Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think extra lessons for top students isn’t fair?

775 replies

Beepboobeep · 02/11/2026 21:12

My DD’s state primary school has a “top maths club” and “great writers club” for the top performing students in yr 5 and 6 held outside of school hours. There is no charge for this - so it’s free childcare and free tutoring. You have to be invited. This has been running since the second week of the school year and is restarting on the first day of this half term.

By contrast, my dyslexic DD is in a group for those needing more support in writing, also outside of school hours. But they only managed 2 sessions last year and it hasn’t started back up this year. She gets ad hoc in school support; where it happens she misses other lessons that aren’t then caught up on, putting her further behind in the those.

I appreciate these children deserve challenging, but surely that could be done in class with different work and the teacher’s out of hours time, if available, used to help those struggling?

Is this even allowed in a state primary?

OP posts:
Idkrlly17844905 · 03/11/2026 22:37

Beepboobeep · 02/11/2026 21:15

Yes, but is it right to prioritise them over children who are struggling?

Edited

They aren’t being prioritised?

BadBadCat · 03/11/2026 22:41

I think this is very refreshing! Those struggling usually get so much support and extra adult time in school while those that cope fine are largely left to their own devices.

I work in primary school and was just saying today how the most academic children never get anything extra- many are coasting and bored and not performing to the best of their ability. It's nice to hear of a school that is doing something to help those children reach their full potential.

Goldenbear · 03/11/2026 22:44

Timeforachange26 · 03/11/2026 22:15

Yeah private selective prep. I had a scholarship as being the daughter of a postman and shop worker my parents couldn't afford the fees

Did entrance exam at age 6. Dont see what is harsh about ranking us by subject tbh

Wasn't it humiliating for those who didn't rank highly?

Wonderfrau · 03/11/2026 22:45

I’m guessing the staff member who ran the club twice didn’t enjoy it, the children didn’t enjoy it or the ‘club’ was generally unsuccessful. After school provision is voluntary, extra curricular and nothing to do with the support struggling children may or may not need.

Use 1/10th of the £500 per week you spend on a simple tutoring session?

What do you do to support her dyslexia outside of school hours if she is keen for additional learning? This is probably sufficient if you do a little bit each day.

She doesn’t have an EHCP? You wrote her plan? Did the school adopt this?

Idkrlly17844905 · 03/11/2026 22:50

Arbourimage · 02/11/2026 21:41

But it’s already not equal because teaching time is generally spent on those with the lowest abilities in a group setting, so these children are being held back during the school day and given a disproportionately lower amount of teacher attention in class compared to the children who learn at a slower pace.

I’m a secondary teacher (comprehensive) and this is true. The less able are already being prioritised, because logically they have to be in a mixed ability setting for a lesson to work.

Wappycowloz · 03/11/2026 22:56

Why shouldn't those children who are bright get extra support and pushed to achieve thier full potential? Why should those that are struggling always be prioritised?
My youngest DS has just started year 7 at a state school. He knew before he started that they had a grammer stream available for the top 30 children (out of 210) and set himself a goal to get on it. He was already JUST achieving greater depth (which would probably have got him a place as we're in a quite disadvantaged area) but he worked hard outside of school to get absolutely amazing SAT results (and no he wasn't tutored as I don't agree with children being tutored at such a young age to get into Grammer Schools/Streams as if they don't have the natural ability they will always need tutoring to keep up). The school themselves did nothing to help (as their focus was getting as many kids as possible to get required standard rather than ALL kids reaching thier own full potential so he wasn't pushed in school).
His hard work got him easily onto the grammer stream and now he is reaping the benefit. He is in a class with just high achievers and is being pushed no end (they learn an extra language and stdy other subjects in more depth as they are expected to work faster/harder) . They have lots of enrichment activities that take place out of school aimed at their level, including Axiom Maths which he will do all the way through to year 11. Thats not to say the secondary school only care about the top children, they don't. They also have lots of intervention for those struggling to, but it is a breath of fresh air to see a state school want to push their high achievers to reach their full potential. My eldest DS was also a high achiever when he left Primary, went to a different secondary (the school my youngest goes to was one of the worst in our area at the time my eldest was going to secondary and has vastly improved in the last 7 years to become one of, if not the best), wasn't pushed at all and had no enrichment opportunities the whole time he was there.

ScrollingLeaves · 03/11/2026 23:00

FirmSnake · 03/11/2026 20:47

So who exactly benefits from bright kids learning less?

I think Golden’s idea is that they aren’t really bright. If they appear to be, that’s just an unreliable veneer created by all the help their parents gave them. So they have no right to this extra session for ‘bright’ children.

Timeforachange26 · 03/11/2026 23:08

Goldenbear · 03/11/2026 22:44

Wasn't it humiliating for those who didn't rank highly?

Why would it be humiliating? We werent all such snowflakes then. Competition and pushing ourselves wete considered positive things

And seeing as I was bottom everytime in art and music I didn't feel humiliated so why would others. The one girl who was bottom in academic subjects was still miles better than others at different schools

poetryandwine · 03/11/2026 23:14

Mmmsnetter92 · 03/11/2026 22:37

Ah I see. I think we have interpreted differently what the OP has said.

There was a comment in one of her posts about students getting (what I understood her to mean) private tuition at home and because they already receive that extra input, they don't therefore need any more input from the school.

I can appreciate the sentiment that, if students are receiving all of their additional support outside of school hours, and one group has their sessions cancelled while another does not, it could leave a bad taste, however, I'm not convinced that is strictly what's going on here.

In all honesty, I think it's great if a state school is offering additional classes to assist with the 11+ (thereby helping high achievers from low income families who cannot afford private tuition). I don't believe in over tuition to assist with grammar school entry (that's just setting children up to fail) but an introduction to, for example, verbal and non-verbal reasoning, and concepts in English and Maths which go beyond the KS2 curriculum and on which prospective students will be tested, is probably sensible to assist those students in unlocking their potential.

My poor parents... I was adamant I did not want to go to a single sex school (which all our grammar schools were, at the time)... That was, until 3 weeks before the entrance exam for one of the schools (the one I decided I actually very much wanted to attend). I had two private tuition sessions on verbal and non-verbal reasoning, ahead of the entrance exam, and that was all it took for me. I'm not sure how I would have fared without those introductory sessions.

Thank you for this update. I think we have a small difference of opinion concerning OP’s main focus. To me, it is about the school’s disparity.

The preparation you describe sounds quite reasonable - no one should go into a major exam unprepared. And I certainly don’t want children from state schools (even more) disadvantaged when it comes to the 11+. Fundamentally, though, I think children who need to be tutored into grammar school and then ever onwards are being deprived of the chance to find their own voice and properly to thrive.

That may be relatively easy for me to say as I am not British and was educated abroad. Also, my leanings are academic. But that is not an unmixed blessing.

I don’t think we are all that far apart.

Idkrlly17844905 · 03/11/2026 23:16

Goldenbear · 02/11/2026 22:38

IME the make up of these groups at secondary are so arbitrary, particularly when you are determining what distinguishes highly competent from those in a stretching class. Of course, it is easy to classify exceptional students but they are rare and usually the ones in the local paper on GCSE results day! IME the progress of students at A level to outstanding universities for example, does not correlate, in any way, with those placed in 'stretching groups' at GCSE level or younger.

At 9/10 years old I would conclude this is mostly bollox and way too early to place students on a certain track!

As a teacher, I agree with this; I don’t think any IQ or CAT style tests are absolute indicators of natural ability.

poetryandwine · 03/11/2026 23:18

Wappycowloz · 03/11/2026 22:56

Why shouldn't those children who are bright get extra support and pushed to achieve thier full potential? Why should those that are struggling always be prioritised?
My youngest DS has just started year 7 at a state school. He knew before he started that they had a grammer stream available for the top 30 children (out of 210) and set himself a goal to get on it. He was already JUST achieving greater depth (which would probably have got him a place as we're in a quite disadvantaged area) but he worked hard outside of school to get absolutely amazing SAT results (and no he wasn't tutored as I don't agree with children being tutored at such a young age to get into Grammer Schools/Streams as if they don't have the natural ability they will always need tutoring to keep up). The school themselves did nothing to help (as their focus was getting as many kids as possible to get required standard rather than ALL kids reaching thier own full potential so he wasn't pushed in school).
His hard work got him easily onto the grammer stream and now he is reaping the benefit. He is in a class with just high achievers and is being pushed no end (they learn an extra language and stdy other subjects in more depth as they are expected to work faster/harder) . They have lots of enrichment activities that take place out of school aimed at their level, including Axiom Maths which he will do all the way through to year 11. Thats not to say the secondary school only care about the top children, they don't. They also have lots of intervention for those struggling to, but it is a breath of fresh air to see a state school want to push their high achievers to reach their full potential. My eldest DS was also a high achiever when he left Primary, went to a different secondary (the school my youngest goes to was one of the worst in our area at the time my eldest was going to secondary and has vastly improved in the last 7 years to become one of, if not the best), wasn't pushed at all and had no enrichment opportunities the whole time he was there.

This sounds marvellous for your DS. You also write of support for struggling pupils. It should not be an either-or choice. All children deserve appropriate learning support.

HeyMoonPie · 03/11/2026 23:22

So these children are 'gifted' ?! They are 'hot housed' for Grammar School and then what ? It becomes apparent that they can't keep up at senior school and begin to fall behind. These children are used to push the statistics for the schools (falsely) up BUT the real need is for those that struggle with such things as dyslexia to receive help !

Idkrlly17844905 · 03/11/2026 23:27

Goldenbear · 03/11/2026 19:01

You have literally just done the same!

I can't imagine why you think schools doing something is a persuasive argument. Labels of talent at 9 and 10 are mostly misleading, you inadvertently pointed that out with your previous definition of G&T I.e. just means working at a "Greater Depth"
At this age what people interpret as Talent is more down to frequency of exposure, the child's self confidence, the socially adept child is going to be better at unintentional self promotion, your parents level of education and your maturity. Adolescence hasn't even happened which changes things again, you certainly see late Bloomers and the opposite decline with early 'talent' as it rarely based upon innate ability when kids are very young.

This.

Goldenbear · 03/11/2026 23:42

ScrollingLeaves · 03/11/2026 23:00

I think Golden’s idea is that they aren’t really bright. If they appear to be, that’s just an unreliable veneer created by all the help their parents gave them. So they have no right to this extra session for ‘bright’ children.

I don't think it's right to apply rigid labels to children at 9/10. I am sure they are 'bright' but do they deserve exclusivity, what about the other children are they 'talentless'?

LikeASoulWithoutAMind · 03/11/2026 23:43

The best support happens within lessons during the school day OP. It's a bit of a fallacy that taking them out of lessons to support is effective. Do you have evidence that struggling children receive no support at your child's school? I've been a governor at 3 different primary schools and a parent at a 4th (and I work in a secondary school) and I can assure you that children are given lots of support at all of them.

Children who are struggling will generally be pretty tired by the end of the school day and making them stay to do an extra hour of English or maths is quite likely to be counterproductive.

MargotGobby · 03/11/2026 23:50

Bright kids deserve to be stretched as all children deserve to have the best brought out in them - whether that means extra catch-up for those struggling or extra challenges for those who find the work easy.

The vast majority of extra help in UK schools seems to go to those struggling so it’s nice to see bright kids get help too tbh

Electrickittens · 04/11/2026 00:21

poetryandwine · 03/11/2026 16:23

No it is not fair, and I say this as someone who has benefitted from G&T provisions as have my family.

Of course very able children should be taught appropriately, and I agree that too often they are sacrificed. That is wrong. However it is morally repugnant to suggest that they should be prioritised over less able children. The answer is to insist on appropriate teaching for every child.

It is not possible for the rather crude tests given in school meaningfully to capture the features of giftedness at a young age. Treating all children holistically is the best way to encourage the strengths of each.

Given that schools have a duty to offer differentiated teaching, if the main lessons just can’t really do so for the most able children, why is the appropriate teaching for them not a few extra lessons in a club?

DD sat in a class for the entirety of Y6 getting more and more frustrated, while all the maths and English was recapping things she could already do, but the teachers were teaching for the SATS. She (and several others at a similar level) learned nothing in their lessons that entire year. She used to come home so frustrated she would be crying and saying how much she hated it and hated the school. And DD’s primary was actually rather good at greater depth stretch compared to other state schools. But when for an entire year you’re just going over the same maths you learned in Y4 and Y5, and you sit there every day with nothing but an extra problem or two on a greater depth sheet, how is the school providing differentiated teaching? How holistic is that? DD was absolutely desperate for a few extra lessons in something that was new and interesting. Actually, from being enthusiastic about maths (the school team won the Y5 county maths challenge), she quickly started saying how much she hated it. She’s 13 now and still really good at maths, but she’s never started actually liking it again since then. That’s a huge shame; and there were quite a few other kids in her position at her primary (and not at all privileged).

We’re not even talking about some mystic genius-level “giftedness” here; we’re just talking about the most able 15-20 percent of children who get agonisingly bored in lessons that are too easy for them.

Electrickittens · 04/11/2026 00:28

Idkrlly17844905 · 03/11/2026 23:16

As a teacher, I agree with this; I don’t think any IQ or CAT style tests are absolute indicators of natural ability.

No tests are absolute indicators of natural ability. However, there is a lot of very consistent data on the correlations between CAT/SATS/MIDYIS/GCSE and A-level results (across the whole cohort, state and private); which is one of the reasons that private schools make a lot of use out of them (some state schools do too, for example the craze for “flight paths” in some state secondaries). That doesn’t mean they are necessarily definitive or predictive. But the data is actually very good.

SandyY2K · 04/11/2026 01:59

Beepboobeep · 02/11/2026 21:40

I’m not saying prioritised - I’m asking for equal

Life isn't fair or equal unfortunately.

When my kids were in school, my high achieving child A* student, was offered and strongly encouraged to do after school additional lessons.

My other child, higher than average, but not top sets like the other one didn't get any additional support. I paid for additional private tuition for her.

SweetnsourNZ · 04/11/2026 02:39

JLou08 · 02/11/2026 21:18

I've been at both ends of this, one high achiever and one with learning difficulties. I think it's good that the school are making an effort with the high achievers as they often get left to plod along with work that doesn't challenge them and it can damage their progress and motivation to learn.
I think when talking about after school clubs, they're supposed to be fun. Usually made up of sports or art clubs. Maths and writing may be fun for people who do well in it. How much fun will it be for someone who struggles? It's more likely to just feel like extra pressure after a long day of struggling with class work. For that reason, I think it's a good idea to prioritise the club for the high achievers.

This. So much is made of being the top sports person and the academic children who aren't good at sports are often left out or even subjected to open ridicule by making them do things like cross country in front of everyone.
Also, gifted and high achieving academic children have been left out of any extra help for decades all over the world. Good to see them finally getting their share of help.

SweetnsourNZ · 04/11/2026 02:46

Beepboobeep · 02/11/2026 21:26

So what about support for those that need it? What if that is totally lacking?

Then push for that. It's nothing to do with the other children having their needs met. Parents of gifted children have had to push for years to have their voices heard. As have parents in your position.
It doesn't have to be one or the other.

SweetnsourNZ · 04/11/2026 03:00

Beepboobeep · 02/11/2026 21:33

but is it right or fair? Support for naturally gifted children without extra support at home fine. But these children’s parents already pay fortunes for out school tutoring

Surely what the parents of these children spend their money on is none of your business.

SweetnsourNZ · 04/11/2026 03:05

Beepboobeep · 02/11/2026 21:44

They delight in telling me and their children love showing off to my DD (and telling her dyslexia isn’t real, I wonder where they heard that).

Who said I am not investing in her outside of school? Grammar school wouldn’t be right for her, but I pay £2,000 a month on extra curriculum clubs and tutoring for her. She will shortly be moving to private school.

How do the other children know your daughter is dyslexic? This should have been kept private. Did the school tell everyone?

Franjipanl8r · 04/11/2026 03:21

You’re right to feel angry, it’s very isolating and frustrating being the parent of a SEND child at a state school. I’d find out more about the gifted group before you fly off the handle - it could just be a homework club where they’re set extra work and are just left to complete it in a classroom with a teacher who’s marking other work or doing admin.

SEND kids need proper teaching time so this club might not be the same kind of thing.

Franjipanl8r · 04/11/2026 03:25

SweetnsourNZ · 04/11/2026 03:05

How do the other children know your daughter is dyslexic? This should have been kept private. Did the school tell everyone?

Dyslexia isn’t something to be ashamed of that’s meant to be kept private.

Swipe left for the next trending thread