Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be fed up of the phrase 'net contributor'

246 replies

glitterpaperchain · 28/10/2026 18:30

Obviously there is a time and place for this phrase because we need to have a realistic financial plan and a functioning economy.

But society is more than just money. And I feel like this phrase is really making people view each other in a nasty way, purely focused on whether they provide economic value or not.

There are so many ways to contribute. The people who look after our small children, teaching assistants and 1 to 1s who look after SEN children, many healthcare workers, the people who care for our elderly, they all get paid a pittance but that work is so valuable to our society.

We're more than just our finances and there are many ways to contribute to society, many of which are not reflected in the economy.

OP posts:
XenoBitch · 01/11/2026 21:21

WarmHiker · 01/11/2026 21:17

yes they would be paid more. Again, supply and demand. But why would they be paid more when we can just import 10 million low paid people through mass migration in 20 years. Supply and demand.

No they would not 😂
Where would care homes magic up the money to pay staff more?

nearlylovemyusername · 01/11/2026 21:31

Jellycatspyjamas · 29/10/2026 09:15

But then again, this post is a good illustration of why this country is a mess. Apparently these warm and fuzzy contributions which are not based on monetary value a good substitute for net contributing taxes. Who knew.

Except in the real world, the person caring for their loved one at home is saving untold amounts in formal care fees, often sacrifice their earning power to do so. The person working with disabled kids in school, being paid a pittance, enables the child to learn and gives parents the opportunity to work or simply to continue caring.

The person volunteering with cubs, or scouts or whatever enables that provision to continue which gives kids meaningful activity and social engagement making it less likely they’ll end up engaged in offending behaviour - which costs society a huge amount of money.

Yes, the books need to balance, but these “nice to haves, are provided from the contribution of people who may not have much to contribute in cold, hard cash but which saves society millions.

Except in the real world, the person caring for their loved one at home is saving untold amounts in formal care fees, often sacrifice their earning power to do so.

It's interesting how twisted some views are. For the most of human history, across the world, with the exception of the last several decades it was family's responsibility to care for their loved ones. And when there was someone outside of the family to provide any form of help it was greatly appreciated.
Now people sincerely believe that it's state's responsibility to care for their vulnerable relatives and by providing some form of care they actually save the state some money.

XenoBitch · 01/11/2026 21:35

nearlylovemyusername · 01/11/2026 21:31

Except in the real world, the person caring for their loved one at home is saving untold amounts in formal care fees, often sacrifice their earning power to do so.

It's interesting how twisted some views are. For the most of human history, across the world, with the exception of the last several decades it was family's responsibility to care for their loved ones. And when there was someone outside of the family to provide any form of help it was greatly appreciated.
Now people sincerely believe that it's state's responsibility to care for their vulnerable relatives and by providing some form of care they actually save the state some money.

If someone has to give up their job/career to look after a disabled relative, then the state is still stepping in anyway to make sure they can afford to live. The amount they get is no where near what someone working as a carer would get. So yes, they do save the state a ton of money, along with sacrificing a lot themselves too.

What do you think should happen?

nearlylovemyusername · 01/11/2026 21:46

XenoBitch · 01/11/2026 21:35

If someone has to give up their job/career to look after a disabled relative, then the state is still stepping in anyway to make sure they can afford to live. The amount they get is no where near what someone working as a carer would get. So yes, they do save the state a ton of money, along with sacrificing a lot themselves too.

What do you think should happen?

They should appreciate that the state (assuming it's developed world, it's not a given everywhere) is giving them and their vulnerable relatives an opportunity to live. Not pretend that they are saving state the money.

I'm not saying for a moment that it state should not support vulnerable people. This is not the point I'm trying to make. I'm saying that the state support these people and availability of such support is fully dependent on availability of net contributors

XenoBitch · 01/11/2026 21:49

nearlylovemyusername · 01/11/2026 21:46

They should appreciate that the state (assuming it's developed world, it's not a given everywhere) is giving them and their vulnerable relatives an opportunity to live. Not pretend that they are saving state the money.

I'm not saying for a moment that it state should not support vulnerable people. This is not the point I'm trying to make. I'm saying that the state support these people and availability of such support is fully dependent on availability of net contributors

The person that comes to mind for me was a net contributor. He gave up a very well paid job to look after his disabled son.
His DS going into some sort of residential place that meets his needs will cost a hell of a lot more that the amount his dad gets from the state. The lad staying at home is saving the state a hell of a lot of money.
Are you wanting him to write you a letter, thanking you for paying taxes?

nearlylovemyusername · 01/11/2026 21:58

Please read and try to understand my post.
No, I don't want a letter. I was a carer for a disabled relative (used to do it on the top of my very stressful FT job, they never claimed).
It never occurred to me to think that I'm saving state some money - it was me who loved them and cared for them, not the state.

Thirteenblackcats · 02/11/2026 01:04

yellowspanner · 31/10/2026 14:11

I am a net contributor and yes I think the term is appropriate. Some people choose to live on benefits as a life style choice, others work cash only and avoid paying tax, others refuse to do jobs that they consider beneath them or beneath their qualification level, others choose to have children they cannot support financially. These are the people that are not contributing and are the reason my taxes are so high . And yes I use the term and I resent them

I earn under the threshold stated. However I don’t claim benefits. I work part time in the NHS and I am involved in creating lifesaving treatments for cancer patients

I pay a lot of tax and NI

I am able to support my children financially.

Do I fall under your list of people you resent?

glitterpaperchain · 02/11/2026 05:56

InterIgnis · 31/10/2026 21:21

It really isn’t.

It isn’t a value judgement, it’s purely economics.

The entire thread is about how I don't like when people use this economic term AS A value judgement. I don't know why you continue to have trouble understanding that.

OP posts:
glitterpaperchain · 02/11/2026 06:00

WarmHiker · 01/11/2026 21:17

yes they would be paid more. Again, supply and demand. But why would they be paid more when we can just import 10 million low paid people through mass migration in 20 years. Supply and demand.

Do you not see how you are refuting your own point?

'Yes they would be paid more except they wouldn't be paid more because of migration' so then they're not paid more then..? Exactly??

OP posts:
WarmHiker · 02/11/2026 06:32

If the plentiful supply of cheap immigrant labour ends, wages go up. It’s not that difficult to grasp.

Autumnalhibernationisthedream · 02/11/2026 06:37

Isn’t this the problem with life though? The big wig economists, the heads of companies, the government see everything in terms of money and tax intake and ignore that there’s volunteers and carers keeping society functioning on little or no money

nomas · 02/11/2026 07:32

WarmHiker · 02/11/2026 06:32

If the plentiful supply of cheap immigrant labour ends, wages go up. It’s not that difficult to grasp.

But wages are already low and the government top them up with Universal Credit.

Why would wages go up if immigrants leave? The government will still need to top them up.

glitterpaperchain · 02/11/2026 08:08

Autumnalhibernationisthedream · 02/11/2026 06:37

Isn’t this the problem with life though? The big wig economists, the heads of companies, the government see everything in terms of money and tax intake and ignore that there’s volunteers and carers keeping society functioning on little or no money

Yes, but I'm seeing that attitude trickling down to average people

OP posts:
XenoBitch · 02/11/2026 20:20

WarmHiker · 02/11/2026 06:32

If the plentiful supply of cheap immigrant labour ends, wages go up. It’s not that difficult to grasp.

No, it would not.

Totallyfedupnow · 09/11/2026 09:13

bardabunga · 31/10/2026 21:29

If people didn't want to be supermarket shelf-stackers, delivery drivers, nursery workers, toilet attendants, warehouse operatives, coffee shop staff, hospital porters, care home employees... would they be paid more to encourage people to do it? No, they wouldn't, and the chattering classes would be in uproar if the goods and service which make their life so easy cost them more money.

Yes, actually they would be paid more. The economic illiteracy on display on this thread is off the charts.

As we saw during COVID, when there is a mismatch between supply and demand for a specific job role, the price will adjust. Eg, in 2021, long distance lorry drivers were in short supply, while demand remained high. So their basic wages went up by to 45% in a matter of weeks.

