Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Sandie Peggie has lost her case against the nursing union.

1000 replies

RhannionKPSS · 02/11/2026 15:33

Terrible news

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
FlirtsWithRhinos · 03/11/2026 18:30

Set up a breakout thread to move my derail elsewhere

www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5596067-mechanisms-of-biological-sex-and-the-social-consequences-thereof

Rockyroadminibites · 03/11/2026 18:36

And btw the production of large ‘gametes’ does not explain what makes a woman, unless you want to get seriously regressive here.

You think defining women just by their basic biology, where they can dress, behave and present how they wish and carry out any role, is regressive? I presume you think defining women by hair length, clothes, makeup, tits and ‘feminine feels’ is somehow progressive?

Lacksie · 03/11/2026 18:43

FlirtsWithRhinos · 03/11/2026 18:21

Your replies are trivial. And they undermine your case. As does silly tit for tat point scoring.

A fall is not gravity like a woman is not gametes - that is my point.

Just as one does not need to know the mechanisms of gravity to see its effect, one doesn't need to know the mechanisms of biological sex to see its effect. And my wording was "mechanisms of biological sex". Not "gametes". Mechanisms of biological sex.

Female humans exist. We are different physically to male humans. This is an observable fact. Female humans are in our language named "woman and girls".

For some reason, you want those words, and those words only, to name something else.

Fine.

But the reality of female people will continue to exist. And you have not made any case whatsoever for why the words that name us should be deployed elsewhere.

I have never made any objection to recognising and labelling whatever it is you think Gender is under its own name. Only to appropriating the existing language of sex. That is the case you need to make if you want to prove your beliefs are fair and reasonable. To stop looking only at trans identities and consider the bigger meaning, the human meaning.

And I have never ever seen an honest case for this made yet.

I see you want to continue the personal insults, so this will be the last of your posts that I read or respond to.

we agree on more than you think. Biological mechanisms exist, they have observable effects, female people exist and will go on existing, and all of that can be named. Nobody here has denied any of it, so it doesn't need defending.

What I don't accept is the step you keep skipping: that those mechanisms sort people cleanly into two kinds, and that 'woman' is simply the name for one of them. That's a classification, not an observation — you've already had to retreat from 'produces gametes' to 'mechanisms of biological sex' to keep it standing. And in practice 'woman' has never been applied by checking any of those mechanisms. It's applied by recognition — how someone lives, how they're seen, how they're treated. That's how you've been called a woman every day of your life, and nobody checked your gametes and few your genitals. Trans women are called women in exactly that way by the people who know them.

"The existing language of sex" is your framing, not a fact. The word has always been the language of recognition. And 'have your own word' isn't the neutral offer you try to make it sound like. If everyone else is a woman and trans women get a different word, the different word exists to mark them out. That's the exclusion, restated politely.

Datun · 03/11/2026 18:59

Lacksie · 03/11/2026 18:43

I see you want to continue the personal insults, so this will be the last of your posts that I read or respond to.

we agree on more than you think. Biological mechanisms exist, they have observable effects, female people exist and will go on existing, and all of that can be named. Nobody here has denied any of it, so it doesn't need defending.

What I don't accept is the step you keep skipping: that those mechanisms sort people cleanly into two kinds, and that 'woman' is simply the name for one of them. That's a classification, not an observation — you've already had to retreat from 'produces gametes' to 'mechanisms of biological sex' to keep it standing. And in practice 'woman' has never been applied by checking any of those mechanisms. It's applied by recognition — how someone lives, how they're seen, how they're treated. That's how you've been called a woman every day of your life, and nobody checked your gametes and few your genitals. Trans women are called women in exactly that way by the people who know them.

"The existing language of sex" is your framing, not a fact. The word has always been the language of recognition. And 'have your own word' isn't the neutral offer you try to make it sound like. If everyone else is a woman and trans women get a different word, the different word exists to mark them out. That's the exclusion, restated politely.

Edited

Oh for goodness sake. Gametes do determine sex. Not necessarily whether you produce them, but whether your body is organised around the production of small ones or large ones.

Someone disguising themself as the opposite sex is irrelevant to that classification.

And transwomen aren't called women because they look like women. Transwomen are called women because some people want to accommodate them. Or because some people are petrified of not doing it.

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 03/11/2026 19:03

Lacksie · 03/11/2026 18:43

I see you want to continue the personal insults, so this will be the last of your posts that I read or respond to.

we agree on more than you think. Biological mechanisms exist, they have observable effects, female people exist and will go on existing, and all of that can be named. Nobody here has denied any of it, so it doesn't need defending.

What I don't accept is the step you keep skipping: that those mechanisms sort people cleanly into two kinds, and that 'woman' is simply the name for one of them. That's a classification, not an observation — you've already had to retreat from 'produces gametes' to 'mechanisms of biological sex' to keep it standing. And in practice 'woman' has never been applied by checking any of those mechanisms. It's applied by recognition — how someone lives, how they're seen, how they're treated. That's how you've been called a woman every day of your life, and nobody checked your gametes and few your genitals. Trans women are called women in exactly that way by the people who know them.

"The existing language of sex" is your framing, not a fact. The word has always been the language of recognition. And 'have your own word' isn't the neutral offer you try to make it sound like. If everyone else is a woman and trans women get a different word, the different word exists to mark them out. That's the exclusion, restated politely.

Edited

‘It's applied by recognition — how someone lives, how they're seen, how they're treated. That's how you've been called a woman every day of your life, and nobody checked your gametes and few your genitals. Trans women are called women in exactly that way by the people who know them.’

No, it simply isn’t. You’re either born a woman or you’re not. You can dress it up all you like (pun intended) but humans are hard wired to tell which is which without checking gametes or genitals, no matter how you style your hair, how much make up you put on or what clothes you put on your body. It’s present through every cell in your body. Trans women aren’t women, or else they would just be…. Women! And you wouldn’t be on this forum arguing that they are. I’ve never had to argue the toss that I’m a woman and you have no idea how I present or what I wear or how I live my life.

Rockyroadminibites · 03/11/2026 19:04

Lacksie · 03/11/2026 18:43

I see you want to continue the personal insults, so this will be the last of your posts that I read or respond to.

we agree on more than you think. Biological mechanisms exist, they have observable effects, female people exist and will go on existing, and all of that can be named. Nobody here has denied any of it, so it doesn't need defending.

What I don't accept is the step you keep skipping: that those mechanisms sort people cleanly into two kinds, and that 'woman' is simply the name for one of them. That's a classification, not an observation — you've already had to retreat from 'produces gametes' to 'mechanisms of biological sex' to keep it standing. And in practice 'woman' has never been applied by checking any of those mechanisms. It's applied by recognition — how someone lives, how they're seen, how they're treated. That's how you've been called a woman every day of your life, and nobody checked your gametes and few your genitals. Trans women are called women in exactly that way by the people who know them.

"The existing language of sex" is your framing, not a fact. The word has always been the language of recognition. And 'have your own word' isn't the neutral offer you try to make it sound like. If everyone else is a woman and trans women get a different word, the different word exists to mark them out. That's the exclusion, restated politely.

Edited

You are still ignoring the fact that sex is a biological classification that is consistent across species. It is not unique to Homo sapiens.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 03/11/2026 19:24

Lacksie · 03/11/2026 18:43

I see you want to continue the personal insults, so this will be the last of your posts that I read or respond to.

we agree on more than you think. Biological mechanisms exist, they have observable effects, female people exist and will go on existing, and all of that can be named. Nobody here has denied any of it, so it doesn't need defending.

What I don't accept is the step you keep skipping: that those mechanisms sort people cleanly into two kinds, and that 'woman' is simply the name for one of them. That's a classification, not an observation — you've already had to retreat from 'produces gametes' to 'mechanisms of biological sex' to keep it standing. And in practice 'woman' has never been applied by checking any of those mechanisms. It's applied by recognition — how someone lives, how they're seen, how they're treated. That's how you've been called a woman every day of your life, and nobody checked your gametes and few your genitals. Trans women are called women in exactly that way by the people who know them.

"The existing language of sex" is your framing, not a fact. The word has always been the language of recognition. And 'have your own word' isn't the neutral offer you try to make it sound like. If everyone else is a woman and trans women get a different word, the different word exists to mark them out. That's the exclusion, restated politely.

Edited
  1. Stop accusing me of making "personal insults". I said your points are trivial, not you. Whether you chose to continue or not is entirely up to you. Claiming you want to have a conversation but are too hurt to continue is convincing no one.
  2. I have started a dedicated thread for this topic so as not to derail this one. Welcome to join us. I'll aim to include links to previous outings on the same topic too. https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5596067-mechanisms-of-biological-sex-and-the-social-consequences-thereof
  3. Oh dear, bad use of AI mate! I would be laughed out of the office for that! AI gives you what you want to hear but unevidenced assertions are still unevidenced even when AI wraps them in confident prose. If you want to repost that AI slop (again not insulting you, just the AI content you posted) on the new thread I'll happily demolish it for you.
Shortshriftandlethal · 03/11/2026 19:27

Lacksie · 03/11/2026 18:43

I see you want to continue the personal insults, so this will be the last of your posts that I read or respond to.

we agree on more than you think. Biological mechanisms exist, they have observable effects, female people exist and will go on existing, and all of that can be named. Nobody here has denied any of it, so it doesn't need defending.

What I don't accept is the step you keep skipping: that those mechanisms sort people cleanly into two kinds, and that 'woman' is simply the name for one of them. That's a classification, not an observation — you've already had to retreat from 'produces gametes' to 'mechanisms of biological sex' to keep it standing. And in practice 'woman' has never been applied by checking any of those mechanisms. It's applied by recognition — how someone lives, how they're seen, how they're treated. That's how you've been called a woman every day of your life, and nobody checked your gametes and few your genitals. Trans women are called women in exactly that way by the people who know them.

"The existing language of sex" is your framing, not a fact. The word has always been the language of recognition. And 'have your own word' isn't the neutral offer you try to make it sound like. If everyone else is a woman and trans women get a different word, the different word exists to mark them out. That's the exclusion, restated politely.

Edited

That's because women are female and 'transwomen' are male. 'Transwomen' are a category of 'male' not a category of female. Female is a biological category and 'woman' is the word we give to adult human females. Males are, by nature, excluded from the category of Female

StealthTroublemaker · 03/11/2026 19:32

Lacksie · 03/11/2026 17:10

The word ‘woman’ has never meant gametes. Pretending it has is reductive and false, however convenient it may be for you to claim it. Gametes are gametes; a woman is a person — not a snail, not a daffodil, a person. No one has ever decided whether someone is a woman by looking at their gametes. Plenty of women have no gametes at all. They’re still women.

The word ‘woman’ is over a thousand years old; gametes weren’t discovered until the 19th century.

So what is a woman? Without using sexist offensive stereotypes, nebulous feelings or the word woman, define woman…. I dare you.

StealthTroublemaker · 03/11/2026 19:33

Lacksie · 03/11/2026 18:43

I see you want to continue the personal insults, so this will be the last of your posts that I read or respond to.

we agree on more than you think. Biological mechanisms exist, they have observable effects, female people exist and will go on existing, and all of that can be named. Nobody here has denied any of it, so it doesn't need defending.

What I don't accept is the step you keep skipping: that those mechanisms sort people cleanly into two kinds, and that 'woman' is simply the name for one of them. That's a classification, not an observation — you've already had to retreat from 'produces gametes' to 'mechanisms of biological sex' to keep it standing. And in practice 'woman' has never been applied by checking any of those mechanisms. It's applied by recognition — how someone lives, how they're seen, how they're treated. That's how you've been called a woman every day of your life, and nobody checked your gametes and few your genitals. Trans women are called women in exactly that way by the people who know them.

"The existing language of sex" is your framing, not a fact. The word has always been the language of recognition. And 'have your own word' isn't the neutral offer you try to make it sound like. If everyone else is a woman and trans women get a different word, the different word exists to mark them out. That's the exclusion, restated politely.

Edited

Well yes, TIM would be excluded from the same group as women. As they are not women…. Hope this helps 🤣🤣🤣🤣

EmpressDomesticatednottamed · 03/11/2026 19:42

Perhaps a minor point but defining terms in context doesn't mean dragging in every context that can be thought of to bludgeon about and avoid the discipline of staying in one.
That's doing post-modernism wrong.

Also, certain terms describe ideas that do change in different contexts. Dissonance meant a very different thing in Gregorian chant, to Bach, to Stravinsky, and it's worth hashing that out in order to discuss it.
One cannot however argue that a trombone can be a flute because no matter what it's called when one blows down it it makes the sound of a trombone and can never sound like a flute. Oh and that's the sort of flute one usually sees in an orchestra, I could go into things like nose flutes but it stiil won't make them into trombones.

Anyone who sees the relevance of this post will see it, everyone else can ignore it, I really don't mind.

ScrollingLeaves · 03/11/2026 20:09

Lacksie · 03/11/2026 18:43

I see you want to continue the personal insults, so this will be the last of your posts that I read or respond to.

we agree on more than you think. Biological mechanisms exist, they have observable effects, female people exist and will go on existing, and all of that can be named. Nobody here has denied any of it, so it doesn't need defending.

What I don't accept is the step you keep skipping: that those mechanisms sort people cleanly into two kinds, and that 'woman' is simply the name for one of them. That's a classification, not an observation — you've already had to retreat from 'produces gametes' to 'mechanisms of biological sex' to keep it standing. And in practice 'woman' has never been applied by checking any of those mechanisms. It's applied by recognition — how someone lives, how they're seen, how they're treated. That's how you've been called a woman every day of your life, and nobody checked your gametes and few your genitals. Trans women are called women in exactly that way by the people who know them.

"The existing language of sex" is your framing, not a fact. The word has always been the language of recognition. And 'have your own word' isn't the neutral offer you try to make it sound like. If everyone else is a woman and trans women get a different word, the different word exists to mark them out. That's the exclusion, restated politely.

Edited

That's how you've been called a woman every day of your life, and nobody checked your gametes and few your genitals.

You are seeing such superficial aspects it is unbelievable.

When men ogle little pubescent girls and get hold of them for ‘marriage’ or rape, I can assure you they knew what sort of genitals they are getting hold of. The same goes for older ones.

And likewise, when a female human menstruating, pregnant, giving birth, lactating, going through the menopause their whole body and mind is involved in every possible way it can be.

Women are so obviously female to men that that’s why in some countries they shroud their bodies as voluminously and completely as possible to curb their urge towards them.

There was a case (15 years ago?) of an imam raping his four year old daughter then punishing her with torture. When he was apprehended some Saudi Arabian called for beautiful four year olds to be made to wear burkas.

Tell a transwoman to wear a burka . If a man really thought the TW was AW at first sight, he’d soon find out something else.

Catiette · 03/11/2026 20:19

Lacksie · 03/11/2026 12:32

Her feelings are valid. The question is whether they constitute a veto on where other people are allowed to be.
I’m not saying trans people’s boundaries trump women’s — that’s your reversal, not my claim.

A pp said ‘dignity and privacy are for everyone, whether you like them or not’. I questioned whether that applied to trans people. The answer was ‘yes, but only where women’s boundaries allow’. I asked whether trans people are afforded the same ‘boundaries’. And now you’ve reversed it and pointed the same question back at me!

Which rather proves the point doesn't it: this isn’t about boundaries, it’s about how to resolve competing interests in a shared space — and the answer to that can’t just be ‘because MY boundaries’.

Coming to this late, I'm aware, but this and the fact/opinion debate got me thinking.

So if it's a matter of "competing interests in a shared space" (which I agree it is, though I'd say "boundaries" form a part of the competing interests), then the next step's got to be to assess the relative merits of the opposing sides. And this means opinions, but... opinions are founded on facts. An opinion untethered from any material foundation, just floating free, can be such a dangerous thing.

Take the always-popular analogy of racial segregation, teetering precariously on the unfounded conviction that certain races are fundamentally inferior (intellectually, ethically, physically even). The friction of any empty construct like racism rubs up against the evidence - facts - of reality to generate a furious heat that's reflected in the ideological energy of its supporters. You'll always be frustrated trying to balance an impossible equation - and the harder you fight, the harder reality will fight back. If we take a positive view of the overall march of human history in this sense, the scales of justice tend to steady and rebalance over time. Black people, gay people and women aren't inferior, and reality won't support the narrative that they are.

But reality itself can change to obscure or expose a lie of inferiority. The mass casualties or WW1 and 2 created the necessity of a female workforce. The pill enabled the continuation and consolidation of women's success in the public sphere. The internet, on the other hand, has enabled the proliferation of degrading narratives previously confined to dusty top shelves.

Meanwhile, meaning-making shifts, too, often in reactive pendulum shifts - the Enlightenment segued into the Romantics... It feels ironic that we're leaving reason behind again right now, at the height of our scientific knowledge, but maybe that also makes a kind of sick sense. We've reached a point of sufficient privilege that we - in the affluent West, at least - are sufficiently cosseted from the limitations of our physical reality (we have food and shelter, and our bodies can be managed and mitigated to a greater degree than even before) that we at last have the time, space and freedom to choose to (believe we can) construct reality itself: post-modernism rulz OK. And why wouldn't we want to construct reality, after all? Consciousness - meaning-making - is what makes us human.

