Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Sandie Peggie has lost her case against the nursing union.

1000 replies

RhannionKPSS · 02/11/2026 15:33

Terrible news

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Rockyroadminibites · 04/11/2026 12:36

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 12:31

A string of replies full of wrong and overly-simplified assumptions. It's hard to know where to start!

Go on, give it a go… we are all ears!

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 12:44

StealthTroublemaker · 04/11/2026 11:54

It’d be even dafter if their only criteria for their surrogate was a “transwoman”. Don’t think they’d get a baby….

Yes of course that would be extremely daft.

The relevant criterion is being able to gestate a baby.
There's no need to get distracted by being outraged about trans people.

Rockyroadminibites · 04/11/2026 12:47

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 12:44

Yes of course that would be extremely daft.

The relevant criterion is being able to gestate a baby.
There's no need to get distracted by being outraged about trans people.

But you have not explained why men who identify as women could not gestate a baby…

Soontobe60 · 04/11/2026 12:50

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 12:31

A string of replies full of wrong and overly-simplified assumptions. It's hard to know where to start!

Maybe try Reddit?

Shortshriftandlethal · 04/11/2026 12:54

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 12:31

A string of replies full of wrong and overly-simplified assumptions. It's hard to know where to start!

Don't bother, then. Your are not female, this is clear. I know of no trans identified women who would go to such lengths in this way, and on a forum full of men, to insist to then she was a man or that she knew better than they did about what being male was.

Shortshriftandlethal · 04/11/2026 12:56

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 12:44

Yes of course that would be extremely daft.

The relevant criterion is being able to gestate a baby.
There's no need to get distracted by being outraged about trans people.

Nobody is " outraged" they are simply, and firmly, calling time on this nonsense.

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 12:59

Rockyroadminibites · 04/11/2026 12:36

Go on, give it a go… we are all ears!

Sure, I'll start with this:

"Sex doesn’t ‘develop in a person’; it is set at the moment of conception. The brain doesn’t ’read the body’; it is part of the body. A girl born with anencephaly is still a girl (though will never live to become a woman)."

Conception sets the chromosomes, not the result — gonads, genitals, hormones and brain all develop later and don’t always follow them, which is why some XY people have female bodies.

The brain being part of the body doesn’t stop it representing the body; that’s what proprioception is, and why amputees feel limbs they no longer have.

And yes, a baby without a brain can be classified female by anatomy — the classification being made by someone else’s brain :) — nobody disputes that. Everyone gets assigned a sex by others. For those of us with a brain, that assignment doesn’t always match the sex we recognise ourselves to be.

DialSquare · 04/11/2026 12:59

So a female baby who is born with severe brain disabilities and will never understand she is female, is not female then? What a load of bollocks.

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 13:01

Shortshriftandlethal · 04/11/2026 12:54

Don't bother, then. Your are not female, this is clear. I know of no trans identified women who would go to such lengths in this way, and on a forum full of men, to insist to then she was a man or that she knew better than they did about what being male was.

*You're.

I am female and have gestated several babies.

It's very weird that you believe you can reliably tell what sex I am based on my contributions to an online discussion.

Signalbox · 04/11/2026 13:04

💪 SP is going to appeal.

Sandie Peggie has lost her case against the nursing union.
Lacksie · 04/11/2026 13:05

DialSquare · 04/11/2026 12:59

So a female baby who is born with severe brain disabilities and will never understand she is female, is not female then? What a load of bollocks.

No one said she isn’t. She’s female by every observable measure, and nobody’s disputing it.

The point is the one your example proves: being classified female and recognising yourself as female are two different things, and the first can happen without the second.

What your example can’t tell you is what to make of the person in whom the second (self recognition) is present and disagrees with the first (classification by others).

Rockyroadminibites · 04/11/2026 13:11

Conception sets the chromosomes, not the result — gonads, genitals, hormones and brain all develop later and don’t always follow them, which is why some XY people have female bodies.

What is it with TRAs only being able to go down to the level of karyotype? The role of genes was identified in the 19th Century and the structure of DNA identifies seventy years ago. Genes on Chromosomes are set at conception, and genes determine sex. Yes we do follow genes, including where the Y chromosome is missing the SRY gene.

Shedmistress · 04/11/2026 13:13

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 12:31

A string of replies full of wrong and overly-simplified assumptions. It's hard to know where to start!

It seems like you are starting at the end which is 'how many different arguments can I make to get men into women's single sex spaces'?

Rockyroadminibites · 04/11/2026 13:15

The brain being part of the body doesn’t stop it representing the body; that’s what proprioception is, and why amputees feel limbs they no longer have.

Proprioception is one of the eight senses. It is about being able to identify where your body is in space so you can eg touch your nose with your eyes shut. It is no more ‘representing you body’ than the sense of smell is.

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 13:18

Rockyroadminibites · 04/11/2026 13:11

Conception sets the chromosomes, not the result — gonads, genitals, hormones and brain all develop later and don’t always follow them, which is why some XY people have female bodies.

What is it with TRAs only being able to go down to the level of karyotype? The role of genes was identified in the 19th Century and the structure of DNA identifies seventy years ago. Genes on Chromosomes are set at conception, and genes determine sex. Yes we do follow genes, including where the Y chromosome is missing the SRY gene.

You’ve just made my argument for me. You’ve moved from chromosomes to genes, because a Y without SRY gives you a female phenotype — so you’re already following not the karyotype but what the genes do. Keep going. SRY starts the process; whether the body then masculinises depends on two dozen more genes, hormones and receptors acting over months. What’s set at conception is the recipe, not the result. “Genes determine sex” is true in the way “genes determine height” is true — through a development, with an outcome that isn’t readable at the start. And in practice most babies are sex by their genes - and certainly not for most of history; the sex on the birth certificate is almost always anatomy, observed. So your definition isn’t what anyone uses, including you.

DialSquare · 04/11/2026 13:20

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 13:05

No one said she isn’t. She’s female by every observable measure, and nobody’s disputing it.

The point is the one your example proves: being classified female and recognising yourself as female are two different things, and the first can happen without the second.

What your example can’t tell you is what to make of the person in whom the second (self recognition) is present and disagrees with the first (classification by others).

Another load of word salad. Humans are either male or female. A male can recognise himself as the sugarplum fairy for all it matters. He is, and always will be male.
As I asked a long time ago on this thread, why do you not give a shit about the women who will self exclude from their own spaces due to people like you promoting the erosion of their single sex provision?

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 13:20

Rockyroadminibites · 04/11/2026 13:15

The brain being part of the body doesn’t stop it representing the body; that’s what proprioception is, and why amputees feel limbs they no longer have.

Proprioception is one of the eight senses. It is about being able to identify where your body is in space so you can eg touch your nose with your eyes shut. It is no more ‘representing you body’ than the sense of smell is.

That’s what representing is. To touch your nose with your eyes shut, your brain must hold a model of where your arm and face are; proprioception is that model. The proof that the body model is a model and not a direct readout is that it can come apart from the body - amputees feel limbs that are no longer there. Neurologists have called this the body schema since 1911.

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 13:21

DialSquare · 04/11/2026 13:20

Another load of word salad. Humans are either male or female. A male can recognise himself as the sugarplum fairy for all it matters. He is, and always will be male.
As I asked a long time ago on this thread, why do you not give a shit about the women who will self exclude from their own spaces due to people like you promoting the erosion of their single sex provision?

Another load of word salad. Humans are either male or female. A male can recognise himself as the sugarplum fairy for all it matters. He is, and always will be male.

Thank you for your thoughtful and substantive contribution to the discussion.

DialSquare · 04/11/2026 13:22

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 13:21

Another load of word salad. Humans are either male or female. A male can recognise himself as the sugarplum fairy for all it matters. He is, and always will be male.

Thank you for your thoughtful and substantive contribution to the discussion.

You’re welcome. So about those women I mentioned?

Mollyollydolly · 04/11/2026 13:23

I'm so pleased she's appealing. It's hard to overestimate the effect it must all have had on her and her family over the last few years. Such tenacity and bravery. And she's doing it for all of us. Bravo.

ScrollingLeaves · 04/11/2026 13:25

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 13:05

No one said she isn’t. She’s female by every observable measure, and nobody’s disputing it.

The point is the one your example proves: being classified female and recognising yourself as female are two different things, and the first can happen without the second.

What your example can’t tell you is what to make of the person in whom the second (self recognition) is present and disagrees with the first (classification by others).

what to make of the person in whom the second (self recognition) is present and disagrees with the first (classification by others).

Your words made me think of feral children.
This interesting article is about some, beginning with a child who spent a long time living with dogs.
https://allthatsinteresting.com/oxana-malaya

When she was born and thought to be a human baby, I wouldn’t just think of that as being an arbitrary classification. I suppose it could have been widened to ‘baby animal’ though.

She evidently developed self-recognition as a dog. Later, after intervention, she did not fit in with humans very well, and looked after animals, but seems not to have believed she was one by then.

The Shocking Story Of Oxana Malaya, The Feral Child Who Lived With Dogs For Five Years

After she was abandoned by her parents, Oxana Malaya lived with a pack of dogs and picked up some peculiar dog-like behaviors.

https://allthatsinteresting.com/oxana-malaya

Rockyroadminibites · 04/11/2026 13:28

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 13:18

You’ve just made my argument for me. You’ve moved from chromosomes to genes, because a Y without SRY gives you a female phenotype — so you’re already following not the karyotype but what the genes do. Keep going. SRY starts the process; whether the body then masculinises depends on two dozen more genes, hormones and receptors acting over months. What’s set at conception is the recipe, not the result. “Genes determine sex” is true in the way “genes determine height” is true — through a development, with an outcome that isn’t readable at the start. And in practice most babies are sex by their genes - and certainly not for most of history; the sex on the birth certificate is almost always anatomy, observed. So your definition isn’t what anyone uses, including you.

Why would I follow karyotype? You were the one who introduced chromosomes. Genes ALWAYS determine sex. Sex is DEFINED by gametes. You talk of hormone receptors as if hormone receptors are not also determined by genes…

Observation of babies at birth is incredible accurate in determining sex. Very rarely is further testing required and where it is it is unlikely to be karyotyping when full genome sequencing is so readily available,

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 13:28

ScrollingLeaves · 04/11/2026 13:25

what to make of the person in whom the second (self recognition) is present and disagrees with the first (classification by others).

Your words made me think of feral children.
This interesting article is about some, beginning with a child who spent a long time living with dogs.
https://allthatsinteresting.com/oxana-malaya

When she was born and thought to be a human baby, I wouldn’t just think of that as being an arbitrary classification. I suppose it could have been widened to ‘baby animal’ though.

She evidently developed self-recognition as a dog. Later, after intervention, she did not fit in with humans very well, and looked after animals, but seems not to have believed she was one by then.

Fascinating, however the relevance to the current discussion is very limited.

Rockyroadminibites · 04/11/2026 13:29

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 13:20

That’s what representing is. To touch your nose with your eyes shut, your brain must hold a model of where your arm and face are; proprioception is that model. The proof that the body model is a model and not a direct readout is that it can come apart from the body - amputees feel limbs that are no longer there. Neurologists have called this the body schema since 1911.

But courgettes are still male or female.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread