Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Sandie Peggie has lost her case against the nursing union.

1000 replies

RhannionKPSS · 02/11/2026 15:33

Terrible news

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Signalbox · 04/11/2026 14:13

Shame this thread has been derailed.

RhannionKPSS · 04/11/2026 14:16

Can we get back on track regarding Sandie Peggie’s case please ? Thank goodness Sandie has decided to appeal the judgement

OP posts:
Shortshriftandlethal · 04/11/2026 14:17

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 14:06

They could be seen to contradict each other if the dementia reports showed distress at the altered body, but they don’t. What the handful of cases describe is loss of autobiographical memory: people who don’t remember transitioning, revert to an earlier name, and are confused by a present they can’t connect to the past they recall. That’s a memory phenomenon — the same thing happens when a man with dementia doesn’t recognise his wife. It's not a report about the body schema which is what the studies about phantom penises are exploring.

And two broader caveats that apply here:

First all these studies are very small, isolated exploratory pieces of research - they haven't been widely replicated.

Second - dementia disrupts self-recognition generally - people often lose the ability to recognise their own face in the mirror for example, so dementia cases can’t really settle anything about the body model in a healthy brain either way.

All of your arguments and explanations place most emphasis on Self ID as the ultimate arbiter of reality - when it really isn't. We've been conditioned to believe that we are each the centre of the universe and that everything else must revolve around us; that our reality, or our 'truth', or our 'feelings' are all that matters.

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 14:18

Shortshriftandlethal · 04/11/2026 14:06

Dr Sam Hall "gestated" three pregnancies. Using the word 'gestated' seems very detached, or certainaly wanting to detach from the usual terms associated with pregnancy and motherhood.

Well it's not how I generally talk about being pregnant obviously lol.

But in a conversation where people are insistent that in order to meet their definition of a "woman", I have to justify that I have a body organised around the production of large, immobile gametes, it somehow seemed appropriate.

So there you have it. I have a body organised around the production of large, immobile gametes, which has enabled me to conceive and gestate several babies.

None of this can be proved or disproved by how I engage on an online forum, or what my opinions are about the science of sex development, body recognition, and being transgender.

People with large immobile gametes have all sorts of ideas and ways of conversing :).

Signalbox · 04/11/2026 14:18

RhannionKPSS · 04/11/2026 14:16

Can we get back on track regarding Sandie Peggie’s case please ? Thank goodness Sandie has decided to appeal the judgement

Reposting this so it doesn’t get lost.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cm62yk7l54kxo

a woman with shoulder-length blonde hair is wearing a blue jacket over a white top

Nurse Sandie Peggie to appeal after losing discrimination case against union

Peggie failed in her claim that she was discriminated against by a union over her beliefs on biological sex and gender.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cm62yk7l54kxo

Rockyroadminibites · 04/11/2026 14:19

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 14:13

An anecdote about eleven-year-olds playing doesn’t make pretending to be an animal the same as being trans. It manifestly isn’t.

“Sex is a fundamental category” is true, and beside the point: the question is whether a child’s own sense of their sex can diverge from their sex recorded at birth. It categorically can and does, whether you like it or not. None of this has anything to do with your grandchildren playing furies.

How do you determine if a young child’s own sense of their sex differs from their actual sex? As opposed to differing from regressive stereotyped expectations of their sex?

BettyBooper · 04/11/2026 14:20

RhannionKPSS · 04/11/2026 14:16

Can we get back on track regarding Sandie Peggie’s case please ? Thank goodness Sandie has decided to appeal the judgement

Agreed. On both counts.

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 14:21

Rockyroadminibites · 04/11/2026 14:19

How do you determine if a young child’s own sense of their sex differs from their actual sex? As opposed to differing from regressive stereotyped expectations of their sex?

By talking and listening. The same way you learn anything about what a child is subjectively sensing/ perceiving/ experiencing/ feeling.

Rockyroadminibites · 04/11/2026 14:21

Signalbox · 04/11/2026 14:18

Reposting this so it doesn’t get lost.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cm62yk7l54kxo

Thanks.

Shortshriftandlethal · 04/11/2026 14:24

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 14:13

An anecdote about eleven-year-olds playing doesn’t make pretending to be an animal the same as being trans. It manifestly isn’t.

“Sex is a fundamental category” is true, and beside the point: the question is whether a child’s own sense of their sex can diverge from their sex recorded at birth. It categorically can and does, whether you like it or not. None of this has anything to do with your grandchildren playing furies.

I suggest it is just the same; the same as the other girl at her school who came back after Covid declaring she was now a boy, and who would shout at her friends when they accidentally 'mis-gendered' her.

One's "sense of one's sex" doesn't change reality. You are the sex that you are. Self perception does not shape the facts of life on earth, or the facts that are visible to other people.

It is not my granddaughter, by the way, it is two of her friends. They are taking the whole matter very seriously. It certainly seems like a part of the process in their pre-pubertal identity formation.

Shortshriftandlethal · 04/11/2026 14:26

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 14:21

By talking and listening. The same way you learn anything about what a child is subjectively sensing/ perceiving/ experiencing/ feeling.

But we are not obliged to validate everything a child says, especially if it is a false consciousness.

BettyBooper · 04/11/2026 14:26

Signalbox · 04/11/2026 14:18

Reposting this so it doesn’t get lost.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cm62yk7l54kxo

Interesting that the RCN said this

"We are sorry these matters were aired before the tribunal."

Not that they were glad to have the opportunity to put the record straight and address their member's concerns.

Rockyroadminibites · 04/11/2026 14:26

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 14:21

By talking and listening. The same way you learn anything about what a child is subjectively sensing/ perceiving/ experiencing/ feeling.

You need to provide more than that. A child has no understanding of their sex outside that provided to them in the form of sexed expectations. A young child will think you change sex when you change your clothes and if told certain toys are boys toys that they must be a boy if they want to play with them. If boys believe long hair, heels, pink and an interest in the arts are masculine (as they have been historically) then they will think liking those things makes them a boy.

DrSpartacularsMagnificentOctopus · 04/11/2026 14:29

BettyBooper · 04/11/2026 14:26

Interesting that the RCN said this

"We are sorry these matters were aired before the tribunal."

Not that they were glad to have the opportunity to put the record straight and address their member's concerns.

"Aired" is an interesting word choice. Maybe it's just me but I only connect it to the airing of dirty laundry.

Which is apt, I guess.

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 14:30

Rockyroadminibites · 04/11/2026 14:26

You need to provide more than that. A child has no understanding of their sex outside that provided to them in the form of sexed expectations. A young child will think you change sex when you change your clothes and if told certain toys are boys toys that they must be a boy if they want to play with them. If boys believe long hair, heels, pink and an interest in the arts are masculine (as they have been historically) then they will think liking those things makes them a boy.

A child has no understanding of their sex outside that provided to them in the form of sexed expectations.

What makes you believe this and state it so assertively?
Research shows that infants can recognise sex differences in faces and sort faces by sex, long before they have any concept of sex or sexed expectations.

The real problem here is that this is a really complex area of science that has become heavily politicised, and much of what circulates as common sense about it doesn’t survive contact with the research.

Shortshriftandlethal · 04/11/2026 14:31

BettyBooper · 04/11/2026 14:26

Interesting that the RCN said this

"We are sorry these matters were aired before the tribunal."

Not that they were glad to have the opportunity to put the record straight and address their member's concerns.

Sounds like the biggest concern was the airing and exposure of the dirty laundry.

BettyBooper · 04/11/2026 14:32

DrSpartacularsMagnificentOctopus · 04/11/2026 14:29

"Aired" is an interesting word choice. Maybe it's just me but I only connect it to the airing of dirty laundry.

Which is apt, I guess.

Yes, I thought the same. Not exactly giving the impression of openness and transparency...

Shortshriftandlethal · 04/11/2026 14:32

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 14:30

A child has no understanding of their sex outside that provided to them in the form of sexed expectations.

What makes you believe this and state it so assertively?
Research shows that infants can recognise sex differences in faces and sort faces by sex, long before they have any concept of sex or sexed expectations.

The real problem here is that this is a really complex area of science that has become heavily politicised, and much of what circulates as common sense about it doesn’t survive contact with the research.

Edited

Yes, children can recognise the differences between male and female even before they have the language and accompanying cognitive structures to organise the world into sexed categories with words/name attached.

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 14:34

Shortshriftandlethal · 04/11/2026 14:32

Yes, children can recognise the differences between male and female even before they have the language and accompanying cognitive structures to organise the world into sexed categories with words/name attached.

Edited

Absolutely.

Which is precisely why it doesn't follow that a child's recognition of their own sex must be determined by socially learned categories/ stereotypes.

Shortshriftandlethal · 04/11/2026 14:36

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 14:34

Absolutely.

Which is precisely why it doesn't follow that a child's recognition of their own sex must be determined by socially learned categories/ stereotypes.

Edited

No, babies actually recognise a female face when they see one. That is not the same as a man performing 'motherly' or 'care-giving'. Recognition of another's sex is deeply coded because survival depends on it.

Mollyollydolly · 04/11/2026 14:37

I don't normally comment on threads being derailed but I've come to this one today to see discussion on Sandie appealing and its pages of bollocks. I do wish people wouldn't take the bait. It's a tactic to make the threads too difficult to follow. Just start your own thread or bugger off.
Thank you.

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 14:40

Shortshriftandlethal · 04/11/2026 14:36

No, babies actually recognise a female face when they see one. That is not the same as a man performing 'motherly' or 'care-giving'. Recognition of another's sex is deeply coded because survival depends on it.

Edited

babies actually recognise a female face when they see one.

Yes

That is not the same as a man performing 'motherly' or 'care-giving'.

Agree.

Recognition of another's sex is deeply coded because survival depends on it.

Agree it is deeply coded. The second part is a hypothesis that I don't have much comment on.

None of this contradicts anything I said. I agree with you that babies can recognise a female face and this is deeply coded.

It does not depend on recognising/ understanding social categories or stereotypes.

That's exactly the point.

Shortshriftandlethal · 04/11/2026 14:41

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 14:34

Absolutely.

Which is precisely why it doesn't follow that a child's recognition of their own sex must be determined by socially learned categories/ stereotypes.

Edited

If a child is incorrectly 'identifying' itself as the opposite sex to which it is - it has to be for social-environmental reasons. It cannot be anything other than environmental. The child's developing cognition has shaped itself around the environmental messages and 'encouragements' emanating from adults around it.

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 14:42

Shortshriftandlethal · 04/11/2026 14:41

If a child is incorrectly 'identifying' itself as the opposite sex to which it is - it has to be for social-environmental reasons. It cannot be anything other than environmental. The child's developing cognition has shaped itself around the environmental messages and 'encouragements' emanating from adults around it.

No this doesn't follow at all. None of it follows.

See how the neurocognitive science of body recognition works. It's got nothing to do with social-environmental learning.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.