Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think extra lessons for top students isn’t fair?

775 replies

Beepboobeep · 02/11/2026 21:12

My DD’s state primary school has a “top maths club” and “great writers club” for the top performing students in yr 5 and 6 held outside of school hours. There is no charge for this - so it’s free childcare and free tutoring. You have to be invited. This has been running since the second week of the school year and is restarting on the first day of this half term.

By contrast, my dyslexic DD is in a group for those needing more support in writing, also outside of school hours. But they only managed 2 sessions last year and it hasn’t started back up this year. She gets ad hoc in school support; where it happens she misses other lessons that aren’t then caught up on, putting her further behind in the those.

I appreciate these children deserve challenging, but surely that could be done in class with different work and the teacher’s out of hours time, if available, used to help those struggling?

Is this even allowed in a state primary?

OP posts:
Easterchicken · 04/11/2026 04:14

Why on earth wouldn't it be allowed

It's there to support those kids who are aiming for GD mark to ensure they hit that target and to boost the schools results

Granville82 · 04/11/2026 05:54

Beepboobeep · 02/11/2026 21:40

I’m not saying prioritised - I’m asking for equal

You did say prioritised OP.

morbiddest · 04/11/2026 06:06

Beepboobeep · 02/11/2026 21:15

Yes, but is it right to prioritise them over children who are struggling?

Edited

I disagree with you actually. this is a special out-of-hours club that might be run by a teacher who volunteered. I am a teacher (albeit in an international private school abroad, so it may be different), and when we are asked to offer an after school activity, we are allowed to choose what it is based on our own special interest or talent that we want to share with children. Some of these classes can only be offered to students who are suitable for the activity. Having a 'great writers club' is wonderful! But of course, as the name suggests, it can't really be open to non-great writers. That sort of defeats to point! After school activities are very often (at least in my experience as both a student and teacher) fun and recreational and after school isn't really an appropriate time to expect extra support for students who are struggling - this should be offered during the school day and is a seperate issue altogether.

morbiddest · 04/11/2026 06:10

Also, from a more personal perspective - as a well-behaved and academically high performing student, I was often pretty bored at school, and pretty overlooked by teachers, who mostly focussed on the children who were naughty or struggling. Very few activities or rewards offered by schools to children who didn't need much encouragement or support! I remember thinking that it felt a bit boring and unfair. I think it's fine to have one or two things that acknowledge the children who are performing well in certain subjects and give them something special, seeing as during the school day these children generally get far less time, attention and praise from the teacher.

Packofsix · 04/11/2026 06:58

Ah yes, let’s do it in school time so that other students who cannot do that kind of work are affected. Stupid entitled woman

Besidemyselfwithworry · 04/11/2026 07:02

DogsandDungarees · 02/11/2026 21:14

I’m sorry OP but often schools don’t provide much challenge for pupils who are academically gifted. Let them have something.

I agree with this
ALL children whether they need additional support or are brighter and need challenging should get something.
why is this so bad? It’s great for those kids and just because your child doesn’t get to go try not to think badly of those who benefit from it, that’s not nice.

Speak to the school is you feel your child needs some extra intervention but don’t be bitter about something put on for others. It’s like our school offers 11+ classes for those able - my kids don’t want grammar but it’s good the option is there for those who do and i certainly wouldn’t consider it detrimental to me or my kids and I’d never kick off about it.

BlackCat14 · 04/11/2026 07:24

Beepboobeep · 02/11/2026 21:47

I didn’t say theirs should be cancelled, I am questioning why hers is cancelled for an entire year other than 2 sessions while theirs never is

Have you actually asked the school why her club has been cancelled for the entire year? No one on here can answer that for you.

Newname26 · 04/11/2026 07:38

SweetnsourNZ · 04/11/2026 03:05

How do the other children know your daughter is dyslexic? This should have been kept private. Did the school tell everyone?

Most likely the daughter told people. Give the school some credit

Newname26 · 04/11/2026 07:49

Wonderfrau · 03/11/2026 22:45

I’m guessing the staff member who ran the club twice didn’t enjoy it, the children didn’t enjoy it or the ‘club’ was generally unsuccessful. After school provision is voluntary, extra curricular and nothing to do with the support struggling children may or may not need.

Use 1/10th of the £500 per week you spend on a simple tutoring session?

What do you do to support her dyslexia outside of school hours if she is keen for additional learning? This is probably sufficient if you do a little bit each day.

She doesn’t have an EHCP? You wrote her plan? Did the school adopt this?

I think you have it there. The club was unsuccessful.

What kid wants to go to the 'thick kids club' because regardless of what the school call it, thats how it will be perceived.

Truthfully I wouldn't have wanted to be seen dead there, either in primary or secondary.
I know times have changed. And every other kid these days has 'Special Educational Needs' but there must still be some stigma to actually being one of them.

poetryandwine · 04/11/2026 08:17

Electrickittens · 04/11/2026 00:21

Given that schools have a duty to offer differentiated teaching, if the main lessons just can’t really do so for the most able children, why is the appropriate teaching for them not a few extra lessons in a club?

DD sat in a class for the entirety of Y6 getting more and more frustrated, while all the maths and English was recapping things she could already do, but the teachers were teaching for the SATS. She (and several others at a similar level) learned nothing in their lessons that entire year. She used to come home so frustrated she would be crying and saying how much she hated it and hated the school. And DD’s primary was actually rather good at greater depth stretch compared to other state schools. But when for an entire year you’re just going over the same maths you learned in Y4 and Y5, and you sit there every day with nothing but an extra problem or two on a greater depth sheet, how is the school providing differentiated teaching? How holistic is that? DD was absolutely desperate for a few extra lessons in something that was new and interesting. Actually, from being enthusiastic about maths (the school team won the Y5 county maths challenge), she quickly started saying how much she hated it. She’s 13 now and still really good at maths, but she’s never started actually liking it again since then. That’s a huge shame; and there were quite a few other kids in her position at her primary (and not at all privileged).

We’re not even talking about some mystic genius-level “giftedness” here; we’re just talking about the most able 15-20 percent of children who get agonisingly bored in lessons that are too easy for them.

This is a real problem. I don’t see how some after school activity with an unclear purpose will help much. Your DD needs a more differentiated approach in the classroom.

I have enormous sympathies as I remember those years all too well. It takes a gifted teacher with amole resources to differentiate within lessons properly. Sadly both factors are in short supply.

GeneralPeter · 04/11/2026 08:19

Goldenbear · 03/11/2026 21:28

By when- 9 and 10? Well all the research shows that rigid labels at a young age are highly unreliable and to predict what high achieving as opposed to exceptional pupils, will be achieving all A*s at GCSEs would be even more challenging. Given that there aren't many pupils, if any in some schools, achieving all 9s at GCSE your theory doesn't really bear out.

Which research are you looking at?

I don’t know about rigid labels, but tested IQ at age 9-10 correlates strongly with IQ throughout adult life. Much more strongly than it correlates with socioeconomic status for example.

GeneralPeter · 04/11/2026 08:36

Goldenbear · 03/11/2026 13:18

Oh I see, good point but I don't think that is happening in the OP's case and I don't think we should be streaming 9 year olds.

We do stream children. We just stream them by age rather than ability/attainment.

For most learning, ability/attainment is a better guide to what a child will benefit from than age.

poetryandwine · 04/11/2026 08:36

poetryandwine · 04/11/2026 08:17

This is a real problem. I don’t see how some after school activity with an unclear purpose will help much. Your DD needs a more differentiated approach in the classroom.

I have enormous sympathies as I remember those years all too well. It takes a gifted teacher with amole resources to differentiate within lessons properly. Sadly both factors are in short supply.

Edit: a gifted teacher with ample resources

Scarcityvarcity · 04/11/2026 09:28

GeneralPeter · 04/11/2026 08:19

Which research are you looking at?

I don’t know about rigid labels, but tested IQ at age 9-10 correlates strongly with IQ throughout adult life. Much more strongly than it correlates with socioeconomic status for example.

Yes, you only have to look at the results grammar schools get to see that. The entrance exams are pretty much IQ tests and the pupils that score highly at age 9 or 10 usually do very well in GSCEs and A levels.

Newname26 · 04/11/2026 09:51

Scarcityvarcity · 04/11/2026 09:28

Yes, you only have to look at the results grammar schools get to see that. The entrance exams are pretty much IQ tests and the pupils that score highly at age 9 or 10 usually do very well in GSCEs and A levels.

Edited

Thats probably also half the reasons fee paying schools get the results they do too.

And we all know parental support plays a big part too.

Spirallingdownwards · 04/11/2026 09:54

Presumably if they used actual lesson time to teach to the level of the more academically able kids you would be complaining yours weren't able to keep up. It is important to cater for all levels and if the school is seeking to do so by providing additional out of school lessons then that's good they are catering to the average in class.

Arabelllllllla · 04/11/2026 10:17

Timeforachange26 · 03/11/2026 22:27

I've never known any state school do coaching for the 11plus.

I havent got experience of this as my DC is too young. But there are some replies on this thread indicating that actually some state schools do 11+ prep classes.

I think that's very wrong and I don't agree with it, also the inconsistency of it. Some schools do and some schools don't, our education system is a postcode lottery.

Sdpbody · 04/11/2026 10:22

Beepboobeep · 02/11/2026 21:15

Yes, but is it right to prioritise them over children who are struggling?

Edited

You're welcome to do additional work at home with your daughter.

The amount of extra work we have done for our dyslexic daughter means she is at ARE.

GeneralPeter · 04/11/2026 10:41

Arabelllllllla · 04/11/2026 10:17

I havent got experience of this as my DC is too young. But there are some replies on this thread indicating that actually some state schools do 11+ prep classes.

I think that's very wrong and I don't agree with it, also the inconsistency of it. Some schools do and some schools don't, our education system is a postcode lottery.

Why do you think it’s wrong for state schools to do 11+ prep classes?

Isn’t it good to help students who don’t have that sort of support at home, and/or aren’t at private prep schools?

Scarcityvarcity · 04/11/2026 10:42

Arabelllllllla · 04/11/2026 10:17

I havent got experience of this as my DC is too young. But there are some replies on this thread indicating that actually some state schools do 11+ prep classes.

I think that's very wrong and I don't agree with it, also the inconsistency of it. Some schools do and some schools don't, our education system is a postcode lottery.

Where I live only the grammar schools themselves do and it restricted to pupil premium. They probably just familiarise pupils with the type of question. You can't do much more than that anyway imo.

Scarcityvarcity · 04/11/2026 10:44

Newname26 · 04/11/2026 09:51

Thats probably also half the reasons fee paying schools get the results they do too.

And we all know parental support plays a big part too.

Yes fee paying schools often have entance exams too. They also have the advantage of small class sizes though.

Poppinpoppinpopcorn · 04/11/2026 10:51

I know a young man who excelled in maths at primary, was given extra support, then the same happened in secondary school. He is now at university studying maths then will go onto teacher training to teach maths to secondary kids, like your child soonOP. Now do you see why extra support for the high achievers is relevant? They are the future of maths teachers. Perhaps you don't want qualified maths teachers when your child starts secondary. Oh well, your loss.

Arabelllllllla · 04/11/2026 10:56

GeneralPeter · 04/11/2026 10:41

Why do you think it’s wrong for state schools to do 11+ prep classes?

Isn’t it good to help students who don’t have that sort of support at home, and/or aren’t at private prep schools?

For 2 reasons; the first of which i think you missed in my post, which is that clearly the prep lessons are being applied inconsistently. Either all state schools do it, or none (in grammar school areas).

Secondly, I've alluded to it in another post but I went to a very good grammar school. My observation (and our life experience does inform our views, true of us all) was that the girls who were coached through the 11+ tended to struggle more than the girls who were naturally brighter. Same for those girls who got in on the sibling ticket (so they merely had to scrape a pass). It was a very academically competitive school, I actually do not think its fair to send your child to a school where they are going to struggle. I would not do it to my DC. If naturally bright enough I'd say "do the exam and see how you get on" rather than spending months coaching.

That's my personal opinion and it isnt related to state vs private.

ScrollingLeaves · 04/11/2026 11:37

Arabelllllllla · 04/11/2026 10:56

For 2 reasons; the first of which i think you missed in my post, which is that clearly the prep lessons are being applied inconsistently. Either all state schools do it, or none (in grammar school areas).

Secondly, I've alluded to it in another post but I went to a very good grammar school. My observation (and our life experience does inform our views, true of us all) was that the girls who were coached through the 11+ tended to struggle more than the girls who were naturally brighter. Same for those girls who got in on the sibling ticket (so they merely had to scrape a pass). It was a very academically competitive school, I actually do not think its fair to send your child to a school where they are going to struggle. I would not do it to my DC. If naturally bright enough I'd say "do the exam and see how you get on" rather than spending months coaching.

That's my personal opinion and it isnt related to state vs private.

People have to be given lessons because the national curriculum given out to all the children is at a lower/easier level than the 11+. They will not have not covered maths in the same way covering more complex problem solving, or read the sort of texts requiring nuanced inference for comprehension in English.

Scarcityvarcity · 04/11/2026 11:46

Arabelllllllla · 04/11/2026 10:56

For 2 reasons; the first of which i think you missed in my post, which is that clearly the prep lessons are being applied inconsistently. Either all state schools do it, or none (in grammar school areas).

Secondly, I've alluded to it in another post but I went to a very good grammar school. My observation (and our life experience does inform our views, true of us all) was that the girls who were coached through the 11+ tended to struggle more than the girls who were naturally brighter. Same for those girls who got in on the sibling ticket (so they merely had to scrape a pass). It was a very academically competitive school, I actually do not think its fair to send your child to a school where they are going to struggle. I would not do it to my DC. If naturally bright enough I'd say "do the exam and see how you get on" rather than spending months coaching.

That's my personal opinion and it isnt related to state vs private.

Where I live there is very much a policy for the state primary schools not to get involved in the grammar school exams. I don't know if this applies everywhere but it may well do. Information on how many children get into grammar schools from each primary is not published so why would they spend their time on that rather than things they are assessed on such as SATs? The grammar school exams nowadays are designed as much as possible to not be influenced by tutoring. Grammar schools themselves want the most academic rather than the most tutored so the tests are similar to IQ tests.

Swipe left for the next trending thread