Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think extra lessons for top students isn’t fair?

775 replies

Beepboobeep · 02/11/2026 21:12

My DD’s state primary school has a “top maths club” and “great writers club” for the top performing students in yr 5 and 6 held outside of school hours. There is no charge for this - so it’s free childcare and free tutoring. You have to be invited. This has been running since the second week of the school year and is restarting on the first day of this half term.

By contrast, my dyslexic DD is in a group for those needing more support in writing, also outside of school hours. But they only managed 2 sessions last year and it hasn’t started back up this year. She gets ad hoc in school support; where it happens she misses other lessons that aren’t then caught up on, putting her further behind in the those.

I appreciate these children deserve challenging, but surely that could be done in class with different work and the teacher’s out of hours time, if available, used to help those struggling?

Is this even allowed in a state primary?

OP posts:
Arabelllllllla · 04/11/2026 11:50

ScrollingLeaves · 04/11/2026 11:37

People have to be given lessons because the national curriculum given out to all the children is at a lower/easier level than the 11+. They will not have not covered maths in the same way covering more complex problem solving, or read the sort of texts requiring nuanced inference for comprehension in English.

Thats not necessarily true. Plenty of kids (myself included) pass the 11+ without being given extra lessons. They don't have to be given extra support as they may already be bright enough.

The 11+ is looking for children that excel in logic, pattern recognition etc. These can be taught or they can be innate. The exams havent actually gotten harder over time, the issue now is that competition is fierce. Parents realise they can coach their kids through it, if they are of middling intelligence.

It was designed to tease out bright kids but I think the whole system isnt fit for purpose anymore.

GeneralPeter · 04/11/2026 11:56

Arabelllllllla · 04/11/2026 10:56

For 2 reasons; the first of which i think you missed in my post, which is that clearly the prep lessons are being applied inconsistently. Either all state schools do it, or none (in grammar school areas).

Secondly, I've alluded to it in another post but I went to a very good grammar school. My observation (and our life experience does inform our views, true of us all) was that the girls who were coached through the 11+ tended to struggle more than the girls who were naturally brighter. Same for those girls who got in on the sibling ticket (so they merely had to scrape a pass). It was a very academically competitive school, I actually do not think its fair to send your child to a school where they are going to struggle. I would not do it to my DC. If naturally bright enough I'd say "do the exam and see how you get on" rather than spending months coaching.

That's my personal opinion and it isnt related to state vs private.

I agree that it's unfair to put children into schools where they will struggle, and that over-coaching can produce that.

I think the best result is for everyone to get to a school (or a stream) that roughly matches their aptitude.

But I think having no school prep classes at all takes us further away from that.

That's because impossible (and imo undesirable) to completely ban coaching altogether. You will always have motivated parents who will coach.

So removing it from schools leads to the no-coaching children losing out to the some-coaching children in a way that doesn't reflect underlying aptitude either.

The reason I think that this leads to an even worse mismatch between school and ability is that I think you get a much bigger increase in performance by going from no-coaching to some-coaching than from some-coaching to excessive-coaching.

So, spread some-coaching as widely as possible, accept that you will get some excessive-coaching cases (which I think is inevitable under any scenario), but that the benefit is that you get a more even playing field for the rest.

AnExcessofConfidence · 04/11/2026 12:06

At my kid's school, it's two very different provisions. The clubs for kids that are ahead and might benefit from some new challenges are run by one teacher that volunteers her time and isn't the same SENCO specialised teacher that works with the children who need additional support. I don't think cutting off the provision for children in the advanced groups actually creates more provision for the kids in the additional needs groups.

Removing X creates more room for Y is a simple approach and I can see how you've landed on it, OP. But it is unlikely to be how it actually works.

And also, there are a few kids in the advanced groups who are extremely bright and also have dyslexia so I'm not sure the two are mutually exclusive of one another. Ditto I can think of at least one child who is diagnosed autistic and is in the advanced group for year 6 maths.

Final point: not sure it counts as childcare.

ScrollingLeaves · 04/11/2026 12:09

Arabelllllllla · 04/11/2026 11:50

Thats not necessarily true. Plenty of kids (myself included) pass the 11+ without being given extra lessons. They don't have to be given extra support as they may already be bright enough.

The 11+ is looking for children that excel in logic, pattern recognition etc. These can be taught or they can be innate. The exams havent actually gotten harder over time, the issue now is that competition is fierce. Parents realise they can coach their kids through it, if they are of middling intelligence.

It was designed to tease out bright kids but I think the whole system isnt fit for purpose anymore.

When did you do the 11+ @Arabelllllllla ?

I think there is a difference between coaching someone into being able to pass and introducing them to maths or English they have not experienced before.

In the 1960s early 1970s most people just took the exam one day and their everyday school work was the only tool they needed.

If so many are being coached or taught now it is probably more difficult for an equally bright child, but one who has no experience of what will be asked, to get in. All the more reason for school to help such children if they live in a grammar school area.

Arabelllllllla · 04/11/2026 13:53

GeneralPeter · 04/11/2026 11:56

I agree that it's unfair to put children into schools where they will struggle, and that over-coaching can produce that.

I think the best result is for everyone to get to a school (or a stream) that roughly matches their aptitude.

But I think having no school prep classes at all takes us further away from that.

That's because impossible (and imo undesirable) to completely ban coaching altogether. You will always have motivated parents who will coach.

So removing it from schools leads to the no-coaching children losing out to the some-coaching children in a way that doesn't reflect underlying aptitude either.

The reason I think that this leads to an even worse mismatch between school and ability is that I think you get a much bigger increase in performance by going from no-coaching to some-coaching than from some-coaching to excessive-coaching.

So, spread some-coaching as widely as possible, accept that you will get some excessive-coaching cases (which I think is inevitable under any scenario), but that the benefit is that you get a more even playing field for the rest.

Edited

I dont necessarily disagree with this approach. As you say, the problem is that parents are going to coach their kids regardless. Equality of opportunity (rather than outcome) is a good thing, I wouldnt argue against that.

It has to be that all schools offer these classes or none of them do.

Personally if I felt my kid wasn't cut out for the 11+ I just wouldn't make a big deal out of it. The OP and this thread shows me far too many parents want to push their children into extra lessons in the name of achievement without considering if its evening appropriate.

I genuinely think the 11+ isnt fit for purpose anymore with the way it's used now. The exam hasnt changed and there was not this level of coaching for it back in the 90s.

Scarcityvarcity · 04/11/2026 14:03

Arabelllllllla · 04/11/2026 11:50

Thats not necessarily true. Plenty of kids (myself included) pass the 11+ without being given extra lessons. They don't have to be given extra support as they may already be bright enough.

The 11+ is looking for children that excel in logic, pattern recognition etc. These can be taught or they can be innate. The exams havent actually gotten harder over time, the issue now is that competition is fierce. Parents realise they can coach their kids through it, if they are of middling intelligence.

It was designed to tease out bright kids but I think the whole system isnt fit for purpose anymore.

The gcse and a level results demonstrate the great majority at grammar schools are not just of middling intelligence. When did you go to a grammar school and was it in England?

Arabelllllllla · 04/11/2026 14:04

ScrollingLeaves · 04/11/2026 12:09

When did you do the 11+ @Arabelllllllla ?

I think there is a difference between coaching someone into being able to pass and introducing them to maths or English they have not experienced before.

In the 1960s early 1970s most people just took the exam one day and their everyday school work was the only tool they needed.

If so many are being coached or taught now it is probably more difficult for an equally bright child, but one who has no experience of what will be asked, to get in. All the more reason for school to help such children if they live in a grammar school area.

Im a millennial, I didnt take it in the 60s or 70s. I understand that it has changed since then.

"If so many are being coached or taught now it is probably more difficult for an equally bright child".....that's why it is no longer fit for purpose. That's my whole point.

Some kids will be bright and pass anyway. Some kids will be bright but need a few pointers on maths they haven't done before. I do understand what youre saying but this should be relatively limited.

As I've mentioned before, the problem is the kids who are going to struggle because they are not actually very bright. I encountered them at my own school.

One of my colleagues is taking weeks off to tutor their kid, and they have paid privately for a tutor. I was shocked to learn that is quite common now compared to when I took it. That is intensive and tells me there is a significant number of children for whom this system is not appropriate. It needs to be abolished or overhauled to meet children where they are at and actually test their aptitude without coaching.

Scarcityvarcity · 04/11/2026 14:07

I don't think heavy coaching for grammar makes much difference. The ones that get in will generally have had a bit to familiarise themselves with the questions. Parents can do that.

Scarcityvarcity · 04/11/2026 14:10

Arabelllllllla · 04/11/2026 14:04

Im a millennial, I didnt take it in the 60s or 70s. I understand that it has changed since then.

"If so many are being coached or taught now it is probably more difficult for an equally bright child".....that's why it is no longer fit for purpose. That's my whole point.

Some kids will be bright and pass anyway. Some kids will be bright but need a few pointers on maths they haven't done before. I do understand what youre saying but this should be relatively limited.

