Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be fed up of the phrase 'net contributor'

246 replies

glitterpaperchain · 28/10/2026 18:30

Obviously there is a time and place for this phrase because we need to have a realistic financial plan and a functioning economy.

But society is more than just money. And I feel like this phrase is really making people view each other in a nasty way, purely focused on whether they provide economic value or not.

There are so many ways to contribute. The people who look after our small children, teaching assistants and 1 to 1s who look after SEN children, many healthcare workers, the people who care for our elderly, they all get paid a pittance but that work is so valuable to our society.

We're more than just our finances and there are many ways to contribute to society, many of which are not reflected in the economy.

OP posts:
glitterpaperchain · 29/10/2026 17:54

InterIgnis · 29/10/2026 17:20

I’m not sure why motivation matters. Money is money - it isn’t worth more because it came from someone that acted against their own self interest in order to make it. Someone making it for their own benefit doesn’t negate the fact that they are a net contributor.

It matters because the entire thread is about people who think being a net contributor makes them a better person

OP posts:
Livinglavidaloco · 29/10/2026 17:54

glitterpaperchain · 29/10/2026 16:49

I think that's a good point that it's an involuntary contribution.

And also the quite telling the amount of high earners obviously MN who have said they would move to a different country if taxes increased. They're not interested in contributing anything to society

Edited

Plenty of lower earners do so out of choice. And there are plenty of lower earners that aren't working in roles that positively contribute towards society. And in the same way, plenty of higher earners do. It is ridiculous to try and claim that earning less means you contribute more to society or have better morals.

glitterpaperchain · 29/10/2026 18:05

Livinglavidaloco · 29/10/2026 17:54

Plenty of lower earners do so out of choice. And there are plenty of lower earners that aren't working in roles that positively contribute towards society. And in the same way, plenty of higher earners do. It is ridiculous to try and claim that earning less means you contribute more to society or have better morals.

I'm not trying to claim that. The entire thread is about people who think 'net contributors' are better than other people. I'm glad you agree that someone's morals aren't related to their income.

OP posts:
InterIgnis · 29/10/2026 18:09

glitterpaperchain · 29/10/2026 17:54

It matters because the entire thread is about people who think being a net contributor makes them a better person

No on has said higher earners are better people when it comes to some vaguely defined philosophical metric.

Foundational as they are to an economy that actually runs, it is certainly better for any society that the number of net contributors to be greater than the number of takers.

Livinglavidaloco · 29/10/2026 18:16

glitterpaperchain · 29/10/2026 18:05

I'm not trying to claim that. The entire thread is about people who think 'net contributors' are better than other people. I'm glad you agree that someone's morals aren't related to their income.

Most of your follow up posts list the reasons you believe lower earners contribution to society is superior. Not all lower earners provide care and not all higher earners work in finance. Some higher earners are caring compassionate people and some lower earners have lengthy criminal records. As I said earlier in the thread, I haven't seen the term used in the way you describe and when asked to give examples you have refused
But regardless, you are doing the same thing you complain about, judging people by their income bracket.

glitterpaperchain · 29/10/2026 18:17

InterIgnis · 29/10/2026 18:09

No on has said higher earners are better people when it comes to some vaguely defined philosophical metric.

Foundational as they are to an economy that actually runs, it is certainly better for any society that the number of net contributors to be greater than the number of takers.

'No one has said' - plenty of people on this thread have seen it multiple times here on MN. Just because you personally haven't seen something doesn't mean it hasn't happened.

Your second sentence is completely irrelevant to the discussion as no one is disputing that.

OP posts:
glitterpaperchain · 29/10/2026 18:21

Livinglavidaloco · 29/10/2026 18:16

Most of your follow up posts list the reasons you believe lower earners contribution to society is superior. Not all lower earners provide care and not all higher earners work in finance. Some higher earners are caring compassionate people and some lower earners have lengthy criminal records. As I said earlier in the thread, I haven't seen the term used in the way you describe and when asked to give examples you have refused
But regardless, you are doing the same thing you complain about, judging people by their income bracket.

I am giving examples of ways non-net contributors contribute to society in non-economic ways. Because that is what the thread is about - no one is superior, it takes all sorts.

OP posts:
InterIgnis · 29/10/2026 18:55

glitterpaperchain · 29/10/2026 18:17

'No one has said' - plenty of people on this thread have seen it multiple times here on MN. Just because you personally haven't seen something doesn't mean it hasn't happened.

Your second sentence is completely irrelevant to the discussion as no one is disputing that.

In hard economic terms yes, higher earners are more valuable. They are quite literally worth more. That’s what I’ve seen posters say.

glitterpaperchain · 29/10/2026 19:05

InterIgnis · 29/10/2026 18:55

In hard economic terms yes, higher earners are more valuable. They are quite literally worth more. That’s what I’ve seen posters say.

Ok and I and others on this thread have seen different. Why are you arguing with me when you haven't witnessed the thing I'm talking about? Just because you personally haven't seen something doesn't mean it hasn't happened.

OP posts:
socialdilemmawhattodo · 29/10/2026 19:07

Tulipsriver · 29/10/2026 11:10

I agree. It reminds me of the attitude nazis used to demonise disabled people as a drain on society through propaganda.

Yes, there is a tiny minority of people who choose not to work in favour of sitting around doing nothing, but the majority of people who are not 'net contributors' are either disabled, ill, or contributing in other (just as valuable) ways.

My friend would has fallen into this category for years. She studied for a professional career, then had a child with high needs SEN. She has worked in some capacity for years, but no school can keep her child full time, and after school care is impossible for him so her earning potential is vastly reduced. Her son is incredibly unlikely to ever earn enough to be a net contributor himself... should they both feel guilty for things completely out of their control?

Sadly I no longer believe it is a TINY minority. I think there are far too many people wanting to be on gateway benefits - sounded a good idea at the time - but no more. Gateway benefits mean for that individual/family - work will always look 2nd best. And that option should no longer be available.

For your friend - I am curious - but you dont need to reply - where the dad of that young person is in all of this? It is no longer a good idea for only the mum to take the earnings/career hit.

Tideturn · 29/10/2026 19:42

It seems clear that there are net social contributors to society and net financial contributors to society (some people are both). I appreciate that both are difficult to measure; indeed, perhaps no one measures the former. (Net financial contribution is also hard to calculate as per PP.) Both types of contribution are needed for society to function and this is belied by the term ‘net contributor.’

Totallyfedupnow · 29/10/2026 20:04

Havanananana · 29/10/2026 13:35

This is nonsense. No business or sector can just pay more in order to attract the employees that it needs, particularly if it takes time and money to train these employees. There is not an unlimited supply of skilled workers and access to many qualifications is restricted either because a certain level of intellect or ability is required or because there are financial barriers that poorer students cannot overcome. There is not an unlimited pot of money with which to pay the employees, and what the economics textbooks describe as "supply and demand" only applies to a mythical perfect market where money and profit are the sole drivers.

For humans money is not the only driver. Double the wages of nurses and there would still be a shortage if working conditions are not acceptable. People want a certain level of quality of life, a good life balance, recognition and respect - beyond a certain point they work to live rather than living to work. Some people have ethical values - e.g. they will not work for tobacco companies or companies that manufacture arms - and no amount of money will persuade them to work in these industries. Some jobs are so dangerous, unpleasent or strenuous that people refuse to do them regardless of the wage, setting a higher value on their health rather than on money.

No.
Paying more is EXACTLY what businesses do to attract employees they need. This is why AI engineers in their twenties can earn £200k a year, or why lorry drivers in the pandemic suddenly got 30% pay rises. If a skill is valuable enough and the supply of it is restricted, then its price will rise.

I am afraid your other contention - that people are indifferent to higher pay if working conditions are not cushy enough - is also false. While there are some individuals who may seem to act economically irrationally, overall there are more than enough people prepared to work more or to undertake more onerous or risky work in exchange for higher pay. This is why offshore oil rig workers get paid £150k a year, or why luxury yacht crews get £2000 tips, or why junior investment banking analysts work 110 hour weeks.

socialdilemmawhattodo · 29/10/2026 20:28

Totallyfedupnow · 29/10/2026 20:04

No.
Paying more is EXACTLY what businesses do to attract employees they need. This is why AI engineers in their twenties can earn £200k a year, or why lorry drivers in the pandemic suddenly got 30% pay rises. If a skill is valuable enough and the supply of it is restricted, then its price will rise.

I am afraid your other contention - that people are indifferent to higher pay if working conditions are not cushy enough - is also false. While there are some individuals who may seem to act economically irrationally, overall there are more than enough people prepared to work more or to undertake more onerous or risky work in exchange for higher pay. This is why offshore oil rig workers get paid £150k a year, or why luxury yacht crews get £2000 tips, or why junior investment banking analysts work 110 hour weeks.

Actually I don't quite agree with you. I get some of your point. But people won't take on dangerous or more likely now uncomfortable jobs without a salary uplift. But few roles now offer that. Yes - your examples of oil rig workers or yacht crews - do get an uplift. But working for tobacco or arms manufacturers, as quoted by the PP you were quoting. These are emotional/moral objections. I don't believe that if someone wants benefits, or needs to feed their family, these are considerations that society can afford. So if they opt out I am NOT prepared to fund that individual. And I will be vocal about that.

ThingsAreNotWhatTheyWere · 29/10/2026 20:31

Thinking about it some more, the converse of the net contributor, a net taker, is particularly problematic as it is redolent of the "useless eater" trope - might sound overly dramatic, but the rhetoric doesn't appear out of nowhere.

RelicMaster · 29/10/2026 20:31

glitterpaperchain · 28/10/2026 18:30

Obviously there is a time and place for this phrase because we need to have a realistic financial plan and a functioning economy.

But society is more than just money. And I feel like this phrase is really making people view each other in a nasty way, purely focused on whether they provide economic value or not.

There are so many ways to contribute. The people who look after our small children, teaching assistants and 1 to 1s who look after SEN children, many healthcare workers, the people who care for our elderly, they all get paid a pittance but that work is so valuable to our society.

We're more than just our finances and there are many ways to contribute to society, many of which are not reflected in the economy.

The worst phrase ever is “For Meeee … blah blah blah “ used in the most arrogant, self important tone, ever.

XenoBitch · 29/10/2026 20:37

ThingsAreNotWhatTheyWere · 29/10/2026 20:31

Thinking about it some more, the converse of the net contributor, a net taker, is particularly problematic as it is redolent of the "useless eater" trope - might sound overly dramatic, but the rhetoric doesn't appear out of nowhere.

Yep, taker is horrible. I think 'net beneficiary' is better. Taker sums up the image of someone with their hand out (and I reckon that is why some people use that term).

Diddleydo43 · 29/10/2026 21:18

MadameMaxGoesler · 28/10/2026 19:53

For reference, the (individual not household) income required to be a net contributor is £42,600.

Edited

Ooh thats me out and DH. Both work in public services.

latetothefisting · 29/10/2026 22:58

glitterpaperchain · 29/10/2026 08:57

Plenty of people on this thread have said they've seen it all over MN/given examples, so I'd suggest reading the thread

I've read the thread, nobody has provided an actual example of when it has been used in a post that is not linked to economics. A vague "I've seen it all over MN" is no more reliable than me saying "I've never seen it ever mentioned on MN."

YOU started the thread, it's on you to provide actual evidence to back up your argument rather than nebulous "someone else said they saw it"

XenoBitch · 29/10/2026 23:01

latetothefisting · 29/10/2026 22:58

I've read the thread, nobody has provided an actual example of when it has been used in a post that is not linked to economics. A vague "I've seen it all over MN" is no more reliable than me saying "I've never seen it ever mentioned on MN."

YOU started the thread, it's on you to provide actual evidence to back up your argument rather than nebulous "someone else said they saw it"

Edited

The thread was removed because it was awful, but there was a thread where OP said that people that were not net contributors should not be allowed to vote.

And if you go on any thread about benefits or disability, there are lots of examples of what OP is on about too.

glitterpaperchain · 29/10/2026 23:09

latetothefisting · 29/10/2026 22:58

I've read the thread, nobody has provided an actual example of when it has been used in a post that is not linked to economics. A vague "I've seen it all over MN" is no more reliable than me saying "I've never seen it ever mentioned on MN."

YOU started the thread, it's on you to provide actual evidence to back up your argument rather than nebulous "someone else said they saw it"

Edited

...this is so weird.

A: I've seen this thing, anyone want to discuss it?
B: Oh I've seen that thing too, I'll discuss it
C: I DO NOT BELIEVE YOU, YOU MUST PROVIDE SPECIFIC EVIDENCE OF WHERE YOU HAVE SEEN THIS THING

I can't give you links to specific threads. If you can't take me at my word, then don't participate in the discussion, no one is forcing you.

OP posts:
ThingsAreNotWhatTheyWere · 29/10/2026 23:16

XenoBitch · 29/10/2026 23:01

The thread was removed because it was awful, but there was a thread where OP said that people that were not net contributors should not be allowed to vote.

And if you go on any thread about benefits or disability, there are lots of examples of what OP is on about too.

Pretty sure that was the thread that prompted me to sign up and comment, it was so awful.

Totallyfedupnow · 30/10/2026 01:07

@socialdilemmawhattodo I don’t really understand your point, or that of the other poster.
There are very few jobs in the tobacco industry in the UK these days but they do pay pretty well. Salary levels reflect the fact that many people have a red line when it comes to tobacco, limiting the supply of labour and increasing its price.
The defence industry, however, is a huge employer within the UK with a lot of crossover into civilian areas of STEM and a good record of offering apprenticeships and other training. Thousands of people are very happy to work in the sector, and don’t need significant salary premiums.

Totallyfedupnow · 30/10/2026 01:56

I feel like this thread has become derailed because the OP is moving the goalposts. OP started out by arguing that value to society can take different forms. Fair enough.

But now OP says they mean that net contributors think they are morally superior to everyone else. Whether or not these people think so (and I don’t think OP has provided any evidence of this), that’s a total non sequitur. Working for £200 per hour does not make you less morally virtuous than someone working for £10 per hour. Or vice versa. There are many reasons why someone ends up working for £10 an hour rather than £200, and most of them are not moral choices.

Furthermore, even if you define “value” as social contribution, rather than financial contribution, that’s still not equivalent to moral superiority. It is possible to be a very morally principled person but to contribute nothing to society, financially or otherwise - think a cloistered monk or nun - or the reverse.

Friendlygingercat · 30/10/2026 02:15

When you assess what someone has contributed to society it should include as well as tax

The actual value of the work
Research work or publications
Time spent training or studying (after secondary school)
Voluntary work done
Unofficial caring

glitterpaperchain · 30/10/2026 07:05

Totallyfedupnow · 30/10/2026 01:56

I feel like this thread has become derailed because the OP is moving the goalposts. OP started out by arguing that value to society can take different forms. Fair enough.

But now OP says they mean that net contributors think they are morally superior to everyone else. Whether or not these people think so (and I don’t think OP has provided any evidence of this), that’s a total non sequitur. Working for £200 per hour does not make you less morally virtuous than someone working for £10 per hour. Or vice versa. There are many reasons why someone ends up working for £10 an hour rather than £200, and most of them are not moral choices.

Furthermore, even if you define “value” as social contribution, rather than financial contribution, that’s still not equivalent to moral superiority. It is possible to be a very morally principled person but to contribute nothing to society, financially or otherwise - think a cloistered monk or nun - or the reverse.

I can explain more clearly because I think my argument is quite clear.

Some people who are net contributors seem to think that makes them better than other people. Nowhere did I say all. I've seen this attitude here on MN. What I'm fed up of is seeing the phrase used in this way.

And I'm saying that being a financial net contributor doesn't make someone better or more valuable than someone else, because there are many non-financial ways to contribute.

Hope that helps

OP posts: