as two years old?

This is not true, but if it were, like a person with a phantom limb, that is in their own individual mind.

They will always be different from those for whom the actual limb/chromosomes do exist and whose lives are accordingly set in motion along certain patterns because of it.

Incidentally, though I understand you are suggesting chromosomes are irrelevant to the meaning given to ‘woman’ anyway, what you said here is not true:

“nobody has ever been called a woman by having her chromosomes read“

This not-reading-of-chromosomes may be true in the context of general daily life (a lot else is ‘read’ though), but obviously chromosomes are read frequently within tests in pregnancy.

In some cases the result leads to the female-identified child being aborted, while a baby boy who escapes to be born to call himself a woman one day will escape this fate.

Was his/her escape just because he was only ‘assigned’ male when the chromosome test was read and they turned out to have got it wrong? Do all test tube tests lack a reality beyond an individual interpretation - resulting in the vagueness of ‘assignment’? Should we not recognise Ebola under a microscope because the Ebola is just a word?

nutmeg7 · 05/11/2026 12:39

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 21:31

No. Why don't you try reading what I actually wrote.

A body has sex characteristics whether or not anyone observes them. But the act of observing them is a process of recognition that is mediated through a brain.

So what?

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread