Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Sandie Peggie has lost her case against the nursing union.

1000 replies

RhannionKPSS · 02/11/2026 15:33

Terrible news

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
StealthTroublemaker · 04/11/2026 07:33

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Soontobe60 · 04/11/2026 08:15

alcovecupboards · 02/11/2026 22:38

I spend very little time here. Perhaps you mistake your own posting and reading time as someone else's?

You spent over 8 hours on this board from approx 3.30pm to 11.30pm in one day on this board. That’s pretty much a full working day with people whom you just want to argue.
Maybe take up crocheting?

Soontobe60 · 04/11/2026 08:17

Lacksie · 03/11/2026 14:29

Of course biological parents are real - no one said otherwise. The point is that a term becomes a dog whistle through what the speaker is doing with it.

If the term ‘biological parent’ were being deployed for the purposes of claiming some parents (e.g. adoptive parents) aren’t REAL parents, it would be reasonable to call the use of the term, in that context, a nebulous dog whistle.

Edited

The term ‘biological parent’ is used to differentiate between a parent who has a biological connection to someone and a parent who doesn’t.

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 04/11/2026 08:31

alcovecupboards · 02/11/2026 22:38

I spend very little time here. Perhaps you mistake your own posting and reading time as someone else's?

You have been using this username for less than two months & have made more than 1,300 posts. That's over twenty posts a day. You are one of the most prolific posters on MN.

MarieDeGournay · 04/11/2026 09:16

Lacksie · 03/11/2026 13:53

Phewweeee . Look at how many assumptions are packed into that:

  1. That there is one clear, consistent, scientific definition of woman/female. Which one — chromosomes, gametes, gonads, hormones, anatomy? They don’t always agree.
  1. That being verifiable makes a definition “more true” than another. But plenty of definitions are verifiable — chromosomes, gonads, birth certificate, legal sex — and they don’t all pick out the same people. If verifiability were the test, they’d all be equally “true”. So how does that make any sense?
  1. That your definition of the word "woman" is the only one that counts. This is the entire dispute. Why have you assumed the answer?
  1. That every alternative definition lacks clarity and consistency. Have you examined them? Demonstrate why.
  1. That the definition is “established” and there is consensus. If so, why is it in front of the Supreme Court, Parliament and the tribunals? A definition under active legal dispute is contested, not established.
  1. That "works fine for the majority" is the definitive test of the value of a definition. Every exclusion works fine for the people it doesn’t exclude.
  1. That majority usage settles meaning, but minority usage doesn’t count. Which is it? Every change in a word’s meaning started with a minority using it differently. Also you haven't established that your definition is the "majority" one - you've just asserted it.
  1. That a group being “very small” reduces the weight of its interests. Where did that principle come from?
  1. That disputing what a word covers is “post-factual.” Which fact has anyone denied?
  1. That using language more inclusively than you want to use it is “disproportionate.” Disproportionate to what? You haven’t named a single cost to the majority.

  2. “I believe that makes it unfair and unacceptable” — so the conclusion rests on your belief. Which is where we started.

Thank you for the detailed reply, Lacksie.

I'm going to post a response over on the new Mechanisms of biological sex and the social consequences thereof | Mumsnet thread.
Sometime.. soon, it's a very busy morningSmile

Rockyroadminibites · 04/11/2026 09:25

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 06:33

It seems to me that their criteria would be that the woman should be fertile . Which would rule out a huge proportion of women.

If they were so transphobic that their only criteria were "I want a REAL (not trans) woman", they'd be making a really very basic error lol. Luckily I don't think most are that naive/ daft.

Many men who identify as women are fertile. So does that make them a suitable surrogate for a gay couple?

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 09:34

Soontobe60 · 04/11/2026 08:17

The term ‘biological parent’ is used to differentiate between a parent who has a biological connection to someone and a parent who doesn’t.

No one said otherwise, so your point is what?

Soontobe60 · 04/11/2026 10:06

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 09:34

No one said otherwise, so your point is what?

Your responses indicate that you appear to have trouble understanding basic things - I find it useful to state the bleedin’ obvious to people who fall into the same category…

SidewaysOtter · 04/11/2026 10:11

According to the Darlington Nurses Union, Peggie is appealing. Good for her.

ArabellaScott · 04/11/2026 10:19

SidewaysOtter · 04/11/2026 10:11

According to the Darlington Nurses Union, Peggie is appealing. Good for her.

Admirable tenacity.

BettyBooper · 04/11/2026 10:35

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 06:33

It seems to me that their criteria would be that the woman should be fertile . Which would rule out a huge proportion of women.

If they were so transphobic that their only criteria were "I want a REAL (not trans) woman", they'd be making a really very basic error lol. Luckily I don't think most are that naive/ daft.

It seems to me that their criteria would be that the woman should be fertile

The 'woman'? What does this word mean in this context? Does it include fertile TiM? If not, why not?🤔

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 11:03

Rockyroadminibites · 04/11/2026 09:25

Many men who identify as women are fertile. So does that make them a suitable surrogate for a gay couple?

You're right I should have been more precise in my language. And fertile wouldn't cover it anyway.
The criterion is quite obviously capable of gestating a baby.
The point, however, is the same.
If the couple's only criterion was REAL (not trans) woman, they would be very daft indeed.

Shortshriftandlethal · 04/11/2026 11:05

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 06:33

It seems to me that their criteria would be that the woman should be fertile . Which would rule out a huge proportion of women.

If they were so transphobic that their only criteria were "I want a REAL (not trans) woman", they'd be making a really very basic error lol. Luckily I don't think most are that naive/ daft.

A woman is an adult human female....not a figment or creation of an individiual's imagination.

Shedmistress · 04/11/2026 11:06

None of this has anything to do with Sandie Peggie.

Shortshriftandlethal · 04/11/2026 11:07

Shedmistress · 04/11/2026 11:06

None of this has anything to do with Sandie Peggie.

I see she is appealing the decision. She has to.

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 11:16

Shortshriftandlethal · 04/11/2026 11:05

A woman is an adult human female....not a figment or creation of an individiual's imagination.

Not a figment — a construction in the brain, which is a different thing. Nobody has direct access to their own sex; you know yours because your brain recognised it, developmentally, long before you knew what a gamete was. That recognition is part of how sex develops in a person, not an alternative to it. ‘Adult human female’ assumes the body speaks for itself. It doesn’t; a brain has to read it, and that reading is where ‘woman’ lives.

Rockyroadminibites · 04/11/2026 11:22

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 11:03

You're right I should have been more precise in my language. And fertile wouldn't cover it anyway.
The criterion is quite obviously capable of gestating a baby.
The point, however, is the same.
If the couple's only criterion was REAL (not trans) woman, they would be very daft indeed.

Edited

So what is it about men who identify as women that stops them being able to gestate babies?

Soontobe60 · 04/11/2026 11:24

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 11:16

Not a figment — a construction in the brain, which is a different thing. Nobody has direct access to their own sex; you know yours because your brain recognised it, developmentally, long before you knew what a gamete was. That recognition is part of how sex develops in a person, not an alternative to it. ‘Adult human female’ assumes the body speaks for itself. It doesn’t; a brain has to read it, and that reading is where ‘woman’ lives.

Oh dear…

Totallygripped · 04/11/2026 11:27

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 11:16

Not a figment — a construction in the brain, which is a different thing. Nobody has direct access to their own sex; you know yours because your brain recognised it, developmentally, long before you knew what a gamete was. That recognition is part of how sex develops in a person, not an alternative to it. ‘Adult human female’ assumes the body speaks for itself. It doesn’t; a brain has to read it, and that reading is where ‘woman’ lives.

I have no idea what "nobody has direct access to their own sex" means. Nor i suspect would 99.99% of the general population.

Rockyroadminibites · 04/11/2026 11:32

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 11:16

Not a figment — a construction in the brain, which is a different thing. Nobody has direct access to their own sex; you know yours because your brain recognised it, developmentally, long before you knew what a gamete was. That recognition is part of how sex develops in a person, not an alternative to it. ‘Adult human female’ assumes the body speaks for itself. It doesn’t; a brain has to read it, and that reading is where ‘woman’ lives.

Sex doesn’t ‘develop in a person’; it is set at the moment of conception. The brain doesn’t ’read the body’; it is part of the body. A girl born with anencephaly is still a girl (though will never live to become a woman).

DrSpartacularsMagnificentOctopus · 04/11/2026 11:43

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 11:16

Not a figment — a construction in the brain, which is a different thing. Nobody has direct access to their own sex; you know yours because your brain recognised it, developmentally, long before you knew what a gamete was. That recognition is part of how sex develops in a person, not an alternative to it. ‘Adult human female’ assumes the body speaks for itself. It doesn’t; a brain has to read it, and that reading is where ‘woman’ lives.

This makes no sense.

Our sex, ie our reproductive class, is independent of our knowing.

My brain doesn't need to recognise my sex, my sex just is. It was determined at conception and my thoughts on the matter are irrelevant.

Likewise, I do not need to know I am a human to be a human. I just am a human.

My cat doesn't know she's a cat, but she is a cat. Like me, her sex was also determined at conception. Like me, she doesn't need her brain to tell her she's female, she just is female.

StealthTroublemaker · 04/11/2026 11:54

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 11:03

You're right I should have been more precise in my language. And fertile wouldn't cover it anyway.
The criterion is quite obviously capable of gestating a baby.
The point, however, is the same.
If the couple's only criterion was REAL (not trans) woman, they would be very daft indeed.

Edited

It’d be even dafter if their only criteria for their surrogate was a “transwoman”. Don’t think they’d get a baby….

Shortshriftandlethal · 04/11/2026 12:20

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 11:16

Not a figment — a construction in the brain, which is a different thing. Nobody has direct access to their own sex; you know yours because your brain recognised it, developmentally, long before you knew what a gamete was. That recognition is part of how sex develops in a person, not an alternative to it. ‘Adult human female’ assumes the body speaks for itself. It doesn’t; a brain has to read it, and that reading is where ‘woman’ lives.

Construction/Creation....semantics.

If you are male you can only imagine what it is to be female ( a woman) because you are not. Being female is a biological category, not purely a mental one. The sooner you accept the nature of this reality the happier you'll be. If you are male then you will always be male. You cannot change sex.

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 12:31

A string of replies full of wrong and overly-simplified assumptions. It's hard to know where to start!

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread