Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be fed up of the phrase 'net contributor'

246 replies

glitterpaperchain · 28/10/2026 18:30

Obviously there is a time and place for this phrase because we need to have a realistic financial plan and a functioning economy.

But society is more than just money. And I feel like this phrase is really making people view each other in a nasty way, purely focused on whether they provide economic value or not.

There are so many ways to contribute. The people who look after our small children, teaching assistants and 1 to 1s who look after SEN children, many healthcare workers, the people who care for our elderly, they all get paid a pittance but that work is so valuable to our society.

We're more than just our finances and there are many ways to contribute to society, many of which are not reflected in the economy.

OP posts:
Jellycatspyjamas · 29/10/2026 12:02

WarmHiker · 29/10/2026 09:28

If people didn’t want to be nurses and teachers, nurses and teachers would be paid more to encourage people to want to do it. Its. called supply and demand. It’s not that hard to understand.

Edited

Well no, what happens is governments start to shift the bar, so jobs previously only done by qualified teachers, nurses and social workers are hived off to lower paid, less/differently qualified staff. They remove the requirement for qualified status from some roles and employ cheaper labour, the hive out roles to the private sector, or the third sector. They don’t pay more money, they look for ways to take the pesky, expensive professionals out of the equation.

Totallyfedupnow · 29/10/2026 12:25

Can OP/someone explain please, practically speaking, when are we allowed to use this phrase and when are we not allowed to use this?

I kind of feel like it’s very easy to spend money but it’s much harder to earn it, and if as a society we are too squeamish about talking about money and how the bills are paid, we are going to get into a lot of trouble.

EstoyRobandoSuCasa · 29/10/2026 12:32

Is it even a useful concept, given how over-simplified and potentially misleading it is? It’s used because it’s easy to measure and it suits some political agendas.

TorroFerney · 29/10/2026 12:32

littlemousebigcheese · 28/10/2026 19:19

The only time I hear it is when used constructively in arguments with muppets who think their tax is paying for immigrants and free houses and lambos for those fresh off the boat and someone reminds them that they probably aren’t net contributors so ‘their’ tax isn’t even paying for their own needs. I think it’s important to acknowledge that a vast number of people ‘cost’ more than they contribute. We are so so much more than our income tax bracket but when it comes to discussions about how tax should be used it is important to recognise that actually not that many people are heavily contributing! It reminds most that they BENEFIT from taxation and society set up as it is as most take more than they give

Oh it never occurs to me like that, more that I’m perhaps paying for myself or more towards myself so money can go towards others who need it.

VioletsTale · 29/10/2026 12:37

WarmHiker · 29/10/2026 10:50

If there isn’t enough people in a profession or job, then that sector starts to pay more. What’s so hard to understand about that. You can have an opinion on it all you like. That’s just a fact and how it works in reality.

Then why didn’t the government do that instead of recruiting whole wards of nurses and midwives from Eastern European countries (for example)?

glitterpaperchain · 29/10/2026 12:38

Totallyfedupnow · 29/10/2026 12:25

Can OP/someone explain please, practically speaking, when are we allowed to use this phrase and when are we not allowed to use this?

I kind of feel like it’s very easy to spend money but it’s much harder to earn it, and if as a society we are too squeamish about talking about money and how the bills are paid, we are going to get into a lot of trouble.

🙄 You are allowed to say whatever you want

My post is about being fed up of seeing people use it as a way to make high earners sound more important than everyone else

OP posts:
AndSoFinally · 29/10/2026 12:40

Are you considered a net contributor if you earn £45k a year? Or are you only a net contributor if you also contribute enough to cover all the people in your household? Is someone on £45k still a net contributor if they have 3 kids and a stay at home partner?

(Genuine question, I don’t know if this is accounted for?)

malificent7 · 29/10/2026 12:44

Well this attitude doesn't surprise me given that we live in an increasingly materialistic society.

Totallyfedupnow · 29/10/2026 12:50

SomersetBrie · 29/10/2026 11:15

Do you have actual examples of this from low paid sectors?

If there aren't enough people working in care homes, will they increase the wage?
Who pays for this?

