Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Sandie Peggie has lost her case against the nursing union.

1000 replies

RhannionKPSS · 02/11/2026 15:33

Terrible news

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
FlirtsWithRhinos · 04/11/2026 16:40

Wow, amazing. Clear acknowledgement that women pushing for their rights are just a money wasting nusiance.

I sympathise, I really do. Many things over history would have been much easier for the great and good if the people being fucked over at the bottom had just accepted their role with good grace.

Coatsoff42 · 04/11/2026 16:41

@Rockyroadminibites that was agreeing with you!

Shortshriftandlethal · 04/11/2026 16:46

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 15:07

The bottom line you can’t wriggle around and evade, however, much you try, is that sex isn’t only coded at conception; it’s a developmental process — observed, recognised, recorded and lived.

For some children, their own recognition of their sex doesn’t align with what was recorded at birth.

That is an empirical reality/ truth, whether you like it or not; whether it corresponds to your common sense prejudices or not. It is what it is.

You’ve assumed this mismatch between sex recognition and sex assignment is
caused by “faulty information” or “strong messaging”; there’s no evidence for that, and your hypothesis is not supported by the neuro-cognitive science of body recognition, nor the developmental literature relating to sex/ gender cognition, nor the empirical research with children themselves.

Yes, a mismatch between recognition and assignment can be profoundly distressing.

No, it doesn’t change chromosomes or gametes.

But what can change is how a person is treated: the words used for them, how we treat them legally and socially, easily; and, where needed, the hormones that shape secondary characteristics and the anatomy that causes the distress — not as easy, but possible.

Nobody is claiming otherwise.

Edited

Our self perception/recognition does not change fundamental truths and realities that exist beyond our self perception.

Nobody is 'assigned' a sex. Sex is recorded at birth, and it was determined at conception.

No, we/society does not automatically treat people according to their self perception or definition - for the reason not everything is about us as individuals. Beyond us are common/shared and measurable realities, which in turn determine, or certainly shape, our experience of life and community.

Female only spaces, services and catgeries have arisen to recognise the specific needs/requirements and characteristics of the female sex - and to provide them with some dignity in the facts and conditions of that sex.

Males are not females no matter how they feel or how they 'recognise' themselves, and our society has decided that the needs and the dignity of the group ( females/women and girls) supercede those of the individual male who 'identifies' himself as a woman, certainly when it comes to categories, services and facilities designated for females.

It would be much better for mental health if people who 'identify as ' the opposite sex came to terms with the fact of their sex. What they feel or imagine is a private matter; one that has no bearing on the way that society organises or understands itself.

Shortshriftandlethal · 04/11/2026 16:48

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 15:20

Two psychoanalysts a century ago not finding something they weren’t looking for tells you nothing about anything.

And nobody is “born in the wrong body” — that’s a polemic claim, not a scientific descriptor. People are born in the body they’re born in - nothing "wrong" or "right" about it. The question is what that body is, and how the psyche represents it.

Self perception does not supercede measurable reality.

nutmeg7 · 04/11/2026 17:01

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 11:16

Not a figment — a construction in the brain, which is a different thing. Nobody has direct access to their own sex; you know yours because your brain recognised it, developmentally, long before you knew what a gamete was. That recognition is part of how sex develops in a person, not an alternative to it. ‘Adult human female’ assumes the body speaks for itself. It doesn’t; a brain has to read it, and that reading is where ‘woman’ lives.

Nonsense.

An unconscious person still has a sex.
A person whose brain stem is dead still has a sex.
A dead body has a sex.

Functioning brain is not needed for sex to be ascertained.

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 17:16

Shortshriftandlethal · 04/11/2026 16:46

Our self perception/recognition does not change fundamental truths and realities that exist beyond our self perception.

Nobody is 'assigned' a sex. Sex is recorded at birth, and it was determined at conception.

No, we/society does not automatically treat people according to their self perception or definition - for the reason not everything is about us as individuals. Beyond us are common/shared and measurable realities, which in turn determine, or certainly shape, our experience of life and community.

Female only spaces, services and catgeries have arisen to recognise the specific needs/requirements and characteristics of the female sex - and to provide them with some dignity in the facts and conditions of that sex.

Males are not females no matter how they feel or how they 'recognise' themselves, and our society has decided that the needs and the dignity of the group ( females/women and girls) supercede those of the individual male who 'identifies' himself as a woman, certainly when it comes to categories, services and facilities designated for females.

It would be much better for mental health if people who 'identify as ' the opposite sex came to terms with the fact of their sex. What they feel or imagine is a private matter; one that has no bearing on the way that society organises or understands itself.

Edited

Our self perception/recognition does not change fundamental truths and realities that exist beyond our self perception.

True, and nobody claimed otherwise.

Nobody is ‘assigned’ a sex. Sex is recorded at birth, and it was determined at conception.

Not quite. Sex is recorded at birth based on observation, usually of the genitals.

That is what people mean when they use the language of sex being ‘assigned’.

It is also not precise to say that sex is determined at conception. What’s fixed at conception is a set of chromosomes. What those chromosomes produce is a developmental process — gonads, hormones, anatomy — that unfolds over months and years and doesn’t always arrive where the chromosomes would predict. So chromosomal sex is set at conception; the sex of a body develops.

No, we/society does not automatically treat people according to their self perception or definition.

Sure. Nothing is automatic; these are choices. Which is why they can be argued about.

Beyond us are common/shared and measurable realities, which in turn
determine, or certainly shape, our experience of life and community.

Sure. And our own experience and cognition also shape our experience of life and community.

Female only spaces, services and categories have arisen to recognise the specific needs/requirements and characteristics of the female sex — and to provide them with some dignity in the facts and conditions of that sex.

That’s one account of why single-sex spaces exist, and a contested one. Either way, a story about why a category, space or service arose doesn’t settle who belongs in it.

Males are not females no matter how they feel or how they ‘recognise’ themselves.

True by definition, and therefore empty. The question was never whether males are females; it’s how each category is defined, and who gets to decide.

Our society has decided that the needs and the dignity of the group (females/women and girls) supersede those of the individual male who ‘identifies’ himself as a woman, certainly when it comes to categories, services and facilities designated for females.

False. One court ruled on the meaning of one word in one Act. That isn’t ‘society has decided’ and they didn't rule that "the dignity of the group - females/ women -supersede those of individual males who identify as women". That's nothing like what the court said at all. And anyway all these questions are in live dispute, which is why we’re having it. And even if society had decided, ‘society decided’ has never been the same as ‘society was right’.

It would be much better for mental health if people who ‘identify as’ the opposite sex came to terms with the fact of their sex. What they feel or imagine is a private matter; one that has no bearing on the way that society organises or understands itself.

Asserted, not evidenced. If you have evidence that denial produces better mental health than recognition, cite it. The clinical literature doesn’t say that.

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 17:19

nutmeg7 · 04/11/2026 17:01

Nonsense.

An unconscious person still has a sex.
A person whose brain stem is dead still has a sex.
A dead body has a sex.

Functioning brain is not needed for sex to be ascertained.

Functioning brain is not needed for sex to be ascertained

Lol.

‘Ascertained’ by what? Or who? A person with a brain.
You’ve just moved it from the body to the observer that's all.

A dead body has sex characteristics; it doesn’t know them, and nobody else does either until a brain observes (ascertains) them. Which is exactly what I said.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 04/11/2026 17:25

As with anything, if one focuses on the minutae it's easy to lose track of what matters and what doesn't. In ones urgency to follow the exceptions, one forgets that the context one wishes to reject is in fact required to give the exceptions one is obsessing over meaning.

DialSquare · 04/11/2026 17:29

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 17:19

Functioning brain is not needed for sex to be ascertained

Lol.

‘Ascertained’ by what? Or who? A person with a brain.
You’ve just moved it from the body to the observer that's all.

A dead body has sex characteristics; it doesn’t know them, and nobody else does either until a brain observes (ascertains) them. Which is exactly what I said.

Well using this logic, most people ascertain that transwomen are men. Case closed. They need to stay out of female single sex spaces.

Back to the thread. Good to hear that SP is appealing this.

Totallygripped · 04/11/2026 18:04

I don't want to derail (or invite response) but am getting a sense of deja vue. I recall a rather persistent poster on the original Sandie Peggie v Fife tribunal threads (set up by Nauticant). T...m..a? The same under a new guise? Wish boiledbeetle was still on with her brilliant artwork. I didn't get the gerbils reference but it was all delightful.

Arran2024 · 04/11/2026 18:40

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 15:20

Two psychoanalysts a century ago not finding something they weren’t looking for tells you nothing about anything.

And nobody is “born in the wrong body” — that’s a polemic claim, not a scientific descriptor. People are born in the body they’re born in - nothing "wrong" or "right" about it. The question is what that body is, and how the psyche represents it.

They weren't just "two psychoanalysts" though. Bowlby theorised that children develop internal working models and so you would have thought he would have spotted the trans working model? But he didn't. There was no framework to even consider it because it came later.

It is something that is part of the Zeitgeist, just as interest in the paranormal was for the late Victorians. It cannot be viewed outside our culture.

PollyNomial · 04/11/2026 19:08

SidewaysOtter · 04/11/2026 10:11

According to the Darlington Nurses Union, Peggie is appealing. Good for her.

Unfortunate typo.

Winederlust · 04/11/2026 20:08

alcovecupboards · 02/11/2026 22:23

I think you've misunderstood something quite important. I don't care what you or most people on here think about anything. Never mind what you think about me. I pop on this board to pass the time - unlike many of you it isn't my entire personality. Frankly I don't hold you in any regard whatsoever.

You've done some very bizarre mental gymnastics to take offence because a woman who uses racist slurs and vile dehumanising language about trans people, not to mention had an incredibly homophobic reaction to discovering her daughter is gay was labelled a bigot. Do you defend all racists with such rage or is Sandie different because she hates trans people as much as you seem to?

I have to say to read this statement following 11 pages of obsessive posting gave me a chuckle at the outstanding lack of self-awareness from this particular poster.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 20:15

Totallygripped · 04/11/2026 15:55

Don't know and don't care. NHS Fife certainly had a lot of cash to splash and i doubt that was crowdfunded.

Sadly not, all Scottish taxpayers money that Fife are pissing up the wall.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 20:17

Shortshriftandlethal · 04/11/2026 14:31

Sounds like the biggest concern was the airing and exposure of the dirty laundry.

Indeed.

Shortshriftandlethal · 04/11/2026 20:21

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 17:16

Our self perception/recognition does not change fundamental truths and realities that exist beyond our self perception.

True, and nobody claimed otherwise.

Nobody is ‘assigned’ a sex. Sex is recorded at birth, and it was determined at conception.

Not quite. Sex is recorded at birth based on observation, usually of the genitals.

That is what people mean when they use the language of sex being ‘assigned’.

It is also not precise to say that sex is determined at conception. What’s fixed at conception is a set of chromosomes. What those chromosomes produce is a developmental process — gonads, hormones, anatomy — that unfolds over months and years and doesn’t always arrive where the chromosomes would predict. So chromosomal sex is set at conception; the sex of a body develops.

No, we/society does not automatically treat people according to their self perception or definition.

Sure. Nothing is automatic; these are choices. Which is why they can be argued about.

Beyond us are common/shared and measurable realities, which in turn
determine, or certainly shape, our experience of life and community.

Sure. And our own experience and cognition also shape our experience of life and community.

Female only spaces, services and categories have arisen to recognise the specific needs/requirements and characteristics of the female sex — and to provide them with some dignity in the facts and conditions of that sex.

That’s one account of why single-sex spaces exist, and a contested one. Either way, a story about why a category, space or service arose doesn’t settle who belongs in it.

Males are not females no matter how they feel or how they ‘recognise’ themselves.

True by definition, and therefore empty. The question was never whether males are females; it’s how each category is defined, and who gets to decide.

Our society has decided that the needs and the dignity of the group (females/women and girls) supersede those of the individual male who ‘identifies’ himself as a woman, certainly when it comes to categories, services and facilities designated for females.

False. One court ruled on the meaning of one word in one Act. That isn’t ‘society has decided’ and they didn't rule that "the dignity of the group - females/ women -supersede those of individual males who identify as women". That's nothing like what the court said at all. And anyway all these questions are in live dispute, which is why we’re having it. And even if society had decided, ‘society decided’ has never been the same as ‘society was right’.

It would be much better for mental health if people who ‘identify as’ the opposite sex came to terms with the fact of their sex. What they feel or imagine is a private matter; one that has no bearing on the way that society organises or understands itself.

Asserted, not evidenced. If you have evidence that denial produces better mental health than recognition, cite it. The clinical literature doesn’t say that.

It is not "denial" to accept reality. Coming to terms with reality and the acceptance of certain boundaries and limits tends to be the way that most people reach a measure of fulfillment in life.

nutmeg7 · 04/11/2026 21:01

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 17:19

Functioning brain is not needed for sex to be ascertained

Lol.

‘Ascertained’ by what? Or who? A person with a brain.
You’ve just moved it from the body to the observer that's all.

A dead body has sex characteristics; it doesn’t know them, and nobody else does either until a brain observes (ascertains) them. Which is exactly what I said.

You cannot really be saying that no-one has a sex until it is observed?

Are there other things that don’t exist or happen until a human brain observes them?

Actually, don’t bother with another screed of philosophical drivel. You can believe nothing is materially real if you want to.

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 21:31

nutmeg7 · 04/11/2026 21:01

You cannot really be saying that no-one has a sex until it is observed?

Are there other things that don’t exist or happen until a human brain observes them?

Actually, don’t bother with another screed of philosophical drivel. You can believe nothing is materially real if you want to.

No. Why don't you try reading what I actually wrote.

A body has sex characteristics whether or not anyone observes them. But the act of observing them is a process of recognition that is mediated through a brain.

JanesLittleGirl · 04/11/2026 21:33

Can Sandie Peggie appeal against @Lacksie's massive derail of this thread?

MassiveWordSalad · 04/11/2026 21:35

Great news that Sandie is going to appeal. Thank god she and her team have unswerving tenacity to get them through all this.

ScrollingLeaves · 04/11/2026 21:44

nutmeg7 · 04/11/2026 21:01

You cannot really be saying that no-one has a sex until it is observed?

Are there other things that don’t exist or happen until a human brain observes them?

Actually, don’t bother with another screed of philosophical drivel. You can believe nothing is materially real if you want to.

The 20thC theologian Ronald Knox wrote this limerick to satirise the 18thC philosopher Bishop Berkeley’s belief that nothing exists unless it is perceived, and perception is caused aspects of the senses. He thought God created the capacity for these in us.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Berkeley

I am not a philosopher, cannot claim to even begin to understand the subtleties of his Ideas, but in light of the question of whether someone’s sex exists or is perceived, and if perceived, by whom? wanted to share this this wonderful poem.

What Ronald Knox wrote:

^There once was a man who said "God
Must think it exceedingly odd
If he finds that this tree
Continues to be
When there's no one about in the Quad."^

Then there was the amusing anonymous answer:

^Dear Sir, Your astonishment's odd:
I am always about in the Quad.
And that's why the tree
Will continue to be
Since observed by, Yours faithfully, God^

FlirtsWithRhinos · 04/11/2026 22:02

nutmeg7 · 04/11/2026 21:01

You cannot really be saying that no-one has a sex until it is observed?

Are there other things that don’t exist or happen until a human brain observes them?

Actually, don’t bother with another screed of philosophical drivel. You can believe nothing is materially real if you want to.

It's subtle. They's effectively saying whatever a person's sex is, it's irrelevant until observed, either by the person or by someone else.

I've considered the question, and the limitations of it in practice, in more detail here : www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5596067-mechanisms-of-biological-sex-and-the-social-consequences-thereof?page=3&reply=155747915

FlirtsWithRhinos · 04/11/2026 22:03

ScrollingLeaves · 04/11/2026 21:44

The 20thC theologian Ronald Knox wrote this limerick to satirise the 18thC philosopher Bishop Berkeley’s belief that nothing exists unless it is perceived, and perception is caused aspects of the senses. He thought God created the capacity for these in us.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Berkeley

I am not a philosopher, cannot claim to even begin to understand the subtleties of his Ideas, but in light of the question of whether someone’s sex exists or is perceived, and if perceived, by whom? wanted to share this this wonderful poem.

What Ronald Knox wrote:

^There once was a man who said "God
Must think it exceedingly odd
If he finds that this tree
Continues to be
When there's no one about in the Quad."^

Then there was the amusing anonymous answer:

^Dear Sir, Your astonishment's odd:
I am always about in the Quad.
And that's why the tree
Will continue to be
Since observed by, Yours faithfully, God^

One of my favourites 😍 I love FWR

FlirtsWithRhinos · 04/11/2026 22:09

Of course quantum mechanics creates an interesting coda to this one...

And Heisenberg cried "Now I see
The reason that God has to be!
He's keeping an eye on
Each Quark, tau and pion
To ensure there's no uncertainty"

ScrollingLeaves · 04/11/2026 23:03

FlirtsWithRhinos · 04/11/2026 22:09

Of course quantum mechanics creates an interesting coda to this one...

And Heisenberg cried "Now I see
The reason that God has to be!
He's keeping an eye on
Each Quark, tau and pion
To ensure there's no uncertainty"

Thank you I never knew of that coda.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.