As I've mentioned before, the problem is the kids who are going to struggle because they are not actually very bright. I encountered them at my own school.

One of my colleagues is taking weeks off to tutor their kid, and they have paid privately for a tutor. I was shocked to learn that is quite common now compared to when I took it. That is intensive and tells me there is a significant number of children for whom this system is not appropriate. It needs to be abolished or overhauled to meet children where they are at and actually test their aptitude without coaching.

Without doubt there are nuts parents doing that amount of tutoring. It doesn't mean it works! Both my DC were at grammar schools not long ago and most class mates did about an hour a week for a few months before exams.

Timeforachange26 · 04/11/2026 14:28

Scarcityvarcity · 04/11/2026 14:07

I don't think heavy coaching for grammar makes much difference. The ones that get in will generally have had a bit to familiarise themselves with the questions. Parents can do that.

Yeah my dd2 had a few practise papers that I showed her how to do. Managed to get in the grammar, which is called a super selective

The exams aren't the same everywhere though. The kent one is a piece of piss in comparison with Essex. Both my kids in comprehensive schools in Essex tried old Kent papers and sailed through

Newname26 · 04/11/2026 15:50

I think its natural to want to help your kids when you see they are struggling.

However its also known a higher percentage of kids drop out of uni from the top schools than the average schools.
With the theory being they are coached and tutored through school then struggle at Uni.

poetryandwine · 04/11/2026 16:12

SweetnsourNZ · 04/11/2026 03:00

Surely what the parents of these children spend their money on is none of your business.

OP is contrasting the free after school, by invitation only, for certain able learners with the lack of provision for SEN children.

poetryandwine · 04/11/2026 16:14

Newname26 · 04/11/2026 15:50

I think its natural to want to help your kids when you see they are struggling.

However its also known a higher percentage of kids drop out of uni from the top schools than the average schools.
With the theory being they are coached and tutored through school then struggle at Uni.

This would seem to argue against tutoring students intensively for the 11+. I am also wary of that.

Emily3325 · 04/11/2026 16:14

Beepboobeep · 02/11/2026 21:44

They delight in telling me and their children love showing off to my DD (and telling her dyslexia isn’t real, I wonder where they heard that).

Who said I am not investing in her outside of school? Grammar school wouldn’t be right for her, but I pay £2,000 a month on extra curriculum clubs and tutoring for her. She will shortly be moving to private school.

Of course you do

I can guarantee that the school supports your child during the school day

NiaAndFar · 04/11/2026 16:28

It's not fair on the teachers expected to run these sessions , that's for sure!

poetryandwine · 04/11/2026 16:31

Emily3325 · 04/11/2026 16:14

Of course you do

I can guarantee that the school supports your child during the school day

Posters upthread have said that the availability of help for children with SEN varies quite a bit in practice.

Mmmsnetter92 · 04/11/2026 17:17

Arabelllllllla · 04/11/2026 10:17

I havent got experience of this as my DC is too young. But there are some replies on this thread indicating that actually some state schools do 11+ prep classes.

I think that's very wrong and I don't agree with it, also the inconsistency of it. Some schools do and some schools don't, our education system is a postcode lottery.

Why do you think it's wrong for primary schools to offer classes to help with the 11+?

Mmmsnetter92 · 04/11/2026 17:22

Arabelllllllla · 04/11/2026 10:56

For 2 reasons; the first of which i think you missed in my post, which is that clearly the prep lessons are being applied inconsistently. Either all state schools do it, or none (in grammar school areas).

Secondly, I've alluded to it in another post but I went to a very good grammar school. My observation (and our life experience does inform our views, true of us all) was that the girls who were coached through the 11+ tended to struggle more than the girls who were naturally brighter. Same for those girls who got in on the sibling ticket (so they merely had to scrape a pass). It was a very academically competitive school, I actually do not think its fair to send your child to a school where they are going to struggle. I would not do it to my DC. If naturally bright enough I'd say "do the exam and see how you get on" rather than spending months coaching.

That's my personal opinion and it isnt related to state vs private.

Offering some lessons on the 11+ is quite different to lengthy coaching.

Most children in primary school have never come across verbal and non-verbal reasoning, or has the opportunity to study Maths and English beyond Level 5.

I think there is a huge difference between giving students the opportunity to learn and hard-core coaching. I cannot imagine, for a moment, that a state primary school would have the resources to do the latter, so I think that's a bit of a non-issue.

As to parity across schools, whilst it would be wonderful if every school could offer every thing, it's just not feasible, but surely it's better than some do, rather than none, in which case the only students receiving support for the 11+ are those at prep school and / or whose parents can afford private tuition.

Mmmsnetter92 · 04/11/2026 17:27

Arabelllllllla · 04/11/2026 13:53

I dont necessarily disagree with this approach. As you say, the problem is that parents are going to coach their kids regardless. Equality of opportunity (rather than outcome) is a good thing, I wouldnt argue against that.

It has to be that all schools offer these classes or none of them do.

Personally if I felt my kid wasn't cut out for the 11+ I just wouldn't make a big deal out of it. The OP and this thread shows me far too many parents want to push their children into extra lessons in the name of achievement without considering if its evening appropriate.

I genuinely think the 11+ isnt fit for purpose anymore with the way it's used now. The exam hasnt changed and there was not this level of coaching for it back in the 90s.

I strongly disagree that there wasn't this sort of coaching in the 90s - the prep school, next door to my grammar school, put a lot into coaching their students for the entrance exam.

Mmmsnetter92 · 04/11/2026 17:31

poetryandwine · 04/11/2026 16:12

OP is contrasting the free after school, by invitation only, for certain able learners with the lack of provision for SEN children.

Look at the OP's previous message:

Beepboobeep · 02/11/2026 21:33

but is it right or fair? Support for naturally gifted children without extra support at home fine. But these children’s parents already pay fortunes for out school tutoring

She isn't only referring to what the school offers and does seem to take issue with the fact the bright students' parents pay for external input.

MushMonster · 04/11/2026 17:45

I think OP should focus on getting support for her struggling DD, instead of criticising any extra lessons that anyone else gets or does not get. It is really none of her business. And nobody can tell a volunteer what to do with their time, because this extra maths time the school is currently offering is on the teachers own time, no expense to the parents.
Why not joining forces with the parents of other struggling pupils to either support the teacher that had started the extra lessons for struggling children or find someone else to tutor them a bit?

Newname26 · 04/11/2026 17:46

Mmmsnetter92 · 04/11/2026 17:31

Look at the OP's previous message:

Beepboobeep · 02/11/2026 21:33

but is it right or fair? Support for naturally gifted children without extra support at home fine. But these children’s parents already pay fortunes for out school tutoring

She isn't only referring to what the school offers and does seem to take issue with the fact the bright students' parents pay for external input.

She also pays a fortune for extra stuff £2 grand a month

She obviously lives in a very affluent area.

Jllllllll · 04/11/2026 17:54

The school will want to challenge their most able children. They need evidence to support their teacher judgements and they also have to prove they are doing this and those children are not just coasting. They will probably enjoy it. A child who struggles will not.

Wendywoopp · 04/11/2026 18:08

Beepboobeep · 02/11/2026 21:12

My DD’s state primary school has a “top maths club” and “great writers club” for the top performing students in yr 5 and 6 held outside of school hours. There is no charge for this - so it’s free childcare and free tutoring. You have to be invited. This has been running since the second week of the school year and is restarting on the first day of this half term.

By contrast, my dyslexic DD is in a group for those needing more support in writing, also outside of school hours. But they only managed 2 sessions last year and it hasn’t started back up this year. She gets ad hoc in school support; where it happens she misses other lessons that aren’t then caught up on, putting her further behind in the those.

I appreciate these children deserve challenging, but surely that could be done in class with different work and the teacher’s out of hours time, if available, used to help those struggling?

Is this even allowed in a state primary?

In the current climate high achievers are often the most neglected. They are often the most conscientious and are rewarded by having to deal with everyone else’s issues and behaviour. They are usually very bored for hours but having to learn extreme patience. They are very often ignored completely and left to their own devices because they are able. I think it’s great they are getting some attention and some motivation. They are also doing it in their own time, when they likely could be doing something more fun. Good for them.

Wadsworthy · 04/11/2026 18:09

She isn't only referring to what the school offers and does seem to take issue with the fact the bright students' parents pay for external input.

Yet she then drip feeds a lot later in her posts that she herself spends over £2000 per month for extra tutoring for her DD.

Yes, of course the school should be providing appropriate support for a dyslexic child, but the whole tone of @Beepboobeep 's posts is of envy about the school providing opportunities for other DC as well.

Maybe, just maybe? the OP's DD isn't particularly academically gifted - with or without dyslexia - and the OP is unconsciously angry or bitter about this, but obviously can't blame anyone for her DD's lower academic achievement, and so rails against the gifted & talented kids and their parents.

The tall poppy syndrome is alive and well !

I bear the scars - which run quite deep - of this kind of irrational envy of the clever child by classmates & their parents. It's horrible to be on the receiving end of it.