Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think extra lessons for top students isn’t fair?

775 replies

Beepboobeep · 02/11/2026 21:12

My DD’s state primary school has a “top maths club” and “great writers club” for the top performing students in yr 5 and 6 held outside of school hours. There is no charge for this - so it’s free childcare and free tutoring. You have to be invited. This has been running since the second week of the school year and is restarting on the first day of this half term.

By contrast, my dyslexic DD is in a group for those needing more support in writing, also outside of school hours. But they only managed 2 sessions last year and it hasn’t started back up this year. She gets ad hoc in school support; where it happens she misses other lessons that aren’t then caught up on, putting her further behind in the those.

I appreciate these children deserve challenging, but surely that could be done in class with different work and the teacher’s out of hours time, if available, used to help those struggling?

Is this even allowed in a state primary?

OP posts:
Bellsandthistle · 04/11/2026 18:09

The school has to provide evidence they are stretching the more able. No doubt there is a teacher who has this as a performance management target and has volunteered their own unpaid time to run this club. It’s nothing to do with SEND.

Wadsworthy · 04/11/2026 18:11

MushMonster · 04/11/2026 17:45

I think OP should focus on getting support for her struggling DD, instead of criticising any extra lessons that anyone else gets or does not get. It is really none of her business. And nobody can tell a volunteer what to do with their time, because this extra maths time the school is currently offering is on the teachers own time, no expense to the parents.
Why not joining forces with the parents of other struggling pupils to either support the teacher that had started the extra lessons for struggling children or find someone else to tutor them a bit?

One of the best posts on this thread! Excellent advice!

Wendywoopp · 04/11/2026 18:11

ACynicalDad · 03/11/2026 19:46

Teachers are giving up their own time this is extra time that is not depriving your child of anything. I’m sure the teachers get a lot of pleasure from doing this and build relationships with kids who they hope will achieve greater depth in their stats which will be a development point for the school, just as helping your child to reach the expected standard will be. There is probably some guilt that the most able children children are often not getting the support they would ideally get in school hours.

This is what drives me a bit mad. Teachers are literally having to plan and resource these extra lessons and give up their very little time to do it. They’ll be working far later in the evening as a result, probably taking them away from their own families. Someone will always complain it’s not enough. I don’t know why some schools don’t just lock the doors up at 3:30pm and tell every one to clear off. Give them something to actually moan about.

Wendywoopp · 04/11/2026 18:24

Squeakytoys · 02/11/2026 21:53

I am sure it's a factor. We compromised by treating primary school as predominantly about social skills /childcare and having tutors so he could get the stretch he wanted and enjoyed.
But it was dispiriting that about 50% of his primary school teachers would tie themselves in knots to come up with reasons not to stretch him in class time.

It’s pretty simple why he couldn’t be stretched and that’s because there’s one adult to 30 children. All with wildly different needs and abilities. They can’t teach 5 different lessons at once.

Wadsworthy · 04/11/2026 18:33

I think if @Beepboobeep had phrased her OP better, she'd have had a lot more support and some good advice from other parents of dyslexic DC. She has a reasonable complaint, but she has expressed it very unreasonably.

She could have asked about strategies to put (gentle then tough) pressure on the school to provide the sessions she knows they should be providing, and ask for other parents' experiences of this and their successes.

Instead, she blames the lack of sessions for her DD on the sessions for other categories of children. Not a good strategy.

Wadsworthy · 04/11/2026 18:40

Wendywoopp · 04/11/2026 18:24

It’s pretty simple why he couldn’t be stretched and that’s because there’s one adult to 30 children. All with wildly different needs and abilities. They can’t teach 5 different lessons at once.

This is why I think it's a pity that setting and streaming at secondary school have mostly been done away with. My secondary school (bog standard comprehensive) in the 1970s streamed us from 1st form onwards. We still had English, Maths and Science classes of up to 40 pupils, but at least if you were in the top set of your year, people put their heads down and worked, and the teachers could push us, quite hard, because we were supposedly the top pupils!

Squeakytoys · 04/11/2026 19:44

Wadsworthy · 04/11/2026 18:40

This is why I think it's a pity that setting and streaming at secondary school have mostly been done away with. My secondary school (bog standard comprehensive) in the 1970s streamed us from 1st form onwards. We still had English, Maths and Science classes of up to 40 pupils, but at least if you were in the top set of your year, people put their heads down and worked, and the teachers could push us, quite hard, because we were supposedly the top pupils!

My son's secondary streams for all the core subjects. The top sets provide a lovely learning environment

Notmycircusnotmyotter · 04/11/2026 20:55

Beepboobeep · 02/11/2026 21:15

Yes, but is it right to prioritise them over children who are struggling?

Edited

Yes. Not everything has to cater for lowest common denominator. Gifted children deserve support, especially in the state sector.

poetryandwine · 04/11/2026 21:08

Notmycircusnotmyotter · 04/11/2026 20:55

Yes. Not everything has to cater for lowest common denominator. Gifted children deserve support, especially in the state sector.

All children deserve appropriate support. It should not be provided to some at the apparent expense of others.

poetryandwine · 04/11/2026 21:09

Wadsworthy · 04/11/2026 18:33

I think if @Beepboobeep had phrased her OP better, she'd have had a lot more support and some good advice from other parents of dyslexic DC. She has a reasonable complaint, but she has expressed it very unreasonably.

She could have asked about strategies to put (gentle then tough) pressure on the school to provide the sessions she knows they should be providing, and ask for other parents' experiences of this and their successes.

Instead, she blames the lack of sessions for her DD on the sessions for other categories of children. Not a good strategy.

This is a fair point.

potenial · 04/11/2026 21:10

Goldenbear · 03/11/2026 21:28

By when- 9 and 10? Well all the research shows that rigid labels at a young age are highly unreliable and to predict what high achieving as opposed to exceptional pupils, will be achieving all A*s at GCSEs would be even more challenging. Given that there aren't many pupils, if any in some schools, achieving all 9s at GCSE your theory doesn't really bear out.

The point isn't these are the kids who'll be the smartest forever though. It's about the fact they're smart at the moment, and deserve to be stretched and challenged as such. The kids who are best at football at age 8 aren't necessarily going to be the best at 18, but that doesn't mean they shouldn't get to be in the team at 8, and get suitable training to the level they're at now!

poetryandwine · 04/11/2026 21:20

Mmmsnetter92 · 04/11/2026 17:31

Look at the OP's previous message:

Beepboobeep · 02/11/2026 21:33

but is it right or fair? Support for naturally gifted children without extra support at home fine. But these children’s parents already pay fortunes for out school tutoring

She isn't only referring to what the school offers and does seem to take issue with the fact the bright students' parents pay for external input.

I don’t read that as taking issue with the external support the able learners get. I think she is saying ‘Why is the school prioritisng children who are not struggling, [apparently] at the expense of those who are, when their parents also pay for outside tutoring?’

Genevieva · 04/11/2026 21:24

These are not free childcare or free tutoring. They are extension opportunities for children who have mastered everything in class. These children sit quietly day after day, receiving no attention at all because the teacher needs to focus on brining less able children up to speed. Back in the early 2000s there was a real push for gifted and talented educational opportunities, but they went after the financial crash. It’s really nice to hear of a primary school supporting 9-11 year olds this way.

Genevieva · 04/11/2026 21:34

Bellsandthistle · 04/11/2026 18:09

The school has to provide evidence they are stretching the more able. No doubt there is a teacher who has this as a performance management target and has volunteered their own unpaid time to run this club. It’s nothing to do with SEND.

I agree. A teacher giving their time free of charge getting flack for it. You couldn’t make it up. I’m so bored of the ‘special me’ mentality that has swept over this country in recent years. Notice how it was framed as ‘free childcare’ before anything else.

poetryandwine · 04/11/2026 21:55

Genevieva · 04/11/2026 21:24

These are not free childcare or free tutoring. They are extension opportunities for children who have mastered everything in class. These children sit quietly day after day, receiving no attention at all because the teacher needs to focus on brining less able children up to speed. Back in the early 2000s there was a real push for gifted and talented educational opportunities, but they went after the financial crash. It’s really nice to hear of a primary school supporting 9-11 year olds this way.

I wish we actually knew this. It is also possible that they are coaching for the 11+. Whilst the idea that a state school can even provide such tuition is refreshing, restricting entry seems ethically dubious to me (even if doing so is a practical necessity).

@Goldenbear has written correctly of how difficult it is to correctly identify the complicated components of intelligence in young children. Several of us see the damage that overtutoring causes.

Several others write that grammars must be able to select properly because they have better GCSE and A level outcomes than nonselective schools. We never said the 11+ and similar assessments are worthless at scale. Even if you are able to select pupils within the top half of their cohort - and grammars aim quite a bit higher than this - of course you will get better results.

It doesn’t mean that the primary teachers are necessarily identifying the right children to put forward.

I keep wondering if entry would be restricted to ‘invitation only’ for anything except 11+ tuition. Is anyone aware of an existing programme of academic enrichment for primary children (for tuition is really something different) that is so restricted? Yes, I know about musical groups, etc - I am looking for an academic example.

Electrickittens · 04/11/2026 22:21

poetryandwine · 04/11/2026 21:55

I wish we actually knew this. It is also possible that they are coaching for the 11+. Whilst the idea that a state school can even provide such tuition is refreshing, restricting entry seems ethically dubious to me (even if doing so is a practical necessity).

@Goldenbear has written correctly of how difficult it is to correctly identify the complicated components of intelligence in young children. Several of us see the damage that overtutoring causes.

Several others write that grammars must be able to select properly because they have better GCSE and A level outcomes than nonselective schools. We never said the 11+ and similar assessments are worthless at scale. Even if you are able to select pupils within the top half of their cohort - and grammars aim quite a bit higher than this - of course you will get better results.

It doesn’t mean that the primary teachers are necessarily identifying the right children to put forward.

I keep wondering if entry would be restricted to ‘invitation only’ for anything except 11+ tuition. Is anyone aware of an existing programme of academic enrichment for primary children (for tuition is really something different) that is so restricted? Yes, I know about musical groups, etc - I am looking for an academic example.

Coding and robotics were restricted/invitation only clubs in my DD’s primary, for example. DD was a bit miffed that she wasn’t chosen, but to be honest she wouldn’t actually have been that interested. Coding isn’t her interest or her strength. That doesn’t mean I went and complained to the school that they shouldn’t offer it to other children.

Ofsted will be looking at whether a school is actually stretching GD children. The school is supposed to be offering these children differentiated opportunities. If they can’t do that within a lesson, a club may be another way of showing that they are doing this. Why do you think this is somehow illegitimate? It also doesn’t seem from the OP’s post that this is “tutoring for the 11+” — she describes a maths and writing club aimed at both Y5 and Y6 children.

On the testing front - it’s a bit of wishful thinking to suggest that testing at the transition between primary and secondary has no relation to later academic success. We might not like it, but there are high correlations between scores on KS3 adaptive aptitude tests like MIDYIS, and later GCSE / A-level points scores. These also tend to map on to SATS / CAT4 scores at the high range, with an even better correlation in the higher stanines. Of course this isn’t determinative or true in every case (that’s not how statistics work); but this style of test is also used very effectively to pinpoint children who are struggling in the lower stanines and who needs specific kinds of support, and/or have specific learning challenges.

Tiredmama53 · 04/11/2026 22:23

Beepboobeep · 02/11/2026 21:36

Happy for them to have clubs if those that need it have support first.

You keep saying 'if those that need support have it'. Gifted children do need support. The gifted childrens academic potential is higher than your childs. In the same way your child isn't meeting their potential the gift children in our schools generally aren't either because classes have to be taught at a level for the majority.

Genevieva · 04/11/2026 23:06

poetryandwine · 04/11/2026 21:55

I wish we actually knew this. It is also possible that they are coaching for the 11+. Whilst the idea that a state school can even provide such tuition is refreshing, restricting entry seems ethically dubious to me (even if doing so is a practical necessity).

@Goldenbear has written correctly of how difficult it is to correctly identify the complicated components of intelligence in young children. Several of us see the damage that overtutoring causes.

Several others write that grammars must be able to select properly because they have better GCSE and A level outcomes than nonselective schools. We never said the 11+ and similar assessments are worthless at scale. Even if you are able to select pupils within the top half of their cohort - and grammars aim quite a bit higher than this - of course you will get better results.

It doesn’t mean that the primary teachers are necessarily identifying the right children to put forward.

I keep wondering if entry would be restricted to ‘invitation only’ for anything except 11+ tuition. Is anyone aware of an existing programme of academic enrichment for primary children (for tuition is really something different) that is so restricted? Yes, I know about musical groups, etc - I am looking for an academic example.

Based on the OP it is reasonable to answer on the assumptions motion that these are what she describes - maths and writing for the most able children.

It’s a long time ago, but I went to a primary school in a grammar area and they didn’t give a fig about the 11+. Most kids wouldn’t get in, so it wasn’t their priority. I don’t think I was even aware I was taking it until shortly beforehand. I know the world has changed, but if anything it has moved more towards putting all efforts into under achievers and SEN. There’s no funding for stretching able children any more. Consequently, it’s reasonable to assume the teacher is doing this of their own volition on a voluntary basis. The longterm academic potential of the kids is irrelevant. This is about who the teacher judges needs a little extra stretch now. That’s his / her prerogative. If they had to open it to everyone, it would defeat the point and they’d probably rather go home earlier. The OP framed it first as free childcare, which shows that missing out on a quiet creative writing or challenging maths session is not her concern.

firef1y · 04/11/2026 23:20

Ok as someone who was at the higher academic ability end of the spectrum, I am going to say that I would have greatly benefited from those.sessions. I was bored in school, which meant I would sometimes simply not bother going.

I was extremely lucky in junior school, it was recognised that I was above average academically and I was given extra work, and spent time each week in a special class. What wasn't recognised is that in common with a lot of girls with a higher than average IQ, I am autistic.

I went to a grammar school, but because everyone was more academically gifted than average (this was over 40 years ago. Everyone took the 11+, we spent time from the 1st year juniors learning how to do the verbal reasoning, maths etc as a whole class) it was kind of ignored that I was bored the whole time. I only passed my GCSEs to annoy the teachers who said I was going to fail (I am still very good at exams), was regularly bunking off and labelled as naughty.

Sorry long essay, but long story short, 40+ years ago it was recognised that a proportion of academically gifted children also have extra needs and need support to reach their full potential

Mmmsnetter92 · 05/11/2026 09:25

poetryandwine · 04/11/2026 21:20

I don’t read that as taking issue with the external support the able learners get. I think she is saying ‘Why is the school prioritisng children who are not struggling, [apparently] at the expense of those who are, when their parents also pay for outside tutoring?’

She literally says she thinks it's fine for gifted children, who do not receive extra support at home, to receive support from school. She then says these children's parents already pay fortunes for out of school tutoring.

Surely, she's therefore saying it's not fine for gifted children, who do receive extra support at home, to receive support from school. And the children invited to these extra curricular sessions are such children (i.e. their parents are paying fortunes for out of school tutoring).

I'm not sure what I'm missing here (genuinely) but appreciate something may well be going over my head.

Ultimately, I don't think it's at all relevant what parents are paying for their children to do in their free time and I'm not sure why the OP has referenced it at all. It also seems a very strange decision, whilst she spends £2k per month on her own DD's extra curriculars.

poetryandwine · 05/11/2026 10:19

Mmmsnetter92 · 05/11/2026 09:25

She literally says she thinks it's fine for gifted children, who do not receive extra support at home, to receive support from school. She then says these children's parents already pay fortunes for out of school tutoring.

Surely, she's therefore saying it's not fine for gifted children, who do receive extra support at home, to receive support from school. And the children invited to these extra curricular sessions are such children (i.e. their parents are paying fortunes for out of school tutoring).

I'm not sure what I'm missing here (genuinely) but appreciate something may well be going over my head.

Ultimately, I don't think it's at all relevant what parents are paying for their children to do in their free time and I'm not sure why the OP has referenced it at all. It also seems a very strange decision, whilst she spends £2k per month on her own DD's extra curriculars.

I don’t think we have a good picture of what is going on at the school. I don’t think OP was tightly focused from one post to the next. Some of the responses were brutal and themselves poorly reasoned, which must have been hard on her.

I think you and I are coping with small gaps and inconsistencies from OP a bit differently, that’s all.

Do you know of any real world examples of an after (state) school programme of intellectual enrichment, that is not tuition under another name, for which entry is by invitation only? Teachers in my family, at excellent state schools in the UK and the US, consistently say that the problem is building enrolment. My post asking for such examples got no responses.

I would still bet that this is 11+ tuition under a different name. Your (?) point, or possibly @Electrickittens, that it is a good thing for state school children to receive any such tuition in school, in a gesture towards parity with children at independent schools, is excellent. And I recognise that open enrolment could cause chaos.

Nevertheless I think the larger points about meaningfully assessing the intelligence of young children, teachers’ unconscious biases, etc, are problematic enough that the enrichment should be done properly, open to all comers, or not at all.

