Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think extra lessons for top students isn’t fair?

775 replies

Beepboobeep · 02/11/2026 21:12

My DD’s state primary school has a “top maths club” and “great writers club” for the top performing students in yr 5 and 6 held outside of school hours. There is no charge for this - so it’s free childcare and free tutoring. You have to be invited. This has been running since the second week of the school year and is restarting on the first day of this half term.

By contrast, my dyslexic DD is in a group for those needing more support in writing, also outside of school hours. But they only managed 2 sessions last year and it hasn’t started back up this year. She gets ad hoc in school support; where it happens she misses other lessons that aren’t then caught up on, putting her further behind in the those.

I appreciate these children deserve challenging, but surely that could be done in class with different work and the teacher’s out of hours time, if available, used to help those struggling?

Is this even allowed in a state primary?

OP posts:
poetryandwine · 07/11/2026 23:03

Apotofrealcoffee · 07/11/2026 04:15

Nobody else is going to say it, so I’m going to.

Some ‘SEN’ parents are maddeningly entitled to the extent, as you can see from this thread, that empathy for their situation is waning.

Our education system is dominated by SEN, in fact this is the first extra support for bright and able children that I’ve ever heard of.

Bright and able children are our future and will be occupying jobs the rest of the cohort cannot do. It is absolutely right we support them to achieve this and don’t leave them to languish while throwing all resources at kids who, sadly, will never catch up to their level.

Bright children are also entitled to an education that meets their needs. It isn’t ALL about SEN, and the fact you seem to think it is is part of the problem.

If your daughter needs extra help perhaps you can arrange some tuition for her.

Some SEN parents do seem entitled. I do not see that we have the data to conclude that OP is one of them. However I do know two things.

Firstly, you posit a false dichotomy between SEN pupils and very bright pupils. In fact these categories can and do overlap. In particular a number of our most highly esteemed scientists, engineers and mathematicians - you know ‘those who occupy [top] jobs the rest … cannot do’ have significant SEN.

Secondly, OP already pays very substantially for external tuition for her DD. I could quote the amount for you but it has been mentioned so often on this thread that doing so would be redundant.

Wonderfrau · 08/11/2026 00:33

Goldenbear · 07/11/2026 09:39

Yes, I realised that the OP hadn't used single inverted commas.

I don't use commercial AI to do my thinking for me. I correctly used single inverted commas as the whole point of that post was to discuss the relevance of the names. I am using British English grammatical rules though perhaps your AI tool is unreliable in that sense as it defaults to American English.

Not sure what you mean, but thanks for acknowledging.

Wonderfrau · 08/11/2026 01:05

poetryandwine · 07/11/2026 22:45

Working with these children this way is fantastic. But why would this activity be restricted to participation by invitation only?

The Teacher will have a good understanding of their pupil’s interest and abilities. They will likely invite the pupils they think would benefit the most from these sessions and who they believe are not having their needs met in class. This is a professional judgement. I’m not sure that this is the wrong approach? It will likely be aimed at 10-20% of pupils. It would defeat the object and reduce the benefit if 80% of the class attended, especially as some parents might view it as free childcare (I’m looking at you, OP 🙄)

A bit like being selected for the football team, I suppose. Those who show little interest or aptitude in PE are less likely to be chosen. A little anecdote for you all: I ran the after school hockey club for a few years. We ran that club in rain or shine, thrashing hail storms and freezing finger weather. Many of the children were fantastic and so enthusiastic, even if their skills were limited. I was an equally bad coach, but loved the club, as the children enjoyed it so much. I ‘invited’ children to come to the club who showed interest in hockey during PE. Unlike in OPs case, nobody was excluded. I had to select children to attend inter-school tournaments. I tried to be as fair as possible, rotating places, so that hopefully everyone got to attend a tournament at some point during the year. Unusually, I didn’t just select the most able players. We often weren’t successful in our games. I suffered the most tremendous backlash from parents who were annoyed that I’d not selected the ‘strongest’ team. After 4 years I gave up.

Bear in mind a primary school teacher spends all day with their pupils, most days. They know them pretty well. That does not mean that some pupils will not flourish in a subject area later in life or ‘catch up’ to their peers. But the teacher is taking a snapshot, for now. If they read some of this thread (although, thankfully not most of it), they’ll wish they’d never given up their own time for free!

Puffin69 · 08/11/2026 07:15

Beepboobeep · 02/11/2026 21:32

But her out of school hours support (which I’m not saying should be offered regardless to anyone) managed 2 sessions in a year! These free clubs haven’t missed a week. Make that make sense?

It isn't like the person running the camps every week would oitherwise be providing extra support to her child. How many weeks did the football.club etc miss? How many struggling with sports students get extra support or is most of it going to those who will win games? Yes there should have been more than two sessions for the struggling learners but that is entirely separate to an after-school club for those needing extension. And unless you live in a very wealthy area or the access to the club is based on something other than actual talent (possible) then there will be kids there who otherwise would not get their needs met.

Puffin69 · 08/11/2026 07:24

shuggles · 02/11/2026 21:59

@Beepboobeep The truth is though that students who are academic don't even need the extra help.

Even in my day, it was possible to learn a lot of stuff on the internet. That's even more true today. And now there's even AI to act as a personal tutor.

Teachers are barely even needed now, because all "textbook" learning can be done online.

That is not true. Many highly gifted children crash and burn in their teens and 20s because they have never been challenged or had to work at academics. There is no justification for sacrificing those children just because you have some anti intellectual bias. On the other hand bright, compliant kids with supportive families usually do well. Actual gifted kids are another story.

Goldenbear · 08/11/2026 08:42

Wonderfrau · 08/11/2026 00:33

Not sure what you mean, but thanks for acknowledging.

I mean that I adhered to British English grammar rules in that post and as such, my use of the single inverted comma was correct.

poetryandwine · 08/11/2026 09:42

Wonderfrau · 08/11/2026 01:05

The Teacher will have a good understanding of their pupil’s interest and abilities. They will likely invite the pupils they think would benefit the most from these sessions and who they believe are not having their needs met in class. This is a professional judgement. I’m not sure that this is the wrong approach? It will likely be aimed at 10-20% of pupils. It would defeat the object and reduce the benefit if 80% of the class attended, especially as some parents might view it as free childcare (I’m looking at you, OP 🙄)

A bit like being selected for the football team, I suppose. Those who show little interest or aptitude in PE are less likely to be chosen. A little anecdote for you all: I ran the after school hockey club for a few years. We ran that club in rain or shine, thrashing hail storms and freezing finger weather. Many of the children were fantastic and so enthusiastic, even if their skills were limited. I was an equally bad coach, but loved the club, as the children enjoyed it so much. I ‘invited’ children to come to the club who showed interest in hockey during PE. Unlike in OPs case, nobody was excluded. I had to select children to attend inter-school tournaments. I tried to be as fair as possible, rotating places, so that hopefully everyone got to attend a tournament at some point during the year. Unusually, I didn’t just select the most able players. We often weren’t successful in our games. I suffered the most tremendous backlash from parents who were annoyed that I’d not selected the ‘strongest’ team. After 4 years I gave up.

Bear in mind a primary school teacher spends all day with their pupils, most days. They know them pretty well. That does not mean that some pupils will not flourish in a subject area later in life or ‘catch up’ to their peers. But the teacher is taking a snapshot, for now. If they read some of this thread (although, thankfully not most of it), they’ll wish they’d never given up their own time for free!

Your hockey club sounds fantastic. Of course talent must be the key consideration in choosing children for a competition, whether for hockey or maths. But I am delighted that you did not exclude anyone otherwise, and I feel the same way about Maths Club which is less likely to be overwhelmed on the grounds of pupil passion.

Why do you sense OP wants free child care? She is already paying so much for external tuition, as are other parents, that I don’t think it is a major consideration at this school.

I think she is frustrated. She may or may not have all the facts. How much support her DD gets during the school day is an open question as is the purpose of the after school activity. OP could have put her case better.
Nevertheless there are at minimum open questions here.

I am also shocked by the (thankfully few) PP who seem to think that more able children are inherently more deserving, and fail to recognise the overlap between SEN and high ability.

Electrickittens · 08/11/2026 11:27

poetryandwine · 08/11/2026 09:42

Your hockey club sounds fantastic. Of course talent must be the key consideration in choosing children for a competition, whether for hockey or maths. But I am delighted that you did not exclude anyone otherwise, and I feel the same way about Maths Club which is less likely to be overwhelmed on the grounds of pupil passion.

Why do you sense OP wants free child care? She is already paying so much for external tuition, as are other parents, that I don’t think it is a major consideration at this school.

I think she is frustrated. She may or may not have all the facts. How much support her DD gets during the school day is an open question as is the purpose of the after school activity. OP could have put her case better.
Nevertheless there are at minimum open questions here.

I am also shocked by the (thankfully few) PP who seem to think that more able children are inherently more deserving, and fail to recognise the overlap between SEN and high ability.

OP literally says in her first post:

There is no charge for this - so it’s free childcare and free tutoring.

You’ve the whole thread been running off at various tangents claiming this must be 11+ tutoring and all sorts of things that are not in the original post, which says these are clubs for the top performing students in Y5 and Y6. You appear not to know much about current state primary provision, have ignored posters saying that this is likely to be differentiation for GD students that the school isn’t doing elsewhere, and have also ignored many of us pointing out that this is actually required of schools by Ofsted (GD stretch). Yet you also speculate about the personal motivations of the OP while ignoring her actual post (‘why do you sense that the OP wants free child care?’ — well, because she literally posts implying that!)

Really baffled why this issue seems to have become a hobbyhorse for all sorts of other preoccupations about the 11+ and grammar schools and claiming that other posters on the thread ‘think that more able children are inherently more deserving’ - which is very clearly not at all the case, but just a rather scurrilous and unfounded accusation.

hibernatinghedgehog · 08/11/2026 11:46

Ah, the old demanding, entitled, sharp-elbowed SEN parent rhetoric. It is not entitled to expect the school and LA to follow the law.

poetryandwine · 08/11/2026 12:00

Electrickittens · 08/11/2026 11:27

OP literally says in her first post:

There is no charge for this - so it’s free childcare and free tutoring.

You’ve the whole thread been running off at various tangents claiming this must be 11+ tutoring and all sorts of things that are not in the original post, which says these are clubs for the top performing students in Y5 and Y6. You appear not to know much about current state primary provision, have ignored posters saying that this is likely to be differentiation for GD students that the school isn’t doing elsewhere, and have also ignored many of us pointing out that this is actually required of schools by Ofsted (GD stretch). Yet you also speculate about the personal motivations of the OP while ignoring her actual post (‘why do you sense that the OP wants free child care?’ — well, because she literally posts implying that!)

Really baffled why this issue seems to have become a hobbyhorse for all sorts of other preoccupations about the 11+ and grammar schools and claiming that other posters on the thread ‘think that more able children are inherently more deserving’ - which is very clearly not at all the case, but just a rather scurrilous and unfounded accusation.

Edited

I have never claimed this was implicit coaching, simply raised the possibility. I will tag you on some quotes saying that highly able children are more deserving.

poetryandwine · 08/11/2026 12:01

hibernatinghedgehog · 08/11/2026 11:46

Ah, the old demanding, entitled, sharp-elbowed SEN parent rhetoric. It is not entitled to expect the school and LA to follow the law.

I fully agree. The picture we have is murky.

poetryandwine · 08/11/2026 12:05

SunnyOchreNewt · 07/11/2026 02:40

Of course it's right to prioritise them. Do we want schools to enable the brightest and best students to realise their full potential, or do we want them to drag everyone up/smash everyone down to the same level?
That's like saying extra curricular sports clubs should be banned so that the clumsiest students can learn how to walk faster.

Edited

Here is one, @Electrickittens . What is clearer than the opening sentence ‘Of course it is right to prioritise them?’

Scarcityvarcity · 08/11/2026 12:05

poetryandwine · 08/11/2026 12:00

I have never claimed this was implicit coaching, simply raised the possibility. I will tag you on some quotes saying that highly able children are more deserving.

You did more than raise it as a possibility.

poetryandwine · 08/11/2026 12:06

Scarcityvarcity · 08/11/2026 12:05

You did more than raise it as a possibility.

I said my personal bet would be there. I never came close to stating it as fact.

poetryandwine · 08/11/2026 12:07

Electrickittens · 08/11/2026 11:27

OP literally says in her first post:

There is no charge for this - so it’s free childcare and free tutoring.

You’ve the whole thread been running off at various tangents claiming this must be 11+ tutoring and all sorts of things that are not in the original post, which says these are clubs for the top performing students in Y5 and Y6. You appear not to know much about current state primary provision, have ignored posters saying that this is likely to be differentiation for GD students that the school isn’t doing elsewhere, and have also ignored many of us pointing out that this is actually required of schools by Ofsted (GD stretch). Yet you also speculate about the personal motivations of the OP while ignoring her actual post (‘why do you sense that the OP wants free child care?’ — well, because she literally posts implying that!)

Really baffled why this issue seems to have become a hobbyhorse for all sorts of other preoccupations about the 11+ and grammar schools and claiming that other posters on the thread ‘think that more able children are inherently more deserving’ - which is very clearly not at all the case, but just a rather scurrilous and unfounded accusation.

Edited

Her consistent theme is the lack of parity, though.

poetryandwine · 08/11/2026 12:11

Apotofrealcoffee · 07/11/2026 04:15

Nobody else is going to say it, so I’m going to.

Some ‘SEN’ parents are maddeningly entitled to the extent, as you can see from this thread, that empathy for their situation is waning.

Our education system is dominated by SEN, in fact this is the first extra support for bright and able children that I’ve ever heard of.

Bright and able children are our future and will be occupying jobs the rest of the cohort cannot do. It is absolutely right we support them to achieve this and don’t leave them to languish while throwing all resources at kids who, sadly, will never catch up to their level.

Bright children are also entitled to an education that meets their needs. It isn’t ALL about SEN, and the fact you seem to think it is is part of the problem.

If your daughter needs extra help perhaps you can arrange some tuition for her.

Here is another, @Electrickittens . In particular see Paragraph 4. This person posits a dichotomy between highly able pupils and SEN pupils, as if one cannot be both. Astounding ignorance. (I have agreed with her upthread that yes, some SEN parents are entitled. As are some parents of able children).

Scarcityvarcity · 08/11/2026 12:46

poetryandwine · 08/11/2026 12:06

I said my personal bet would be there. I never came close to stating it as fact.

You also said that you can't see any other reason for it and insisted that state primary schools are judged on the number getting into grammar schools. Even when it was pointed out that this information is not published so why would they care you said that parents all know via the grapevine. You insisted you know better about this than primary school teachers and parents of children in grammar areas because people in your family have been to grammar school and you are a university admissions tutor so have spoken to grammar school leadership (as if they would know about primary school grapevines). And you clearly don't know much about the admissions process as if you did you would have known that year 6 have already taken the grammar school exams so coaching them would be pointless.

poetryandwine · 08/11/2026 13:06

Scarcityvarcity · 08/11/2026 12:46

You also said that you can't see any other reason for it and insisted that state primary schools are judged on the number getting into grammar schools. Even when it was pointed out that this information is not published so why would they care you said that parents all know via the grapevine. You insisted you know better about this than primary school teachers and parents of children in grammar areas because people in your family have been to grammar school and you are a university admissions tutor so have spoken to grammar school leadership (as if they would know about primary school grapevines). And you clearly don't know much about the admissions process as if you did you would have known that year 6 have already taken the grammar school exams so coaching them would be pointless.

Exam season for admissions to independent schools is roughly Nov-Jan.

We simply do not know. I do insist on that.

Goldenbear · 08/11/2026 13:07

Electrickittens · 08/11/2026 11:27

OP literally says in her first post:

There is no charge for this - so it’s free childcare and free tutoring.

You’ve the whole thread been running off at various tangents claiming this must be 11+ tutoring and all sorts of things that are not in the original post, which says these are clubs for the top performing students in Y5 and Y6. You appear not to know much about current state primary provision, have ignored posters saying that this is likely to be differentiation for GD students that the school isn’t doing elsewhere, and have also ignored many of us pointing out that this is actually required of schools by Ofsted (GD stretch). Yet you also speculate about the personal motivations of the OP while ignoring her actual post (‘why do you sense that the OP wants free child care?’ — well, because she literally posts implying that!)

Really baffled why this issue seems to have become a hobbyhorse for all sorts of other preoccupations about the 11+ and grammar schools and claiming that other posters on the thread ‘think that more able children are inherently more deserving’ - which is very clearly not at all the case, but just a rather scurrilous and unfounded accusation.

Edited

I mean I am not a teacher so hopefully this fact won't invalidate my point but I thought that you alluded to OFSTED not mandate a G&T programme and this has been the case since 2010?

Equally, I find it perplexing that 'Great Writer's' can be identified at 9 and 10. Writing is a a composite skill, you need emotional maturity, a self awareness that allows you to know how to write in a way that is interesting to to the reader; something a 9 year old would simply lack the maturity to deliver on.

Goldenbear · 08/11/2026 13:08

Goldenbear · 08/11/2026 13:07

I mean I am not a teacher so hopefully this fact won't invalidate my point but I thought that you alluded to OFSTED not mandate a G&T programme and this has been the case since 2010?

Equally, I find it perplexing that 'Great Writer's' can be identified at 9 and 10. Writing is a a composite skill, you need emotional maturity, a self awareness that allows you to know how to write in a way that is interesting to to the reader; something a 9 year old would simply lack the maturity to deliver on.

Mandating not 'mandate'.

Scarcityvarcity · 08/11/2026 13:10

poetryandwine · 08/11/2026 13:06

Exam season for admissions to independent schools is roughly Nov-Jan.

We simply do not know. I do insist on that.

Are you seriously suggesting state primary schools might be coaching for that? You really are clueless about how things work if you think that is even a slight possibility.

Goldenbear · 08/11/2026 13:13

Scarcityvarcity · 08/11/2026 12:46

You also said that you can't see any other reason for it and insisted that state primary schools are judged on the number getting into grammar schools. Even when it was pointed out that this information is not published so why would they care you said that parents all know via the grapevine. You insisted you know better about this than primary school teachers and parents of children in grammar areas because people in your family have been to grammar school and you are a university admissions tutor so have spoken to grammar school leadership (as if they would know about primary school grapevines). And you clearly don't know much about the admissions process as if you did you would have known that year 6 have already taken the grammar school exams so coaching them would be pointless.

You can find this information out via FOIs, you clearly don't understand how they work and having worked for the local authority in this area, schools get inundated with FOIs about everything and they do have a legal obligation to respond as they are public body.

I have the example of Kent for you, where you will find lots of primary schools oversubscribed near to the grammar schools- it is hardly a coincidence. This appears to be such naivety about a well documented and well reported on subject.

poetryandwine · 08/11/2026 13:17

Scarcityvarcity · 08/11/2026 13:10

Are you seriously suggesting state primary schools might be coaching for that? You really are clueless about how things work if you think that is even a slight possibility.

What are your qualifications, @Scarcityvarcity ?

Scarcityvarcity · 08/11/2026 13:20

Goldenbear · 08/11/2026 13:13

You can find this information out via FOIs, you clearly don't understand how they work and having worked for the local authority in this area, schools get inundated with FOIs about everything and they do have a legal obligation to respond as they are public body.

I have the example of Kent for you, where you will find lots of primary schools oversubscribed near to the grammar schools- it is hardly a coincidence. This appears to be such naivety about a well documented and well reported on subject.

You gave an example of a FOI that was answered by a grammar school. This actually demonstrated that it was pretty pointless asking the question as they listed over a 100 primary schools and stated one or more pupils may be from that school. That is what I said they would do if numbers from each school were small so it proved my point rather than yours.

Scarcityvarcity · 08/11/2026 13:25

poetryandwine · 08/11/2026 13:17

What are your qualifications, @Scarcityvarcity ?

I live in a grammar school area and my children went to grammar schools. As you think family are relevant (i don't), many of mine are teachers and school governors. I even have a close family member who is a university admissions tutor.