Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think extra lessons for top students isn’t fair?

775 replies

Beepboobeep · 02/11/2026 21:12

My DD’s state primary school has a “top maths club” and “great writers club” for the top performing students in yr 5 and 6 held outside of school hours. There is no charge for this - so it’s free childcare and free tutoring. You have to be invited. This has been running since the second week of the school year and is restarting on the first day of this half term.

By contrast, my dyslexic DD is in a group for those needing more support in writing, also outside of school hours. But they only managed 2 sessions last year and it hasn’t started back up this year. She gets ad hoc in school support; where it happens she misses other lessons that aren’t then caught up on, putting her further behind in the those.

I appreciate these children deserve challenging, but surely that could be done in class with different work and the teacher’s out of hours time, if available, used to help those struggling?

Is this even allowed in a state primary?

OP posts:
poetryandwine · 05/11/2026 19:04

Scarcityvarcity · 05/11/2026 18:29

Who would collate that information? And given that not everyone who passed grammar school exams would go i sm not sure it would be useful.

Edited

This is a very straightforward use of FOI, @Scarcityvarcity . It is nothing compared to what universities are asked.

The Civil Service has vast expertise in fulfilling these requests. Public institutions such as schools are legally obliged to comply.

Scarcityvarcity · 05/11/2026 19:39

poetryandwine · 05/11/2026 19:04

This is a very straightforward use of FOI, @Scarcityvarcity . It is nothing compared to what universities are asked.

The Civil Service has vast expertise in fulfilling these requests. Public institutions such as schools are legally obliged to comply.

They don't have to comply if only a small number of children went to specific schools. As I said, the local primary gives details for the the nearest comprehensive and grammar but 40 percent is "other"

Twinkylightsg · 05/11/2026 19:42

Beepboobeep · 02/11/2026 21:15

Yes, but is it right to prioritise them over children who are struggling?

Edited

Yes it is. Because children that are struggling are always thought of. The gifted ones are often overlooked and thought of to cope and not provided with nearly as much or any support due to the amount children with support needs require.

Goldenbear · 05/11/2026 20:08

Scarcityvarcity · 05/11/2026 19:39

They don't have to comply if only a small number of children went to specific schools. As I said, the local primary gives details for the the nearest comprehensive and grammar but 40 percent is "other"

It would be submitted to the Grammar school, they would definitely hold the data. From that response you would know which primary schools most students attended.

Journalists frequently submit FOIs to schools and local authorities relating to a range of topics.

Bumblebee0918 · 05/11/2026 20:10

This sounds very much like jealousy on your part OP - unless of course you were just as indignant that children of differing abilities did not get the after school support (albeit minimal) that your dd got last year. Why is your child reaching her full academic potential more important than all children having that opportunity? As a primary teacher, in all of my years I have never met a school or teacher that did not spend a significant amount of extra time providing support to lower attaining children. This could be support in class, pre teaching or time creating visuals, cloze paragraphs, sentence stems or any manner of scaffolding to ensure that every child can access the learning. Interventions within school time also require an adult to run them who is then not free to support elsewhere. Interventions in class time are also very carefully considered to ensure that the benefits outweigh the time missed. The reality is that reading, writing and maths are crucial in almost every subject so longer term the time spent in Interventions will be helpful across the curriculum. I also don't see what these children do in the holidays or after school has to do with what the school offers? By your own admission you spend money yourself on similar so surely dd also shouldn't have been offered after school support? Unless of course, the same principles don't apply to her and you feel entitled to special treatment. I personally think it is fantastic that a school is offering this opportunity.

Scarcityvarcity · 05/11/2026 20:19

Goldenbear · 05/11/2026 20:08

It would be submitted to the Grammar school, they would definitely hold the data. From that response you would know which primary schools most students attended.

Journalists frequently submit FOIs to schools and local authorities relating to a range of topics.

The grammars schools where i live have students attending from 100s of primary schools. There also several grammar schools. Often only one pupil may attend from a specific school. They aren't going to be giving out that kind of detail and there is certainly nothing online suggesting they have.

Goldenbear · 05/11/2026 20:59

Scarcityvarcity · 05/11/2026 20:19

The grammars schools where i live have students attending from 100s of primary schools. There also several grammar schools. Often only one pupil may attend from a specific school. They aren't going to be giving out that kind of detail and there is certainly nothing online suggesting they have.

Edited

How many grammar schools are in the county is irrelevant. Many Grammar schools when oversubscribed, use 'distance to school' hence why in some areas, the primary schools nearest to the grammar school are oversubscribed, for example, Canterbury in Kent. It's just not going to be the case that there would only be 1 or 2 pupils from several different schools across the country. Equally, it is pretty unusual for a child to travel perhaps for an 1.5 in car, even longer on public transport across the distance of a county. Even for selective schools like The Tiffin Girl's school which I believe doesn't use distance to school, they have answered an FOI about intake. Unsure if I can link so I won't but it's easy to Google. I have lots of professional experience in the area of FOIs, believe me this is not an unusual request at all!

Scarcityvarcity · 05/11/2026 21:28

Goldenbear · 05/11/2026 20:59

How many grammar schools are in the county is irrelevant. Many Grammar schools when oversubscribed, use 'distance to school' hence why in some areas, the primary schools nearest to the grammar school are oversubscribed, for example, Canterbury in Kent. It's just not going to be the case that there would only be 1 or 2 pupils from several different schools across the country. Equally, it is pretty unusual for a child to travel perhaps for an 1.5 in car, even longer on public transport across the distance of a county. Even for selective schools like The Tiffin Girl's school which I believe doesn't use distance to school, they have answered an FOI about intake. Unsure if I can link so I won't but it's easy to Google. I have lots of professional experience in the area of FOIs, believe me this is not an unusual request at all!

It's different in different areas. Not all have a catchment area. Not all grammar schools are in Kent. Only one or two pupils from each primary school go to individual grammar schools in my area, if that.

poetryandwine · 05/11/2026 21:34

Scarcityvarcity · 05/11/2026 21:28

It's different in different areas. Not all have a catchment area. Not all grammar schools are in Kent. Only one or two pupils from each primary school go to individual grammar schools in my area, if that.

FOI can cope with this and give quite a lot of information. A lot depends on the wording of the request.

You are grasping at straws with reference only to your local area.

Scarcityvarcity · 05/11/2026 21:43

poetryandwine · 05/11/2026 21:34

FOI can cope with this and give quite a lot of information. A lot depends on the wording of the request.

You are grasping at straws with reference only to your local area.

It is a huge area. I have checked snd the do nit have to comply if small numbers. Plus noone has asked.

poetryandwine · 05/11/2026 23:00

Scarcityvarcity · 05/11/2026 21:43

It is a huge area. I have checked snd the do nit have to comply if small numbers. Plus noone has asked.

If no one has asked, you cannot know what would happen if they did. You also have no grounds for extrapolating: when I said sharp elbowed parents know, I was referring to the grapevine rather than FOI.

Also the courts have ruled that small numbers per se are not a reason to deny an FOI request. Only if the small numbers make individuals identifiable, or similar, are objections to FOI legally valid.

Scarcityvarcity · 05/11/2026 23:16

poetryandwine · 05/11/2026 23:00

If no one has asked, you cannot know what would happen if they did. You also have no grounds for extrapolating: when I said sharp elbowed parents know, I was referring to the grapevine rather than FOI.

Also the courts have ruled that small numbers per se are not a reason to deny an FOI request. Only if the small numbers make individuals identifiable, or similar, are objections to FOI legally valid.

If noone had asked and the information is not published then why would primary schools care about the numbers going to grrammar schools? As I keep saying, the grapevine isn't going to be very accurate given not everyone who could go does go. Some children at my DC primary chose the local comprehensive or private schools rather than a grammar.

Wonderfrau · 06/11/2026 02:29

As an educator from the non-elite, bog standard, non-specialist state primary schools ( one affluent area and others less so), I can assure you that pupils who are working towards the expected standard in maths during class, have very little interest in attending additional maths lessons after school. We did adopt/adapt a maths programme over 10 years ago, based on the Singapore Maths model, whereby pupils who hadn’t demonstrated full understanding/ true mastery by lunchtime were kept back in the afternoon to re-do the session, at the expense of their PE, Art, Science, music etc lessons. Thankfully, we quickly abandoned

It is far more likely, and of course none of us - including the OP - actually know, that the school are either providing what used to be referred to as G&T enhancement or SATs support for borderline student. And it’s possible that OPs daughter hasn’t been invited because she is neither G&T nor borderline enough.

I am surprised that OP has so much information about which pupils are the clever ones? Primary school pupils often have wild ideas about where they rank with their peers in terms of intelligence, although usually know who needs additional support in class, as they observe it. They use all sorts of unusual markers to grade each other 😂 The teachers have a little more data, but certainly wouldn’t be sharing it with OP. And OP should know not to believe anything other parents hinty brag at! 🫣 I am also pretty horrified that other pupils are commenting on OPs DDs dyslexia and I do question whether that is actually happening. Again, pupils have an awareness of peers who receive additional support or different resources but in 20 years, I’ve never heard unkind discussions amongst the children about this, except some children express frustration that they never get ‘taken out’ or given enough additional support in class. OPs DD is likely to be one of approximately 10 children in her class who have additional needs of some kind. Why on earth would they discuss it with their parents in a negative way. The OP does sound a bit paranoid.

lt very much seems that OP has got wind that other children have been invited to after school sessions and her child hasn’t. She feels this is unfair, particularly since her daughter doesn’t qualify for an EHCP and therefore will ‘only’ be having in class support from her teacher. Best thing OP can do is ask teacher what these after school sessions are for and whether the teacher thinks her child might benefit, if her child does indeed wish to attend.

Goldenbear · 06/11/2026 07:20

Wonderfrau · 06/11/2026 02:29

As an educator from the non-elite, bog standard, non-specialist state primary schools ( one affluent area and others less so), I can assure you that pupils who are working towards the expected standard in maths during class, have very little interest in attending additional maths lessons after school. We did adopt/adapt a maths programme over 10 years ago, based on the Singapore Maths model, whereby pupils who hadn’t demonstrated full understanding/ true mastery by lunchtime were kept back in the afternoon to re-do the session, at the expense of their PE, Art, Science, music etc lessons. Thankfully, we quickly abandoned

It is far more likely, and of course none of us - including the OP - actually know, that the school are either providing what used to be referred to as G&T enhancement or SATs support for borderline student. And it’s possible that OPs daughter hasn’t been invited because she is neither G&T nor borderline enough.

I am surprised that OP has so much information about which pupils are the clever ones? Primary school pupils often have wild ideas about where they rank with their peers in terms of intelligence, although usually know who needs additional support in class, as they observe it. They use all sorts of unusual markers to grade each other 😂 The teachers have a little more data, but certainly wouldn’t be sharing it with OP. And OP should know not to believe anything other parents hinty brag at! 🫣 I am also pretty horrified that other pupils are commenting on OPs DDs dyslexia and I do question whether that is actually happening. Again, pupils have an awareness of peers who receive additional support or different resources but in 20 years, I’ve never heard unkind discussions amongst the children about this, except some children express frustration that they never get ‘taken out’ or given enough additional support in class. OPs DD is likely to be one of approximately 10 children in her class who have additional needs of some kind. Why on earth would they discuss it with their parents in a negative way. The OP does sound a bit paranoid.

lt very much seems that OP has got wind that other children have been invited to after school sessions and her child hasn’t. She feels this is unfair, particularly since her daughter doesn’t qualify for an EHCP and therefore will ‘only’ be having in class support from her teacher. Best thing OP can do is ask teacher what these after school sessions are for and whether the teacher thinks her child might benefit, if her child does indeed wish to attend.

Considering the groups names are, "Great Writers Club" and "Top Maths Club", the OP doesn't have to be Miss Marple to deduce that these groups are only for the 'gifted' pupils.

JoB1kenobi · 06/11/2026 07:24

As a teacher myself, I rarely see clubs for the able, in class the able children have to suffer through so much missed learning time due to behaviour, outburst etc etc etc. we can barely get to those able children get barely a look in because there’s always someone with a need in class.

I’m so pleased this a thing.

SummerFeverVenice · 06/11/2026 07:28

Yanbu OP. My DD is severely dyslexic too. I had to get specific outside tutoring for her to succeed. Look into the Linda Mood Bell method.

Newname26 · 06/11/2026 07:32

Goldenbear · 06/11/2026 07:20

Considering the groups names are, "Great Writers Club" and "Top Maths Club", the OP doesn't have to be Miss Marple to deduce that these groups are only for the 'gifted' pupils.

Well what would you call it, the borderliners?
You have to call them something to make them appealing.

Goldenbear · 06/11/2026 08:30

Newname26 · 06/11/2026 07:32

Well what would you call it, the borderliners?
You have to call them something to make them appealing.

It's a gatekeeping name- they are actively excluding all pupils that aren't gifted.

FirmSnake · 06/11/2026 08:56

Goldenbear · 06/11/2026 08:30

It's a gatekeeping name- they are actively excluding all pupils that aren't gifted.

Yes, on purpose. That is how targeted support works.

Scarcityvarcity · 06/11/2026 09:11

Yes, i think the name is to make it more appealing. In particular Year 6 will have taken the grammar school exams by now (probably a couple of months ago) so won't be inclined to attend.

poetryandwine · 06/11/2026 09:34

Scarcityvarcity · 05/11/2026 23:16

If noone had asked and the information is not published then why would primary schools care about the numbers going to grrammar schools? As I keep saying, the grapevine isn't going to be very accurate given not everyone who could go does go. Some children at my DC primary chose the local comprehensive or private schools rather than a grammar.

It is ultimately a certain class of parents who care as @Goldenbear and I have explained upthread. Progression rates will matter to the school’s reputation with these parents. However this information tends to be passed along the grapevine.

And we can never generalise too far from a small sample set..

This is getting a bit repetitive now so I am parking it

Wonderfrau · 06/11/2026 09:36

Goldenbear · 06/11/2026 07:20

Considering the groups names are, "Great Writers Club" and "Top Maths Club", the OP doesn't have to be Miss Marple to deduce that these groups are only for the 'gifted' pupils.

OP placed the club names in inverted commas, suggesting these were not the actual names?

But, even if they were, do you think pupils and more importantly parents would happily attend an ASC club called “Maths Strugglers” or “Could be a bit dim, English.”

I have led groups called Maths Wizards and Monkey Puzzlers, together with many sports teams of different abilities. They were never called fast and slow, even though this is how they were categorised, and the attendees were neither wizards nor monkeys. The more able pupils are never designated as ‘Top’ or ‘Best.’ That’s just not how state primary schools operate.

I quite frankly don’t believe the OP. I think she has filled in the unknowns with her own assumptions. Your post suggests you have not recently worked in a state primary school either.

Scarcityvarcity · 06/11/2026 10:04

poetryandwine · 06/11/2026 09:34

It is ultimately a certain class of parents who care as @Goldenbear and I have explained upthread. Progression rates will matter to the school’s reputation with these parents. However this information tends to be passed along the grapevine.

And we can never generalise too far from a small sample set..

This is getting a bit repetitive now so I am parking it

Maybe it happens somewhere like Kent where i think they still have the old grammar/secondary modern system but totally disagree that this it how it works in areas where there are just a few grammar schools, most DC go to comprehensives and some will actively choose a comprehensive over a grammar. You don't even live in a grammar school area and you don't have children in a grammar school. Why do you think you know so much more about it than someone with actual experience?

poetryandwine · 06/11/2026 10:07

Scarcityvarcity · 06/11/2026 10:04

Maybe it happens somewhere like Kent where i think they still have the old grammar/secondary modern system but totally disagree that this it how it works in areas where there are just a few grammar schools, most DC go to comprehensives and some will actively choose a comprehensive over a grammar. You don't even live in a grammar school area and you don't have children in a grammar school. Why do you think you know so much more about it than someone with actual experience?

Bored

Goldenbear · 06/11/2026 11:32

FirmSnake · 06/11/2026 08:56

Yes, on purpose. That is how targeted support works.

You have taken my reply out of context which was in response to someone else trying to justify the insincere purpose of this group, spread like rancid butter over the surface of 'targeted support'.