Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Sandie Peggie has lost her case against the nursing union.

1000 replies

RhannionKPSS · 02/11/2026 15:33

Terrible news

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
spannasaurus · 04/11/2026 13:29

Signalbox · 04/11/2026 13:24

That article mentions a notice of appeal being submitted next week.
Does anyone know if an appeal notice sets out the grounds of appeal or is it simply saying that an appeal will be made with the detailed grounds being submitted at a later date

Manxexile · 04/11/2026 13:31

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 12:31

A string of replies full of wrong and overly-simplified assumptions. It's hard to know where to start!

Perhaps you could start by explaining why a gay couple looking for a surrogate womb would "... be making a really very basic error lol..." if they excluded transwomen?

You go on to say "... Luckily I don't think most are that naive/ daft."

Again can you explain why they would be naive and/or daft to exclude transwomen?

If they chose a transwoman as surrogate, how would he gestate a baby?

Shortshriftandlethal · 04/11/2026 13:33

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 13:01

*You're.

I am female and have gestated several babies.

It's very weird that you believe you can reliably tell what sex I am based on my contributions to an online discussion.

Whatever your sex, you are wasting your time in pursuit of something which is unattainable. If you are male then you will always be male, and if you are female then you will always remain so. No amount of arguing the toss over what makes a woman or what denotes female is going to change that. These are stable facts. The world over. Sex is a fundamental organisational category on Planet Earth.

ScrollingLeaves · 04/11/2026 13:35

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 13:28

Fascinating, however the relevance to the current discussion is very limited.

Not at all. It was about classification by other people about a person, as opposed to ‘self-recognition’ by themselves. You had introduced this as salient in your post 13:05

being classified female and recognising yourself as female are two different things,

I am saying,

being classified as human and recognising your self as human ( instead of canine in this case) are (can be) two different things.

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 13:35

Rockyroadminibites · 04/11/2026 13:28

Why would I follow karyotype? You were the one who introduced chromosomes. Genes ALWAYS determine sex. Sex is DEFINED by gametes. You talk of hormone receptors as if hormone receptors are not also determined by genes…

Observation of babies at birth is incredible accurate in determining sex. Very rarely is further testing required and where it is it is unlikely to be karyotyping when full genome sequencing is so readily available,

Agreed on both counts. Hormone receptors are genetic: sex is what the whole genetic programme does, acting over months, through gonads, hormones, receptors and tissues. “Genes determine sex” and “sex develops” aren’t rivals; the second is how the first happens. And yes, observation at birth is highly accurate — as a prediction of how that development will go, because the dimensions usually line up. An accurate proxy is still a proxy. The cases we’re arguing about are exactly the ones where the dimensions don’t line up, and there the proxy is the thing that fails.

As for gametes: around one man in a hundred never produces a sperm in his life, and some women never produce a viable egg — and nobody hesitates to call them male and female. So “defined by gametes” has to mean “organised to produce, under typical development,” which is a judgement about what the body is for, not an observation of what it does.
It’s also a definition that philosophers introduced for classifying people about five years ago, after chromosomes and genitals kept failing — so if you want to talk about who’s been changing definitions...
And btw people don't check a baby’s gametes in assigning sex; the birth certificate records anatomy, and anatomy is being used to infer the gamete type. The proxy is doing the work, and the proxy is what fails in the cases we’re arguing about.

spannasaurus · 04/11/2026 13:39

The only time the sex of a baby would be assigned instead of simply being observed would be where the sex of that baby is unclear due to a DSD. The doctors determining the sex of that baby would be checking gametes amongst other things

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 13:41

Manxexile · 04/11/2026 13:31

Perhaps you could start by explaining why a gay couple looking for a surrogate womb would "... be making a really very basic error lol..." if they excluded transwomen?

You go on to say "... Luckily I don't think most are that naive/ daft."

Again can you explain why they would be naive and/or daft to exclude transwomen?

If they chose a transwoman as surrogate, how would he gestate a baby?

I don't know why you think you are making a clever or challenging point.

No one has claimed that a trans woman has a uterus or can gestate a baby. The argument is over whether that necessarily excludes them from being called the word "woman".

Shortshriftandlethal · 04/11/2026 13:42

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 13:01

*You're.

I am female and have gestated several babies.

It's very weird that you believe you can reliably tell what sex I am based on my contributions to an online discussion.

What i find most curious is why a woman would reject her own sex so much that she would put in so much time eand energy into arguing that some male people should be considered female and given access to the facilities and services set aside for the dignity and protection of women and girls?

Why would a woman ( and a mother?) do that? What is it that she could be so invested in and why? Unless, she herself, was trans identifying and using male pronouns, maybe?

DrSpartacularsMagnificentOctopus · 04/11/2026 13:42

Proprioception is an interesting point to bring up and is not the gotcha it's being presented as. We know from research that elderly "transitioned" people who develop dementia can forget about their "transition" and become distressed at their surgically altered bodies and at the "gender identity" others perceive and treat them to be. Proprioception likely has a part to play in this, ie the brain knows the body should have a penis but it's not there, or vice versa.

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 13:42

ScrollingLeaves · 04/11/2026 13:35

Not at all. It was about classification by other people about a person, as opposed to ‘self-recognition’ by themselves. You had introduced this as salient in your post 13:05

being classified female and recognising yourself as female are two different things,

I am saying,

being classified as human and recognising your self as human ( instead of canine in this case) are (can be) two different things.

Sure and that's the very limited relevance I was referring to.

The reason it's of very limited relevance is that recognition of self as human (or not) is entirely different (in terms of causes/mechanisms/ consequences) from recognition of self as male and female. One tells you almost nothing about the other

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 13:44

Shortshriftandlethal · 04/11/2026 13:42

What i find most curious is why a woman would reject her own sex so much that she would put in so much time eand energy into arguing that some male people should be considered female and given access to the facilities and services set aside for the dignity and protection of women and girls?

Why would a woman ( and a mother?) do that? What is it that she could be so invested in and why? Unless, she herself, was trans identifying and using male pronouns, maybe?

Edited

There’s a small care literature on trans people with dementia (Marshall et al., 2015; Baril and Silverman, 2019). What it describes is loss of autobiographical memory — people who don’t remember transitioning and are distressed by being treated as someone they don’t recall becoming, the way people with dementia forget marriages and children. That’s memory, not proprioception. The one study that actually tested your proprioceptive claim found the opposite: trans women after genital surgery report phantom penises at about half the rate of cis men after penectomy for cancer (Ramachandran and McGeoch, 2008). If the body model “knew” there should be a penis, it would be the other way round.

Rockyroadminibites · 04/11/2026 13:45

spannasaurus · 04/11/2026 13:39

The only time the sex of a baby would be assigned instead of simply being observed would be where the sex of that baby is unclear due to a DSD. The doctors determining the sex of that baby would be checking gametes amongst other things

And even that is historical or only in places without access to modern facilities.

Shortshriftandlethal · 04/11/2026 13:46

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 13:42

Sure and that's the very limited relevance I was referring to.

The reason it's of very limited relevance is that recognition of self as human (or not) is entirely different (in terms of causes/mechanisms/ consequences) from recognition of self as male and female. One tells you almost nothing about the other

I don't think there is any difference between recognising oneself as human and recognising oneself as the sex one is. In both cases the recognition process reflects the reality as it commonly understood.

There are people, of course, who 'identify as' animals or as spirit beings etc They are wrong, of course. Their 'recognition' does not reflect the reality.

Rockyroadminibites · 04/11/2026 13:48

Being deluded as to your sex, species, or ability to fly doesn’t change reality.

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 13:52

Shortshriftandlethal · 04/11/2026 13:46

I don't think there is any difference between recognising oneself as human and recognising oneself as the sex one is. In both cases the recognition process reflects the reality as it commonly understood.

There are people, of course, who 'identify as' animals or as spirit beings etc They are wrong, of course. Their 'recognition' does not reflect the reality.

Edited

You’ve just asserted that a child who thinks he’s a dog and a child who says she’s a girl are the same kind of case. On what basis? What’s the evidence that recognising yourself as a species and recognising yourself as a sex involve the same process? You’ve said “of course” twice, but it couldn’t be less obvious, since sex and species are entirely different things. I might as well say that because a child who thinks he can fly is wrong, a child who says he’s struggling to see must be wrong too.
Makes no sense at all.

Shortshriftandlethal · 04/11/2026 13:54

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 13:44

There’s a small care literature on trans people with dementia (Marshall et al., 2015; Baril and Silverman, 2019). What it describes is loss of autobiographical memory — people who don’t remember transitioning and are distressed by being treated as someone they don’t recall becoming, the way people with dementia forget marriages and children. That’s memory, not proprioception. The one study that actually tested your proprioceptive claim found the opposite: trans women after genital surgery report phantom penises at about half the rate of cis men after penectomy for cancer (Ramachandran and McGeoch, 2008). If the body model “knew” there should be a penis, it would be the other way round.

Which all goes to show that what an individual person 'recognises' has no bearing on objective reality. It either reflects reality or it doesn't. When a person's recognition of reality or everyday events fails it signals a deterioration of cognitive function. The person's senses become detached or removed from normal everyday functioning and patterns of recognition ( My father has dementia which has accelerated quite drastically recently)

All that the penectomy cases show is how strong a part emotion and imagination plays in identity formation. But 'identity' is not the exact same thing as shared and commonly understood reality. 'Identity' is just how we recognise ourselves and centre ourselves - and is a very personal matter.

DialSquare · 04/11/2026 13:57

Shortshriftandlethal · 04/11/2026 13:42

What i find most curious is why a woman would reject her own sex so much that she would put in so much time eand energy into arguing that some male people should be considered female and given access to the facilities and services set aside for the dignity and protection of women and girls?

Why would a woman ( and a mother?) do that? What is it that she could be so invested in and why? Unless, she herself, was trans identifying and using male pronouns, maybe?

Edited

Or maybe one of the babies is “trans”.

DrSpartacularsMagnificentOctopus · 04/11/2026 13:57

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 13:44

There’s a small care literature on trans people with dementia (Marshall et al., 2015; Baril and Silverman, 2019). What it describes is loss of autobiographical memory — people who don’t remember transitioning and are distressed by being treated as someone they don’t recall becoming, the way people with dementia forget marriages and children. That’s memory, not proprioception. The one study that actually tested your proprioceptive claim found the opposite: trans women after genital surgery report phantom penises at about half the rate of cis men after penectomy for cancer (Ramachandran and McGeoch, 2008). If the body model “knew” there should be a penis, it would be the other way round.

But don't these studies contradict each other?

If trans dementia patients are forgetting they've been through surgery doesn't that undermine the idea that their brain has always considered them to be the opposite sex? If surgery is merely "correcting" their body then surely that would not cause dissonance later on?

Totallygripped · 04/11/2026 13:58

Shortshriftandlethal · 04/11/2026 13:42

What i find most curious is why a woman would reject her own sex so much that she would put in so much time eand energy into arguing that some male people should be considered female and given access to the facilities and services set aside for the dignity and protection of women and girls?

Why would a woman ( and a mother?) do that? What is it that she could be so invested in and why? Unless, she herself, was trans identifying and using male pronouns, maybe?

Edited

I share that curiosity.
And were the babies little girls or boys or is that still up for debate? Honestly I am delighted if anyone has had a healthy pregnancy and a healthy baby but I just don't get all the effort to argue that black is white.

Shortshriftandlethal · 04/11/2026 14:02

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 13:52

You’ve just asserted that a child who thinks he’s a dog and a child who says she’s a girl are the same kind of case. On what basis? What’s the evidence that recognising yourself as a species and recognising yourself as a sex involve the same process? You’ve said “of course” twice, but it couldn’t be less obvious, since sex and species are entirely different things. I might as well say that because a child who thinks he can fly is wrong, a child who says he’s struggling to see must be wrong too.
Makes no sense at all.

My granddaughter has a couple of friends who are currently 'identifying as' 'furrians' - one as a pole cat. They spend time practising their movements and creating a new language, and they perform upset when people don't recognise them as what they say they are. They are 11 years of age, almost 12....at secondary school.

All species are divided into two sexes because sex is a fundamental orgainsational category - certainly in all mammalian life forms. A boy who says he is a girl is as wrong as a girl who says she is a pole cat.

DrSpartacularsMagnificentOctopus · 04/11/2026 14:04

Shortshriftandlethal · 04/11/2026 14:02

My granddaughter has a couple of friends who are currently 'identifying as' 'furrians' - one as a pole cat. They spend time practising their movements and creating a new language, and they perform upset when people don't recognise them as what they say they are. They are 11 years of age, almost 12....at secondary school.

All species are divided into two sexes because sex is a fundamental orgainsational category - certainly in all mammalian life forms. A boy who says he is a girl is as wrong as a girl who says she is a pole cat.

Exactly.

None of the obfuscatory guff matters (and I need to stop engaging with it!).

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 14:06

DrSpartacularsMagnificentOctopus · 04/11/2026 13:57

But don't these studies contradict each other?

If trans dementia patients are forgetting they've been through surgery doesn't that undermine the idea that their brain has always considered them to be the opposite sex? If surgery is merely "correcting" their body then surely that would not cause dissonance later on?

They could be seen to contradict each other if the dementia reports showed distress at the altered body, but they don’t. What the handful of cases describe is loss of autobiographical memory: people who don’t remember transitioning, revert to an earlier name, and are confused by a present they can’t connect to the past they recall. That’s a memory phenomenon — the same thing happens when a man with dementia doesn’t recognise his wife. It's not a report about the body schema which is what the studies about phantom penises are exploring.

And two broader caveats that apply here:

First all these studies are very small, isolated exploratory pieces of research - they haven't been widely replicated.

Second - dementia disrupts self-recognition generally - people often lose the ability to recognise their own face in the mirror for example, so dementia cases can’t really settle anything about the body model in a healthy brain either way.

Shortshriftandlethal · 04/11/2026 14:06

DialSquare · 04/11/2026 13:57

Or maybe one of the babies is “trans”.

Dr Sam Hall "gestated" three pregnancies. Using the word 'gestated' seems very detached, or certainaly wanting to detach from the usual terms associated with pregnancy and motherhood.

DialSquare · 04/11/2026 14:07

Shortshriftandlethal · 04/11/2026 14:06

Dr Sam Hall "gestated" three pregnancies. Using the word 'gestated' seems very detached, or certainaly wanting to detach from the usual terms associated with pregnancy and motherhood.

Good point

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 14:13

Shortshriftandlethal · 04/11/2026 14:02

My granddaughter has a couple of friends who are currently 'identifying as' 'furrians' - one as a pole cat. They spend time practising their movements and creating a new language, and they perform upset when people don't recognise them as what they say they are. They are 11 years of age, almost 12....at secondary school.

All species are divided into two sexes because sex is a fundamental orgainsational category - certainly in all mammalian life forms. A boy who says he is a girl is as wrong as a girl who says she is a pole cat.

An anecdote about eleven-year-olds playing doesn’t make pretending to be an animal the same as being trans. It manifestly isn’t.

“Sex is a fundamental category” is true, and beside the point: the question is whether a child’s own sense of their sex can diverge from their sex recorded at birth. It categorically can and does, whether you like it or not. None of this has anything to do with your grandchildren playing furies.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread