Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Sandie Peggie has lost her case against the nursing union.

1000 replies

RhannionKPSS · 02/11/2026 15:33

Terrible news

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Shortshriftandlethal · 04/11/2026 14:46

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 14:40

babies actually recognise a female face when they see one.

Yes

That is not the same as a man performing 'motherly' or 'care-giving'.

Agree.

Recognition of another's sex is deeply coded because survival depends on it.

Agree it is deeply coded. The second part is a hypothesis that I don't have much comment on.

None of this contradicts anything I said. I agree with you that babies can recognise a female face and this is deeply coded.

It does not depend on recognising/ understanding social categories or stereotypes.

That's exactly the point.

Edited

It does depend on the messages being conveyed and on the language/words being used in the environment as as the brain is developing. A child's 'self' develops by what is reflected back to it from those around. Language and words accompany cognitive development. " Girl' Boy' " Good' 'Naughty', and a child's emotional/psychic life is very much lived, and develops, in the shadow of their parent's psyche.

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 14:49

Shortshriftandlethal · 04/11/2026 14:46

It does depend on the messages being conveyed and on the language/words being used in the environment as as the brain is developing. A child's 'self' develops by what is reflected back to it from those around. Language and words accompany cognitive development. " Girl' Boy' " Good' 'Naughty', and a child's emotional/psychic life is very much lived, and develops, in the shadow of their parent's psyche.

Edited

No. Infants’ ability to sort faces by sex comes from perceptual exposure — which faces they see most — not from language, expectations or the parental psyche, which are far more complex forms of social learning that come much later.

Shortshriftandlethal · 04/11/2026 14:53

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 14:42

No this doesn't follow at all. None of it follows.

See how the neurocognitive science of body recognition works. It's got nothing to do with social-environmental learning.

The bottom line that you cannot wriggle around and evade, as much as you try, is that one cannot change sex. Sex is coded at conception. A male/female child 'identyfing' itself as the opposite sex has absorbed faulty or incorrect information - or more usually has absorbed very strong messaging about what their actual sex 'means' that they find very uncomfortable or distressing.

Nobody is the opposite sex to that which they are. Children included.

Shortshriftandlethal · 04/11/2026 14:56

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 14:49

No. Infants’ ability to sort faces by sex comes from perceptual exposure — which faces they see most — not from language, expectations or the parental psyche, which are far more complex forms of social learning that come much later.

Yes, the shape and contours of biological sex are very visible to the eye and are detected at an instinctive level. It is only later that words/names get attached.

Soontobe60 · 04/11/2026 15:01

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 13:01

*You're.

I am female and have gestated several babies.

It's very weird that you believe you can reliably tell what sex I am based on my contributions to an online discussion.

Did you “think” yourself pregnant? Can a male who thinks he’s female also think himself pregnant?

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 15:07

Shortshriftandlethal · 04/11/2026 14:53

The bottom line that you cannot wriggle around and evade, as much as you try, is that one cannot change sex. Sex is coded at conception. A male/female child 'identyfing' itself as the opposite sex has absorbed faulty or incorrect information - or more usually has absorbed very strong messaging about what their actual sex 'means' that they find very uncomfortable or distressing.

Nobody is the opposite sex to that which they are. Children included.

The bottom line you can’t wriggle around and evade, however, much you try, is that sex isn’t only coded at conception; it’s a developmental process — observed, recognised, recorded and lived.

For some children, their own recognition of their sex doesn’t align with what was recorded at birth.

That is an empirical reality/ truth, whether you like it or not; whether it corresponds to your common sense prejudices or not. It is what it is.

You’ve assumed this mismatch between sex recognition and sex assignment is
caused by “faulty information” or “strong messaging”; there’s no evidence for that, and your hypothesis is not supported by the neuro-cognitive science of body recognition, nor the developmental literature relating to sex/ gender cognition, nor the empirical research with children themselves.

Yes, a mismatch between recognition and assignment can be profoundly distressing.

No, it doesn’t change chromosomes or gametes.

But what can change is how a person is treated: the words used for them, how we treat them legally and socially, easily; and, where needed, the hormones that shape secondary characteristics and the anatomy that causes the distress — not as easy, but possible.

Nobody is claiming otherwise.

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 15:08

Shortshriftandlethal · 04/11/2026 14:56

Yes, the shape and contours of biological sex are very visible to the eye and are detected at an instinctive level. It is only later that words/names get attached.

Correct.

Rockyroadminibites · 04/11/2026 15:11

And yet transitioning increases suicide risk eighteen-fold whereas pre-transition trans identified children do not have raised suicide risk.

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 04/11/2026 15:12

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 15:07

The bottom line you can’t wriggle around and evade, however, much you try, is that sex isn’t only coded at conception; it’s a developmental process — observed, recognised, recorded and lived.

For some children, their own recognition of their sex doesn’t align with what was recorded at birth.

That is an empirical reality/ truth, whether you like it or not; whether it corresponds to your common sense prejudices or not. It is what it is.

You’ve assumed this mismatch between sex recognition and sex assignment is
caused by “faulty information” or “strong messaging”; there’s no evidence for that, and your hypothesis is not supported by the neuro-cognitive science of body recognition, nor the developmental literature relating to sex/ gender cognition, nor the empirical research with children themselves.

Yes, a mismatch between recognition and assignment can be profoundly distressing.

No, it doesn’t change chromosomes or gametes.

But what can change is how a person is treated: the words used for them, how we treat them legally and socially, easily; and, where needed, the hormones that shape secondary characteristics and the anatomy that causes the distress — not as easy, but possible.

Nobody is claiming otherwise.

Edited

So "trans" is a mental disorder. A delusion that they are not the sex of their body. Your answer is to change the body to fit the delusion whereas the correct approach is to treat the delusion.

Arran2024 · 04/11/2026 15:13

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 15:07

The bottom line you can’t wriggle around and evade, however, much you try, is that sex isn’t only coded at conception; it’s a developmental process — observed, recognised, recorded and lived.

For some children, their own recognition of their sex doesn’t align with what was recorded at birth.

That is an empirical reality/ truth, whether you like it or not; whether it corresponds to your common sense prejudices or not. It is what it is.

You’ve assumed this mismatch between sex recognition and sex assignment is
caused by “faulty information” or “strong messaging”; there’s no evidence for that, and your hypothesis is not supported by the neuro-cognitive science of body recognition, nor the developmental literature relating to sex/ gender cognition, nor the empirical research with children themselves.

Yes, a mismatch between recognition and assignment can be profoundly distressing.

No, it doesn’t change chromosomes or gametes.

But what can change is how a person is treated: the words used for them, how we treat them legally and socially, easily; and, where needed, the hormones that shape secondary characteristics and the anatomy that causes the distress — not as easy, but possible.

Nobody is claiming otherwise.

Edited

Bowl by, Freud etc found no evidence of children born in the wrong body. This is a new development which fits specifically into our time and place. It uses top/down theories created in gender studies departments rather than coming up from the streets. It flourishes among certain groups. The idea that it is intrinsic, organic is ridiculous.

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 15:15

Rockyroadminibites · 04/11/2026 15:11

And yet transitioning increases suicide risk eighteen-fold whereas pre-transition trans identified children do not have raised suicide risk.

This is a misreading of a well known study, Dhejne et al. (2011), a Swedish cohort study of people who had undergone sex-reassignment surgery between 1973 and 2003.

It compared them with general-population controls matched on birth sex, and found suicide mortality about nineteen times higher.

It did not compare transitioned with untransitioned trans people — there was no such group in the study — so it says nothing about whether transition raised or lowered the risk.

The authors said so explicitly, and Dhejne has spent a decade publicly objecting to the use being made of it.

The elevated risk was also concentrated in the earlier cohort (1973–88) and fell sharply in the later one, which is more consistent with improving care and declining stigma than with surgery as the cause.

Your second claim - “pre-transition trans-identified children do not have raised suicide risk” — is simply false: trans-identified young people show elevated suicidal ideation and attempts in every population survey that has looked (Toomey et al., 2018, for the US; the Cass Review’s own commissioned research for the UK). The study usually cited for the second claim is Ruuska et al. (2024, Finland). This study looked at young people who had been referred to gender clinics and asked whether more of them died by suicide than other young people. The answer was: not once you took account of their psychiatric histories — the extra deaths were explained by mental illness, not by gender identity as such. Three things follow. It’s about completed suicides, which are rare, not about suicidal thoughts or attempts, which are common and elevated in trans youth. It’s about a group referred to clinics, which is not the same as “pre-transition children.” And it says nothing about transition, because the group included both those who went on to treatment and those who didn’t, and wasn’t split by that. So it can’t support “pre-transition children have no raised risk,” and it can’t be paired with Dhejne to suggest transition raises it.

heathspeedwell · 04/11/2026 15:17

I'm so impressed with Sandie's bravery and her determination to see justice for all women.

I wonder if there's something we can do to show our support for her?

The last few days must have been tough seeing men spreading lies about her in the press and gloating over what happened.

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 15:20

Arran2024 · 04/11/2026 15:13

Bowl by, Freud etc found no evidence of children born in the wrong body. This is a new development which fits specifically into our time and place. It uses top/down theories created in gender studies departments rather than coming up from the streets. It flourishes among certain groups. The idea that it is intrinsic, organic is ridiculous.

Two psychoanalysts a century ago not finding something they weren’t looking for tells you nothing about anything.

And nobody is “born in the wrong body” — that’s a polemic claim, not a scientific descriptor. People are born in the body they’re born in - nothing "wrong" or "right" about it. The question is what that body is, and how the psyche represents it.

Rockyroadminibites · 04/11/2026 15:22

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 15:15

This is a misreading of a well known study, Dhejne et al. (2011), a Swedish cohort study of people who had undergone sex-reassignment surgery between 1973 and 2003.

It compared them with general-population controls matched on birth sex, and found suicide mortality about nineteen times higher.

It did not compare transitioned with untransitioned trans people — there was no such group in the study — so it says nothing about whether transition raised or lowered the risk.

The authors said so explicitly, and Dhejne has spent a decade publicly objecting to the use being made of it.

The elevated risk was also concentrated in the earlier cohort (1973–88) and fell sharply in the later one, which is more consistent with improving care and declining stigma than with surgery as the cause.

Your second claim - “pre-transition trans-identified children do not have raised suicide risk” — is simply false: trans-identified young people show elevated suicidal ideation and attempts in every population survey that has looked (Toomey et al., 2018, for the US; the Cass Review’s own commissioned research for the UK). The study usually cited for the second claim is Ruuska et al. (2024, Finland). This study looked at young people who had been referred to gender clinics and asked whether more of them died by suicide than other young people. The answer was: not once you took account of their psychiatric histories — the extra deaths were explained by mental illness, not by gender identity as such. Three things follow. It’s about completed suicides, which are rare, not about suicidal thoughts or attempts, which are common and elevated in trans youth. It’s about a group referred to clinics, which is not the same as “pre-transition children.” And it says nothing about transition, because the group included both those who went on to treatment and those who didn’t, and wasn’t split by that. So it can’t support “pre-transition children have no raised risk,” and it can’t be paired with Dhejne to suggest transition raises it.

Edited

Suicidal thoughts are not the same as suicide, as you point out. Suicide is not higher in trans identified children. Including ‘suicidal thoughts’, especially when children are told to report them to access medication, is manipulative.

StealthTroublemaker · 04/11/2026 15:24

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 12:44

Yes of course that would be extremely daft.

The relevant criterion is being able to gestate a baby.
There's no need to get distracted by being outraged about trans people.

So are you saying à transwoman would not be able to gestate a baby? Why? I mean, you were the one arguing sex is not binary and no one can see their true sex. If no one can see their sex, how do you know à transwoman is not female and therefore able to gestalt à baby?

spannasaurus · 04/11/2026 15:26

DrSpartacularsMagnificentOctopus · 04/11/2026 14:29

"Aired" is an interesting word choice. Maybe it's just me but I only connect it to the airing of dirty laundry.

Which is apt, I guess.

Me too.

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 15:26

Rockyroadminibites · 04/11/2026 15:22

Suicidal thoughts are not the same as suicide, as you point out. Suicide is not higher in trans identified children. Including ‘suicidal thoughts’, especially when children are told to report them to access medication, is manipulative.

Suicides are is not higher in trans identified children

Wrong again. Absence of evidence isn't evidence of absence.

Completed suicide in children is so rare that no study can compare rates with any confidence; Ruuska’s raw rate was elevated and only fell after adjusting for psychiatric history.

And it isn’t just thoughts: suicide attempts are markedly elevated in trans-identified young people in every population survey (Toomey et al., 2018, for instance), and population surveys aren’t gatekeeping anyone’s medication.

Suicidal thoughts and attempts are very important measures of clinical distress, and nothing manipulative at all about taking them seriously.

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 15:30

StealthTroublemaker · 04/11/2026 15:24

So are you saying à transwoman would not be able to gestate a baby? Why? I mean, you were the one arguing sex is not binary and no one can see their true sex. If no one can see their sex, how do you know à transwoman is not female and therefore able to gestalt à baby?

So are you saying à transwoman would not be able to gestate a baby?

Of course. there is no sane person who claims that a transwoman can gestate a baby,

Why?

Because a trans woman does not have a uterus.

I mean, you were the one arguing sex is not binary

There is a powerful binary that underlines sex development with most individuals progressing along one of two pathways, but there are also minority variations that combine elements of each pathway.

and no one can see their true sex.

Bizarre claim that bears no relation to anything I have said.

If no one can see their sex, how do you know à transwoman is not female and therefore able to gestalt à baby?

Nonsensical line of logic, founded on a premise that you hallucinated.

spannasaurus · 04/11/2026 15:34

It will be interesting so see the grounds of appeal and whether its based solely on an error of law or if they will also be claiming on other legal errors such as perverse decision or lack of evidence for a decision

StealthTroublemaker · 04/11/2026 15:36

So @Lacksie if sex is so nebulous and cannot be defined, how do TIM know they are feeling like a female and not a male? Did you ever come up with a definition of woman or did you forget?

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 15:37

I wonder where all the money for all these appeals is coming from? She really must be loaded this nurse.

Anthophile · 04/11/2026 15:48

BunnyBunbunbun · 03/11/2026 12:04

She didn't use the word "devastated". You are been disingenuous. It's already been pointed out to you that it wasn't her word, so the fact you're still using it simply goes to show that you are deliberately twisting and distorting.

As for daft comments about Pakistani or Chinese people, I don't use that language myself but it's not malicious and it's not some kind of evil character flaw that she should be cancelled for. I suspect in Pakistan and China you'd hear far worse about people from other cultures.

Aside from throwing out "isms" and "phobias", do you have any arguments?

As for daft comments about Pakistani or Chinese people, I don't use that language myself but it's not malicious and it's not some kind of evil character flaw that she should be cancelled for.

She knowingly used slurs multiple times and attributed it to her upbringing (she "had been brought up like that", in her own words).

Many people face criticism for things that they have done without malice but are still ethically, morally or legally wrong. That doesn't mean they shouldn't face criticism.

That doesn't mean her need for access to single-sex spaces should be denied or derided, either.

I suspect in Pakistan and China you'd hear far worse about people from other cultures.

@BunnyBunbunbun , what are you trying to say here exactly? Are there any racist undertones, or is it a simple case of whataboutism?

Even if you genuinely suspect people in Pakistan and China use far worse terms than the slurs she has uttered, what does it have to do with her conduct in this specific instance?

Is it your argument that if they use far worse terms it makes what she said deserve less scrutiny, or is it something else?

Totallygripped · 04/11/2026 15:55

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 15:37

I wonder where all the money for all these appeals is coming from? She really must be loaded this nurse.

Don't know and don't care. NHS Fife certainly had a lot of cash to splash and i doubt that was crowdfunded.

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 16:14

Totallygripped · 04/11/2026 15:55

Don't know and don't care. NHS Fife certainly had a lot of cash to splash and i doubt that was crowdfunded.

NHS Fife’s costs aren’t a mystery — they’re public money, FOI’d and published: £220k by May 2025, £320k by August, after the Information Commissioner ordered disclosure. Most of it is paid through NHS Scotland’s central legal service and a shared pot that all the health boards pay into; NHS Fife’s own share is capped at £25. That’s a public body defending an employment claim with pooled public funds. I'm sure that money could have been much better spent elsewhere, but someone has endless cash to keep these lawsuits coming.

Coatsoff42 · 04/11/2026 16:38

Rockyroadminibites · 04/11/2026 14:26

You need to provide more than that. A child has no understanding of their sex outside that provided to them in the form of sexed expectations. A young child will think you change sex when you change your clothes and if told certain toys are boys toys that they must be a boy if they want to play with them. If boys believe long hair, heels, pink and an interest in the arts are masculine (as they have been historically) then they will think liking those things makes them a boy.

If you ask most children who they want to marry when they grow up, they will say one of their parents.
Listening only goes so far, children do not have incestuous ideas, they are not identifying a sexuality, they are not trans, they are little kids who live in a fairy tale world of stories and dreams.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.