Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think extra lessons for top students isn’t fair?

775 replies

Beepboobeep · 02/11/2026 21:12

My DD’s state primary school has a “top maths club” and “great writers club” for the top performing students in yr 5 and 6 held outside of school hours. There is no charge for this - so it’s free childcare and free tutoring. You have to be invited. This has been running since the second week of the school year and is restarting on the first day of this half term.

By contrast, my dyslexic DD is in a group for those needing more support in writing, also outside of school hours. But they only managed 2 sessions last year and it hasn’t started back up this year. She gets ad hoc in school support; where it happens she misses other lessons that aren’t then caught up on, putting her further behind in the those.

I appreciate these children deserve challenging, but surely that could be done in class with different work and the teacher’s out of hours time, if available, used to help those struggling?

Is this even allowed in a state primary?

OP posts:
poetryandwine · 05/11/2026 11:20

Wonderfrau · 05/11/2026 11:11

You seem to think that state schools give a fig about 11+ examination success?

What benefit is there for the state schools to run an 11+ tutoring club? They are far more likely to use their stretched resources to provide clubs (that Ofsted would recognise as enrichment) that students themselves would like to attend after school.

Are you in the UK or US?

Edited

And yes, PP have said and I agree that good results at 11+ are a selling point in areas with grammar schools. OP and the families she discusses sound MC.

poetryandwine · 05/11/2026 11:29

Electrickittens · 05/11/2026 10:31

Do you know of any real world examples of an after (state) school programme of intellectual enrichment, that is not tuition under another name, for which entry is by invitation only? Teachers in my family, at excellent state schools in the UK and the US, consistently say that the problem is building enrolment. My post asking for such examples got no responses.

People have given examples, including music, sport and things like coding club in the case of my DD’s school. Over several years, DD’s ordinary state primary had teachers running a programme of after-school clubs including at various points, depending on individual teacher skills and interests (not all at the same time obviously): Italian club, robotics club, running club, netball club, school magazine, chess club, coding club, Go club, football club, softball club, recorder club, dance club, creative writing club, puzzle club, choir, Spanish club, and many others I’ve forgotten. DD didn’t get into all of them that she wanted to, as the school tried to make sure they weren’t all dominated by the same kids, but they could all be classified as “intellectual enrichment” in some way. Many primary schools offer clubs like this - and they have to do it if they want a good Ofsted rating, in any case. I don’t really know why you are finding it difficult to believe? Have you or the teachers in your family been involved in school governance recently? If so, they can surely tell you about clubs at their schools which are similar?

I’m also not sure what you mean by “the problem is building enrolment”. For the clubs above at DD’s school the problem was that too many kids inevitably wanted to go to each one. Hence the school operating an application and/or invitation system to make sure all the kids got a turn at something and the same kids didn’t suck up all the after-school activity time.

Edited

This is interesting.

As a practical matter, only a few of the activities you’ve mentioned are intellectual, though they all sound worthwhile. Are all children with extracurricular interests accommodated? To roughly the same extent?

The other PP who wrote of activities by invitation tended to write of band, competitive sport, drama (well, drama club should be open to everyone although objective auditions are a reasonable requirement). Activities with a public face.

Scarcityvarcity · 05/11/2026 11:35

poetryandwine · 05/11/2026 11:20

And yes, PP have said and I agree that good results at 11+ are a selling point in areas with grammar schools. OP and the families she discusses sound MC.

I don't think the results are a selling point at state schools. They aren't published. Schools are more interested in ofsted ratings, sats etc.

poetryandwine · 05/11/2026 11:37

Scarcityvarcity · 05/11/2026 11:35

I don't think the results are a selling point at state schools. They aren't published. Schools are more interested in ofsted ratings, sats etc.

I think the word gets around!

Scarcityvarcity · 05/11/2026 11:41

poetryandwine · 05/11/2026 11:37

I think the word gets around!

Word might get around but if results aren't published and a school and teaching is not officially judged on it why would they care?

Wonderfrau · 05/11/2026 11:42

poetryandwine · 05/11/2026 11:17

I am in the UK with family in both countries. Yes, some are involved in school governance.

Okay, thanks for confirming you are UK. I think the school governance question was a different PP?

Anyway, IME state schools do not have the funding or staff willing to volunteer their free time to coach children for 11+ exams. This is something that is usually done by parents.

Why would state primary school teachers provide 11+ tuition, which is normally offered by private tutors? It would be unusual for state primary schools to get involved in this, unless they are specifically advertising it as a USP, trying to recruit pupils in upper KS2, to attract parents keen to save private tutoring money. I suppose it’s possible but I’ve never heard of it in 20 years.

Some state primary schools do offer SATs booster classes near to examination time, but this is often to help students meet the expected standard, which is important to schools, in terms of their published results.

Students who are ‘working towards’ and unlikely to reach expected standard are unlikely to be invited, as a few booster sessions just prior to exams is unlikely to increase their mark sufficiently.

They may even offer some after school sessions to pupils who might be able to attain the ‘greater depth’ mark, if staff want to volunteer their own time.

Both of these additional support classes are likely to be invitation only, based on mock exam results and offered to pupils who are a few marks off the next grade boundary.

poetryandwine · 05/11/2026 11:48

Scarcityvarcity · 05/11/2026 11:41

Word might get around but if results aren't published and a school and teaching is not officially judged on it why would they care?

Are you familiar with the lengths some parents will go to in order to secure their DC a place at grammar school? Whether it us in the child’s best interests or not?

Goldenbear · 05/11/2026 11:54

Scarcityvarcity · 05/11/2026 11:35

I don't think the results are a selling point at state schools. They aren't published. Schools are more interested in ofsted ratings, sats etc.

You can easily work it through catchment areas, localities- something like only 3% of children attending Grammar schools are on FSM. The stakes are high to many of these parents so probable and likely they have submitted Freedom Of Information requests on historical data showing percentages of children from various local primary schools.

poetryandwine · 05/11/2026 11:57

Wonderfrau · 05/11/2026 11:42

Okay, thanks for confirming you are UK. I think the school governance question was a different PP?

Anyway, IME state schools do not have the funding or staff willing to volunteer their free time to coach children for 11+ exams. This is something that is usually done by parents.

Why would state primary school teachers provide 11+ tuition, which is normally offered by private tutors? It would be unusual for state primary schools to get involved in this, unless they are specifically advertising it as a USP, trying to recruit pupils in upper KS2, to attract parents keen to save private tutoring money. I suppose it’s possible but I’ve never heard of it in 20 years.

Some state primary schools do offer SATs booster classes near to examination time, but this is often to help students meet the expected standard, which is important to schools, in terms of their published results.

Students who are ‘working towards’ and unlikely to reach expected standard are unlikely to be invited, as a few booster sessions just prior to exams is unlikely to increase their mark sufficiently.

They may even offer some after school sessions to pupils who might be able to attain the ‘greater depth’ mark, if staff want to volunteer their own time.

Both of these additional support classes are likely to be invitation only, based on mock exam results and offered to pupils who are a few marks off the next grade boundary.

OP has said these are maths and writing activities for strong pupils, available by invitation only.

Not coding, robotics, chess, etc - enrichment activities - to the best of our understanding. Straight up maths and writing. Of course, our understanding is limited.

As a STEM academic from a strong maths-adjacent School it is my experience that those self selecting true extra curricular maths enrichment are generally able, enthusiastic learners. To exclude interested pupils seems barbaric to me, quite aside from OP’s initial point. I also believe the numbers for non-goal orientated maths enrichment would be manageable. Tuition for the 11+ would be a different matter, of course.

Goldenbear · 05/11/2026 11:59

poetryandwine · 05/11/2026 11:48

Are you familiar with the lengths some parents will go to in order to secure their DC a place at grammar school? Whether it us in the child’s best interests or not?

Exactly, it's hardly a rarity, you only have to look on here to see that!

Goldenbear · 05/11/2026 12:01

Wonderfrau · 05/11/2026 11:42

Okay, thanks for confirming you are UK. I think the school governance question was a different PP?

Anyway, IME state schools do not have the funding or staff willing to volunteer their free time to coach children for 11+ exams. This is something that is usually done by parents.

Why would state primary school teachers provide 11+ tuition, which is normally offered by private tutors? It would be unusual for state primary schools to get involved in this, unless they are specifically advertising it as a USP, trying to recruit pupils in upper KS2, to attract parents keen to save private tutoring money. I suppose it’s possible but I’ve never heard of it in 20 years.

Some state primary schools do offer SATs booster classes near to examination time, but this is often to help students meet the expected standard, which is important to schools, in terms of their published results.

Students who are ‘working towards’ and unlikely to reach expected standard are unlikely to be invited, as a few booster sessions just prior to exams is unlikely to increase their mark sufficiently.

They may even offer some after school sessions to pupils who might be able to attain the ‘greater depth’ mark, if staff want to volunteer their own time.

Both of these additional support classes are likely to be invitation only, based on mock exam results and offered to pupils who are a few marks off the next grade boundary.

People are responding to the OP, they are basing their replies on the information provided.

poetryandwine · 05/11/2026 12:03

Wonderfrau · 05/11/2026 11:42

Okay, thanks for confirming you are UK. I think the school governance question was a different PP?

Anyway, IME state schools do not have the funding or staff willing to volunteer their free time to coach children for 11+ exams. This is something that is usually done by parents.

Why would state primary school teachers provide 11+ tuition, which is normally offered by private tutors? It would be unusual for state primary schools to get involved in this, unless they are specifically advertising it as a USP, trying to recruit pupils in upper KS2, to attract parents keen to save private tutoring money. I suppose it’s possible but I’ve never heard of it in 20 years.

Some state primary schools do offer SATs booster classes near to examination time, but this is often to help students meet the expected standard, which is important to schools, in terms of their published results.

Students who are ‘working towards’ and unlikely to reach expected standard are unlikely to be invited, as a few booster sessions just prior to exams is unlikely to increase their mark sufficiently.

They may even offer some after school sessions to pupils who might be able to attain the ‘greater depth’ mark, if staff want to volunteer their own time.

Both of these additional support classes are likely to be invitation only, based on mock exam results and offered to pupils who are a few marks off the next grade boundary.

Booster sessions for pupils who may be capable of achieving the next grade would be a good idea, and a sensible use of the ‘invitation only’ principle. Thank you for raising this point.

Surely they should be offered equally to those who are ‘working towards’ and those who are capable of achieving ‘greater depth’? OP indicates after school provision only for the latter.

Newname26 · 05/11/2026 13:42

poetryandwine · 05/11/2026 10:19

I don’t think we have a good picture of what is going on at the school. I don’t think OP was tightly focused from one post to the next. Some of the responses were brutal and themselves poorly reasoned, which must have been hard on her.

I think you and I are coping with small gaps and inconsistencies from OP a bit differently, that’s all.

Do you know of any real world examples of an after (state) school programme of intellectual enrichment, that is not tuition under another name, for which entry is by invitation only? Teachers in my family, at excellent state schools in the UK and the US, consistently say that the problem is building enrolment. My post asking for such examples got no responses.

I would still bet that this is 11+ tuition under a different name. Your (?) point, or possibly @Electrickittens, that it is a good thing for state school children to receive any such tuition in school, in a gesture towards parity with children at independent schools, is excellent. And I recognise that open enrolment could cause chaos.

Nevertheless I think the larger points about meaningfully assessing the intelligence of young children, teachers’ unconscious biases, etc, are problematic enough that the enrichment should be done properly, open to all comers, or not at all.

How this interacts with OP’s concerns is a separate question. It is complex. One frustrating point is that we aren’t clear how much support is actually being provided to the DD in the classroom.

It will be impossible to gauge how much support is needed or given in the classroom.

If two kids have done the same work and got all the same answers but Ops child is spelt a zillion different ways and difficult to read, thats extra time the teacher needs to spend, making sense of it and trying to figure out whats actually written.

I remember being in awe of a teacher pointing out what my child had written "deoddel" was actually meant to be "people", with the ps upside down, extra p and the le the wrong way round.

poetryandwine · 05/11/2026 13:49

Newname26 · 05/11/2026 13:42

It will be impossible to gauge how much support is needed or given in the classroom.

If two kids have done the same work and got all the same answers but Ops child is spelt a zillion different ways and difficult to read, thats extra time the teacher needs to spend, making sense of it and trying to figure out whats actually written.

I remember being in awe of a teacher pointing out what my child had written "deoddel" was actually meant to be "people", with the ps upside down, extra p and the le the wrong way round.

Edited

This is awesome. The ability of good teachers to get inside children’s heads is a real gift.

Scarcityvarcity · 05/11/2026 14:54

poetryandwine · 05/11/2026 11:48

Are you familiar with the lengths some parents will go to in order to secure their DC a place at grammar school? Whether it us in the child’s best interests or not?

Obviously parents care!! I am talking about the schools. The numbers getting into grammar school isn't published and so schools aren't judged it and I don't think they care that much. I don't think word of mouth would be very accurate either. I didn't know exactly how many children could have gone to a grammar in my DCs year if they wanted to. Some took the exams to keep their options open but ultimately chose different schools.

Scarcityvarcity · 05/11/2026 15:00

Goldenbear · 05/11/2026 11:54

You can easily work it through catchment areas, localities- something like only 3% of children attending Grammar schools are on FSM. The stakes are high to many of these parents so probable and likely they have submitted Freedom Of Information requests on historical data showing percentages of children from various local primary schools.

I don't think they could find out that sort of information from a freedom of information request. And some parents would have chosen a private school or local comprehensive even if their child did do well enough in the 11 plus to get in.

poetryandwine · 05/11/2026 15:16

We have an honest difference of opinion, @Scarcityvarcity .

NiaAndFar · 05/11/2026 15:32

poetryandwine · 05/11/2026 11:20

And yes, PP have said and I agree that good results at 11+ are a selling point in areas with grammar schools. OP and the families she discusses sound MC.

State schools are specifically prohibitedvfrom coaching for the 11+

poetryandwine · 05/11/2026 16:15

NiaAndFar · 05/11/2026 15:32

State schools are specifically prohibitedvfrom coaching for the 11+

Indeed.

Scarcityvarcity · 05/11/2026 16:40

poetryandwine · 05/11/2026 15:16

We have an honest difference of opinion, @Scarcityvarcity .

Yes, but what is your opinion based on? Do you live in a grammar school area and do your children go to a grammar school?

poetryandwine · 05/11/2026 17:28

Children in the family have, and are preparing to do so again. The family are involved in teaching and school governance.

Anyone can see that an after school programme in writing and maths, by invitation only, that does not have a purpose known to OP is ….. interesting. It isn’t like chess or coding or MFL, where PP described that at her DC’s school the invitations are allocated equitably. Furthermore, the latter are curricular enrichments.

Someone else suggested that perhaps these are children at the borderline of being able to work at Greater Depth, getting help with that. That’s possible, but then surely children working towards the expected standard should be offered the same opportunities, and it seems they are not. If this is the case, I understand OP’s distress.

If the opportunities in English and maths are enrichment for top children, modern research at least on the maths side favours breadth and depth rather than advancing through the curriculum. It is hard to see a pedagogical need for exclusivity, and I write as a STEM academic. Children are actually quite good at self selection. Would that Maths Club were overenrolled!

OTOH it is very easy to package an activity as enrichment when it is really implicit tuition for the 11+. I am not suggesting that the activity time is devoted to mock exams.

Scarcityvarcity · 05/11/2026 17:46

I'm not sure the fact that children in your family have been to grammar schools would give you much insight on this issue tbh. My parents, siblings and in laws certainly wouldn't have much of a clue. My children's primary school certainly didn't get involved in 11 plus tuition. They were interested in SATs and I think that is most likely what these lessons about as they are judged on this rather than on unpublished word of mouth and probably inaccurate information.

Edit: they did do extra lessons for sats in year 6.

Goldenbear · 05/11/2026 18:21

Scarcityvarcity · 05/11/2026 15:00

I don't think they could find out that sort of information from a freedom of information request. And some parents would have chosen a private school or local comprehensive even if their child did do well enough in the 11 plus to get in.

You absolutely can find that information out by submitting a FOI. Exemptions can be made but depending on how you ask the question, they would be hard pushed to refuse it.

Scarcityvarcity · 05/11/2026 18:29

Goldenbear · 05/11/2026 18:21

You absolutely can find that information out by submitting a FOI. Exemptions can be made but depending on how you ask the question, they would be hard pushed to refuse it.

Who would collate that information? And given that not everyone who passed grammar school exams would go i sm not sure it would be useful.

Scarcityvarcity · 05/11/2026 18:40

Actually, I just looked at my nearest primary school. It does give the percentage going to the nearest comprehensive and two grammar schools but 40 percent is "other" . Impossible to know if that means they went to another grammar, independent or comprehensive.