The truth, though, is that whatever we do or say, or think or believe, there will always remain an undeniable concrete reality that can't be changed, and it will always be a frightening one. We're all dying, women are physically weaker, the universe is hostile and indifferent. We can't change these facts, we can only pretend to. And the paradox is that the harder we pretend, the harder reality will bite back, and the more vulnerable to it we'll be. Global warming - the product of the mass delusion that we can keep living as comfortably as we are. Mass communication, reassuring us that we're connected even as we drift further apart. And, most cruelly of all, the more tech we have, the more vulnerable we are to escapist avoidance and physical catastrophe - ancient subsistence farmers would be far better equipped to face what's probably coming than humanity is now.

And that's where I see the difference between the respective pulls of the sex- and gender- based arguments. One is absolutely, indisputably concrete, while the other, while very real in a way - perception is everything in a sense; where would humans be without their own construction of reality? - must inevitably give way to the other. The pendulum swings back, the scales rebalance, and physical reality reasserts itself over the lie, however appealing that lie may be.

The tragedy is that a comforting narrative - of ass-kicking female superheroes, or TWAW, does better if it's less aggressively asserted, as it doesn't then generate the same strength of inevitable opposing force. Social constructs can rub along together quite nicely with minimal friction as long as they don't cut into each other, like the appropriately violent Progress flag chevron into gay and lesbian rights. This is complex, too - the MRA argument that, "You asked for equality, and you got it!" is a distortion of it, as the push and pull of gendered power dynamics continue. But when trans ideology seeks to cut up reality itself...?

Maslow had it down, really. The solid foundation of his pyramid of needs will always be there - the demands of our physical reality. Everything else built on top of it is precariously reliant on what's below.

So yes, I think sex supersedes gender. Regardless which way the winds of social constructs blow, the reality of facts, evidence, necessity, scale, and the laws of physics will endure.

Single sex spaces may be a construct, but whereas racial segregation is the product of empty prejudice, single-sex spaces acknowledge something true and necessary and entirely distinct from warped value judgements (at least outside the frightened noise of the manosphere).

Edited a bit on rereading after furious typing! 😅

Catiette · 03/11/2026 20:20

Sorry for the essay. Got a bit too much into thinking it all through and putting it into words!

Catiette · 03/11/2026 20:42

Just catching up, and the latter end of this post by Lacksie is exactly what I mean.

And in practice 'woman' has never been applied by checking any of those mechanisms. It's applied by recognition — how someone lives, how they're seen, how they're treated. That's how you've been called a woman every day of your life, and nobody checked your gametes and few your genitals. Trans women are called women in exactly that way by the people who know them.

"The existing language of sex" is your framing, not a fact. The word has always been the language of recognition. And 'have your own word' isn't the neutral offer you try to make it sound like. If everyone else is a woman and trans women get a different word, the different word exists to mark them out. That's the exclusion, restated politely.

Yes, we do indeed layer language on to reality, Lacksie. We're reliant on our perception to experience and process and name it, after all. But it endures regardless. Argue that the medium of human perception is sufficiently powerful to filter and reshape reality, by all means, but I'd counter that that's a luxurious illusion. And don't, in so doing, presume to remove our ability to recognise and name reality, as well. You can take our words - woman, in this case - but you can't take what they name, nor our right to be permitted to name this.

That's why, above all, I think the GC cause is the more ethical. Gender ideology at its most extreme is a theft of others' rights to perceive and speak objective truth about the physical world.

By all means, use another word, create another reality, invite others in or ask them to respect it. Do all that - it's plurality of belief, it's great! But deny something that will exist regardless of that denial, or deny others their right to unambiguously name and understand it, merely on the tenuous basis of we-see-therefore-it-is?

We're seeing how that ends - the backlash against the extremes of genderism is now clear, as reality bites back. Women are real, existing beyond a limiting ideological lens. That we all look through flawed lenses, with scope to make mistakes, doesn't change what's on the other side. To assert that it does is supremely arrogant. To acknowledge that it doesn't and yet insist on the corresponding invalidity of a signifier for something real, on the basis of flawed human "sight" is frankly ironic - the height of human hubris.

JanesLittleGirl · 03/11/2026 21:21

Bloody hell @Catiette. Please can I have one tenth of your ability to frame both the question and the answer?

overhare · 03/11/2026 22:34

Lacksie · 03/11/2026 12:32

Her feelings are valid. The question is whether they constitute a veto on where other people are allowed to be.
I’m not saying trans people’s boundaries trump women’s — that’s your reversal, not my claim.

A pp said ‘dignity and privacy are for everyone, whether you like them or not’. I questioned whether that applied to trans people. The answer was ‘yes, but only where women’s boundaries allow’. I asked whether trans people are afforded the same ‘boundaries’. And now you’ve reversed it and pointed the same question back at me!

Which rather proves the point doesn't it: this isn’t about boundaries, it’s about how to resolve competing interests in a shared space — and the answer to that can’t just be ‘because MY boundaries’.

You misrepresent me - I am the 'pp' you quote.

I never said, 'yes, but only where women's boundaries allow', so you shouldn't have put that in quote marks. What I said was, 'I'm sorry, but no. I still don't want them in female changing areas or toilets. The fears of many women outweigh those of a handful of men.'

When you accused me of saying that 'privacy and dignity are for everyone — except the handful whose bodies and identities don’t fit the majority norm', I clarified by saying that I had zero objection to there being male, female and unisex spaces.

So, no, I never said that trans people's rights to privacy and dignity are trumped by women's. I suggested a way in which everybody could be happy. But I still think that TWANW, and should stay out of women's spaces.

As I noted before, you do not seem to be arguing in good faith. You are so desperate to persuade us that we should allow to men into our spaces that you appear to be pretzeling yourself into believing that the category 'woman' isn't historically based on observed sex, but rather upon gender - what you term 'recognition', as if 'recognition' wasn't historically (well, until about 5 minutes ago) based on sex observed at birth, and later on the self-evident sexual characteristics that people develop as they mature.

Anyway, @Catiette has dealt far with your post than I can.

overhare · 03/11/2026 22:37

That's why, above all, I think the GC cause is the more ethical. Gender ideology at its most extreme is a theft of others' rights to perceive and speak objective truth about the physical world.
Spot on, @Catiette

Manxexile · 03/11/2026 23:49

StealthTroublemaker · 03/11/2026 19:32

So what is a woman? Without using sexist offensive stereotypes, nebulous feelings or the word woman, define woman…. I dare you.

I think I can confidently warrant that @Lacksie will not even attempt to give a definition of "woman".

Unless it's along the lines of "any person who identifies as one".

Manxexile · 04/11/2026 00:29

Lacksie · 03/11/2026 12:39

If it were being weaponised as a term to imply that some parents aren't REAL parents then absolutely hell to the yes.

Can anyone tell me what "... then absolutely hell to the yes." means here?

I'm a native english speaker and I think I'd take the phrasing "hell to something" to mean I was opposed to it whereas I think Lacksie means that he's in agreement with it...

Manxexile · 04/11/2026 00:58

Can anybody tell me whether when, for example, a gay couple want to have a child via surrogacy, do they opt for a transwoman to be the surrogate, or do they go for the more conventional, you know, actual real woman?

I can't help but think that the answer to that question might be of assistance in defining what a women is - and isn't...

Heggettypeg · 04/11/2026 01:05

I'd be very surprised if most people throughout history looked and saw what they thought was a woman, and then went on thinking "that's a woman" after discovering that the person's sex was male.

It's more likely that they would think (depending on the circumstances) either "Oh, I was mistaken" or "Oh, I was deceived".

In other words, an appearance of womanhood is not being taken to be womanhood, except by modern genderists. It is merely being trusted to indicate that womanhood is present. And of course, if people start finding that the trust is no longer justified ( e.g. because hormones and surgery make a visually plausible facsimile easier to achieve), they'll stop trusting appearances like they did.

Lacksie · 04/11/2026 06:33

Manxexile · 04/11/2026 00:58

Can anybody tell me whether when, for example, a gay couple want to have a child via surrogacy, do they opt for a transwoman to be the surrogate, or do they go for the more conventional, you know, actual real woman?

I can't help but think that the answer to that question might be of assistance in defining what a women is - and isn't...

It seems to me that their criteria would be that the woman should be fertile . Which would rule out a huge proportion of women.

If they were so transphobic that their only criteria were "I want a REAL (not trans) woman", they'd be making a really very basic error lol. Luckily I don't think most are that naive/ daft.

LinearALinearB · 04/11/2026 07:00

God, another day and more denial of reality word salad bollocks. Get a job, for fuck's sake.

LinearALinearB · 04/11/2026 07:04

I'm imagining the Titanic and the cry 'women and children first' (to the lifeboats).And then a filtering process before each person declaring themself a woman is allowed admittance to the lifeboat 'Hello person who says they are woman, do you have, or are you able to have children?' . That would have taken bloody ages, but according to our resident TRA would have totally been necessary.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.