Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be fed up of the phrase 'net contributor'

246 replies

glitterpaperchain · 28/10/2026 18:30

Obviously there is a time and place for this phrase because we need to have a realistic financial plan and a functioning economy.

But society is more than just money. And I feel like this phrase is really making people view each other in a nasty way, purely focused on whether they provide economic value or not.

There are so many ways to contribute. The people who look after our small children, teaching assistants and 1 to 1s who look after SEN children, many healthcare workers, the people who care for our elderly, they all get paid a pittance but that work is so valuable to our society.

We're more than just our finances and there are many ways to contribute to society, many of which are not reflected in the economy.

OP posts:
glitterpaperchain · 29/10/2026 09:30

WarmHiker · 29/10/2026 09:28

If people didn’t want to be nurses and teachers, nurses and teachers would be paid more to encourage people to want to do it. Its. called supply and demand. It’s not that hard to understand.

Edited

I think this is the Dunning-Kruger effect in action. This kind of thing is incredibly complex and people literally write entire books on the subject

OP posts:
WarmHiker · 29/10/2026 09:34

Indeed supply and demand has had tons of books written on it. It’s one of the most basic principles in economics, often also taught in school. Alas, it seems some people don’t pay attention.

brownbootsandhats · 29/10/2026 09:40

I see it in response to anti immigration posts / immigrants and second generation immigrants are more likely to be net contributors

I do agree that a society that values money over people is distorted

glitterpaperchain · 29/10/2026 09:41

WarmHiker · 29/10/2026 09:34

Indeed supply and demand has had tons of books written on it. It’s one of the most basic principles in economics, often also taught in school. Alas, it seems some people don’t pay attention.

Okay, so what you're essentially saying is that poor people are poor because they choose to do low paying jobs and if they collectively chose not to do those jobs, then we would have to increase the pay in order to make them do the jobs.

Ignoring the ridiculous premise, this isn't actually how things work. In reality, if people don't want to do jobs for low pay, then we become reliant on foreign workers who are willing to do it for low pay. This already happens in many sectors.

OP posts:
bardabunga · 29/10/2026 09:42

It's an accounting term so of course it only relates to the money side. Either you are making a net financial contribution or you are not.

fieldofdoom · 29/10/2026 09:45

WarmHiker · 29/10/2026 09:28

If people didn’t want to be nurses and teachers, nurses and teachers would be paid more to encourage people to want to do it. Its. called supply and demand. It’s not that hard to understand.

Edited

Most teachers would be net contributors

BusyGreySnail · 29/10/2026 09:46

Another immigrant, another net contributor. I only use the phrase in that context really becuase being an immigrant is only, apparently, ok if you are. Even though immigrants make us a huge number of the socially beneficial and low paid jobs mentioned in this thread (carers etc).

glitterpaperchain · 29/10/2026 09:49

BusyGreySnail · 29/10/2026 09:46

Another immigrant, another net contributor. I only use the phrase in that context really becuase being an immigrant is only, apparently, ok if you are. Even though immigrants make us a huge number of the socially beneficial and low paid jobs mentioned in this thread (carers etc).

Economically, immigrants are great, because we get ready made, educated, skilled workers without having to pay for their education or any of their childhood needs. Even unskilled workers are 'free' workers in this sense.

Not that I like to reduce people down to their Economic value, but for people that do, they should love immigration

OP posts:
brownbootsandhats · 29/10/2026 09:52

BusyGreySnail · 29/10/2026 09:46

Another immigrant, another net contributor. I only use the phrase in that context really becuase being an immigrant is only, apparently, ok if you are. Even though immigrants make us a huge number of the socially beneficial and low paid jobs mentioned in this thread (carers etc).

It’s if the in response to immigrants taking all our money

and often comments are made about the NHS and care system too

there is no point talking to a racist about humanity, human dignity / beat them on their own terms

Havanananana · 29/10/2026 09:58

WarmHiker · 29/10/2026 09:34

Indeed supply and demand has had tons of books written on it. It’s one of the most basic principles in economics, often also taught in school. Alas, it seems some people don’t pay attention.

"Supply and demand" relates solely to a market economy - it assumes that people, companies and organisations only do the things that provide a profit, and that they look to derive the maximum amount of profit from any activity.
It is a fundamental mistake to assume that a society can operate solely on profit-driven supply and demand.

What about activities that don't produce a profit? What "profit" does a teacher generate? Should schools only exist in order to make a profit (and who should benefit from this "profit"?) or does society in general need teachers in order that there are people in the future who can be the inventors, entrepreneurs, doctors, nurses, designers, engineers, administrators - and teachers - that a functioning society requires?

If good education, healthcare, housing, transport and other vital services become the sole preserve of those who can afford to pay, what happens to those who cannot afford to pay? Instead of the most capable people being able to fulfil their potential, society becomes controlled by a financial elite who fight tooth and nail to preserve their position. "Net contributors, "market-led ecoonomy" and "supply and demand" are just some of the terms used by these elites to justify their own position while denigrating the contributions made by those who don't fit their false narrative of wealth being equal to importance or success.

brownbootsandhats · 29/10/2026 10:10

One could argue that teachers do produce a profit in that they produce children who can contribute to holding our society together

its just the idea of profit is very short term and narrow in scope that’s the issue

TrappedByThisDesk · 29/10/2026 10:28

bardabunga · 29/10/2026 09:42

It's an accounting term so of course it only relates to the money side. Either you are making a net financial contribution or you are not.

And of course most people are not. Because that is just the way the maths works out. There are only so many highly paid jobs to go round. And the ones that are extremely highly paid are taxed to subsidise the 'net-takers'.
The more unequal wealth and income are, the fewer net contributors there are.
It is just maths.

The trouble starts when right-wingers use the term with any kind of judgement of moral worth attached, or as a bait-and-switch to start advocating for lower taxes on the 'net contributors'.

Tideturn · 29/10/2026 10:42

WarmHiker · 29/10/2026 09:28

If people didn’t want to be nurses and teachers, nurses and teachers would be paid more to encourage people to want to do it. Its. called supply and demand. It’s not that hard to understand.

Edited

I think the term ‘want’ has more nuance. For the sake of argument, you could have a nurse or teacher WANTS to do that job because she wants to contribute to society. Whereas you could have a wealthy CEO who WANTED to go into business/finance to make money, to feather his own nest only. (Perhaps his company is even harming the environment or the social fabric in some way.) Using this logic, he should be taxed very significantly because, using a different metric, he is contributing nothing (socially) to society, so at the very least he should do so financially.

SomersetBrie · 29/10/2026 10:49

WarmHiker · 29/10/2026 09:28

If people didn’t want to be nurses and teachers, nurses and teachers would be paid more to encourage people to want to do it. Its. called supply and demand. It’s not that hard to understand.

Edited

Would you apply this to care home staff, supermarket staff and people who work in school and hospital canteens?

If people refused to do the jobs, would you offer more money? Where would you get the money?

WarmHiker · 29/10/2026 10:50

If there isn’t enough people in a profession or job, then that sector starts to pay more. What’s so hard to understand about that. You can have an opinion on it all you like. That’s just a fact and how it works in reality.

Raiderofthelostbattenburg · 29/10/2026 11:06

WarmHiker · 29/10/2026 10:50

If there isn’t enough people in a profession or job, then that sector starts to pay more. What’s so hard to understand about that. You can have an opinion on it all you like. That’s just a fact and how it works in reality.

Well, no - because in the real world, things are more complicated than they are in an introduction to economics text book. In the public sector, the government can't just raise wages when there are shortages, because they're constrained by tax revenues and competing spending proprites. It doesn't mean there's low demand for care workers, just because their wages are low.

Lemieux7 · 29/10/2026 11:07

WarmHiker · 29/10/2026 09:28

If people didn’t want to be nurses and teachers, nurses and teachers would be paid more to encourage people to want to do it. Its. called supply and demand. It’s not that hard to understand.

Edited

Thatcherite nonsense. Flawed logic.

Lemieux7 · 29/10/2026 11:09

Indeed, there are shortages of nurses atm because people are leaving the NHS is swathes and indeed they don’t want to do it. The NHS is not putting their wages up.

Tulipsriver · 29/10/2026 11:10

I agree. It reminds me of the attitude nazis used to demonise disabled people as a drain on society through propaganda.

Yes, there is a tiny minority of people who choose not to work in favour of sitting around doing nothing, but the majority of people who are not 'net contributors' are either disabled, ill, or contributing in other (just as valuable) ways.

My friend would has fallen into this category for years. She studied for a professional career, then had a child with high needs SEN. She has worked in some capacity for years, but no school can keep her child full time, and after school care is impossible for him so her earning potential is vastly reduced. Her son is incredibly unlikely to ever earn enough to be a net contributor himself... should they both feel guilty for things completely out of their control?

glitterpaperchain · 29/10/2026 11:11

WarmHiker · 29/10/2026 10:50

If there isn’t enough people in a profession or job, then that sector starts to pay more. What’s so hard to understand about that. You can have an opinion on it all you like. That’s just a fact and how it works in reality.

It's absolutely not a fact, what often happens in reality is we rely on foreign workers to come and do the work for low pay instead, we're seeing this in lots of sectors

OP posts:
SomersetBrie · 29/10/2026 11:15

WarmHiker · 29/10/2026 10:50

If there isn’t enough people in a profession or job, then that sector starts to pay more. What’s so hard to understand about that. You can have an opinion on it all you like. That’s just a fact and how it works in reality.

Do you have actual examples of this from low paid sectors?

If there aren't enough people working in care homes, will they increase the wage?
Who pays for this?

Lemieux7 · 29/10/2026 11:16

glitterpaperchain · 29/10/2026 11:11

It's absolutely not a fact, what often happens in reality is we rely on foreign workers to come and do the work for low pay instead, we're seeing this in lots of sectors

Yep, and then people who use that term are the ones complaining about ‘forrinners’ taking ‘our’ jobs.

glitterpaperchain · 29/10/2026 11:20

Lemieux7 · 29/10/2026 11:16

Yep, and then people who use that term are the ones complaining about ‘forrinners’ taking ‘our’ jobs.

And they also complain about people who live on benefits because they'd rather do that than work a low paid job in mcdonalds

OP posts:
glitterpaperchain · 29/10/2026 11:22

@WarmHiker I'm all for collective action though, are you advocating for more unionisation and strike action in low paid jobs? I'd support that definitely

OP posts:
Barrydoughnut · 29/10/2026 11:36

I’d like the country to get to a position where rent (or mortgage payments) and energy bills get down to the levels they used to be and tax is then increased for mid and lower earners. These are the groups who pay much lower rates than their equivalents in the Scandi countries but their income is now hollowed out by the exorbitant amount of money required to cover the essentials. If that was the case disposable income levels would be the same but people wouldn’t get shit for not being (in pure micro economic level) financial “net contributors”.