Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think extra lessons for top students isn’t fair?

775 replies

Beepboobeep · 02/11/2026 21:12

My DD’s state primary school has a “top maths club” and “great writers club” for the top performing students in yr 5 and 6 held outside of school hours. There is no charge for this - so it’s free childcare and free tutoring. You have to be invited. This has been running since the second week of the school year and is restarting on the first day of this half term.

By contrast, my dyslexic DD is in a group for those needing more support in writing, also outside of school hours. But they only managed 2 sessions last year and it hasn’t started back up this year. She gets ad hoc in school support; where it happens she misses other lessons that aren’t then caught up on, putting her further behind in the those.

I appreciate these children deserve challenging, but surely that could be done in class with different work and the teacher’s out of hours time, if available, used to help those struggling?

Is this even allowed in a state primary?

OP posts:
Wonderfrau · 09/11/2026 13:35

poetryandwine · 09/11/2026 10:26

At least play fair and read OP’s posts properly. She is investing plenty of money and effort into extracurricular help for her DD.

This is great. It looks like the OP is in a position to afford any extra help DD might need. I’m guessing she must be doing that already, given she’s spending £500 per week. I’m not sure how much benefit one extra 45 minute after school club will add to DDs already extensive programme. Adaptive teaching, ensuring appropriate resources and scaffolding are likely to be most helpful to DD in school. OP would benefit from speaking to the class teacher about what that looks like for DD and whether it is happening.

OP said she wrote her daughter’s own plan, but it’s not clear whether this was agreed and adopted by the school. I fear it was not, since the SENDCo never prepared a plan themselves. Alternatively, the OP might just decide not to bother, as she has now decided to move her daughter to private school, perhaps after seeing her flounder and struggle for 6 years without adequate support? 😬

OP hasn’t come back to this post, so she could be a ‘shoot from the hip’ kind, a bit like myself, and just wanted to rant because she had a temporary weakness of jealousy, but has been able to reflect a little now. I am susceptible to similar myself, so no judgement here.

The school is unlikely to have any funding to provide more support than they currently do, as DD doesn’t have an EHCP.

poetryandwine · 09/11/2026 14:23

TillyGoat · 09/11/2026 11:25

If that along with the extra resources being poured into her child isn't enough to get them to the expected standard then perhaps it's time to look at special schools?!

How gracious of you to acknowledge ypur error.

poetryandwine · 09/11/2026 14:33

Wonderfrau · 09/11/2026 13:35

This is great. It looks like the OP is in a position to afford any extra help DD might need. I’m guessing she must be doing that already, given she’s spending £500 per week. I’m not sure how much benefit one extra 45 minute after school club will add to DDs already extensive programme. Adaptive teaching, ensuring appropriate resources and scaffolding are likely to be most helpful to DD in school. OP would benefit from speaking to the class teacher about what that looks like for DD and whether it is happening.

OP said she wrote her daughter’s own plan, but it’s not clear whether this was agreed and adopted by the school. I fear it was not, since the SENDCo never prepared a plan themselves. Alternatively, the OP might just decide not to bother, as she has now decided to move her daughter to private school, perhaps after seeing her flounder and struggle for 6 years without adequate support? 😬

OP hasn’t come back to this post, so she could be a ‘shoot from the hip’ kind, a bit like myself, and just wanted to rant because she had a temporary weakness of jealousy, but has been able to reflect a little now. I am susceptible to similar myself, so no judgement here.

The school is unlikely to have any funding to provide more support than they currently do, as DD doesn’t have an EHCP.

I agree completely with your first paragraph. The picture would be much clearer if we knew how much help the DD was receiving during the school day. I would expect any reasonable parent to acknowledge that help in setting up the story. I do know from the sad stories of friends and SEN students that the reality does not always match the promise, so I have been taken aback wondering how PP can be so certain of actual practices throughout the UK?

I think if the mandated provision is not happening, many parents would seethe whilst watching their DC flail whilst limited resources went towards helping others shine. Parity is the only good answer. Your recommendation is spot on.

Excellent post.

TillyGoat · 09/11/2026 15:32

poetryandwine · 09/11/2026 14:23

How gracious of you to acknowledge ypur error.

Thanks Admin

Valeriekat · 10/11/2026 05:43

Presumably the teachers are volunteering to do this. Like sports coaching, adults like helping children who are keen and talented (gifted perhaps).

Puffin69 · 10/11/2026 06:32

poetryandwine · 08/11/2026 09:42

Your hockey club sounds fantastic. Of course talent must be the key consideration in choosing children for a competition, whether for hockey or maths. But I am delighted that you did not exclude anyone otherwise, and I feel the same way about Maths Club which is less likely to be overwhelmed on the grounds of pupil passion.

Why do you sense OP wants free child care? She is already paying so much for external tuition, as are other parents, that I don’t think it is a major consideration at this school.

I think she is frustrated. She may or may not have all the facts. How much support her DD gets during the school day is an open question as is the purpose of the after school activity. OP could have put her case better.
Nevertheless there are at minimum open questions here.

I am also shocked by the (thankfully few) PP who seem to think that more able children are inherently more deserving, and fail to recognise the overlap between SEN and high ability.

Because she makes a point of mentioning free childcare in her post.

Didyousaynutella · 10/11/2026 06:38

Try being in the lost middle. The absolute worst place to be.

the7Vabo · 10/11/2026 07:19

Valeriekat · 10/11/2026 05:43

Presumably the teachers are volunteering to do this. Like sports coaching, adults like helping children who are keen and talented (gifted perhaps).

I always roll my eyes at the sheer number of people who claim they child is “gifted”.

And as for the horrible comment/s on this thread about children who won’t “amount to anything” - the only time I my life I have excelled has been in an academic environment. Outside of that I'm fairly average. So it’s perfectly possible that OP’s daughter will go on to do better in life than her “gifted” peers.

CloggedPores · 10/11/2026 07:46

the7Vabo · 10/11/2026 07:19

I always roll my eyes at the sheer number of people who claim they child is “gifted”.

And as for the horrible comment/s on this thread about children who won’t “amount to anything” - the only time I my life I have excelled has been in an academic environment. Outside of that I'm fairly average. So it’s perfectly possible that OP’s daughter will go on to do better in life than her “gifted” peers.

How will OPs daughter exceed if she struggles to read and write

BuildbyNumbere · 10/11/2026 07:48

Beepboobeep · 02/11/2026 21:22

My point is they are giving MORE time to those already getting full marks than those struggling.

We live in an area with two of the top grammar schools in the country (no catchment) and border two grammar areas where kids out of area have to get extremely high marks to get in to them. 70% of the kids will go to grammar from this school. They are already heavily tutored outside of school. When asked how they spent the summer it was in 11+ camp 5 days a week.

Why should they get more free teacher hours on top than children that need more support?

Why shouldn’t they … we all pay the same taxes! What makes your child more important? They’re struggling so get the priority do they? Maybe you should fund some private tutoring if you’re that concerned!! Sick of hearing about SEN kids being entitled to everything!!

BuildbyNumbere · 10/11/2026 07:51

Beepboobeep · 02/11/2026 21:38

Well we will shortly be moving her to a private school so yes, but why should children who get full marks get more free support than those that don’t? I’d be fine with it if they also gave support to those who need it.

Edited

Why shouldn’t they? They are entitled to as much additional support as your child!

Newname26 · 10/11/2026 07:55

CloggedPores · 10/11/2026 07:46

How will OPs daughter exceed if she struggles to read and write

Well we don't actually know what the daughter struggles with.

But I can tell you spell check ✔️ and Grammar checkers are wonderful things. Nobody hand writes anything these days so those tools can hide a million errors.

Word etc even has websearch which can be useful if you have two words and not quite sure which is correct. Like quite and quiet.

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · 10/11/2026 07:57

BuildbyNumbere · 10/11/2026 07:48

Why shouldn’t they … we all pay the same taxes! What makes your child more important? They’re struggling so get the priority do they? Maybe you should fund some private tutoring if you’re that concerned!! Sick of hearing about SEN kids being entitled to everything!!

You're sick about hearing about support for disabled children? Aren't you lovely!

the7Vabo · 10/11/2026 08:01

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · 10/11/2026 07:57

You're sick about hearing about support for disabled children? Aren't you lovely!

I’ve never heard anybody argue that kids struggling should not get extra support before this thread. It seems some people think they should be written-off, instead of being supported so that all childen leave the education system on a good footing.

CloggedPores · 10/11/2026 08:13

If you give the top kids extra who knows what heights they can reach. They are gonna be the future of this nation

the7Vabo · 10/11/2026 08:26

CloggedPores · 10/11/2026 08:13

If you give the top kids extra who knows what heights they can reach. They are gonna be the future of this nation

If they are genuinely that gifted they’ll be absolutely fine. And in my experience many of the top kids in my school did perfectly well, but they are not determining the future.

And as for some of the no doubt highly intelligent tech bros that have unfortunately determined our future, if they’d be taught the value of inclusion and helping others maybe the world would be in a better place.

poetryandwine · 10/11/2026 09:35

CloggedPores · 10/11/2026 07:46

How will OPs daughter exceed if she struggles to read and write

A significant percentage of renowned scientists, engineers and mathematicians are dyslexic.

poetryandwine · 10/11/2026 09:49

the7Vabo · 10/11/2026 08:26

If they are genuinely that gifted they’ll be absolutely fine. And in my experience many of the top kids in my school did perfectly well, but they are not determining the future.

And as for some of the no doubt highly intelligent tech bros that have unfortunately determined our future, if they’d be taught the value of inclusion and helping others maybe the world would be in a better place.

All of this. HMG discontinued the use of the phrase ‘gifted and talented’ back in 2010.

Ten years after graduation from a top STEM programme we see that graduates, almost all of whom would have been classified as G&T in earlier times, are all over the map. And many students who may have had less stellar intellectual gifts are starting to make big impacts on the world. We are much more than our IQs.

On the whole I would say those previously classified as G&T who are lucky enough to be admitted to degree programmes that provide good outcomes fare a bit better than reasonably able students admitted to somewhat less elite programmes. Everyone focuses on the high flyers from a small number of elite programmes who ‘go into the City’ but actually their percentages are very small and their failure rate is rather high. Parents who map out such a future forctheir progeny do them no favours.

poetryandwine · 10/11/2026 09:55

BuildbyNumbere · 10/11/2026 07:48

Why shouldn’t they … we all pay the same taxes! What makes your child more important? They’re struggling so get the priority do they? Maybe you should fund some private tutoring if you’re that concerned!! Sick of hearing about SEN kids being entitled to everything!!

Neither group should be prioritised at the expense of the other.

I will be interested to see where OP says her DD is more important than other children, if you can find it for me. Along the way you might come across her description of the considerable resources she already devotes to DD’s tutoring.

I hope this will make you feel better.

poetryandwine · 10/11/2026 09:58

BuildbyNumbere · 10/11/2026 07:51

Why shouldn’t they? They are entitled to as much additional support as your child!

Our view of the situation is murky, but OP’s issue is that these other children appear to be getting more.

poetryandwine · 10/11/2026 10:07

Puffin69 · 10/11/2026 06:32

Because she makes a point of mentioning free childcare in her post.

It’s relatively minor. I think @Wonderfrau characterised it well as a ‘shoot from the hip’ thing. OP was clearly upset. The comment was part of a bigger theme about prioritising able children.

Anneleesa · 10/11/2026 10:11

I have “one of each” - a dc16 who is effortlessly brilliant and aiming to become a doctor.

Being extremely bright is, in fact, identified as a SEN.

My dd’s SEN was unmet. She went to a state school that invested ALL its resources into trying to drag the kids at the bottom up to the middle. As a result - the few super bright kids most of year 6 staring out of the window. Dd would come home and say she spent her day planning what she’d do in the event of a zombie apocalypse. Or doodling or chatting and causing trouble with the “bad” kids. It hasn’t held her back in secondary school but she HATED her primary school and speaks of it now with more resentment than you can imagine; she describes it once as “a prison where the teachers ignored anyone who was doing okay and not throwing chairs round the classroom.”

My youngest is at a better and different school (for obvious reasons!) where the teaching is balanced. i agree with you OP that all needs should be met. I certainly wouldn’t want any child to go through what my dd went through. If the high ability clubs create space to focus on low ability SEN in class, great. Otherwise- complain to the governors.

CloggedPores · 10/11/2026 10:23

poetryandwine · 10/11/2026 09:35

A significant percentage of renowned scientists, engineers and mathematicians are dyslexic.

Yes but they eventually managed to learn to read and write didn't they

poetryandwine · 10/11/2026 10:25

CloggedPores · 10/11/2026 10:23

Yes but they eventually managed to learn to read and write didn't they

Are you implying that the intellectual abilities of OP’s DD and others whom you have never met preclude this?

Wendywoopp · 13/11/2026 17:24

Wadsworthy · 04/11/2026 18:40

This is why I think it's a pity that setting and streaming at secondary school have mostly been done away with. My secondary school (bog standard comprehensive) in the 1970s streamed us from 1st form onwards. We still had English, Maths and Science classes of up to 40 pupils, but at least if you were in the top set of your year, people put their heads down and worked, and the teachers could push us, quite hard, because we were supposedly the top pupils!

They still stream in my children’s secondary. However it does come with its own problems. The middle children are often not pushed enough, the bottom are either pushed as much as possible or given up on (depending on dynamics and behaviour) and a lot of attention is given to the higher set. It’s not a perfect system either but I think it makes more sense.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page