Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think extra lessons for top students isn’t fair?

775 replies

Beepboobeep · 02/11/2026 21:12

My DD’s state primary school has a “top maths club” and “great writers club” for the top performing students in yr 5 and 6 held outside of school hours. There is no charge for this - so it’s free childcare and free tutoring. You have to be invited. This has been running since the second week of the school year and is restarting on the first day of this half term.

By contrast, my dyslexic DD is in a group for those needing more support in writing, also outside of school hours. But they only managed 2 sessions last year and it hasn’t started back up this year. She gets ad hoc in school support; where it happens she misses other lessons that aren’t then caught up on, putting her further behind in the those.

I appreciate these children deserve challenging, but surely that could be done in class with different work and the teacher’s out of hours time, if available, used to help those struggling?

Is this even allowed in a state primary?

OP posts:
Goldenbear · 06/11/2026 11:39

Wonderfrau · 06/11/2026 09:36

OP placed the club names in inverted commas, suggesting these were not the actual names?

But, even if they were, do you think pupils and more importantly parents would happily attend an ASC club called “Maths Strugglers” or “Could be a bit dim, English.”

I have led groups called Maths Wizards and Monkey Puzzlers, together with many sports teams of different abilities. They were never called fast and slow, even though this is how they were categorised, and the attendees were neither wizards nor monkeys. The more able pupils are never designated as ‘Top’ or ‘Best.’ That’s just not how state primary schools operate.

I quite frankly don’t believe the OP. I think she has filled in the unknowns with her own assumptions. Your post suggests you have not recently worked in a state primary school either.

In British English, single inverted commas can be used to refer to a name of something, like a group.

Goldenbear · 06/11/2026 11:41

Wonderfrau · 06/11/2026 09:36

OP placed the club names in inverted commas, suggesting these were not the actual names?

But, even if they were, do you think pupils and more importantly parents would happily attend an ASC club called “Maths Strugglers” or “Could be a bit dim, English.”

I have led groups called Maths Wizards and Monkey Puzzlers, together with many sports teams of different abilities. They were never called fast and slow, even though this is how they were categorised, and the attendees were neither wizards nor monkeys. The more able pupils are never designated as ‘Top’ or ‘Best.’ That’s just not how state primary schools operate.

I quite frankly don’t believe the OP. I think she has filled in the unknowns with her own assumptions. Your post suggests you have not recently worked in a state primary school either.

I have never worked in a state primary school, I am not a teacher, I don't think I ever suggested I was.

Goldenbear · 06/11/2026 11:42

Scarcityvarcity · 06/11/2026 10:04

Maybe it happens somewhere like Kent where i think they still have the old grammar/secondary modern system but totally disagree that this it how it works in areas where there are just a few grammar schools, most DC go to comprehensives and some will actively choose a comprehensive over a grammar. You don't even live in a grammar school area and you don't have children in a grammar school. Why do you think you know so much more about it than someone with actual experience?

Perhaps she can read!

Scarcityvarcity · 06/11/2026 11:46

Goldenbear · 06/11/2026 11:42

Perhaps she can read!

Read what? Opinions from other people who also don't have children at grammar school?

poetryandwine · 06/11/2026 11:58

Goldenbear · 06/11/2026 11:42

Perhaps she can read!

I’ve told @Scarcityvarcity and others repeatedly my family have loads of experience with this. As a former admissions tutor in a very high tariff degree programme I have had plenty of opportunity to interact formally and informally with grammar school leadership and to learn their formal and informal processes. I am also rather familiar with FOI processes.

I have never given MumsNet much indication where in England I live, and won’t do so now.

Scarcityvarcity · 06/11/2026 12:04

poetryandwine · 06/11/2026 11:58

I’ve told @Scarcityvarcity and others repeatedly my family have loads of experience with this. As a former admissions tutor in a very high tariff degree programme I have had plenty of opportunity to interact formally and informally with grammar school leadership and to learn their formal and informal processes. I am also rather familiar with FOI processes.

I have never given MumsNet much indication where in England I live, and won’t do so now.

Talking to grammar school leadership about their processes won't tell you that primary schools are tutoring pupils or what parents do or don't know "on the grapevine". Regardless as you are so familiar with the process and are sure the clubs are to help children get into grammar schools do you not wonder why these clubs include year 6 as well as year 5?

poetryandwine · 06/11/2026 12:14

Scarcityvarcity · 06/11/2026 12:04

Talking to grammar school leadership about their processes won't tell you that primary schools are tutoring pupils or what parents do or don't know "on the grapevine". Regardless as you are so familiar with the process and are sure the clubs are to help children get into grammar schools do you not wonder why these clubs include year 6 as well as year 5?

Show me where I have said I am sure. I have simply raised the possibility and said that as someone who likes a bet, in the absence of an explanation that’s where I would put my money.

It is possible there is an explanation OP has not mentioned and may not know. The only plausible counter-suggestion IIRC is that these are the children working towards Greater Depth, in which case the lack of parity for the children working towards standards seems wrong.

That was a suggestion from someone who knows no more than me, and contradicts OP’s claim that these groups are for top pupils.

I have described family background above and I have no idea why you think grammar school leadership are ignorant of the grapevine.

Now stop putting words in my mouth.

Scarcityvarcity · 06/11/2026 12:21

poetryandwine · 06/11/2026 12:14

Show me where I have said I am sure. I have simply raised the possibility and said that as someone who likes a bet, in the absence of an explanation that’s where I would put my money.

It is possible there is an explanation OP has not mentioned and may not know. The only plausible counter-suggestion IIRC is that these are the children working towards Greater Depth, in which case the lack of parity for the children working towards standards seems wrong.

That was a suggestion from someone who knows no more than me, and contradicts OP’s claim that these groups are for top pupils.

I have described family background above and I have no idea why you think grammar school leadership are ignorant of the grapevine.

Now stop putting words in my mouth.

Why would you bet it is to do with grammar school tuition rather than SATs though given the clubs are for both year 5 and 6? And why would grammar school leadership specifically know what parents at primary schools (not even their schools) are talking about?

Goldenbear · 06/11/2026 12:29

poetryandwine · 06/11/2026 11:58

I’ve told @Scarcityvarcity and others repeatedly my family have loads of experience with this. As a former admissions tutor in a very high tariff degree programme I have had plenty of opportunity to interact formally and informally with grammar school leadership and to learn their formal and informal processes. I am also rather familiar with FOI processes.

I have never given MumsNet much indication where in England I live, and won’t do so now.

I think it's very clear you have a greater insight than many for the reasons you have explained. It's really clear that is the case and I'm unsure why your position is being dismissed.

I gave the example of Kent grammars but I don't live in Kent. I also gave the example of The Tiffin Girl's School because if posters on this thread Googled it an FOI was submitted regarding this very question and they responded. This likely proves that parents very much do submit FOIs on this topic, to understand how to gain an advantage presumably.

Dandelion456 · 06/11/2026 12:45

Children who struggle at school should have the support they need to reach the expected standard. It seems like the children who need the most help and attention receive it during school hours. If that’s not happening at the school, then that should absolutely be questioned. Targeting resources for other children isn’t the answer to that.

I wish that my son’s school had something like this. He loves learning and challenge but feels that school offers very little of it. I can see that it’s starting to affect him now, after years of hoping for more. We try to be realistic and respectful of the fact that there are other children who need those resources more, but it’s also difficult to watch your own child lose their love of learning.

Scarcityvarcity · 06/11/2026 12:55

Goldenbear · 06/11/2026 12:29

I think it's very clear you have a greater insight than many for the reasons you have explained. It's really clear that is the case and I'm unsure why your position is being dismissed.

I gave the example of Kent grammars but I don't live in Kent. I also gave the example of The Tiffin Girl's School because if posters on this thread Googled it an FOI was submitted regarding this very question and they responded. This likely proves that parents very much do submit FOIs on this topic, to understand how to gain an advantage presumably.

Have you looked at the FOI answer? It lists the primary schools in the area and states "more than one student may have come from the school below". Not exactly informative and the fact that one parent asked doesn't prove anything either.

FirmSnake · 06/11/2026 14:32

Goldenbear · 06/11/2026 11:32

You have taken my reply out of context which was in response to someone else trying to justify the insincere purpose of this group, spread like rancid butter over the surface of 'targeted support'.

It isn't out of context. We can all read the quote history. I just think you're being daft.

Timeforachange26 · 06/11/2026 14:38

Scarcityvarcity · 06/11/2026 12:55

Have you looked at the FOI answer? It lists the primary schools in the area and states "more than one student may have come from the school below". Not exactly informative and the fact that one parent asked doesn't prove anything either.

In Kent about 25% of kids attend grammar schools so the information wouldn't really be mulch use there

JudgeJ · 06/11/2026 14:41

NiaAndFar · 04/11/2026 16:28

It's not fair on the teachers expected to run these sessions , that's for sure!

I ran extra lessons for those aiming for the highest GCSE grades, it was helpful for them (hopefully) but it was also a pleasure for me to be able to teach without dealing with the dross who couldn't care less, it reminded me of why I went into teaching. There were no problems working at lunchtime or after school with those who tried but still needed some extra help, it was the dross I could have cared less about.

Wonderfrau · 06/11/2026 14:52

Beepboobeep · 02/11/2026 21:12

My DD’s state primary school has a “top maths club” and “great writers club” for the top performing students in yr 5 and 6 held outside of school hours. There is no charge for this - so it’s free childcare and free tutoring. You have to be invited. This has been running since the second week of the school year and is restarting on the first day of this half term.

By contrast, my dyslexic DD is in a group for those needing more support in writing, also outside of school hours. But they only managed 2 sessions last year and it hasn’t started back up this year. She gets ad hoc in school support; where it happens she misses other lessons that aren’t then caught up on, putting her further behind in the those.

I appreciate these children deserve challenging, but surely that could be done in class with different work and the teacher’s out of hours time, if available, used to help those struggling?

Is this even allowed in a state primary?

What is a teacher’s ‘out of hours time’ in a state primary?

Endorewitch · 06/11/2026 14:54

Bright kids also have special needs. They can become disruptive otherwise.
But outside agencies are suposed to offer help to kids with other problems. Sorry you are being let down by system. But for children with special needd apart from gifted kids,the school needs help and guidance.

Goldenbear · 06/11/2026 15:44

Timeforachange26 · 06/11/2026 14:38

In Kent about 25% of kids attend grammar schools so the information wouldn't really be mulch use there

What do you mean, it wouldn't be much use?

Goldenbear · 06/11/2026 15:46

FirmSnake · 06/11/2026 14:32

It isn't out of context. We can all read the quote history. I just think you're being daft.

There are huge number of 'daft' posters on this thread but I'm not one of them!

Wonderfrau · 06/11/2026 18:41

Goldenbear · 06/11/2026 11:39

In British English, single inverted commas can be used to refer to a name of something, like a group.

OP didn’t use single inverted commas.

Also from AI : The specific, official name of a particular group or team is a proper noun and does not require inverted commas.

You should only use inverted commas with a group name in specific, rare contexts:

  • Scare Quotes / Irony: If you are expressing skepticism about whether the group is legitimate (e.g., the so-called "charity").
  • …
  • Nicknames: If the group goes by an informal, unofficial nickname (in this case, one that the OP may have created herself)

So OPs use of inverted commas changes the meaning and can quite strongly be interpreted as her demonstrating her skepticism and could be the nicknames she herself has attributed to the groups.

I’m not sure why she would use inverted commas otherwise?

And whilst it’s clear you have not worked in a state primary, there is no shame in that. You and #Poetryandwine can have infinite experience of grammar schools, STEM academia, ‘very high tariff degree programmes’, ‘grammar school leadership,' Tiffin School and Kent in general, whilst at the same time have absolutely no clue how most state primary schools operate.