Was just thinking about this.
One of the reasons social care, cleaners, kitchen staff etc are paid so little is that there is an almost indefinite supply of labour via legal or illegal immigration. As long as cheap labour can be imported from overseas, wages will stay low.

An example of when wages started to rise in response to reduced labour supply was during COVID, when cross border mobility was obviously restricted. For example, do you remember the great lorry driver shortage of 2021? Companies started offering 25-40% increases in basic pay (which for some drivers had been less than £12.50 p/h before the pandemic) to stop their existing drivers being poached by the competition.

Totallyfedupnow · 29/10/2026 13:03

glitterpaperchain · 29/10/2026 12:38

🙄 You are allowed to say whatever you want

My post is about being fed up of seeing people use it as a way to make high earners sound more important than everyone else

But in many contexts they ARE more important. The top 1% by income pay £74.5 billion every year in income tax and that alone is enough to pay the wages of 1.5 million nurses and social care workers. And on top of that they pay billions more in stamp duty, dividend tax, CGT, inheritance tax, council tax etc. Without them we do not have an NHS or any state funded social care or schools, and nobody gets welfare payments.

Note - I am not saying they are morally superior - just that they are paying for the whole system that all of us benefit from, and it is highly unwise to pretend otherwise.

Thesillysocks · 29/10/2026 13:10

Could our society work if suddenly all the non-net contributors went away? I’m pretty sure it could, either by paying people more to be nurses / teachers / shelves stackers etc or even by attracting people from other countries to do these jobs.
Could our society work if suddenly all the net contributors went away? I don’t see how it could, no salary for teachers / nurses, not even money to keep schools and hospitals open, no police force…

I have used the term net contributor before, usually when people express hatred for high earners but refuse to acknowledge that they benefit from them. Or when people argue that « they pay taxes » without acknowledging that the amount they pay is less than the one they receive.

Verv · 29/10/2026 13:10

I have no issue with its use. Its just a way of quickly identifying a demographic.

Tinofspoons · 29/10/2026 13:17

As someone who has been unable to have children due to infertility I have experienced the opposite as well. I have read on here many times that I (anyone without children) will be a drain on society in my old age because I have no one to look after me. And because I have not procreated I am not contributing to the next generation of workers and as such should be taxed more in order to pay for being such a drain. Those with children are going to be the ones to “wipe my bum” in old age so no matter what I earn now it will never make up for the drain I will become later and nothing will ever contribute as much as having children would have.

Notmycircusnotmyotter · 29/10/2026 13:21

glitterpaperchain · 28/10/2026 19:29

I think in theory this is true. But in reality I often see people talking about net contributors as if they are better or more important than other people.

Well they are more important in a financial sense than the very many people who do not work or who work part time and claim UC. Without them, the state aid wouldn't be possible.

glitterpaperchain · 29/10/2026 13:25

Totallyfedupnow · 29/10/2026 13:03

But in many contexts they ARE more important. The top 1% by income pay £74.5 billion every year in income tax and that alone is enough to pay the wages of 1.5 million nurses and social care workers. And on top of that they pay billions more in stamp duty, dividend tax, CGT, inheritance tax, council tax etc. Without them we do not have an NHS or any state funded social care or schools, and nobody gets welfare payments.

Note - I am not saying they are morally superior - just that they are paying for the whole system that all of us benefit from, and it is highly unwise to pretend otherwise.

And in other contexts they're not. Why are you so determined to weigh up who is more or less important? That's exactly the attitude I'm fed up of seeing, using someone's finances to judge their value and importance. It's disgusting.

As if people who work in care homes for the elderly need someone going 'but remember you're not a net contributor!!!!!'

Economics is one thing. The 'value' of a human life is another. And we should remember that they are not one and the same.

OP posts:
Everanewbie · 29/10/2026 13:26

I think those offended by the term object to being reminded that their lifestyle is funded by someone else, and it is easier to attack the phrase than face reality with good grace and gratitude.

glitterpaperchain · 29/10/2026 13:26

Notmycircusnotmyotter · 29/10/2026 13:21

Well they are more important in a financial sense than the very many people who do not work or who work part time and claim UC. Without them, the state aid wouldn't be possible.

I am not interested in trying to order people from most to least important

OP posts:
glitterpaperchain · 29/10/2026 13:29

Everanewbie · 29/10/2026 13:26

I think those offended by the term object to being reminded that their lifestyle is funded by someone else, and it is easier to attack the phrase than face reality with good grace and gratitude.

It makes me kind of sick to see people placing value on a human life purely by what they contribute economically

Oh sorry, what I mean is, give me more benefits please I want to spend all the rich people's money on lip filler

OP posts:
InterIgnis · 29/10/2026 13:32

What matters more, the cold hard facts of what is, or the philosophy of what ‘should’ be?

What is the engine that enables society to organize and function? The economy. What is critical to the economy? The financing of it. Net contributors are foundational.

What happens when a society can no longer afford to sustain itself is ugly, especially so for the vulnerable. Moral principles as to what is and isn’t worthy become immediately irrelevant, and ‘meaningful’ civility falls very quickly to the wayside.

You don’t have to like net contributors being held up as particularly important, nay crucial, because it runs counter to your philosophy, but the fact remains that they are. The UK for at least the past decade has simultaneously been bleeding high net worth individuals and failing to attract enough to plug the holes. It’s the country with the highest amount of millionaire emigration in the world. This translates to the economy losing billions.

Verv · 29/10/2026 13:34

glitterpaperchain · 29/10/2026 13:26

I am not interested in trying to order people from most to least important

You may not be, but its a function of society, like it or not.

labamba007 · 29/10/2026 13:34

I’ve not seen it outside of economics and politics. I think the conversation needs to be more clear - we need net contributors to pay for hospitals, schools, roads etc and all the hard working people who work in them. Unfortunately, net contributors are facing higher tax burdens which ultimately means less money for public services.

EstoyRobandoSuCasa · 29/10/2026 13:34

Everanewbie · 29/10/2026 13:26

I think those offended by the term object to being reminded that their lifestyle is funded by someone else, and it is easier to attack the phrase than face reality with good grace and gratitude.

Maybe the net recipients should go on strike as a PP suggested?

Within a week, there would be no food in the shops nor staff to work in them, and various CFOs, marketing directors, tax lawyers and hedge fund managers would be pondering the old saying about how money cannot be eaten.

Havanananana · 29/10/2026 13:35

WarmHiker · 29/10/2026 10:50

If there isn’t enough people in a profession or job, then that sector starts to pay more. What’s so hard to understand about that. You can have an opinion on it all you like. That’s just a fact and how it works in reality.

This is nonsense. No business or sector can just pay more in order to attract the employees that it needs, particularly if it takes time and money to train these employees. There is not an unlimited supply of skilled workers and access to many qualifications is restricted either because a certain level of intellect or ability is required or because there are financial barriers that poorer students cannot overcome. There is not an unlimited pot of money with which to pay the employees, and what the economics textbooks describe as "supply and demand" only applies to a mythical perfect market where money and profit are the sole drivers.

For humans money is not the only driver. Double the wages of nurses and there would still be a shortage if working conditions are not acceptable. People want a certain level of quality of life, a good life balance, recognition and respect - beyond a certain point they work to live rather than living to work. Some people have ethical values - e.g. they will not work for tobacco companies or companies that manufacture arms - and no amount of money will persuade them to work in these industries. Some jobs are so dangerous, unpleasent or strenuous that people refuse to do them regardless of the wage, setting a higher value on their health rather than on money.

Verv · 29/10/2026 13:36

glitterpaperchain · 29/10/2026 13:29

It makes me kind of sick to see people placing value on a human life purely by what they contribute economically

Oh sorry, what I mean is, give me more benefits please I want to spend all the rich people's money on lip filler

Its not only "rich people" though is it?
Just under half of the population are considered net contributors.

randomchap · 29/10/2026 13:36

Everanewbie · 29/10/2026 13:26

I think those offended by the term object to being reminded that their lifestyle is funded by someone else, and it is easier to attack the phrase than face reality with good grace and gratitude.

And those earning that money are only doing so because of the contributions of the wider society around them. They should be grateful too