The reason that pay for jobs like care workers, kitchen/hospital porters and shelf stackers is low and does not rise very fast is principally because there is an almost indefinite supply of people willing to do these jobs, thanks to immigration. They are relatively unskilled jobs requiring no qualifications, and you might not even need to speak much English, so there are no barriers to entry.

renovationchoas · 09/11/2026 09:26

Yes and no.

Not all contribution, positive and negative, to society is easy to estimate or quantifiable so it can be quite reductionist.

There are two ways it is helpful:

firstly, immigration has become controversial due to poor management and, unfortunately, the Treasury orthodoxy that GDP rises due to immigration, which it does, but GDP per capita (ie how wealthy people feel) ONLY does if it is well managed. The net contributor concept helps to explain this issue, even if it is crude.

secondly, we have a welfare state that has started to become a bit too geared towards what people are “entitled to” claim, rather than individual responsibilities. Could you support yourself, rather than asking everyone else to fund this is not the default mentality. This is why there is currently a welfare backlash. The rise of the use of “net contributor” is a way of pushing back against this trend.

I think that the (over)use of the term is sort of a bit of a canary in the coal mine, due to the fact that we as a society have taken a bit of a wrong term - debt on current trajectory will be crippling for all of our children and grandchildren and there will have to be a scaling back of entitlement.

Bedroomdilemmas113 · 09/11/2026 09:31

Often this comes as a result of people who say ‘I pay my taxes so XXX’ (insert unreasonable or entitled viewpoint). They’re on minimum wage, with 2 children in school, have had 2 pregnancies and births and a number of medical appointments. They don’t understand that yes, they pay their taxes, but their taxes don’t cover even a fraction of what they are ‘using’ in education and healthcare alone. They’re unclear on how the system actually works, but using how they think it works to express a negative view.

Similarly, when the non net contributors have a rant about the more well off or higher earners, without understanding that if society didn’t have us, the things they enjoy as standard (healthcare, schooling etc) would not actually exist in their current state because there wouldn’t be enough money to pay for them, and money doesn’t grow on trees.

That is my experience of when the phrase generally comes out.

renovationchoas · 09/11/2026 09:37

(Also, yes, unfortunately this thread has some very basic economic incompetences - immigration of low skill workers suppresses wages for low skill work. It is very basic supply and demand)

OonaStubbs · 09/11/2026 09:40

There needs to be more givers and fewer takes IMO.

There are too many people who are happy to take everything and give nothing back in return.

No I am not talking about low-paid/unpaid carers and volunteers etc.

Totallyfedupnow · 09/11/2026 09:45

@glitterpaperchain You are deliberately missing the point (which is ironically what you don’t seem to like about the people who allegedly run around muttering about “net contributors”).

@WarmHiker is saying that in an alternative universe where we had not had huge waves of net migration under Tony Blair, Gordon Brown and Boris Johnson, unskilled wages would very likely be higher because labour supply would be much tighter.

As it is, that mass immigration did happen, and we are seeing job market where there is an almost indefinite supply of people willing to do these lower paid jobs, keeping the cost of labour down. (Which might seem low paid to someone born in the UK but to an economic migrant from Bangladesh or Albania might seem very different, especially with a generous helping of benefits on top). If anyone is wondering why the caring, sharing Governments of Mr Starmer and Mr Burnham have not allowed asylum seekers to work, this is why. Not only would that double the rates that the people smugglers would charge, but it would make competition for the lowest paid jobs even more intense, further driving down pay.

TherapyName · 09/11/2026 11:03

One of my biggest bugbears is seeing the role a failing NHS plays in making our population sicker, leading to rising working age disability and chronic illness. Until politicians understand this I doubt things will change in any meaningful way.

OP I do understand what you are saying. Unfortunately the language of economics is being weaponised, largely by the wealthiest in society to divide and conquer everyone else. I think we should all aim to be net contributors but that comes with a responsibility to create well paid employment, decent healthcare and affordable homes for people.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread