Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think extra lessons for top students isn’t fair?

775 replies

Beepboobeep · 02/11/2026 21:12

My DD’s state primary school has a “top maths club” and “great writers club” for the top performing students in yr 5 and 6 held outside of school hours. There is no charge for this - so it’s free childcare and free tutoring. You have to be invited. This has been running since the second week of the school year and is restarting on the first day of this half term.

By contrast, my dyslexic DD is in a group for those needing more support in writing, also outside of school hours. But they only managed 2 sessions last year and it hasn’t started back up this year. She gets ad hoc in school support; where it happens she misses other lessons that aren’t then caught up on, putting her further behind in the those.

I appreciate these children deserve challenging, but surely that could be done in class with different work and the teacher’s out of hours time, if available, used to help those struggling?

Is this even allowed in a state primary?

OP posts:
Electrickittens · 08/11/2026 13:26

Goldenbear · 08/11/2026 13:13

You can find this information out via FOIs, you clearly don't understand how they work and having worked for the local authority in this area, schools get inundated with FOIs about everything and they do have a legal obligation to respond as they are public body.

I have the example of Kent for you, where you will find lots of primary schools oversubscribed near to the grammar schools- it is hardly a coincidence. This appears to be such naivety about a well documented and well reported on subject.

Ofsted don’t mandate anything. They assess how schools comply with all aspects of schools’ curriculum, safeguarding, etc. etc. There hasn’t been a national G&T programme for a long time; however, schools are still assessed on whether they are providing education to the whole range of pupils with different needs.

Throughout primary each school has a cohort tracking program showing how children are achieving compared to national and local LEA metrics — and they can clearly see which children are scoring at greater depth. They will be looking to push children up at each stage, not just at key points like the phonics check and TT check, but especially in years leading up to SATS. They will be actively trying to improve their stats at each level of achievement because they are being measured by not just their results, but also what interventions they are providing. OP’s post states Y5 and Y6 children - so the years leading up to Y6 SATS. Ofsted will be looking at whether the school is providing the appropriate teaching not just for children with SEND (which is a different obligation), but also whether they are providing teaching to all ability levels. And the school management (and trust management, if they’re in a MAT), and/or the LEA, will also have that data.

The idea that state primary schools are providing tutoring for independent school entrance exams, as opposed to just trying to improve their own SATS scores, is so far off base it’s genuinely laughable.

Nationwide, grammar schools are only in very very few areas. State school curricula and Ofted inspection are just not interested in the number of children who go on to grammars. They have very different priorities.

poetryandwine · 08/11/2026 13:27

Scarcityvarcity · 08/11/2026 13:25

I live in a grammar school area and my children went to grammar schools. As you think family are relevant (i don't), many of mine are teachers and school governors. I even have a close family member who is a university admissions tutor.

Edited

Interestingly, the mirror image of mine. What a remarkable coincidence! So why are you convinced that you know more than me?

Goldenbear · 08/11/2026 13:31

Scarcityvarcity · 08/11/2026 13:20

You gave an example of a FOI that was answered by a grammar school. This actually demonstrated that it was pretty pointless asking the question as they listed over a 100 primary schools and stated one or more pupils may be from that school. That is what I said they would do if numbers from each school were small so it proved my point rather than yours.

Edited

That is one example and it confirms the Tiffin school's intake is disparate and it does confirm schools.

Goldenbear · 08/11/2026 13:33

Electrickittens · 08/11/2026 13:26

Ofsted don’t mandate anything. They assess how schools comply with all aspects of schools’ curriculum, safeguarding, etc. etc. There hasn’t been a national G&T programme for a long time; however, schools are still assessed on whether they are providing education to the whole range of pupils with different needs.

Throughout primary each school has a cohort tracking program showing how children are achieving compared to national and local LEA metrics — and they can clearly see which children are scoring at greater depth. They will be looking to push children up at each stage, not just at key points like the phonics check and TT check, but especially in years leading up to SATS. They will be actively trying to improve their stats at each level of achievement because they are being measured by not just their results, but also what interventions they are providing. OP’s post states Y5 and Y6 children - so the years leading up to Y6 SATS. Ofsted will be looking at whether the school is providing the appropriate teaching not just for children with SEND (which is a different obligation), but also whether they are providing teaching to all ability levels. And the school management (and trust management, if they’re in a MAT), and/or the LEA, will also have that data.

The idea that state primary schools are providing tutoring for independent school entrance exams, as opposed to just trying to improve their own SATS scores, is so far off base it’s genuinely laughable.

Nationwide, grammar schools are only in very very few areas. State school curricula and Ofted inspection are just not interested in the number of children who go on to grammars. They have very different priorities.

Edited

'You' are the one suggesting they are interested but they simply aren't.

Electrickittens · 08/11/2026 13:43

I would add that as a school governor we also see each year group’s anonymised tracking data relative to the start of year baseline at each meeting. This shows you the proportions of children working towards, working at and exceeding the levels at each stage compared to LEA and national data. Primary school management is very data-heavy these days, and schools are very aware of where they need to improve results or add interventions. They use this cohort tracking data to monitor the progress of all sorts of markers, eg. boys vs girls, SEND, EAL, PP, ECHP, GD, summer-born vs autumn-born, and so on.

GD out of all of these things normally gets very little attention because the focus is overwhelmingly on SEND and the other end of the achievement picture (eg. bringing up struggling pupils to pass the phonics or TT check, and so on). The run-up to Y6 SATS is pretty much the only time able pupils are offered many resources because schools have so many other more pressing interventions to provide. But in KS2 you may get a bit of extra GD/G&T provision such as maths challenges, English challenges etc. to stretch the potential GD pupils. Many schools just don’t have the resources to do this extra stuff, though.

Electrickittens · 08/11/2026 14:01

Goldenbear · 08/11/2026 13:33

'You' are the one suggesting they are interested but they simply aren't.

Eh? I’ve been involved in several Ofsted inspections as a chair of governors. Why on earth do you think Ofsted aren’t interested in cohort tracking data, SATS results, or targeted interventions?

ProudCat · 08/11/2026 14:03

Goldenbear · 07/11/2026 22:45

The teacher still represents the school whether they are paid or not, they have to comply with Teaching Standards.

Running a club for gifted children entirely complies with TS.

Being expected to run an intervention group / childcare after school without being paid or given time off in lieu doesn't comply with the Burgundy Book.

What has almost certainly happened here is that there's a funding issue around the provision. Literally nothing to do with Teachers' Standards and everything to do with cuts to education.

arggggg · 08/11/2026 14:47

Life isn’t ‘fair’. This actually seems quite reasonable to me, though.

Scarcityvarcity · 08/11/2026 14:50

poetryandwine · 08/11/2026 13:27

Interestingly, the mirror image of mine. What a remarkable coincidence! So why are you convinced that you know more than me?

I got the impression that you do not live in a grammar school area and that you are not a parent whose children went to a state primary school and then state grammar school. Are you telling me your children did go to a grammar school and state primary school?

poetryandwine · 08/11/2026 15:01

Scarcityvarcity · 08/11/2026 14:50

I got the impression that you do not live in a grammar school area and that you are not a parent whose children went to a state primary school and then state grammar school. Are you telling me your children did go to a grammar school and state primary school?

It is your turn to answer a question. All you have done so far is to ask, rudely at that.

Wonderfrau · 08/11/2026 15:55

Goldenbear · 08/11/2026 13:07

I mean I am not a teacher so hopefully this fact won't invalidate my point but I thought that you alluded to OFSTED not mandate a G&T programme and this has been the case since 2010?

Equally, I find it perplexing that 'Great Writer's' can be identified at 9 and 10. Writing is a a composite skill, you need emotional maturity, a self awareness that allows you to know how to write in a way that is interesting to to the reader; something a 9 year old would simply lack the maturity to deliver on.

G&T (Gifted & Talented) did finish years ago, but we now have children who are formally assessed as working at Greater Depth (GD). I think I may have muddied the waters by referring to G&T, which isn’t a thing any more and rather shows my age! Apologies. And as a non teacher, your opinions are valid too!

GD is reserved for the various academic assessments within English, maths, reading and SPaG. G&T was used to include a much wider range and included music, art, sports etc.

A “Great Writer” can most definitely be supported, encouraged and extended at aged 9 or 10. They can be ‘great,’ regardless of their ability, particularly when you are referring to primary age. A lower ability pupil can still be told that a piece of writing they have done is great, if it is at the top end of their ability. You wouldn’t say to a 9 year old that, although they’d tried really hard and it was their best work, it’s still a bit shit. You would tell them that it’s great and explain to them why, so they can try and replicate and build on this with their next piece. It’s not just empty, false praise but I can see that they themselves are maybe not ‘great’ in the strict sense. This is why I’m not entirely convinced the great writers ASC the OP refers to is for the best or most able pupils. The OP certainly wouldn’t know the children’s assessment results.

It takes me back to the point that the group titles (if they are even what the groups are called and not the OPs own nicknames for them) Group titles that veer away from simple ‘y5 maths’ etc, are meant to inspire the pupils and really aren’t that deep. I agree they are very unlikely to be great writers by comparison to more mature writers, with the necessary composite skill, emotional maturity and self awareness that we recognise as needed. They won’t be great by comparison to published authors, but they can be great, for them. It’s a bit unfair to imply you can’t praise younger children or recognise their achievements because older, more experienced or more able pupils would do better. ‘Great’ in a primary school scenario is a relative complement and nearly everyone will understand it as such. It is good for children to be told they are doing something well. By university and beyond, we become a bit more hardened to the blunt critique, but in primary I think it’s okay to describe pupils (or their work) as great, even if they are not the best/top/highest.

Goldenbear · 08/11/2026 16:25

Electrickittens · 08/11/2026 13:43

I would add that as a school governor we also see each year group’s anonymised tracking data relative to the start of year baseline at each meeting. This shows you the proportions of children working towards, working at and exceeding the levels at each stage compared to LEA and national data. Primary school management is very data-heavy these days, and schools are very aware of where they need to improve results or add interventions. They use this cohort tracking data to monitor the progress of all sorts of markers, eg. boys vs girls, SEND, EAL, PP, ECHP, GD, summer-born vs autumn-born, and so on.

GD out of all of these things normally gets very little attention because the focus is overwhelmingly on SEND and the other end of the achievement picture (eg. bringing up struggling pupils to pass the phonics or TT check, and so on). The run-up to Y6 SATS is pretty much the only time able pupils are offered many resources because schools have so many other more pressing interventions to provide. But in KS2 you may get a bit of extra GD/G&T provision such as maths challenges, English challenges etc. to stretch the potential GD pupils. Many schools just don’t have the resources to do this extra stuff, though.

I know what data analytics is- I am disputing this approach to determine who qualifies for admission to the 'Top' groups.

Scarcityvarcity · 08/11/2026 16:33

poetryandwine · 08/11/2026 15:01

It is your turn to answer a question. All you have done so far is to ask, rudely at that.

The answer to your question of why I think i know more than you about this is because I don't believe your experience mirrors mine because unlike me you are not a parent of children who went to a state primary and grammar school. You haven't mentioned having children at all and you are obviously not a teacher at a state school. Am I wrong about that?

Scarcityvarcity · 08/11/2026 16:39

Goldenbear · 08/11/2026 13:31

That is one example and it confirms the Tiffin school's intake is disparate and it does confirm schools.

You gave that example to prove that the information could be obtained from FOI. It proved the opposite. Listing over 100 schools proves nothing. The intake from most grammar school areas is quite disparate outside Kent so answers to FOI would be similar imo.

Electrickittens · 08/11/2026 16:53

Goldenbear · 08/11/2026 16:25

I know what data analytics is- I am disputing this approach to determine who qualifies for admission to the 'Top' groups.

Not sure you are getting what I mean here. All schools have to do this cohort tracking. It allows them to see where proportions of their pupils are falling short relative to the local and national data. If a school can see, for example, that they have fewer pupils who are achieving at greater depth in Y5 and Y6 relative to local and national percentages, they may want to put in targeted interventions to help pupils who could move up to that level achieve their potential. These children may well be drawn from all sorts of backgrounds, may have SEND, may be Pupil Premium, whatever. OP hasn’t got any actual knowledge of why these children are being asked to join (many of them may be PP children for all she knows, with cross-funding from PP).

What is strange to me is that no matter how many times I or other posters who work in the field explain that this is not just perfectly normal practice in primary schools, but is also actively considered good practice, you seem to persist in thinking that it’s some kind of occult discrimination. What is wrong with schools targeting a group of kids with the aim of helping them move up to a higher SATS banding they may be capable of getting, which is good for their potential and for the school’s results? That in itself is not evidence of discrimination. The school’s obligation to provide SEND and other forms of support and intervention to other ability bands is not a zero sum exercise. All primary schools have an obligation to focus on these, and a greater number of kids achieving greater depth isn’t going to outweigh a poor score achieving at the lower levels - they need to be targeting both (and the average kid in the middle!)

Most state primaries are at the moment devoting enormous amounts of resources to SEND and bringing up pupils to the required standard - they rarely have the resources to deliver interventions for GD students, and where they are, you usually find it’s being done in the free time of one of the head of subject Y5/6 teachers with an interest in this. They are not necessarily (in fact are probably rarely) the teachers or TAs who are the ones specialised in delivering SEND/literacy support interventions.

The OP needs to find out why her daughter’s extra provision isn’t happening. But it isn’t likely to be not happening because other interventions are happening. As a pp said, most kids aren’t ’invited’ to join sensory circuits or specific lunchtime activities delivering 1-1 reading support, or small group phonics support in advance of the Phonics Check, for example. But that doesn’t mean they are somehow being discriminated against, or that it’s appropriate for every kid to be offered them who might want them, or that they are preventing support or enrichment for other kids.

poetryandwine · 08/11/2026 17:03

Electrickittens · 08/11/2026 16:53

Not sure you are getting what I mean here. All schools have to do this cohort tracking. It allows them to see where proportions of their pupils are falling short relative to the local and national data. If a school can see, for example, that they have fewer pupils who are achieving at greater depth in Y5 and Y6 relative to local and national percentages, they may want to put in targeted interventions to help pupils who could move up to that level achieve their potential. These children may well be drawn from all sorts of backgrounds, may have SEND, may be Pupil Premium, whatever. OP hasn’t got any actual knowledge of why these children are being asked to join (many of them may be PP children for all she knows, with cross-funding from PP).

What is strange to me is that no matter how many times I or other posters who work in the field explain that this is not just perfectly normal practice in primary schools, but is also actively considered good practice, you seem to persist in thinking that it’s some kind of occult discrimination. What is wrong with schools targeting a group of kids with the aim of helping them move up to a higher SATS banding they may be capable of getting, which is good for their potential and for the school’s results? That in itself is not evidence of discrimination. The school’s obligation to provide SEND and other forms of support and intervention to other ability bands is not a zero sum exercise. All primary schools have an obligation to focus on these, and a greater number of kids achieving greater depth isn’t going to outweigh a poor score achieving at the lower levels - they need to be targeting both (and the average kid in the middle!)

Most state primaries are at the moment devoting enormous amounts of resources to SEND and bringing up pupils to the required standard - they rarely have the resources to deliver interventions for GD students, and where they are, you usually find it’s being done in the free time of one of the head of subject Y5/6 teachers with an interest in this. They are not necessarily (in fact are probably rarely) the teachers or TAs who are the ones specialised in delivering SEND/literacy support interventions.

The OP needs to find out why her daughter’s extra provision isn’t happening. But it isn’t likely to be not happening because other interventions are happening. As a pp said, most kids aren’t ’invited’ to join sensory circuits or specific lunchtime activities delivering 1-1 reading support, or small group phonics support in advance of the Phonics Check, for example. But that doesn’t mean they are somehow being discriminated against, or that it’s appropriate for every kid to be offered them who might want them, or that they are preventing support or enrichment for other kids.

Edited

The crux of the matter is that OP does see this as a zero sum game, and we have no idea why. That these activities are really sessions for children within striking distance of Greater Depth is a sensible alternative, but it isn’t how OP presented the situation and none of us are closer to it than she is.

One hopes that if OP’s DD was really getting good support during the school day, she would have mentioned it. If she is not and SEN pupils are not receiving parity, that would explain her post.

Goldenbear · 08/11/2026 17:13

Electrickittens · 08/11/2026 16:53

Not sure you are getting what I mean here. All schools have to do this cohort tracking. It allows them to see where proportions of their pupils are falling short relative to the local and national data. If a school can see, for example, that they have fewer pupils who are achieving at greater depth in Y5 and Y6 relative to local and national percentages, they may want to put in targeted interventions to help pupils who could move up to that level achieve their potential. These children may well be drawn from all sorts of backgrounds, may have SEND, may be Pupil Premium, whatever. OP hasn’t got any actual knowledge of why these children are being asked to join (many of them may be PP children for all she knows, with cross-funding from PP).

What is strange to me is that no matter how many times I or other posters who work in the field explain that this is not just perfectly normal practice in primary schools, but is also actively considered good practice, you seem to persist in thinking that it’s some kind of occult discrimination. What is wrong with schools targeting a group of kids with the aim of helping them move up to a higher SATS banding they may be capable of getting, which is good for their potential and for the school’s results? That in itself is not evidence of discrimination. The school’s obligation to provide SEND and other forms of support and intervention to other ability bands is not a zero sum exercise. All primary schools have an obligation to focus on these, and a greater number of kids achieving greater depth isn’t going to outweigh a poor score achieving at the lower levels - they need to be targeting both (and the average kid in the middle!)

Most state primaries are at the moment devoting enormous amounts of resources to SEND and bringing up pupils to the required standard - they rarely have the resources to deliver interventions for GD students, and where they are, you usually find it’s being done in the free time of one of the head of subject Y5/6 teachers with an interest in this. They are not necessarily (in fact are probably rarely) the teachers or TAs who are the ones specialised in delivering SEND/literacy support interventions.

The OP needs to find out why her daughter’s extra provision isn’t happening. But it isn’t likely to be not happening because other interventions are happening. As a pp said, most kids aren’t ’invited’ to join sensory circuits or specific lunchtime activities delivering 1-1 reading support, or small group phonics support in advance of the Phonics Check, for example. But that doesn’t mean they are somehow being discriminated against, or that it’s appropriate for every kid to be offered them who might want them, or that they are preventing support or enrichment for other kids.

Edited

Again, I am very familiar with data analytics. It's an ideological difference in opinion, I don't believe Education should be delivered in this way, particularly in primary school, I don't believe it is 'good' practice. Human brains are wired to perceive patterns, we observe patterns in things that don't necessarily exist, on that basis I am not convinced of the reliability of using data to label children as being 'top' particularly at the ages of 9 and 10.

Electrickittens · 08/11/2026 17:17

Goldenbear · 08/11/2026 17:13

Again, I am very familiar with data analytics. It's an ideological difference in opinion, I don't believe Education should be delivered in this way, particularly in primary school, I don't believe it is 'good' practice. Human brains are wired to perceive patterns, we observe patterns in things that don't necessarily exist, on that basis I am not convinced of the reliability of using data to label children as being 'top' particularly at the ages of 9 and 10.

Okay, so if a school can see that in one or two specific year-groups it has much fewer children achieving at greater depth than either the local LEA or national percentages would suggest ought to be the case, what should they do? Just say ‘ah, we’ll write off that bunch as just being a bit thicker than usual’?

Goldenbear · 08/11/2026 17:28

Electrickittens · 08/11/2026 17:17

Okay, so if a school can see that in one or two specific year-groups it has much fewer children achieving at greater depth than either the local LEA or national percentages would suggest ought to be the case, what should they do? Just say ‘ah, we’ll write off that bunch as just being a bit thicker than usual’?

Well that's the point I'm making you are looking at this from that perspective of what you want the data to show you, from the outset your biases are influencing who gets picked for this group. At 9 and 10 education should have a holistic approach, where the humans are the focus of attention, they are not reduced to things on a spreadsheet!

Electrickittens · 08/11/2026 18:14

Goldenbear · 08/11/2026 17:28

Well that's the point I'm making you are looking at this from that perspective of what you want the data to show you, from the outset your biases are influencing who gets picked for this group. At 9 and 10 education should have a holistic approach, where the humans are the focus of attention, they are not reduced to things on a spreadsheet!

But it’s the exact same data and process that will be used to identify the OP’s daughter, for example, as in need of targeted support.

WorkingMum90 · 09/11/2026 00:11

It's an after-school club because that's the only attention and stretch that academic kids get. In my experience the entire school day focuses on those who are struggling and primary school classes move at the speed of the slowest. The nice word for this is 'mastery' but it's very frustrating for the able kids to be constantly held back.

Maybe look at what support you can offer at home rather than lashing out and calling for others provision taken away? I can guarantee you the parents of the more able kids will have done work at home with them.

TillyGoat · 09/11/2026 09:49

To think extra lessons, complete focus of attention in the classroom away from other children, extra staff for 1:1 support, extra funding etc for struggling children isn't fair.

Are you getting it yet OP? If my child was getting so much extra support and taking up the school's time, there's no way I would begrudge other children getting a tiny bit of it.

TillyGoat · 09/11/2026 09:54

WorkingMum90 · 09/11/2026 00:11

It's an after-school club because that's the only attention and stretch that academic kids get. In my experience the entire school day focuses on those who are struggling and primary school classes move at the speed of the slowest. The nice word for this is 'mastery' but it's very frustrating for the able kids to be constantly held back.

Maybe look at what support you can offer at home rather than lashing out and calling for others provision taken away? I can guarantee you the parents of the more able kids will have done work at home with them.

Exactly this.

The entitlement by OP is shocking. They have time to complain that teachers are giving able kids some attention for once, but don't have time to help their kids themselves?
If my kid was behind I'd be doing everything in my power to get them to where they need to be. If I didn't think the free extra support they were getting was enough then I'd be spending money or my own time getting them up to speed.

Perhaps if more interest was taken in your child's learning before then maybe they wouldn't be struggling?

poetryandwine · 09/11/2026 10:26

TillyGoat · 09/11/2026 09:54

Exactly this.

The entitlement by OP is shocking. They have time to complain that teachers are giving able kids some attention for once, but don't have time to help their kids themselves?
If my kid was behind I'd be doing everything in my power to get them to where they need to be. If I didn't think the free extra support they were getting was enough then I'd be spending money or my own time getting them up to speed.

Perhaps if more interest was taken in your child's learning before then maybe they wouldn't be struggling?

At least play fair and read OP’s posts properly. She is investing plenty of money and effort into extracurricular help for her DD.

TillyGoat · 09/11/2026 11:25

poetryandwine · 09/11/2026 10:26

At least play fair and read OP’s posts properly. She is investing plenty of money and effort into extracurricular help for her DD.

If that along with the extra resources being poured into her child isn't enough to get them to the expected standard then perhaps it's time to look at special schools?!