How this interacts with OP’s concerns is a separate question. It is complex. One frustrating point is that we aren’t clear how much support is actually being provided to the DD in the classroom.

Electrickittens · 05/11/2026 10:31

Do you know of any real world examples of an after (state) school programme of intellectual enrichment, that is not tuition under another name, for which entry is by invitation only? Teachers in my family, at excellent state schools in the UK and the US, consistently say that the problem is building enrolment. My post asking for such examples got no responses.

People have given examples, including music, sport and things like coding club in the case of my DD’s school. Over several years, DD’s ordinary state primary had teachers running a programme of after-school clubs including at various points, depending on individual teacher skills and interests (not all at the same time obviously): Italian club, robotics club, running club, netball club, school magazine, chess club, coding club, Go club, football club, softball club, recorder club, dance club, creative writing club, puzzle club, choir, Spanish club, and many others I’ve forgotten. DD didn’t get into all of them that she wanted to, as the school tried to make sure they weren’t all dominated by the same kids, but they could all be classified as “intellectual enrichment” in some way. Many primary schools offer clubs like this - and they have to do it if they want a good Ofsted rating, in any case. I don’t really know why you are finding it difficult to believe? Have you or the teachers in your family been involved in school governance recently? If so, they can surely tell you about clubs at their schools which are similar?

I’m also not sure what you mean by “the problem is building enrolment”. For the clubs above at DD’s school the problem was that too many kids inevitably wanted to go to each one. Hence the school operating an application and/or invitation system to make sure all the kids got a turn at something and the same kids didn’t suck up all the after-school activity time.

Goldenbear · 05/11/2026 10:55

To me, the OP's scenario is an example of what is wrong with English (if it is in England) educational policy. The heavy influence of neo-liberal ideologies that promote individualism via standardised testing at young age, this alienates many from the learning process as only test results count. Schools 'should' have a moral mandate, they should reduce inequalities not widen them! In the current system those who are not 'high achievers', which is going to be the majority of the class, become teens who are further disengaged, who become adults who don't have a connection to their communities as from a very young age it's all been a competition! This is a problem when we want people to contribute to the economy and make a contribution to society, something we regularly see reported on in the news lately. It's a cultural problem since the Thatcher years and actually there are other ways of doing things. I have Danish family and the Education system they experienced is much better than here. The differentiation is done in the classroom, no special classes because education isn't a competition there it's inclusive and in the long run that is hugely beneficial to society.

Wonderfrau · 05/11/2026 11:11

poetryandwine · 05/11/2026 10:19

I don’t think we have a good picture of what is going on at the school. I don’t think OP was tightly focused from one post to the next. Some of the responses were brutal and themselves poorly reasoned, which must have been hard on her.

I think you and I are coping with small gaps and inconsistencies from OP a bit differently, that’s all.

Do you know of any real world examples of an after (state) school programme of intellectual enrichment, that is not tuition under another name, for which entry is by invitation only? Teachers in my family, at excellent state schools in the UK and the US, consistently say that the problem is building enrolment. My post asking for such examples got no responses.

I would still bet that this is 11+ tuition under a different name. Your (?) point, or possibly @Electrickittens, that it is a good thing for state school children to receive any such tuition in school, in a gesture towards parity with children at independent schools, is excellent. And I recognise that open enrolment could cause chaos.

Nevertheless I think the larger points about meaningfully assessing the intelligence of young children, teachers’ unconscious biases, etc, are problematic enough that the enrichment should be done properly, open to all comers, or not at all.

How this interacts with OP’s concerns is a separate question. It is complex. One frustrating point is that we aren’t clear how much support is actually being provided to the DD in the classroom.

You seem to think that state schools give a fig about 11+ examination success?

What benefit is there for the state schools to run an 11+ tutoring club? They are far more likely to use their stretched resources to provide clubs (that Ofsted would recognise as enrichment) that students themselves would like to attend after school.

Are you in the UK or US?

poetryandwine · 05/11/2026 11:17

Wonderfrau · 05/11/2026 11:11

You seem to think that state schools give a fig about 11+ examination success?

What benefit is there for the state schools to run an 11+ tutoring club? They are far more likely to use their stretched resources to provide clubs (that Ofsted would recognise as enrichment) that students themselves would like to attend after school.

Are you in the UK or US?

Edited

I am in the UK with family in both countries. Yes, some are involved in school governance.

Swipe left for the next trending thread