It is wonderful that this state school is offering any ASCs for pupils, when there is no obligation to do so. A teacher has clearly decided/ been compelled by senior leadership to give up their own free time to run the club.

None of us actually know what these clubs are for: 11+ (unlikely, as schools will not devote resources and teacher goodwill for free for results which are not published/ have no impact on the school itself. Also, as I understand this year’s tests have concluded in most areas,) SATs boosters (seems a bit early in the year for this), Expected Standard or Greater Depth target groups (OP will have no idea how well these children are actually performing in assessments) or simply, plain exploration and enrichment (I hope it is this.)

Whoever agreed to do the club that DDs daughter attended briefly last year doesn’t want to or can’t do it anymore. Many ASCs run for a short period of time and are not statutory provision. Members of staff leave, their roles change, their private lives and responsibilities change and clubs fold. An after school English group for dyslexic children would not be massively popular.

The above ASCs are a separate issue to SEN provision during lesson time. If OP is dissatisfied with the support her daughter currently gets, she should enquire again whether this is likely to change. She’s said she’s moving her daughter. I hope she has agreed a programme of support in advance of that move, although smaller class sizes in a private setting will almost certainly help. A dyslexia diagnosis alone does not automatically garner significant adult intervention in state schools, although she should expect adaptation in class. What does OPs plan advise is needed? Without an EHCP, I’m guessing the school does not have additional resources for extra adult support/intervention. The TAs that used to provide this support are no longer employed and the remaining ones are dealing with the behaviour or significant learning needs of other pupils.

Does anybody have advice for Op, so she can get the extra hours childcare she’s missing. Also, how much does she need to set aside from her £500 weekly budget for specialist English support due to her DDs dyslexia (one hour per week). Unfortunately, not everyone has this option. Perhaps that is also why her DD is not considered a priority and given the amount OP is spending, I’m surprised she has any after school time free.

poetryandwine · 06/11/2026 20:23

Wonderfrau · 06/11/2026 18:41

OP didn’t use single inverted commas.

Also from AI : The specific, official name of a particular group or team is a proper noun and does not require inverted commas.

You should only use inverted commas with a group name in specific, rare contexts:

  • Scare Quotes / Irony: If you are expressing skepticism about whether the group is legitimate (e.g., the so-called "charity").
  • …
  • Nicknames: If the group goes by an informal, unofficial nickname (in this case, one that the OP may have created herself)

So OPs use of inverted commas changes the meaning and can quite strongly be interpreted as her demonstrating her skepticism and could be the nicknames she herself has attributed to the groups.

I’m not sure why she would use inverted commas otherwise?

And whilst it’s clear you have not worked in a state primary, there is no shame in that. You and #Poetryandwine can have infinite experience of grammar schools, STEM academia, ‘very high tariff degree programmes’, ‘grammar school leadership,' Tiffin School and Kent in general, whilst at the same time have absolutely no clue how most state primary schools operate.

It is wonderful that this state school is offering any ASCs for pupils, when there is no obligation to do so. A teacher has clearly decided/ been compelled by senior leadership to give up their own free time to run the club.

None of us actually know what these clubs are for: 11+ (unlikely, as schools will not devote resources and teacher goodwill for free for results which are not published/ have no impact on the school itself. Also, as I understand this year’s tests have concluded in most areas,) SATs boosters (seems a bit early in the year for this), Expected Standard or Greater Depth target groups (OP will have no idea how well these children are actually performing in assessments) or simply, plain exploration and enrichment (I hope it is this.)

Whoever agreed to do the club that DDs daughter attended briefly last year doesn’t want to or can’t do it anymore. Many ASCs run for a short period of time and are not statutory provision. Members of staff leave, their roles change, their private lives and responsibilities change and clubs fold. An after school English group for dyslexic children would not be massively popular.

The above ASCs are a separate issue to SEN provision during lesson time. If OP is dissatisfied with the support her daughter currently gets, she should enquire again whether this is likely to change. She’s said she’s moving her daughter. I hope she has agreed a programme of support in advance of that move, although smaller class sizes in a private setting will almost certainly help. A dyslexia diagnosis alone does not automatically garner significant adult intervention in state schools, although she should expect adaptation in class. What does OPs plan advise is needed? Without an EHCP, I’m guessing the school does not have additional resources for extra adult support/intervention. The TAs that used to provide this support are no longer employed and the remaining ones are dealing with the behaviour or significant learning needs of other pupils.

Does anybody have advice for Op, so she can get the extra hours childcare she’s missing. Also, how much does she need to set aside from her £500 weekly budget for specialist English support due to her DDs dyslexia (one hour per week). Unfortunately, not everyone has this option. Perhaps that is also why her DD is not considered a priority and given the amount OP is spending, I’m surprised she has any after school time free.

My understanding is that the 11+ for state grammar schools has concluded in most areas. However the entrance test season for independent schools is just beginning.

Papyrophile · 06/11/2026 20:39

hibernatinghedgehog · 03/11/2026 19:12

The number of children being categorised as SEN has skyrocketed in recent years

There hasn’t been such a big increase in the proportion of DC with SEN as some like to believe. The most recent statistics released this year show 20.8% of pupils have SEN. In 2010, it was 20.9% or 21.1% (depending on which statistics you look at - I think it is a rounding issue adding up SA, SA+ and SSEN). In 2005, it was 18%.

IQ average is defined at around 100, so 40% of the population will be above that and 40% below it. It should not be news to anyone capable of reading English at a level to pass GCSE (which is not a very high hurdle) that there are a lot of people who are intellectually incapable of doing work that requires much thought. It does not make them useless or only deserving of NMW. There are lots of jobs that need brawn that should be properly paid, but the number of openings are decreasing.

hibernatinghedgehog · 06/11/2026 20:41

Papyrophile · 06/11/2026 20:39

IQ average is defined at around 100, so 40% of the population will be above that and 40% below it. It should not be news to anyone capable of reading English at a level to pass GCSE (which is not a very high hurdle) that there are a lot of people who are intellectually incapable of doing work that requires much thought. It does not make them useless or only deserving of NMW. There are lots of jobs that need brawn that should be properly paid, but the number of openings are decreasing.

I’m not sure why you have quoted me? Your post isn’t anything to do with what I wrote. I didn’t mention IQ or jobs/wages.

Wonderfrau · 06/11/2026 21:25

poetryandwine · 06/11/2026 20:23

My understanding is that the 11+ for state grammar schools has concluded in most areas. However the entrance test season for independent schools is just beginning.

Yes, I think you are right. Independent’s tests go on until Jan/ Feb and even beyond, maybe?

Again, state primary schools/voluntary teachers are just as unlikely to be funding/offering tuition for independent school entrance tests as they are 11+ coaching. I briefly helped a friend’s child with entrance tests some years ago, for their confidence, but they were an able student who would have likely passed without any additional support anyway.

poetryandwine · 06/11/2026 21:36

Wonderfrau · 06/11/2026 21:25

Yes, I think you are right. Independent’s tests go on until Jan/ Feb and even beyond, maybe?

Again, state primary schools/voluntary teachers are just as unlikely to be funding/offering tuition for independent school entrance tests as they are 11+ coaching. I briefly helped a friend’s child with entrance tests some years ago, for their confidence, but they were an able student who would have likely passed without any additional support anyway.

We simply have no idea what this after school stuff is about. If OP had not suggested that the students were very strong I would think they were the ones approaching the ability to work at Greater Depth. As it is, nothing makes sense. Show me an oversubscribed primary school maths club!

Wonderfrau · 06/11/2026 21:50

This post has thrown up some really interesting facts for me.

Firstly, I had no idea that Kent still has the two tier system - I thought it had been phased out years ago. An amazing 30-31% of secondary school places in Kent are at Grammar school!

In the West Midlands this is 4% and accordingly, is much more competitive and highly selective.

Greater Manchester is 2%, although Trafford, within Greater Manchester, is 35% due to the exclusive concentration of grammar schools in that borough.

Fascinating stuff.